
KENOSHA, Wis. — Evan Braithwaite Jr., 17, of Kenosha, is facing a new felony and three misdemeanor charges after police say he accidentally shot himself in the leg with a handgun he was prohibited from possessing, then invented a story about a masked gunman that sent Kenosha police searching for a nonexistent suspect. The November 9 shooting comes less than nine months after Braithwaite was caught with a loaded handgun at Bradford High School and Kenosha County Circuit Court Judge Chad Kerkman (D) denied prosecutors’ request to try him as an adult. On Tuesday, November 17, Kenosha County Court Commissioner Daniel “Catch & Release” Kellum set only $3,500 cash bail for Braithwaite in the new criminal case.





The incident is renewing scrutiny of Kerkman’s earlier decision to keep Braithwaite in the juvenile justice system despite the seriousness of bringing a loaded firearm into a public high school. Although Braithwaite was subsequently adjudicated delinquent for a felony gun offense, he was back in the community and, according to prosecutors, illegally possessing another firearm when he seriously injured himself.
Kenosha County Eye first reported on March 25, 2026, that Kerkman had rejected a request by Kenosha County District Attorney Xavier Solis to prosecute Braithwaite as an adult following his February 11 arrest at Mary D. Bradford High School. The teenager was just 16 years old when school officials and a Kenosha police officer confronted him after receiving an anonymous tip that he might be carrying a weapon.
According to the earlier investigation, Braithwaite refused to cooperate with officers and became involved in a physical struggle before being subdued. Police recovered a concealed, loaded handgun from his possession, and the school was temporarily placed on hold while additional officers responded. School officials reported that no threats had been made against students or staff, but the discovery of the weapon raised serious safety concerns.
Solis confirmed to Kenosha County Eye at the time that his office had petitioned the court to transfer the case into adult court, but Kerkman denied the request. Sources also indicated that the Kenosha County Division of Children and Family Services recommended keeping Braithwaite in the juvenile justice system, believing that doing so was in both the teenager’s and the community’s best interests.
On April 29, 2026, Braithwaite was adjudicated delinquent in Kenosha County juvenile case 26JV24 for felony possession of a firearm on school grounds, misdemeanor obstructing or resisting an officer, and misdemeanor carrying a concealed weapon. The juvenile adjudication remained in effect when the latest criminal complaint was filed, making his subsequent possession of a firearm a new felony offense.
Because Braithwaite is now 17, Wisconsin law places his new criminal charges in adult court. Kerkman will not have the same opportunity to keep these new charges in juvenile court through the waiver process used in the earlier case.
A Mysterious Masked Gunman Who Never Existed
At approximately 4:17 p.m. on November 9, Kenosha police were dispatched to 4930 42nd Avenue for a report of a shooting. Officers found Braithwaite inside the residence wearing only his underwear and bleeding from what appeared to be a gunshot wound to his right thigh.
Braithwaite initially told investigators that he had been walking near apartment buildings on 50th Street when a masked stranger confronted him. He claimed the man asked what he was looking at, pulled out a handgun, and shot him in the leg before running away.
Police took the report seriously, establishing a perimeter, restricting radio traffic, and searching the area for the supposed shooter. Officers investigated locations near 4201 and 4111 50th Street, searched for evidence, and attempted to obtain surveillance footage from nearby businesses.
But investigators quickly encountered problems with Braithwaite’s account. They could not locate evidence of a shooting where he claimed it happened, and there was no blood trail connecting the supposed outdoor crime scene to his grandmother’s residence.
Instead, police discovered what appeared to be blood inside the home, including a pool near the kitchen stairs, droplets leading into the basement, and blood on a couch and blanket. Investigators also recovered a fired 9mm cartridge casing on the basement floor next to a PlayStation 5.
The search uncovered additional evidence, including multiple firearm magazines and ammunition of different calibers. In the backyard, police recovered a silver-and-tan Taurus G3 9mm handgun equipped with an extended magazine and a mounted flashlight and laser.
