Kenoshacountyeye

Kenosha County Eye

Search
Close this search box.
Search
Close this search box.

Kraus and Binger Lose Again: Jury Finds Rape Suspect Not Guilty After Year And A Half Behind Bars

Share
Tweet
Robert Thomas, 24 of Kenosha

A Special Birthday

Paid Advertisement

Wednesday, December 8, 2021. Robert Thomas’s 24th birthday was almost certainly different from all of his others. This birthday, he spent outside of the Kenosha County jail, smelling the cold fall air after a year and a half behind bars.

Kenosha ADA Jim Kraus (D)
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson)

Allegation and Charge

Paid Advertisement

Thomas was charged by Kenosha Prosecutor James Kraus (D) of an early-morning rape more than seven years ago, on October 2, 2014. According to court records, a woman, who was severely intoxicated, admitted to using hallucinogenics on the night of her alleged rape. She said that she left a Kenosha bar and was walking to another bar when she was approached by a black male. She said the next thing she remembered, she woke up with her pants down. She then pulled them up and hitched a ride to the Kenosha Police Department. The woman did not have much of a description of her alleged attacker. She was taken to the hospital for a SANE (Sexual Assault Nurse Exam). The swab contained DNA and it was sent to the Wisconsin crime lab. There were no matches. The case was cold. Just over 5 years later, a match was sent to KPD. It was a match to the defendant. He was convicted for disorderly conduct on 10/31/2019 and had to give his DNA to police. Police gave the woman a photo lineup with the defendant’s photo among others. She didn’t pick anyone out. Prosecutor James Kraus decided to charge Thomas anyway. That’s exactly what he did on March 20, 2020. Kraus charged Thomas with Second Degree Sexual Assault which carried a possible prison sentence of 40 years. Kraus had his wife Emily Trigg, notarize the sworn complaint, which is improper.

Kenosha ADA T. Clair Binger (D)
(Court TV non-copyrighted)

T. Clair Binger’s Trial

Paid Advertisement

We spoke to and heard from jurors about the trial. This gave us a lot of insight into the trial and the deliberations. The alleged victim and the defendant both took the stand. One female juror told us that defense attorney Brett Copeland was polite, non-judgemental, and fair, but seemed like a newer attorney. He has been practicing law for four years.. She told us that T. Clair Binger (D) was smart and well-researched. She did share some criticism with the KCE. She said the T. Clair could have done a much better job of focusing on the alleged victim and how the allegations affected her life in the last seven years. She said he relied too much on the DNA evidence and ignored other avenues to pursue. The defendant admitted to having sex with the woman, but said it was consensual. According to one of the jurors we spoke to, there just wasn’t enough evidence to support rape. “There were just too many holes in her story to convince us it wasn’t consensual”

Judge Jason Rossell
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson)

Theft and Third Degree Sexual Assault

Paid Advertisement

T. Clair made an unusual request. He asked Judge Rossell to allow an 11th hour charge of theft, saying there was evidence that Thomas stole the woman’s purse. The Judge denied his request. T. Clair also asked for a lesser-included charge of third degree sexual assault, which the judge allowed. As a former prosecutor, Rossell is seen as a judge by defense attorneys that typically sides with the prosecution.

Deliberations

About half of the jury recognized T. Clair Binger as the prosecutor that unsuccessfully prosecuted Kyle Rittenhouse. “Oh my God, he’s here again” one jurors said of Binger. The jury spoke briefly about the Rittenhouse case and deliberated for about 4 hours. They asked for a few exhibits and came to a unanimous verdict – NOT GUILTY.

Paid Advertisement

We requested comment from T. Clair and have not heard back.

Click the Photo To Review KCE Merchandise

Author

  • Kevin Mathewson

    Kevin Mathewson is a disciple of Christ, husband and a father to two wonderful children. Mathewson was born and raised in Lake County, IL and worked as a police & fire dispatcher from 2005 to 2010 in Round Lake Beach, IL. Mathewson moved to Kenosha County in 2006, later being elected to the position of Alderman of the 8th District in 2012 and 2016. Mathewson is a private investigator, security contractor, journalist, and photographer. He enjoys spending time with his family, watching movies, camping and boating. His favorite amendment is the second, followed closely by the first. He loves his country and community.

