DNR Sued Over Silly, Unconstitutional “Rule” – State Should Avoid Legal Battle And Axe Rule: Opinion

Copied!
(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

The Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources (DNR) has been sued by the Wisconsin Institute for Law and Liberty, Inc. (WILL) to prevent any enforcement of a DNR rule created in 1999. The regulation forbids the possession of any firearm by any person at any time on the waters, banks, or shores or waters in Wisconsin. 

Paid Advertisement

The specific regulation is  NR 20.05(2):

Paid Advertisement

NR 20.05 General restrictions. No person may do any of the following: 

 (2) Possess or control any firearm, gun or similar device at any time while on the waters, banks or shores that might be used for the purpose of fishing.

Any firearm “might be used for the purpose of fishing”. Conversely virtually all “waters, banks or shores” might be used for the purposes of fishing. The regulation bans the possession or control of any firearm by any person at any time on the waters, banks or shores that might be used for the purpose of fishing.  There are no exceptions in the regulation.  

Paid Advertisement

This is forbidden by the Second Amendment in the Bill of Rights in the United States Constitution. 

Paid Advertisement

It is forbidden by Section 25 of the Wisconsin State Constitution:

Paid Advertisement

The people have the right to keep and bear arms for security, defense, hunting, recreation, or any other lawful purpose. (Art. 1, § 25)

The lawyers of WILL have chosen to challenge the regulation under the Second Amendment, because of the clear guidance given by the Supreme Court in the Bruen decision. Pistols were commonly carried in holsters and tackle boxes in Wisconsin to dispatch large fish until 1966. My father routinely carried a Remington Rolling Block .22 single shot pistol in his tackle box for such purposes, until the fishing regulation was changed in 1966. The prohibition on shooting fish was well understood when I was a Wisconsin Conservation Officer (Game Warden) 45 years ago. No one has come forward to take responsibility for inserting NR 20.05(2) into the code in 1999. It is not clear how many people have been prosecuted under the regulation, if any. 

Paid Advertisement

According to the lawsuit, the regulation is being challenged using the procedures of Wis. Stat. §227.40(4)(a). WILL states Wisconsin law requires plaintiffs to use §227.40(4)(a) to construct a case challenging the constitutional validity of a DNR regulation. 

The prohibition on the possession of firearms near or on the water was created in 1999. It has no historical precedent. This makes the regulation difficult to justify under the Bruen standard for the Second Amendment.  

There is no exception in the law for Conservation Officers or other sworn officers. Not all officers carry firearms all the time. It is possible officers avoid flagrant violation of the regulation by locking up their duty firearms in their vehicle before they approach the bank of a river or stream or shoreline of a lake, or enter a boat to perform water patrol duties. 

Analysis: The DNR would do well to settle the lawsuit and agree to not enforce NR 20.05(2) until it can be removed from the code. This would minimize the legal expense by the state on a losing case for a regulation which is seldom enforced.

Author

Copied!
LATEST NEWS

Kenosha Detectives Warn Over 50 Attendees About Sophisticated Scams at Fraud Awareness Event

KENOSHA, Wis. – More than 50 people gathered at Ruffolo’s II on Monday evening as three Kenosha Police Department officers delivered a sobering, and at times startling, presentation about the explosion of fraud and scam activity targeting local residents. The presentation, led by Detective Chad Buchanan, Crime Prevention Officer John Wenberg, and fraud division newcomer Detective Tommar Franklin, offered real-life examples of scams

Plus +

Former Racine Prison Official Pleads Guilty to Reduced Charges in Inmate Sex Case

Jacqueline Heidt, 39, of Racine(Racine County Sheriff’s Office) RACINE, Wis. — A former corrections supervisor who once faced more than 800 years in prison for carrying on a sexual relationship with a prison inmate has pleaded guilty to five reduced charges in a deal struck with prosecutors Monday morning. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

MORE TOP STORIES

Full Parade Lineup Announced for 2025 Kenosha Civic Veterans Parade

KENOSHA, Wis. – The lineup is set for this year’s Kenosha Civic Veterans Parade, which will step off Sunday, June 29, 2025, in downtown Kenosha. Presented by Snap-on, the annual tradition honors the region’s veterans while showcasing dozens of community organizations, marching bands, local leaders, and first responders. The parade

Salem Lakes Man Accused of Punching Elderly Wife, Faces Felony Abuse Charges

SALEM LAKES, Wis. — A 60-year-old man was charged Monday with felony elder abuse and misdemeanor disorderly conduct after allegedly punching his wife in the face during an argument at their mobile home on Sunday. Case G. Marcussen, of Salem Lakes, appeared in court the same day the criminal complaint

Categories
Archives
Authors

7 Responses

  1. I interpret it to mean that “no person may
    possess or control any firearm, gun or similar device at any time while on the waters, banks or shores that might be used for the purpose of SHOOTING fishing”.