Braithwaite was transported to Froedtert Hospital and later to Children’s Hospital in Milwaukee, where medical personnel determined he needed surgery. Doctors recovered a bullet from his leg, which was subsequently turned over to police as evidence.
Teenager Changes His Story Before Finally Admitting He Shot Himself
On November 10, a Kenosha police detective interviewed Braithwaite at Children’s Hospital. This time, Braithwaite admitted that his original account was untrue, but he offered investigators an entirely different explanation.
Braithwaite claimed that an unknown acquaintance of a friend had come to his grandmother’s home and joined him in the basement to play PlayStation and smoke. According to this second version, the visitor began handling a handgun, repeatedly pointed it toward Braithwaite, and eventually placed the barrel against his leg before accidentally pulling the trigger.
Braithwaite claimed the visitor left with the firearm and that he went upstairs to tell his grandmother he had been shot. He also maintained that he was not allowed around firearms and had been concerned about the visitor handling a gun inside the house.
Investigators were not convinced. They had obtained surveillance video from November 8 that appeared to show Braithwaite carrying a concealed handgun with a mounted light as he entered the residence, contradicting his claims that he did not possess firearms.
When confronted with the video, the recovered firearm, and the ammunition and magazines found inside the home, Braithwaite finally admitted that he had accidentally shot himself. He told investigators that he was alone in the basement, pointing the handgun toward his leg, when he accidentally pulled the trigger.
Braithwaite also admitted that he had hidden the handgun outside after the shooting to make it harder for police and his family to find. What began as a report of a masked gunman roaming a Kenosha neighborhood turned out, according to the criminal complaint, to be a self-inflicted gunshot wound and a fabricated account that consumed police resources.
Community Reaction: Most Commenters Criticize Kerkman’s Decision
Following the filing of the new charges, Kenosha County Eye asked readers whether Kerkman had abused his judicial discretion by keeping Braithwaite in juvenile court earlier this year or whether the judge had made the appropriate decision by giving the teenager another opportunity. Among Facebook commenters who clearly expressed a position, most criticized Kerkman’s decision, although several defended the judge or argued that the teenager needed treatment and guidance rather than harsher punishment.
Jeremy Oster argued that the original Bradford High School incident should have resulted in adult prosecution. He wrote that anyone who brings a weapon into a school, threatens school safety, or creates a dangerous emergency should face adult criminal proceedings rather than having the matter handled exclusively in juvenile court.
Megan Weiss also called for tougher consequences for juvenile firearm offenses, arguing that young offenders should face meaningful punishment and that their guardians should share responsibility. She criticized what she described as a pattern of sweeping dangerous behavior aside while hoping teenagers will eventually change, saying society cannot continue expecting better outcomes by repeatedly giving offenders a slap on the wrist.
Kevin Hedges expressed frustration with both the teenager and those responsible for supervising him. “Charge the guardian and the kid to the fullest. It’s past the point of negligence,” Hedges wrote, reflecting concerns among commenters about how a teenager previously caught with a loaded gun at school could obtain another firearm.
Sarah Perez was similarly critical of giving repeated chances to someone accused of serious gun offenses. She argued that Braithwaite should be locked up, saying the earlier encounter with the justice system apparently failed to teach him a lesson and that he now needed to face more serious consequences.
Joe Madrid directly criticized Kerkman’s handling of criminal cases, writing, “More Kerkman decisions that make the community unsafe.” Madrid went further in his criticism of the Kerkman family, expressing frustration that he believes the public has failed to recognize the consequences of those decisions.
Max Mareci warned that repeated leniency could contribute to a cycle of increasingly serious criminal behavior. He expressed concern that judges who continue giving young offenders additional chances could eventually be dealing with far more serious offenses, potentially resulting in lengthy prison sentences after additional harm has already occurred.
A retired Kenosha police officer proposed an even more dramatic approach to judicial accountability. He suggested that lawmakers consider legislation imposing criminal responsibility on judges or other public officials who authorize the release of offenders who subsequently commit additional crimes, including potentially holding those officials responsible for the new offenses. His proposal was a personal opinion, not a description of existing law.
