Ajay Pierangeli Sentenced to 30 Years in Fatal OWI Crash That Killed Two Friends

Copied!
Ajay Gregory Pierangeli, 22, of Pleasant Prairie In Court Today
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

KENOSHA, Wis. — Nearly two years after a drunk driving crash killed two college students and shattered two families, Ajay Gregory Pierangeli was sentenced Thursday to 30 years in prison for the deaths of Dylan Zamora and Jenna Barrette.

Kenosha County Circuit Judge Anthony Milisauskas handed down the sentence in a packed courtroom, ordering 15 years of initial confinement for each victim—Zamora and Barrette—to be served consecutively, followed by 30 years of extended supervision, 15 years per count.

Ajay Gregory Pierangeli, 22, of Pleasant Prairie In Court Today
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

Pierangeli, 22, pleaded guilty earlier this year to two counts of homicide by intoxicated use of a vehicle. Two additional charges related to injuries suffered by other passengers were dismissed but read in for sentencing.

The courtroom was filled with friends and family members, many of whom wept as Dylan’s grandfather and Jenna’s mother gave powerful victim impact statements.

“He was my everything.”

Jon Heinz, Dylan’s grandfather, said he never had children of his own, but Dylan—his first grandchild—was the closest thing he had to a son.

“He was the greatest thing to ever come into my life,” Heinz said through tears. “He was the family rock. I was there for his first words, his first steps, his first time riding a bike. I wanted to be there when he graduated, when he had kids of his own. I’ll never get that now.”

He recalled the night of the crash in vivid detail, receiving a phone call that Dylan had died and letting out a scream he said still haunts him. “It sucked the soul right out of me.”

Heinz said Pierangeli’s actions on July 28, 2023, were not just tragic but arrogant. “A good friend would have said, ‘I’m too wasted to drive.’ He didn’t. And now my grandson is gone.”

“She was pure sunshine.”

Tammy Barrett, Jenna’s mother, described her daughter as “pure sunshine,” the kind of person who made everyone feel like they were the most important person in the room.

“She never said goodbye without saying ‘I love you,’” Barrett told the court. “She was supposed to be the maid of honor in her sister’s wedding. We lost her laughter, her future, and our future grandchildren. There are no more memories.”

Barrett expressed frustration that prosecutors had recommended 12 years for each victim. “I will never understand how my daughter’s life is only worth 12 years,” she said. “Ajay will walk out of prison someday. Jenna and Dylan never will.”

Assistant District Attorney Zachary Brost in Court Today
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

Prosecutor Calls Case ‘Gut-Wrenching’

Assistant District Attorney Zachary Brost described the crash as one of the most emotional cases of his career.

“This wasn’t just dangerous—it was deadly,” he told the court. “And this wasn’t even the defendant’s first OWI. His BAC was nearly .23. He hit the accelerator instead of the brake and crashed into a building at 50 miles an hour.”

Brost said police bodycam video showed a horrific scene and that officers were “flabbergasted” upon arrival. “There were five people in that truck. Only one was conscious. The others were already gone or clinging to life.”

He emphasized that Pierangeli made a choice that no one else did. “There’s no allegation that anyone was forced into that truck. But only one person took the keys. And that person had a duty not just to his friends, but to the public.”

Defense Highlights Acceptance and Character

Defense attorney Eric Olson said Pierangeli took full responsibility from the start and declined to challenge the case at trial.

“AJ made the mature decision not to contest this,” Olson said. “He said from the beginning, ‘This is all my fault.’ That kind of acceptance is rare.”

Olson pushed back against claims that Pierangeli was arrogant or reckless by nature. “Everyone at the party before the accident was there because of AJ. He worked at the Boys & Girls Club, won a Bully Buster award in high school, had no serious criminal history, and helped kids.”

Olson noted that Pierangeli attended Bible study twice weekly in jail and asked the judge for mercy, suggesting a 14-year sentence instead of 30.

Kenosha County Circuit Court Judge Anthony Milisauskas in Court Today
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

Judge Cites Aggravating Factors in 30-Year Sentence

Judge Milisauskas said he considered the gravity of the crime, Pierangeli’s prior OWI, the high speed of the crash, and the devastating loss to the victims’ families.

“You drove into a building. Two people died,” the judge said. “There has to be a serious consequence. Each life is precious. And your decision took that from two families forever.”

Milisauskas acknowledged Pierangeli’s remorse but said deterrence, public safety, and justice required a strong sentence. “This isn’t just a tragic accident. This is a preventable one. You made a decision. And others are paying for it with their lives.”

The judge sentenced Pierangeli to 15 years of initial confinement for each victim—served consecutively—and 15 years of extended supervision per count, for a total of 30 years in prison and 30 years on paper.


Ajay Gregory Pierangeli, 22, of Pleasant Prairie In Court Today
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

Apology from Defendant

Pierangeli addressed the court and the families directly.

“I failed as a friend. I failed as a brother. I failed as a son,” he said. “I would give anything to bring Dylan and Jenna back. I hate myself every day.”

He added, “If prison brings healing, even in the slightest, that is the good I hope for. I am so sorry. I will do whatever I can to atone.”

Looking Ahead

Pierangeli was credited with 714 days already served. If he serves the full 30 years of confinement, he will be nearly 50 years old when released.

Under Wisconsin law, homicide by intoxicated use of a vehicle is a Class C felony punishable by up to 40 years per count. While the state recommended 24 years total, Judge Milisauskas imposed a more sever punishment than the plea deal—15 years per victim.

“This sentence won’t bring Dylan and Jenna back,” Milisauskas said. “But it will send a message—and protect the community from something like this happening again.”

Ajay Gregory Pierangeli, 22, of Pleasant Prairie In Court Today
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)
Jenna Barrette and Dylan Zamora
(Legacy.com)

According to Jenna’s obituary:

“She loved spending time with her family, friends, and especially her cat Max. Her love for animals didn’t stop there as she worked at the Humane Society and fostered kittens and puppies in her free time. She also loved going to the beach and pool, working out with her sister, taking naps, and playing volleyball.

