
RACINE COUNTY, Wis. — The Racine County Board of Supervisors took a significant step Tuesday evening, November 17, 2026, toward publicly releasing two previously confidential investigative reports involving former Sheriff’s Deputy Preston Kite and Captain Cary Madrigal, who was disciplined for her handling of misconduct allegations involving Kite. The development comes less than two weeks after Madrigal, the recently defeated Republican candidate for sheriff, was placed on paid administrative leave amid separate, unanswered questions about whether confidential information from a child pornography investigation involving Union Grove school administrator Thomas Johnson was improperly shared with Johnson or Union Grove Union High School Board President Diane Skewes, a political supporter of Madrigal.
The County Board’s Committee of the Whole met behind closed doors Tuesday to discuss the independent investigation conducted by the law firm Crivello, Nichols & Hall, as well as a pending personnel matter involving an employee of the Racine County Sheriff’s Office. After returning to open session, supervisors approved a motion directing Corporation Counsel to prepare a resolution that would waive attorney-client privilege and authorize the public release of two redacted investigative reports dated December 2, 2024, and February 4, 2025. The resolution is scheduled for consideration on December 8, when the County Board could finally authorize the release of records that county attorneys have previously argued should remain confidential.
The investigation dates back to early 2024, when Racine County Sheriff Christopher Schmaling commissioned outside attorneys to examine allegations involving Kite, a former deputy who was subsequently convicted of serious sexual offenses involving children and incarcerated. Because Kite worked for the Racine County Sheriff’s Office, the criminal investigation was conducted by the Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office to avoid conflicts of interest. The separate administrative investigation examined misconduct allegations, the handling of complaints, and the culture within the Sheriff’s Office.
According to a November 13 memorandum from Racine County Corporation Counsel Michael Lanzdorf, the outside investigation lasted approximately 12 months and included interviews with at least 13 witnesses, including Sheriff’s Office personnel and individuals associated with the courts. Investigators reviewed extensive records and examined firsthand experiences involving Kite, rumors and secondhand information about his conduct, and the department’s overall culture surrounding misconduct and the reporting of inappropriate behavior.
Although investigators reportedly found no evidence of widespread misconduct or sexual harassment throughout the Sheriff’s Office, they recommended additional training, improved reporting procedures, and an anonymous mechanism for employees to report concerns. More significantly, investigators recommended a personnel investigation into Captain Cary Madrigal concerning her response to allegations that another deputy had received inappropriate photographs from Kite. Those findings ultimately resulted in disciplinary action against Madrigal, including a 10-day unpaid suspension.
Kenosha County Eye previously reported extensively on Madrigal’s disciplinary problems and her unsuccessful attempt to prevent the public from obtaining records concerning her handling of the Kite allegations. The records raised serious questions about whether Madrigal properly addressed complaints involving a subordinate who would later face disturbing criminal charges. Madrigal challenged the disclosure of her disciplinary records in Racine County Circuit Court, but the county successfully defended its decision to release them, and a judge ordered the records disclosed on May 22, 2026.
Despite those disciplinary problems, Sheriff Schmaling publicly endorsed Madrigal in her unsuccessful campaign to replace him as Racine County sheriff. Kenosha County Sheriff David Zoerner also endorsed Madrigal, as did Racine County District Attorney Patricia Hanson (D) and Union Grove Union High School Board President Diane Skewes. Madrigal ultimately lost the November 3 election to Democrat Donald Vandervest by 2,439 votes, receiving approximately 48.5% of the vote compared with Vandervest’s 51.5%.
Just three days after losing that election, Madrigal was placed on paid administrative leave and prohibited from entering restricted areas of the Racine County Sheriff’s Office. An internal communication obtained by Kenosha County Eye announced the restrictions, and a Sheriff’s Office spokesman subsequently confirmed the communication was authentic. Neither the Sheriff’s Office nor Madrigal publicly explained the reason for her removal from normal duties, and Madrigal declined to comment when contacted by KCE.
The unexplained administrative leave came amid growing questions surrounding a separate investigation involving Thomas William Johnson, 51, of Burlington, the Union Grove Union High School District administrator charged with two felony counts of possession of child pornography. Johnson was arrested November 4 after Kenosha County investigators discovered two images suspected to constitute child sexual abuse material on his electronic devices. The investigation was initially handled by Racine County authorities before being transferred to Kenosha County because of the Racine County Sheriff’s Office’s close working relationship with the school district.
Court documents obtained by Kenosha County Eye revealed that Johnson had advance knowledge of the investigation before detectives formally interviewed him. Johnson acknowledged that someone from the Racine County Sheriff’s Office visited him at his school office on October 22 and discussed the investigation. Investigators subsequently documented deleted applications, missing internet history, and a factory reset of one of Johnson’s phones, raising concerns about whether potentially relevant evidence had been removed before investigators could conduct a complete forensic examination.