Some Readers Defend The Judge Or Call For Rehabilitation
Not everyone agreed that Kerkman should be blamed for what happened months after the original Bradford incident. Cody James questioned whether it was fair to judge a court’s earlier decision based on conduct that occurred afterward, writing, “Judging a judge for not judging the future is a strange request.”
James argued that the more important questions involve what legal options were actually available to Kerkman, what evidence was presented during the juvenile proceedings, and why the judge determined that keeping the teenager in juvenile court was appropriate. He emphasized that courts must follow the law and should not impose punishment beyond what the evidence and applicable legal standards permit.
Mary Ann Conforti also defended Kerkman’s original decision, although she believed additional intervention should have been required. “I think the judge did the right thing,” she wrote, while suggesting that mandatory therapy or other assistance might have helped the teenager address the behavior that led to his repeated involvement with firearms.
Conforti questioned where Braithwaite was obtaining guns and whether his parents or guardians had done enough to intervene. She described his behavior as a possible cry for help and suggested that influences in his home and surroundings deserved closer examination.
Melissa Kamer Schulz took a more measured approach, questioning whether the public had enough information about Braithwaite’s prior contacts with law enforcement, school disciplinary history, and access to firearms. She emphasized that the teenager should be held accountable but also questioned whether adults who may have supplied or failed to secure the weapons should share responsibility.
The responses illustrate a divide over how courts should handle teenagers accused of serious firearm offenses. While many commenters believed the original school incident warranted adult prosecution and stronger consequences, others maintained that juvenile court can be appropriate when accompanied by meaningful supervision, treatment, and accountability.
Four New Charges And $3,500 Cash Bail
Braithwaite was formally charged Tuesday, November 17, with felony possession of a firearm by a person previously adjudicated delinquent for a felony, misdemeanor possession of a dangerous weapon by a person under 18, misdemeanor obstructing an officer, and misdemeanor carrying a concealed weapon. The felony is punishable by up to five years of initial confinement in prison, if convicted.
During a brief initial appearance Tuesday afternoon, Braithwaite appeared in custody with attorney Lorenzo Rodriguez. Assistant District Attorney Morgan Millar appeared for the state, and Kenosha County Court Commissioner Daniel “Catch & Release” Kellum set $3,500 cash bail.
A preliminary hearing is scheduled for November 24, 2026, at 10:45 a.m. before Kellum. The criminal case has been assigned to Kenosha County Circuit Court Judge Jodi L. Meier.
The new case raises questions about whether the juvenile justice system adequately addressed Braithwaite’s earlier firearm offense and whether the supervision and interventions that followed were sufficient. Kerkman’s decision to deny adult prosecution did not cause Braithwaite to pull the trigger, but the teenager’s subsequent illegal gun possession, serious self-inflicted injury, and false account to police have renewed public scrutiny of the judge’s earlier ruling.
For those who criticized Kerkman’s decision in March, the November shooting has given them another reason to question whether keeping Braithwaite in juvenile court was appropriate. For those who supported that decision, the case presents a different question: what additional intervention might have prevented the teenager from obtaining another gun and seriously injuring himself?































8 Responses
Who knows when Kerkmam is up for re-election? Enough is enough. Just think, we fix his position, we fix the commissioner position too.
This coming April
Kerman to busy sleeping with personal in his court room to give a crap about whats going on in the streets.
Bad Chad needs to go…. At some point you have to hold the parent accountable…..
I’m fine with it. This kid will end up running his mouth to the wrong person and being dead in 3 years probably. It’s the way it should be. Or, maybe we get lucky and he accidentally shoots himself in the head.
Fucking piece of shit Dindo.
Oh look, another Braithwaite. Thats a bloodline that has contributed nothing but death and despair in this community. Its a shame they are allowed to reproduce and walk among us.
So his father is a coward who won’t stand his ground as well? Checks out.. 🖕pops.
Man I have no words free you