She played competitive volleyball since she was nine years old, including club, high school, and college. Jenna always lived life to the fullest. Just in the last few months, she completed her junior year of college, went on a Mediterranean cruise, and went to Summerfest and Country Thunder. Jenna made everyone around her feel special and loved. Countless people thought of her as their best friend. She had a smile and personality that would light up any room she walked into. Although many are grieving here, Jenna ultimately fulfilled her purpose on earth, and God called her home to Heaven.”

According to Dylan’s obituary:

“Born on July 20, 2001, in Kenosha; he was the son of Erin Zamora.

He was educated in the schools of Kenosha and was a graduate of Tremper High School. He was attending the University of Wisconsin Parkside as a senior pursuing a Bachelor’s degree in Health Sciences with the goal of becoming a Physician’s Assistant.

He was an avid lover of all sports, especially soccer, having spent four years on the Tremper soccer team. In his younger years, he played a season of CYC football for the Bears, which didn’t bode well with him as he was a Packer’s fan.

He also greatly enjoyed video games, playing online with friends from all corners of the world. He loved animals, especially dogs and would always talk about how he wanted to have the biggest dog possible someday. He enjoyed traveling and loved going to Minnesota to see his many relatives. He recently shared his aspirations of someday moving to Seattle and raising a family of his own.”

Memorial For Jenna Barrette
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)
Memorial For Jenna Barrette
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)
Memorial For Jenna Barrette
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)
Memorial For Jenna Barrette
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

Author

Copied!
LATEST NEWS

36-Year-Old Kenosha Man Critically Injured In Sheridan Road Motorcycle Crash; Police Searching For Driver Who Allegedly Left Scene

KENOSHA, Wis. — A 36-year-old Kenosha man was seriously injured in a motorcycle crash on Sheridan Road at around 8:20 p.m. Thursday, and police were searching for another driver who witnesses said may have been involved and fled the scene.. The crash occurred in the 7800 block of Sheridan Road, also known as State Highway 32. According to Kenosha Police Department scanner traffic,

KUSD Ends Districtwide Free Meal Program At 17 Schools, Citing Depleted Food Service Reserves And $250,000 Monthly Cost

KENOSHA, Wis. — Kenosha Unified School District families are facing a significant change to the district’s school meal program this year, with 17 schools no longer participating in a program that previously provided breakfast and lunch to every student at no charge regardless of household income. The change has generated questions and calls from parents during the opening days of the 2026-27 school

MORE TOP STORIES

Kenosha Unified Girls Make History With First-Ever Flag Football Games

KENOSHA, Wis. — About 70 girls from Kenosha Unified School District made school history Wednesday, taking the field for the district’s first-ever girls flag football games. Teams from Bradford, Indian Trail and Tremper high schools competed Sept. 2 at Hammes Field at Racine Case High School as part of the

Kenosha County Sheriff Lied To Community About Flock Investigation, Like He Has So Many Times Before: Kenosha County Eye Has The Receipts

KENOSHA, Wis. — Kenosha County Sheriff David Zoerner told the public that his administration took the Frank McGrath Flock scandal seriously “from the outset” and made sure the matter was independently reviewed for possible criminal conduct. Newly obtained records tell a much different story. The evidence shows the Sheriff’s Office

Kenosha Mayor, Police Chief Defend License Plate Readers, Tout Crime-Solving Successes And New Privacy Guardrails

KENOSHA, Wis. — Kenosha Mayor David Bogdala and Police Chief Patrick Patton issued a joint statement Thursday defending the city’s use of Automated License Plate Reader technology, pointing to several major criminal investigations in which the technology assisted police while emphasizing new restrictions intended to protect residents’ privacy. The statement

$805 a Case: How Kenosha’s Flat-Fee Public Defender Contract Pays a Lawyer to Avoid Trial

Kenosha County Eye has obtained, through a public records request to the Wisconsin State Public Defender’s Office, the contract governing Attorney Aileen Henry’s fixed-fee misdemeanor defense work for indigent clients in Kenosha County. The numbers in that contract, combined with what CCAP shows about Henry’s current caseload, describe a payment

Categories
Archives
Authors

111 Responses

  1. Jenna was a very special young lady. I did not know Dylan.
    This man surely deserves punishment, but the other 4 made their own bad decisions that night. I think the 24 years would have been more appropriate.

    40
    21
      1. Ajay’s Kenosha extended Italian family-network is certainly quite the group. Ajay, a year younger than Dylan, beat Dylan up bad enough a year prior puttlng him in the hospital. That Dylan continued with “bad hang” Ajay, including his clownish drunken behavior immediately prior to his instant death illustrated either/or very compromised judgment and/or or some form of Stockholm psychological syndrome connection to Ajay. Nevertheless, it’s very regrettable that Dylan, who had a future, lost his life. Kudos to Judge Milasauskas for imposing the 30 year sentence, ensuring proper time in the WI Big House Cooler for the young Italian bully. Should Ajay survive his sentence, hopefully he will be converted to evolve into becoming a spiritually wise man upon his release.

        22
        5
          1. Being drunk is not the clownish behavior…. Its the fact he decided to drive while hammered and killed people genius

        1. A reply to this…Dylan never went to the hospital after her attack from Ajay. He never shared with family. This incident with photos was shared after my grandsons death. Dylan did distance himself from Ajay for along time. As far as Dylan a passenger at the time of the crash, he was in the back seat. Dylan didn’t deserve what happened to him. Jenna either. They trusted a friend who was driving.

          15
    1. Yes, the mistake from Jenna of picking Ajay out of the group to drive after testing him by making him “walk the plank” & Dylan by hanging out the window blowing kisses at the ambulance they’ve brought up in court multiple times (talk about a distraction while trying to drive your friends home). Quincy & Alex for getting in the car & letting their friends also get in it, Ajay has accepted responsibility as shown in his moving statement today, what about the others?

      24
      22
        1. Doesn’t murder require intent and even premeditation? I think you might be posting on the wrong article.