Perhaps even more troubling were Johnson’s statements concerning Union Grove Union High School Board President Diane Skewes. According to court documents, Johnson told investigators that Skewes had informed him his phones were clean. When questioned about how the School Board president could have known information concerning the examination of his electronic devices, Johnson reportedly suggested that someone from the Racine County Sheriff’s Office had contacted her.
Those revelations, combined with Madrigal’s sudden placement on administrative leave and her political relationship with Skewes, have fueled suspicions that confidential information from the Johnson investigation may have been improperly disclosed. One theory deserving scrutiny is whether Madrigal provided investigative information to Johnson or Skewes, who had publicly supported her campaign for sheriff. However, no publicly disclosed evidence establishes that Madrigal was responsible for any such disclosure, that Skewes improperly received confidential information, or that Madrigal’s administrative leave is connected to the Johnson investigation. The extent to which those suspicions are shared within law enforcement or the broader community has not been independently established.
The political relationships nevertheless raise legitimate questions about investigative independence. Schmaling, whose administration placed Madrigal on leave, supported her campaign. Zoerner, whose agency is investigating Johnson, also endorsed Madrigal. Hanson, the Racine County district attorney who could potentially be involved in a charging decision arising from a separate investigation within her jurisdiction, supported Madrigal politically, while Skewes, the School Board president identified in Johnson’s statements, also publicly backed her candidacy.
Kenosha County Eye previously contacted the officials involved seeking answers about the circumstances surrounding Madrigal’s administrative leave, the possibility of confidential information being shared, and whether an independent agency should investigate any allegations involving the sheriff’s captain. At the time of that reporting, no official had publicly established a connection between Madrigal and any improper disclosure. The unanswered questions are particularly significant because Johnson’s reported advance knowledge of the investigation and the condition of his electronic devices became important issues for investigators.
The Johnson investigation has also exposed additional allegations involving Danielle Marshall, 56, of Mount Pleasant, a longtime Union Grove Elementary School teacher who reportedly maintained a six- or seven-year extramarital relationship with Johnson. Court documents describe Johnson admitting to sexual encounters with Marshall at an elementary school and a hotel, along with sexually explicit voicemails, deleted electronic information, and inconsistencies investigators identified in statements provided during interviews. Marshall submitted a retirement or resignation request November 6, the same day Kenosha County Eye began questioning school officials about the allegations.
Union Grove Elementary School Superintendent Amber Torres told Kenosha County Eye that her district had not previously been aware of the alleged sexual encounters on school property and had not been contacted by law enforcement concerning Marshall’s involvement. Meanwhile, the Union Grove Union High School Board placed Johnson on unpaid leave pending investigations into his conduct and the criminal allegations. The investigation has raised questions about what school officials knew, when they learned it, and whether information was shared before Johnson’s arrest.
The County Board’s action Tuesday does not establish any connection between the earlier Kite investigation and the current Johnson investigation. The reports being considered for release concern the handling of misconduct allegations involving Kite, including Madrigal’s previous disciplinary problems, rather than the circumstances surrounding Johnson’s arrest or Madrigal’s November 6 administrative leave. Nevertheless, their potential disclosure could provide the public with a more complete understanding of how Sheriff’s Office leadership handled serious misconduct allegations involving one of its deputies.
In his November 13 memorandum, Corporation Counsel Lanzdorf defended the confidentiality of the outside investigation, arguing that disclosure could discourage witnesses from cooperating in future internal investigations and expose employees to privacy concerns or retaliation. He also maintained that the reports contained privileged legal advice, including assessments of potential litigation and legal risk. Lanzdorf acknowledged Wisconsin’s strong public policy favoring access to government records but cautioned that waiving attorney-client privilege could have lasting consequences.
The County Board now appears prepared to consider a different approach. Under the motion approved Tuesday, the proposed resolution would authorize release of two redacted reports, rather than the complete collection of investigative materials. The November 13 memorandum identifies three reports produced by the investigation, including two dated December 2, 2024, and a February 4, 2025 follow-up addressing a discrepancy in the timeline of events. The precise scope of the proposed redactions has not yet been disclosed.
County Board Chairman Tom Kramer said supervisors must balance investigative integrity, employee privacy, and legal obligations against the public’s interest in transparency and accountability. The decision to pursue a possible waiver of attorney-client privilege represents a notable development after months of controversy surrounding the investigation, Madrigal’s discipline, and the confidentiality of the underlying records.
For Madrigal, the potential release comes at a particularly consequential moment. She lost her bid to become Racine County sheriff, was placed on paid administrative leave days later, and remains the subject of unanswered questions concerning her employment status and the reasons for the restrictions imposed upon her. The previously documented disciplinary action involving Kite is established, while the more recent suspicions concerning the Johnson investigation remain unproven.
The Racine County Board is scheduled to consider the proposed resolution on December 8, 2026. If approved, the public could gain access to additional findings concerning the Sheriff’s Office’s handling of misconduct allegations involving Kite and Madrigal, while separate questions about Johnson’s advance knowledge of his investigation, Skewes’ reported statements, and Madrigal’s administrative leave remain unresolved.






