    2
    1
    1. Yeah…but you know the “interpretation” would be under the discretion of the arresting officer and you know what that means… arrest now, take yur guns, charge you for using your gun illegally and maybe even get a felony and have all your gun rights stripped. Glad they are sueing the DNR. That should be off the books!

  2. This is an incredibly ridiculous and unenforceable rule.

    So the (friendly) Kenosha Co. Sheriff Deputies that stopped me on my boat last year at Camp Lake to check licenses and regulation compliance were themselves in violation of this rule as they had their duty weapons on them?

    This is a no-brainer, remove this rule for all.

  3. The authors analysis is 100% correct. Any weapon could be used to shoot a big fish, I can’t even type that and keep a straight face. If someone Acts badly with a firearm, we already have all the laws we could need to deal with them. This law is clearly unconstitutional, and should be abandoned immediately

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LATEST NEWS

Kenosha Detectives Warn Over 50 Attendees About Sophisticated Scams at Fraud Awareness Event

KENOSHA, Wis. – More than 50 people gathered at Ruffolo’s II on Monday evening as three Kenosha Police Department officers delivered a sobering, and at times startling, presentation about the explosion of fraud and scam activity targeting local residents. The presentation, led by Detective Chad Buchanan, Crime Prevention Officer John Wenberg, and fraud division newcomer Detective Tommar Franklin, offered real-life examples of scams

Plus +

Former Racine Prison Official Pleads Guilty to Reduced Charges in Inmate Sex Case

Jacqueline Heidt, 39, of Racine(Racine County Sheriff’s Office) RACINE, Wis. — A former corrections supervisor who once faced more than 800 years in prison for carrying on a sexual relationship with a prison inmate has pleaded guilty to five reduced charges in a deal struck with prosecutors Monday morning. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Full Parade Lineup Announced for 2025 Kenosha Civic Veterans Parade

KENOSHA, Wis. – The lineup is set for this year’s Kenosha Civic Veterans Parade, which will step off Sunday, June 29, 2025, in downtown Kenosha. Presented by Snap-on, the annual tradition honors the region’s veterans while showcasing dozens of community organizations, marching bands, local leaders, and first responders. The parade will feature five themed divisions and a robust pre-parade segment, with entries ranging

Plus +

Kenosha Man Accused of Severely Beating Elderly Wife When He Was Confronted Over Not Showering in Two Months

Michael R. Navrotsky, 67, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 67-year-old Kenosha man, and former corrections Sergeant is facing multiple felony charges after allegedly assaulting his elderly wife during a dispute that began when she asked him to take a shower for the first time in two months. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Plus +

Kenosha Man Accused of New Offenses Days After Release on Drug and Threat Charges

Ryan M. Phillips, 40, of Kenosha in Court(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye) KENOSHA, Wis. – Less than 48 hours after posting bail on felony drug and threat charges, a Kenosha man is back in court facing new allegations that he violently confronted a roommate over a demand for a ride to buy crack cocaine. You must be logged in to

Salem Lakes Man Accused of Punching Elderly Wife, Faces Felony Abuse Charges

SALEM LAKES, Wis. — A 60-year-old man was charged Monday with felony elder abuse and misdemeanor disorderly conduct after allegedly punching his wife in the face during an argument at their mobile home on Sunday. Case G. Marcussen, of Salem Lakes, appeared in court the same day the criminal complaint was filed. Court Commissioner William Michel II ordered a $1,000 cash bail. A

Kenosha Police to Host First-Ever Community Day and Movie Night at Tremper High School

KENOSHA, Wis. — The Kenosha Police Department will host its inaugural Community Day and Movie Night on Saturday, June 28, 2025, at Tremper High School, offering a full day of free family activities and public safety outreach. The event runs from 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. at the school’s campus at 8560 26th Ave., and will be followed by an outdoor showing of

Plus +

Secret Talks for Waterpark and Amphitheater Spark Uproar in Salem Lakes

Salem Lakes Village Hall(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye) SALEM LAKES, Wis. — A sweeping and potentially transformative development may be on the horizon in the Village of Salem Lakes — but many residents are furious they’re being kept in the dark. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Steil Secures $700K Federal Grant for Pike River Restoration in Kenosha County

KENOSHA, Wis. – Kenosha County will receive $700,000 in federal funding to support water quality improvements and habitat restoration along the Pike River, Congressman Bryan Steil announced Friday. The money, awarded through the Environmental Protection Agency’s Great Lakes Restoration Initiative, will go to the Kenosha County Division of Parks. The grant is intended to help restore more than 3,200 feet of streambank and