          11
          2
          1. Ajay intentionally got behind the wheel almost 3 times the legal limit. He made that decision intentionally. He knew the consequences of driving drunk as he flipped a car drunk driving at 17. He just never got caught drunk driving between 17 and 20 years old. which makes him underage. The law needs to be changed, to reflect killing someone while driving drunk is murder.

            8
            2
            1. His parents should have gotten him help a long time ago not just his Italian father how about his non Italian mom. People r focusing on his Italian background. He’s half Italian.

        1. Isn’t there a concept called contributory negligence? Spreading the blame seems reasonable here.

          15
          2
          1. Go fuck yourself Birdwatcher sick of your bullshit comments We
            Got justice today for Dylan amd Jenna!

            10
            9
          2. You should go to school. become a lawyer, then a judge. The Judge would not entertain culpability. I believe he knows more than you.

            3
            1
      1. How is someone doing something not in the front at all, how could that ever distract him:..fyi that wasn’t near where Ajay crashed!!!!

        3
        2
        1. Not a fukking Zamora saying that lol that’s comical. 90 percent of zamoras are trash. You had me until your last comment.

          5
          1
      2. the others are dead. i’m sorry but how much accountability can they take? he literally took their lives by getting behind that wheel. no other details matter

  2. RIP where you there for every court hearing? I think the Judge was being lenient with 30 years. Ajay got behind the wheel, not the others, Ajay was arrogant enough to think he could drive drunk, and crash into a building while doing 50+ mph, hitting the accelerator to the floor instead of the brake. Don’t even think that blaming the dead deserves a lighter. sentence. Until you hear all the facts, don’t make ignorant comments.

    Kevin, thank you for factual reporting, and being at the courthouse today.

    22
    16
    1. 30 Years !! Kid didn’t see that coming.

      But he got it. Every person that knows him or the ones who died can think twice about driving drunk.

      That’s why I’m happy the judge gave him consecutive sentences.
      Though it really should be life !
      He took life. We should take his

      17
      6
  3. 20yrs would have been harsh, 15 total probably fair. Didn’t follow this case, but how is a DWI first offense not even a felony, yet when death occurs you get 30yrs? Seems like intentional homicide levels of punishment.

    8
    15
  4. There’s no excuse for committing murder. Why is anyone even doubting this?!? The blood alcohol level of anyone not driving isn’t an issue. They didn’t commit a crime.😡. What the f***. DON’t Drink and drive!!!!!!! There’s no way excuse for the stupidity

    17
    2
    1. I agree with this punishment he should have never been driving ANYONE..when drunk and being his second offense is just ridiculous…the laws are so bad with OWIs that people think they can keep getting away with it…bc they CAN and then finally something bad happens and it’s awful….I also think that there is some fault with those who also got in the car with AJ we reach out kids to never get in the car with a drunk driver EVER…it’s not a hard thing to do they have a job to do too by keeping themselves and their friends safe.

      14
      1
  5. This whole deal is tragic. Such great lives lost. My thoughts and prayers are with those who lost loved ones, and I hope the family of the family of Ajay realizes their part in this mess. I hope they realize that he is still alive, something others do not have that convince. The loss is real, and so are the consequences.

    8
    2
  6. Judges who accept and then exceed plea bargains are just asking for more trials. I hope the defense attorney on this case remembers that next time the state offers to recommend X years in exchange for a plea in front of this judge. Make them all pay with a jury trial. The final sentence wouldn’t have been any worse.

    10
    6
    1. This judge is retiring, so he does not care.
      The rest of the judges who play for the press had better be ready to work. Lots of week long trials coming; cancel your Wednesday golf leagues.

      3
      6
    1. It dosent matter who bought the alcohol it is illegal to drink and drive especially your sending offense!

      3
      6
      1. Erin I was on your side until you made a wildly racist comment. But I also hear you abandoned your child. So maybe white knight somewhere else.

        11
        1
    2. likely
      One of the others as Ajay was the only one still 20… they were drinking at his girlfriend at the time Allie stone’s who was also not 21 at the time.. the barrettes told everyone that’s where they were that night so I’d assume it’s true

  7. This isn’t the FIRST time he violated the law regarding alcohol use, this is not even the SECOND time he committed an alcohol or drug related violation and was caught (seems nobody looked hard enough to see there was indeed a second citation issued for underage alcohol use which resulted in a forfeiture and an education opportunity), this is the THIRD OFFENSE (that he was caught for) and sadly, the very thing many of us tried desperately to prevent. He was warned, he had every chance imaginable, this sentence does not serve justice. He should be incarcerated the maximum amount of time allowed by law- he used up his “second chances” a long time ago.

    I’m so sorry to the families, friends, and loved ones of the victims. I’m so sorry this happened, you’ll be in my prayers forever.

    Ajay- you deserve every moment of your prison sentence. You were warned, you were offered every chance under the sun to get help, and you rejected those offers. You manipulated the system at every stop, and your parents did you no favors by attempting to mitigate, minimize, and control the narrative every time there were consequences to your actions. This is what happens when you choose to ignore those trying to help you. See ya in 30 buddy- we’ll be waiting for your call, again.

    43
    4
    1. PS- the next time you feel compelled to complain about “all the hoops you have to jump through” and “how much it costs” and about “how hard everyone makes it” to resolve an OWI – I hope you think about this case and consider that every single instance of impaired driving can have this exact same deadly result- some people just get lucky and only get arrested….

      34
  8. Erin Zamora,
    Aren’t you the addict who lost custody of your son when he was 7 years old? Your poor old mother had to raise him.

    Both of these kids would be alive if they were wearing their seat belts.

    The crash was through a glass window, not a brick wall.

    19
    21
    1. I’m pretty sure I saw bricks laying on the ground. Hitting something while going 50mph is an impact as if he was doing 100mph.

      5
      3
    2. I’m sorry but who are you ??
      you know nothing about our family
      and she will forever be more of a mother then you or whoever this we ever be thank you !!!