Share
Tweet
LATEST NEWS

Kenosha Man Known As The “Black Kyle Rittenhouse” Is Free After Having Charge Dismissed

Jarred Cooks, a 28-year-old Kenosha man, walked out of the Kenosha County Courthouse today as a free man, with a big smile. In court today, preparations were underway for a trial that was scheduled for April 8, 2024 – just 11 days away. Instead, today a Circuit Court Judge dismissed the serious felony against Cooks, at the request of the prosecutor. He was facing one count of First Degree Recklessly Endangering Safety, Use of a Dangerous

Read More »

Kenosha Judge Candidates Debate Issues At Forum Hosted By The Kenosha County BAR Association: Video

Lawyers from the private and public sectors, prosecutors, judges, court staff, the Sheriff, other members of the legal community, and members of the public packed into Casa Capris tonight to watch a spirited debate between the two candidates for Circuit Court Judge in Kenosha’s Branch 3. Court Commissioner Heather Iverson and Judge Frank Gagliardi are going head-to head for the position which will be decided by voters on April 2, 2024. Gagliardi was appointed by Governor

Read More »
MORE TOP STORIES

Man Killed In Brighton After Striking Cow With Vehicle

On Thursday, March 28, 2024, around 4:50 AM, the Kenosha County Sheriff’s Department responded to the 29500 block of 31st Street  (CTH-JB) in the Town of Brighton for a single-vehicle crash that had hit a cow. The cow had escaped its pasture and was found in the middle of 31st Street at the time of the crash. The vehicle operator was the only occupant of the vehicle and was pronounced deceased at the scene by the Kenosha County

Read More »

Kenosha’s Peter Barca Leaves Governor’s Administration

MADISON — Gov. Tony Evers today announced Wisconsin Department of Revenue (DOR) Secretary Peter Barca will be leaving the Evers Administration after serving the administration for more than five years. Secretary Barca was one of the governor’s first appointments to his cabinet in 2019. “Peter has been with our administration since Day One, and I knew from the beginning that he would be a dedicated, enthusiastic, and effective leader for the Department of Revenue,” said Gov.

Read More »

Carthage College Student Assaulted on Campus – Person of Interest in Custody

On Tuesday, March 26, 2024, at about 8:30 PM, officers from the Kenosha Police Department responded to the campus of Carthage College to investigate an attempted assault and robbery that occurred on campus. The adult female student screamed for help during the attack, causing another student to respond. Their actions caused the man to flee. The Kenosha Police Department and Carthage Public Safety immediately began a collaborative investigation. The campus community was notified of the incident

Read More »

Controversy Surrounds Kemper Center Appointment of Daniel Gaschke as Executive Director

In a move that has sparked controversy and raised serious questions about its transparency and governance, the Kemper Center has appointed Daniel Gaschke, a Kenosha County Board Member, as its new executive director. Gaschke’s appointment comes amidst allegations of impropriety and procedural irregularities, further compounded by attempts to suppress information and limit public scrutiny. Gaschke will succeed Ed Kubicki, another County Board member, who was hired in 2018 under similarly suspicious circumstances. Citizens and politicians claimed

Read More »

Kenosha Unified School District To Host Events Celebrating Legacy Of Schools Slated To Close

WHAT: At the end of this school year, the Kenosha Unified School District will have six schools closing, one merging with another, and one changing locations. To honor their legacy in our community, the district will be celebrating the history of each of the buildings impacted prior to the end of the school year. WHO: All current and past students, staff and families, as well as general community members, are invited to celebrate the history of

Read More »

Video Released Of High School Teacher’s Police Chase And Arrest For Third OWI – No Discipline From School District

The dash-cam and body-cam footage of a Tremper High School teacher leading police on a drunken pursuit through Kenosha was released today. Pursuant to a public records request, KPD turned over the videos to KCE today. Mark P. Wisniewski, 41, of Kenosha, was sentenced to six months in jail earlier this month after leading Kenosha Police on a 1 mile chase with a blood alcohol content of .300 – almost four times the legal limit. Wisniewski

Read More »

8 Responses

  1. Speaking of rape…After the last story on Smith Pumkin Farm and Michael Perrine (Registered Sex Offender against children) being associated with them they would have washed their hands of him as they said they would. Also said they didn’t know the extent of his assault.(were informed) Michael Perrine has been seen working a stand again at the Smith Pumkin Farm’s Christmas Lights On The Farm last week. Why would a business that caters to children allow this? Makes a lot of us speculate

  2. God some jurors are so stupid. What would how it affected her life over the last few years have any effect on whether it was consensual or not?

    This was always the biggest threat in the Rittenhouse case….stupid ass people on the jury.

    That being said, Binger and Kraus need to move on from the Kenosha County DA’s office. They don’t come across as likable to jurors anymore and they are always going to be “those guys”. Guilty people are going to walk because of this.

    1. I can think of one plausible reason…it might be to evaluate the believability of the witness. A blackout story is pretty hard to cross-examine/ask useful questions about, however, the effect on someone who knows they were raped vs one who knows they had consensual sex will be different…such that if the witness were lying, they would have to make something up, and a brave defense attorney may be able to point out some inconsistencies. A female juror in particular will want to evaluate not only the witness’s words, but the body language and whatever else feeds into their intuition.

  3. Eighteen months in prison, awaiting trial. Whatever happened to the “speedy and public trial” that the Sixth Amendment enumerates?

  4. God bless prosecutors like Binger and Krause. They are the Justice system’s best hope for fair and balanced justice for all.

    I’m totally messing with you.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LATEST NEWS

Subscribe to updates

Get notified of new articles. We'll never share your email address.