Plus +

Teen Charged in High-Speed Chase That Endangered Multiple Children

SOMERS, Wis. – A Kenosha teenager is facing six felony charges after allegedly leading deputies on a dangerous high-speed chase through residential neighborhoods with three juveniles in the vehicle, including two minors who had reportedly stolen a relative’s car. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Plus +

$17,500 Bail Set for Kenosha Man Caught with Fentanyl, MDMA, and Marijuana, Police Say

Elijah B. Echols, 27, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff) KENOSHA, Wis. – A 27-year-old Kenosha man with a violent criminal history is facing three new felony drug charges after police say they caught him with more than 30 counterfeit pills containing fentanyl and MDMA, along with a stash of marijuana hidden in his body. You must be logged in to view the rest of

Somers Man Accused of Assaulting Elderly Housemate, Obstructing Arrest

SOMERS, Wis. — A 61-year-old Somers man is facing felony charges after allegedly assaulting his elderly housemate and refusing to cooperate with sheriff’s deputies during a chaotic arrest at a deteriorating home in the Town of Somers. Nick W. Picazo was formally charged Friday in Kenosha County Circuit Court with felony physical abuse of an elder person—intentionally causing bodily harm. He also faces

Plus +

Underwear-Clad Intruder Charged After Breaking Into Porch, Banging on Door

Phillipp Schiavi, 58, of Kenosha KENOSHA, Wis. — A 58-year-old Kenosha man is facing three criminal charges after allegedly running through a neighborhood in his underwear and trying to force his way into a stranger’s home while screaming profanities. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Plus +

Trio Charged in Kenosha Wallet Theft and Gift Card Scheme

Keir Saunders, 47, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff) KENOSHA, Wis. — Three suspects are facing felony charges after a Kenosha grocery store manager’s stolen wallet was used to buy over $1,200 in gift cards at Walmart last month. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Plus +

Salem Lakes Board Sparks Outrage After Voting to Let Convicted Predator Live Near Park, Boy Scout Camp

Child Predator Joshuah C. Koboldt, 40, of Salem Lakes (9416 276th Avenue)(Wisconsin Sex Offender Registry) SALEM LAKES, Wis. — The Salem Lakes Village Board ignited a firestorm this week after narrowly approving a convicted child predator’s request to live just steps away from a children’s park and Camp Wonderland, a well-known Boy Scout campground. You must be logged in to view the rest

Extreme Heat Warning: Kenosha County Reminds Residents of Available Cooling Centers

KENOSHA COUNTY, Wis. – With extreme heat warnings in effect this week, Kenosha County officials are urging residents to take precautions and make use of designated cooling centers throughout the area. Cooling centers are available at various municipal buildings, libraries, and community organizations across the county. These locations offer air-conditioned relief and are open to the public during the hours listed below: .

Plus +

Strangulation, Threats, and False Imprisonment: Kenosha Man Faces 10 Charges

Arturo L. Martinez III, 24, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff) KENOSHA, Wis. – A 24-year-old Kenosha man is facing ten criminal charges—including felony strangulation, false imprisonment, and threats to injure—after a woman reported months of domestic violence that allegedly occurred in front of their young children. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Plus +

Kenosha Man Charged in Drive-By Shooting at Family Party

Damien C. Wess, 24, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff) KENOSHA, Wis. – A 24-year-old Kenosha man is facing two felony charges after allegedly driving a getaway vehicle from a shooting that took place at a family gathering. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Paddock Lake Man Accused of Strangling Neighbor Over Property Dispute

PADDOCK LAKE, Wis. — A 54-year-old Paddock Lake man has been charged with felony strangulation and elder abuse after allegedly attacking his 66-year-old neighbor during a property line dispute on June 15 in the Village of Paddock Lake. Richard K. Ruck faces three charges: physical abuse of an elder person, strangulation and suffocation, and disorderly conduct. The criminal complaint, filed June 17 in

Free German-Style Pop-Up Biergarten Returns to Kenosha’s Lakefront July 17–19

KENOSHA, Wis. — A popular summer tradition is returning to HarborPark as the Hofbräu Pop-up Biergarten sets up along the lakefront from July 17 through July 19. The event is free to attend and promises three days of festive, family-friendly fun in the spirit of a traditional German Biergarten. Held at Celebration Place, 5501 Ring Road, the biergarten will serve authentic Hofbräuhaus beer

LATEST NEWS

Kenosha Detectives Warn Over 50 Attendees About Sophisticated Scams at Fraud Awareness Event

KENOSHA, Wis. – More than 50 people gathered at Ruffolo’s II on Monday evening as three Kenosha Police Department officers delivered a sobering, and at times startling, presentation about the explosion of fraud and scam activity targeting local residents. The presentation, led by Detective Chad Buchanan, Crime Prevention Officer John Wenberg, and fraud division newcomer Detective Tommar Franklin, offered real-life examples of scams

Plus +

Former Racine Prison Official Pleads Guilty to Reduced Charges in Inmate Sex Case