      6
      3
    3. What kind of person speaks to the mother of a dead child this way? She is in pain and grieving an unbearable loss. Her past, good or bad, has absolutely no bearing on what’s happened. Heaven forbid you ever have to feel the pain this woman is suffering and if so, I pray you never experience the callous cruelty you’ve displayed here anonymously. If you’re a family member of the young man convicted, I understand how painful it must be as well but lashing out at the victims families is not what a truly repentant person would want his family to be doing.

      Ms. Zamora, your pain is palpable and pray you find a way to live through your loss with some semblance of peace.

      14
      1
      1. I get the impression she is the type to use this for sympathy…..she obviously didn’t care enough for her kids when she lost custody of them.

  9. Kenosha County Case Number 2023CT000317 State of Wisconsin vs. Erin M. Zamora
    Get a license!
    Kenosha County Case Number 2019CM000221 State of Wisconsin vs. Erin M. Zamora
    Stop stealing from stores!

    13
    13
    1. You people are sickening! What happened to her son is NOT her fault it’s Ajay’s!! Have some respect for the deceased for christ sake!

      12
      4
      1. It is her partly the mom’s fault, though. She seems like a POS given her CCAP.
        Like, how many kids does she have with different guys? Driving after revocation, retail theft…..like yeah, there is way more to the story here.

        Where was his father?

        Tragic situation but there is lots of blame here…but let’s be honest, those having kids at like 20 and that whole generation now….it’s not surprising.

        7
        5
        1. she’s amazing once you get too know her
          Let’s stop leaving hate comments on someone who’s still grieving her very own son’s death pls .

          what does looking back at his moms past have to do with Ajay !!

          I grew up with Dylan and Dylan always loved his mom his family

          They don’t deserve this hate
          For both families deserve more 🤍

          7
          4
          1. Once you “get to know her”?

            Please STFU. No one who has kids with tons of guys, is stealing shit in her late 30s according to CCAP and supposedly lost custody of her child is “amazing” once you get to know her.

            Sounds like the trainwrecks you see profiled on this site all the time….professional victims, always an excuse as to why they committed their behavior, etc.

            This basically describes both sides of this case. Bad parenting….no responsibility. There are a 100 mothers like this in Kenosha….

            10
            3
            1. again this is about two families who lost there children
              please get out the comments with negative comments

              Justice was served for them 🤍

              Dylan and Jenna were both amazing young people

              5
              3
              1. Wow whomever posted the original comment is a total waste of space. What a loser!! “I’m mad and am gonna pout and victim blame”
                Such a douche

        2. Why anything about me is important to
          You or anyone else is beyond me but my parenting or who I am or my past my kids is none of anyone’s business. Ajay and his family did this crime!

          4
          2
          1. Erin, why anything about YOU is important to anyone else, is because you repeatedly made blanket comments blaming Ajays family as well as degrading all Italians. If you don’t want mud slung at your parenting or lack thereof, then don’t do it to others, because you sure as hell are not a perfect person nor a perfect parent.

    2. I say try ajay for death row. But me personally I can’t wait till the little bitch hangs himself so I can piss on his grave during the funeral 💨💨💨 smoking ajay pack rn😂😂😂

      6
      8
      1. You’d probably have to wait until AFTER the funeral to “piss on his grave.”
        What does “smoking ajay pack rn” mean? Please decode.

        6
        2
        1. Nah during the funeral. Anybody gotta problem with it can catch an asswhooping. And it mean I hope they burn his fucking body before his bitch ass family can pick him up.

          1. Okay, have it your way, but the casket won’t be in the grave until AFTER the funeral. So judge the wind direction carefully before you start “pissing” upwards.

  10. AJ got what he deserved! He had 1 too many chances too straighten his shit out but chose not too so this is what happens.

    11
    1
  11. Kenosha County Case Number 2019CM000221 State of Wisconsin vs. Erin M. Zamora

    The defendant Erin M. Zamora was found guilty of the following charge(s) in this case.

    Retail Theft – Intentionally Take (<=$500), a class A misdemeanor, Wisconsin Statutes 943.50(1m)(b).

    Are you so high you forgot about your retail theft conviction?

    6
    11
    1. IS THIS UR BUISNESS ???

      She lost her son

      Ajay DESERVES WHAT HE GOT !!!
      fix you’re own family problems and get the fuck out of this one
      LOOK AT AJAYS FAMILY RECORD IF YOU RLLY WANT TO GET TO COMPARING PLS
      I WILL PULL EVRYTHING
      HIS DEADBEAT MOM AND DAD GRANDPARENTS
      COME ON

      15
      3
    2. You’re such a dumbass, only a real loser would victim blame.
      Get a life, glad AJ is rotting in prison.

    3. What does theft have to do with this. Also the young lady in Ohio who ran into a building and killed her boyfriend and friend got life shes 17. Look it up Mackenzie Shirilla. So he got off easy.

      5
      1
  12. Is Ajay a giver or taker? I’ll bet he’s a taker. After 30 years in prison, 50 year old Ajay’s prostate exams will interesting.

    6
    7
  13. This is the problem with the world. The cruel words and judgments, about all parties, should have you hoping and praying that you can live a long and healthy life. Fate has something in store for us all.

  14. Maybe this little shit can make pizza In prison for his fellow inmates. Justice has been served, 30 years is the perfect sentence.

    4
    2
  15. This might be an unpopular opinion but I believe Ajay should be allowed out of prison a few times a year to speak to high schooler’s. The benefits would be two-fold: 1) His personal testimony could be powerful enough to prevent future drunk drivers. 2) It would honor the victims by keeping names and life stories prevalent.

    18
    3
  16. Sometimes the creatures crawl out from under the rocks like in this case.
    A child made some horrible decisions and he will pay.
    When u say nasty vile things about this boy you also say it about everybody who cared for him
    Please have respect for them and yourselves

    11
    1. Yes, we should show respect to his mommy, Amber. Believe she is facing some felonies herself. This family is TRASH!

        1. Are you stupid? Her son was just sentenced to 30 years in prison. His life probably would have taken a different trajectory if he didn’t have shit parents.

  17. Too lenient. Anybody that drives drunk, and kills somebody deserves a harsher sentence than that.
    And I bet plenty of you making comments, drive over the limit yourselves. This should be a wake up call,
    but it won’t be. Why? Because you can’t fix stupid. And people that cause the same harm TEXTING, deserve
    the same fate. Wake the fuck up people!!!

    3
    1
    1. Yes – and driving recklessly even if totally sober and clean also ….
      Reckless driving is Attempted Murder – multiple.

  18. Their lives were only with 15 years a piece. Sad. He chose to drink and drive. He chose to do it even after doing it before. He will get out in his 50’s, he will have a chance to make a life for himself in some way. His victims won’t. No college graduation. No careers. No weddings. No opportunity to become parents. He stole that from them. A selfish child that thinks of nothing but himself.

    12
  19. Sad all the way around. No winners here.

    Another judge jumping a plea deal. Pretty soon there’s going to be zero reason to take a plea around these parts.

    6
    2
    1. The Italian should have taken his chance and pleaded not guilty. a guilty verdict may have resulted in less time.

      1
      1
  20. May all involved seek the Lord in the heavens to bring his Grace and mercy beyond what we can comprehend.

    11
    1
  21. The part that sucks about alcohol is it clouds your decision-making to drive. It is not as if he had his unimpaired brain making the decision to drive. His ability to make that decision was also impaired by the alcohol. I put some blame everywhere though mostly him. I was around when the drinking age 18. If I knew I was driving, I bought 1 beer and nursed it for hours until it was warm and only drank half. The alcohol can hit you hard unexpectedly though at times if you have more than 2. If you are a passenger, just take the keys away if your driver drunk. If all of you drunk, then take the Uber. 3 lives ruined or over because of that night. Complete tragedy and this a good kid outside of one poor decision. I do not blame the mother asking for more than 12 years. Her life is ruined forever. She will never have peace.

  22. He should just been smoking, right Heywood? LOL! Ignorance is your forte!

    If that word is above you, look it up in dictionary. You seem to know right where the “F” words are.

  23. As a Behind the Wheel instructor this situation should remind us all never take the risk of getting in the car in which you are aware the driver is impaired. If your gut feeling is that the consequence could be bad. Base your Decision on your gut. Like was in prior poster said call Uber, call a friend or family member. No matter how many times I stress this example to my students of what happens when poor choices are made unfortunately these type of under the influence fatalities will continue in the future until convicted drivers are given the harshest penalties. Don’t be impulsive be disciplined to make the right decisions. Remember the cliche nothing positive happens on roadways after midnight.

  24. What gives anyone the right to comment on this? Ya’ll are really hashing out some personal problems with grief ridden individuals and exposing your prejudices behind a screen instead of taking this tragedy for what it is. Why can’t we just give our condolences to all that have had to suffer these past 2 years and aim to make sure no one else has to go through such a soul sucking experience instead of hurting people who are already hurting?

    9
    1
  25. You should be investigating his mother who has been charged with stealing several thousands of dollars from her employer.

  26. This whole posting and all the comments are so very sad. I think all of you posters should think about getting some counseling.

    7
    3
  27. Articles state .23 others .28….. that young man was a maintenance drunk!! This was NOT a one off!
    To be at that level… shame on everyone in his life for not trying to get him sobered up.
    Now he has a life of prison and 2 souls on his docket……..

    1
    1
  28. What upsets me about this situation is that this entire group of kids partied every weekend, and I can’t help but wonder how many of them got in their cars and drove after drinking. I’m not saying AJay isn’t responsible I believe he should be held accountable, and maybe 10 or 15 years would have been fair. But where is the conversation about the responsibility we all have to prevent these situations?

    As a mother, I’m going to teach my kids not only to never drink and drive, but to also never let their friends do it either. I’m going to teach them not to get in the car with someone who’s been drinking. We need to raise kids who have the courage to speak up and protect each other, even when it’s uncomfortable.

    Every single one of those kids partied every weekend. Every memory they post with the friends they lost involves drinking. I’m not saying drinking at 21 is abnormal. I’m not saying they were bad kids. I’m saying this behavior was normal for their group and that’s the problem.

    This whole situation is tragic for everyone involved, including AJay’s family. Why weren’t the kids in the back wearing seatbelts? I have so many questions, but at this point, what’s done is done. Their lives won’t come back. AJay made a terrible decision, but so did the rest of them they just didn’t face the same consequences. He became the one to pay the price for what all of them were doing regularly.

    I truly hope they all learn from this. I know some of that group is still drinking, and I just hope they’re not still driving.

    7
    4
    1. You have made many TRUE and valid points and I completely wholeheartedly agree with you! They all knew the potential consequences and all made the unimpaired decision to get in the car driving or not. It is just devasting on all counts on what had happened to all involved families and friends that night.

      1
      1
  29. This Pierangeli-Rizzo family is filled with people who think they are untouchable and that the rules do not apply to them. There have been multiple KCE articles about several family members. I am sure more is to come.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LATEST NEWS

36-Year-Old Kenosha Man Critically Injured In Sheridan Road Motorcycle Crash; Police Searching For Driver Who Allegedly Left Scene

KENOSHA, Wis. — A 36-year-old Kenosha man was seriously injured in a motorcycle crash on Sheridan Road at around 8:20 p.m. Thursday, and police were searching for another driver who witnesses said may have been involved and fled the scene.. The crash occurred in the 7800 block of Sheridan Road, also known as State Highway 32. According to Kenosha Police Department scanner traffic,

KUSD Ends Districtwide Free Meal Program At 17 Schools, Citing Depleted Food Service Reserves And $250,000 Monthly Cost

KENOSHA, Wis. — Kenosha Unified School District families are facing a significant change to the district’s school meal program this year, with 17 schools no longer participating in a program that previously provided breakfast and lunch to every student at no charge regardless of household income. The change has generated questions and calls from parents during the opening days of the 2026-27 school