Jacqueline Heidt, 39, of Racine(Racine County Sheriff’s Office) RACINE, Wis. — A former corrections supervisor who once faced more than 800 years in prison for carrying on a sexual relationship with a prison inmate has pleaded guilty to five reduced charges in a deal struck with prosecutors Monday morning. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Full Parade Lineup Announced for 2025 Kenosha Civic Veterans Parade

KENOSHA, Wis. – The lineup is set for this year’s Kenosha Civic Veterans Parade, which will step off Sunday, June 29, 2025, in downtown Kenosha. Presented by Snap-on, the annual tradition honors the region’s veterans while showcasing dozens of community organizations, marching bands, local leaders, and first responders. The parade will feature five themed divisions and a robust pre-parade segment, with entries ranging

Plus +

Kenosha Man Accused of Severely Beating Elderly Wife When He Was Confronted Over Not Showering in Two Months

Michael R. Navrotsky, 67, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 67-year-old Kenosha man, and former corrections Sergeant is facing multiple felony charges after allegedly assaulting his elderly wife during a dispute that began when she asked him to take a shower for the first time in two months. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Plus +

Kenosha Man Accused of New Offenses Days After Release on Drug and Threat Charges

Ryan M. Phillips, 40, of Kenosha in Court(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye) KENOSHA, Wis. – Less than 48 hours after posting bail on felony drug and threat charges, a Kenosha man is back in court facing new allegations that he violently confronted a roommate over a demand for a ride to buy crack cocaine. You must be logged in to

Salem Lakes Man Accused of Punching Elderly Wife, Faces Felony Abuse Charges

SALEM LAKES, Wis. — A 60-year-old man was charged Monday with felony elder abuse and misdemeanor disorderly conduct after allegedly punching his wife in the face during an argument at their mobile home on Sunday. Case G. Marcussen, of Salem Lakes, appeared in court the same day the criminal complaint was filed. Court Commissioner William Michel II ordered a $1,000 cash bail. A

Kenosha Police to Host First-Ever Community Day and Movie Night at Tremper High School

KENOSHA, Wis. — The Kenosha Police Department will host its inaugural Community Day and Movie Night on Saturday, June 28, 2025, at Tremper High School, offering a full day of free family activities and public safety outreach. The event runs from 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. at the school’s campus at 8560 26th Ave., and will be followed by an outdoor showing of

Plus +

Secret Talks for Waterpark and Amphitheater Spark Uproar in Salem Lakes

Salem Lakes Village Hall(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye) SALEM LAKES, Wis. — A sweeping and potentially transformative development may be on the horizon in the Village of Salem Lakes — but many residents are furious they’re being kept in the dark. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Steil Secures $700K Federal Grant for Pike River Restoration in Kenosha County

KENOSHA, Wis. – Kenosha County will receive $700,000 in federal funding to support water quality improvements and habitat restoration along the Pike River, Congressman Bryan Steil announced Friday. The money, awarded through the Environmental Protection Agency’s Great Lakes Restoration Initiative, will go to the Kenosha County Division of Parks. The grant is intended to help restore more than 3,200 feet of streambank and

Plus +

Teen Charged in High-Speed Chase That Endangered Multiple Children

SOMERS, Wis. – A Kenosha teenager is facing six felony charges after allegedly leading deputies on a dangerous high-speed chase through residential neighborhoods with three juveniles in the vehicle, including two minors who had reportedly stolen a relative’s car. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Plus +

$17,500 Bail Set for Kenosha Man Caught with Fentanyl, MDMA, and Marijuana, Police Say

Elijah B. Echols, 27, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff) KENOSHA, Wis. – A 27-year-old Kenosha man with a violent criminal history is facing three new felony drug charges after police say they caught him with more than 30 counterfeit pills containing fentanyl and MDMA, along with a stash of marijuana hidden in his body. You must be logged in to view the rest of

Somers Man Accused of Assaulting Elderly Housemate, Obstructing Arrest

SOMERS, Wis. — A 61-year-old Somers man is facing felony charges after allegedly assaulting his elderly housemate and refusing to cooperate with sheriff’s deputies during a chaotic arrest at a deteriorating home in the Town of Somers. Nick W. Picazo was formally charged Friday in Kenosha County Circuit Court with felony physical abuse of an elder person—intentionally causing bodily harm. He also faces

Plus +

Underwear-Clad Intruder Charged After Breaking Into Porch, Banging on Door

Phillipp Schiavi, 58, of Kenosha KENOSHA, Wis. — A 58-year-old Kenosha man is facing three criminal charges after allegedly running through a neighborhood in his underwear and trying to force his way into a stranger’s home while screaming profanities. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Categories
Archives
Authors

Wake Up to What You Missed

Get notified of new articles. We'll never share your email address.