Kenosha Unified Girls Make History With First-Ever Flag Football Games

KENOSHA, Wis. — About 70 girls from Kenosha Unified School District made school history Wednesday, taking the field for the district’s first-ever girls flag football games. Teams from Bradford, Indian Trail and Tremper high schools competed Sept. 2 at Hammes Field at Racine Case High School as part of the Donald Driver-Driven NFL FLAG Football League. Each school fielded a team of approximately

Second KUSD Mold Problem In Days: Bullen Middle School Closed Friday For Professional Remediation

KENOSHA, Wis. — Bullen Middle School will be closed Friday, Sept. 4, after staff discovered mold inside the building Thursday, marking the second mold-related disruption at a Kenosha Unified School District building in just days. Bullen Principal Matthew St. Martin notified families and staff Thursday evening that mold had been discovered in the building earlier in the day. According to the notice, KUSD’s

Kenosha County Sheriff Lied To Community About Flock Investigation, Like He Has So Many Times Before: Kenosha County Eye Has The Receipts

KENOSHA, Wis. — Kenosha County Sheriff David Zoerner told the public that his administration took the Frank McGrath Flock scandal seriously “from the outset” and made sure the matter was independently reviewed for possible criminal conduct. Newly obtained records tell a much different story. The evidence shows the Sheriff’s Office had already completed its internal investigation, had not referred criminal charges, and had

Kenosha Mayor, Police Chief Defend License Plate Readers, Tout Crime-Solving Successes And New Privacy Guardrails

KENOSHA, Wis. — Kenosha Mayor David Bogdala and Police Chief Patrick Patton issued a joint statement Thursday defending the city’s use of Automated License Plate Reader technology, pointing to several major criminal investigations in which the technology assisted police while emphasizing new restrictions intended to protect residents’ privacy. The statement comes as the city transitions away from the Flock ALPR system and toward

$805 a Case: How Kenosha’s Flat-Fee Public Defender Contract Pays a Lawyer to Avoid Trial

Kenosha County Eye has obtained, through a public records request to the Wisconsin State Public Defender’s Office, the contract governing Attorney Aileen Henry’s fixed-fee misdemeanor defense work for indigent clients in Kenosha County. The numbers in that contract, combined with what CCAP shows about Henry’s current caseload, describe a payment structure that a national body of legal scholarship says predictably produces exactly what

Financially Failing KTEC Public Charter School Spends More Than $132,000 With Local Marketing Firm, Uses Bizarre AI-Generated Children In Ads

KENOSHA, Wis. — A failing taxpayer-funded public charter school whose latest audit shows it lost nearly $380,000 in one year and ended the year nearly $250,000 in the red has recorded more than $132,000 in bills from a local marketing firm since June 2024, according to financial records obtained by Kenosha County Eye. The school’s independent auditors have repeatedly identified what they call

Police Say More Than 400 Child Pornography Files Found On Daybreak Youth Pastor’s Phone; 20 New Felonies Added

KENOSHA, Wis. — Prosecutors have added 20 felony child-pornography charges against Dale Robert Nixon, 43, of Kenosha, after police say a forensic examination of his cellphone uncovered more than 400 files of child pornography, also known as child sexual abuse material, or CSAM. The material described in the amended criminal complaint includes some of the most horrific forms of CSAM imaginable, allegedly depicting

Kenosha Metra Station Elevator Back In Service After Nearly Six-Month Replacement Project

KENOSHA, Wis. — The elevator at the Kenosha Metra Station is back in service after being unavailable for nearly six months while it was replaced. The City of Kenosha announced Thursday that the elevator at the station, located at 13th Avenue and 54th Street, is now operational following replacement with a new commercial elevator. Installation work began March 9, 2026, and the new

Plus +

Racine Man Charged With 4th OWI After Children Allegedly Said He Was ‘Driving Crazy’ And They Were ‘Scared For Their Lives’

Quintin Jacob Anderson, 42, of Racine(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 42-year-old Racine man was charged Thursday with a felony fourth-offense OWI after Kenosha police say he was found unresponsive behind the wheel of a running SUV. Quintin Jacob Anderson, 42, of Racine, is charged with OWI fourth offense, a Class H felony, possession of THC and two counts of misdemeanor

Plus +

Kenosha Man Charged With Felony 4th OWI Gets No-Cash Bail From Commissioner Kellum

George S. Hill, 46, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — George S. Hill, 46, of Kenosha, was charged Thursday with felony fourth-offense operating while intoxicated after police say he blew through a red light, admitted drinking at a nearby bar and failed field sobriety tests. Despite the new felony OWI charge and allegations that Hill was driving while revoked without a

Plus +

Somers Man Charged With Sexual Assault, Strangulation; $25,000 Cash Bail Set

Alejandro Stephen Morales, 20, of Somers(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) SOMERS, Wis. — Alejandro Stephen Morales, 20, of Somers, is facing two felony charges after a woman told Kenosha County sheriff’s deputies that Morales strangled her during an incident in July and raped her in August. Prosecutors charged Morales with second-degree sexual assault, a Class C felony carrying a maximum possible sentence of 40

Plus +

Twin Lakes Man Accused Of Grabbing Waitress’s Butt At Ace’s Bar, Charged With Sexual Assault

Curtis J. Mueller, 65, of Twin Lakes(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) TWIN LAKES, Wis. — Curtis J. Mueller, 65, of Twin Lakes, was charged Thursday with fourth-degree sexual assault and disorderly conduct after police say he grabbed and squeezed a waitress’s butt as he walked out of the men’s bathroom at Ace’s Bar. According to the criminal complaint, the alleged incident happened shortly before

Plus +

Trevor Woman Charged After Allegedly Calling 911 Claiming She Killed Her Father, Set House On Fire And Planned To Kill President

Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye) SALEM LAKES, Wis. — A 22-year-old Trevor woman was charged Thursday with misdemeanor disorderly conduct with a domestic abuse modifier after authorities say she called 911 and claimed she had killed her father, set her house on fire and was going to kill the president of the United States. According to the

Plus +

Kenosha Man Charged With Felony Strangulation After Allegedly Choking Girlfriend During Domestic Dispute

Hunter Lucas Crain, 20, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — Hunter Lucas Crain, 20, of Kenosha, was charged Thursday with felony strangulation and suffocation after police say he wrapped his hands around his girlfriend’s neck and choked her during a domestic dispute inside their Washington Road apartment. Crain is also charged with misdemeanor battery and disorderly conduct, both as acts of

Plus +

True To His “Catch & Release” Nickname, Kellum Catches A Big One And Throws Her Back: Woman Facing More Than 41 Years Gets Three New Felony Bail-Jumping Charges And No-Cash Bail

Krystyna M. Rogers, 36, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — Kenosha County Court Commissioner Daniel “Catch & Release” Kellum lived up to his nickname Thursday. Kellum caught a big one and threw her right back, figuratively speaking. Krystyna M. Rogers, 36, of Kenosha, is now facing 10 open criminal charges across four separate cases and a maximum of more than 41

As KUSD’s Numbers Keep Going Down, Jeff Weiss (D)’s Pay Keeps Going Up: Opinion

KENOSHA, Wis. — Kenosha Unified School District Superintendent Jeffrey Weiss (D) will receive well over a quarter-million dollars in salary and direct compensation for the 2026-27 school year, including a $240,261 salary and another $21,000 taxpayer-funded tax-sheltered annuity, for $261,261 before taxpayers spend another dime on his Wisconsin Retirement System pension contribution, health, dental, vision, disability and life insurance, retiree health and dental

Salem Lakes Trustee Resigns Months After Election; Residents Fear Tom Strachan Appointment Could Signal Return To Village’s Darkest Days

SALEM LAKES, Wis. — Salem Lakes Trustee Amanda Procknow has resigned just months after voters elected her to the Village Board, and some residents and Village insiders are sounding alarms over who may replace her. Sources tell Kenosha County Eye that former Salem Lakes Fire Commission Chairman Tom Strachan is poised to receive the appointment, with critics warning that putting Strachan back into

Plus +

16-Year-Old Already Out On Two Felony Bonds Charged In Kenosha Gunfight, Pistol-Beating Cases; $26,500 Cash Bail Set

John’trell J. Wright, 16, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 16-year-old Kenosha boy who was already out on cash bail in two separate felony cases is now facing two new felony prosecutions in Kenosha County, including allegations that he helped identify a target immediately before a gunfight erupted outside a Kenosha store and that he was involved in an earlier

Plus +

Bristol Man Accused Of Robbing, Attacking Elderly Parents Gets Only $5,000 Cash Bail

Andrew S. Willard, 41, of Bristol(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) BRISTOL, Wis. — A 41-year-old Bristol man accused of physically attacking both of his elderly parents, taking their cell phones and trying to prevent them from calling police was charged Wednesday with six criminal counts, including two counts of robbery with use of force and two counts of felony victim intimidation. Despite the serious

Plus +

“Catch & Release” Kellum Dismisses 12-Count Jail Sexual Assault Case Against Woman Already Facing Child Porn, Bestiality Allegations

Alyssa M. Schraeder, 31, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A new 12-count criminal case filed Wednesday against Alyssa M. Schraeder, 31, of Kenosha, who is already jailed while facing 17 felony charges involving allegations that she sexually assaulted and exploited her own young daughter and possessed child pornography, was dismissed within hours of filing by Kenosha County Court Commissioner Daniel

Plus +

Kenosha Man Charged With Felony After Allegedly Injuring Driver During Second OWI

Miguel Angel Moreno Juarez, 24, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) SOMERS, Wis. — Miguel Angel Moreno Juarez, 24, of Kenosha, is facing a felony charge after prosecutors say he drove drunk during his second OWI, crashed into another vehicle and injured its driver. Moreno Juarez is charged with felony operating while intoxicated causing injury, second or subsequent offense, second-offense OWI and failure to

Plus +

New York Man Accused Of Driving Drunk With Toddler In Car, Blows .256 — More Than 3 Times Legal Limit

Vincent Nsanzimfura, 31, of Tonawanda, New York(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 31-year-old New York man is accused of driving drunk on I-94 with his 2- to 3-year-old daughter in the back seat, speeding more than 85 mph and nearly striking other vehicles before registering a preliminary breath test of .256, more than three times Wisconsin’s general legal limit of .08.

LATEST NEWS

36-Year-Old Kenosha Man Critically Injured In Sheridan Road Motorcycle Crash; Police Searching For Driver Who Allegedly Left Scene

KENOSHA, Wis. — A 36-year-old Kenosha man was seriously injured in a motorcycle crash on Sheridan Road at around 8:20 p.m. Thursday, and police were searching for another driver who witnesses said may have been involved and fled the scene.. The crash occurred in the 7800 block of Sheridan Road, also known as State Highway 32. According to Kenosha Police Department scanner traffic,

KUSD Ends Districtwide Free Meal Program At 17 Schools, Citing Depleted Food Service Reserves And $250,000 Monthly Cost

KENOSHA, Wis. — Kenosha Unified School District families are facing a significant change to the district’s school meal program this year, with 17 schools no longer participating in a program that previously provided breakfast and lunch to every student at no charge regardless of household income. The change has generated questions and calls from parents during the opening days of the 2026-27 school

Kenosha Unified Girls Make History With First-Ever Flag Football Games

KENOSHA, Wis. — About 70 girls from Kenosha Unified School District made school history Wednesday, taking the field for the district’s first-ever girls flag football games. Teams from Bradford, Indian Trail and Tremper high schools competed Sept. 2 at Hammes Field at Racine Case High School as part of the Donald Driver-Driven NFL FLAG Football League. Each school fielded a team of approximately

Second KUSD Mold Problem In Days: Bullen Middle School Closed Friday For Professional Remediation

KENOSHA, Wis. — Bullen Middle School will be closed Friday, Sept. 4, after staff discovered mold inside the building Thursday, marking the second mold-related disruption at a Kenosha Unified School District building in just days. Bullen Principal Matthew St. Martin notified families and staff Thursday evening that mold had been discovered in the building earlier in the day. According to the notice, KUSD’s

Kenosha County Sheriff Lied To Community About Flock Investigation, Like He Has So Many Times Before: Kenosha County Eye Has The Receipts

KENOSHA, Wis. — Kenosha County Sheriff David Zoerner told the public that his administration took the Frank McGrath Flock scandal seriously “from the outset” and made sure the matter was independently reviewed for possible criminal conduct. Newly obtained records tell a much different story. The evidence shows the Sheriff’s Office had already completed its internal investigation, had not referred criminal charges, and had

Kenosha Mayor, Police Chief Defend License Plate Readers, Tout Crime-Solving Successes And New Privacy Guardrails

KENOSHA, Wis. — Kenosha Mayor David Bogdala and Police Chief Patrick Patton issued a joint statement Thursday defending the city’s use of Automated License Plate Reader technology, pointing to several major criminal investigations in which the technology assisted police while emphasizing new restrictions intended to protect residents’ privacy. The statement comes as the city transitions away from the Flock ALPR system and toward

$805 a Case: How Kenosha’s Flat-Fee Public Defender Contract Pays a Lawyer to Avoid Trial

Kenosha County Eye has obtained, through a public records request to the Wisconsin State Public Defender’s Office, the contract governing Attorney Aileen Henry’s fixed-fee misdemeanor defense work for indigent clients in Kenosha County. The numbers in that contract, combined with what CCAP shows about Henry’s current caseload, describe a payment structure that a national body of legal scholarship says predictably produces exactly what

Financially Failing KTEC Public Charter School Spends More Than $132,000 With Local Marketing Firm, Uses Bizarre AI-Generated Children In Ads

KENOSHA, Wis. — A failing taxpayer-funded public charter school whose latest audit shows it lost nearly $380,000 in one year and ended the year nearly $250,000 in the red has recorded more than $132,000 in bills from a local marketing firm since June 2024, according to financial records obtained by Kenosha County Eye. The school’s independent auditors have repeatedly identified what they call

Police Say More Than 400 Child Pornography Files Found On Daybreak Youth Pastor’s Phone; 20 New Felonies Added

KENOSHA, Wis. — Prosecutors have added 20 felony child-pornography charges against Dale Robert Nixon, 43, of Kenosha, after police say a forensic examination of his cellphone uncovered more than 400 files of child pornography, also known as child sexual abuse material, or CSAM. The material described in the amended criminal complaint includes some of the most horrific forms of CSAM imaginable, allegedly depicting

Kenosha Metra Station Elevator Back In Service After Nearly Six-Month Replacement Project

KENOSHA, Wis. — The elevator at the Kenosha Metra Station is back in service after being unavailable for nearly six months while it was replaced. The City of Kenosha announced Thursday that the elevator at the station, located at 13th Avenue and 54th Street, is now operational following replacement with a new commercial elevator. Installation work began March 9, 2026, and the new

Plus +

Racine Man Charged With 4th OWI After Children Allegedly Said He Was ‘Driving Crazy’ And They Were ‘Scared For Their Lives’

Quintin Jacob Anderson, 42, of Racine(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 42-year-old Racine man was charged Thursday with a felony fourth-offense OWI after Kenosha police say he was found unresponsive behind the wheel of a running SUV. Quintin Jacob Anderson, 42, of Racine, is charged with OWI fourth offense, a Class H felony, possession of THC and two counts of misdemeanor

Plus +

Kenosha Man Charged With Felony 4th OWI Gets No-Cash Bail From Commissioner Kellum

George S. Hill, 46, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — George S. Hill, 46, of Kenosha, was charged Thursday with felony fourth-offense operating while intoxicated after police say he blew through a red light, admitted drinking at a nearby bar and failed field sobriety tests. Despite the new felony OWI charge and allegations that Hill was driving while revoked without a

Plus +

Somers Man Charged With Sexual Assault, Strangulation; $25,000 Cash Bail Set

Alejandro Stephen Morales, 20, of Somers(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) SOMERS, Wis. — Alejandro Stephen Morales, 20, of Somers, is facing two felony charges after a woman told Kenosha County sheriff’s deputies that Morales strangled her during an incident in July and raped her in August. Prosecutors charged Morales with second-degree sexual assault, a Class C felony carrying a maximum possible sentence of 40

Plus +

Twin Lakes Man Accused Of Grabbing Waitress’s Butt At Ace’s Bar, Charged With Sexual Assault

Curtis J. Mueller, 65, of Twin Lakes(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) TWIN LAKES, Wis. — Curtis J. Mueller, 65, of Twin Lakes, was charged Thursday with fourth-degree sexual assault and disorderly conduct after police say he grabbed and squeezed a waitress’s butt as he walked out of the men’s bathroom at Ace’s Bar. According to the criminal complaint, the alleged incident happened shortly before

Plus +

Trevor Woman Charged After Allegedly Calling 911 Claiming She Killed Her Father, Set House On Fire And Planned To Kill President

Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye) SALEM LAKES, Wis. — A 22-year-old Trevor woman was charged Thursday with misdemeanor disorderly conduct with a domestic abuse modifier after authorities say she called 911 and claimed she had killed her father, set her house on fire and was going to kill the president of the United States. According to the

Plus +

Kenosha Man Charged With Felony Strangulation After Allegedly Choking Girlfriend During Domestic Dispute

Hunter Lucas Crain, 20, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — Hunter Lucas Crain, 20, of Kenosha, was charged Thursday with felony strangulation and suffocation after police say he wrapped his hands around his girlfriend’s neck and choked her during a domestic dispute inside their Washington Road apartment. Crain is also charged with misdemeanor battery and disorderly conduct, both as acts of

Categories
Archives
Authors

Wake Up to What You Missed

Get notified of new articles. We'll never share your email address.