Kenosha Couple Accused of Late-Night Brawl; Man Also Wanted in Illinois DUI Case

Copied!

Laura A. Garst, 31, and Derek A. Mardoian, 52, Both of Kenosha
(Kenosha County Sheriff's Office)

KENOSHA, Wis. — Two Kenosha residents are facing new charges after police responded to a late-night fight Wednesday at their shared home on 21st Avenue.

You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Already have an account? Sign in

Become a Member To Read this Article:

$ 5 Monthly

Immediate Access to Exclusive Content
In-depth investigative journalism
Reduced Ads

$60

$ 55 Yearly

Get your 12th month FREE
Immediate Access to Exclusive Content
Reduced Ads
Support Local Journalism

sale

Author

Kevin Mathewson

Kevin Mathewson is a disciple of Christ, husband and a father to two wonderful children. Mathewson was born and raised in Lake County, IL and worked as a police & fire dispatcher from 2005 to 2010 in Round Lake Beach, IL. Mathewson moved to Kenosha County in 2006, later being elected to the position of Alderman of the 8th District in 2012 and 2016. Mathewson is a private investigator, security contractor, journalist, and photographer. He enjoys spending time with his family, watching movies, camping and boating. His favorite amendment is the second, followed closely by the first. He loves his country and community.

View All Articles

Copied!

LATEST NEWS

Fire Causes Estimated $50,000 In Damage To Twin Lakes Home; Chief Credits Staffing And Volunteers

TWIN LAKES, Wis. — A fire at a home in the 200 block of Hawthorn Drive caused an estimated $50,000 in property damage Tuesday, October 27, according to Twin Lakes Fire/Rescue. No one was home when the fire broke out, and no injuries were reported. Firefighters were dispatched at approximately 12:05 p.m. after initial reports indicated smoke and flames were visible from the

October 27, 2026 3 Comments

Kenosha Defense Attorney Tells Client She’s ‘Stuck In Traffic,’ Never Shows Up — Court Records Place Her In Another County As Juror Questions Her Nose Ring, KCE Criticism

KENOSHA, Wis. — A Kenosha-area criminal defense attorney who has previously been the subject of multiple Kenosha County Eye investigations involving missed court appearances, client complaints, and disciplinary action is facing renewed questions after telling a client she was stuck in traffic and on her way to a deposition, only to never arrive. Court records show that attorney Mackenzie S. Renner appeared in

October 27, 2026 23 Comments

Two Brothers Accused Of Repeatedly Sexually Assaulting Two Girls Beginning Around Ages 6 And 7; Each Held On Half A Million Dollar Bail

Adrian J. Hernandez, 23, of Kenosha and (Mugshot Requested and will be Posted for brother)(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — Adrian J. Hernandez, of Kenosha, and his brother, Dacio R. Hernandez, of Pleasant Prairie, are accused of repeated sexual assaults in an investigation involving two girls. Kenosha County Court

October 27, 2026 5 Comments

Pleasant Prairie Clerk’s Office Sends Duplicate Absentee Ballots; Village Does Not Disclose How Many Voters Affected

PLEASANT PRAIRIE, Wis. — The Village of Pleasant Prairie Clerk’s Office, headed by Village Clerk Jane Snell, sent duplicate absentee ballot packets to voters just eight days before the November 3 general election, according to a village announcement Tuesday. The village said the employee responsible is no longer employed, but

October 27, 2026 24 Comments

Plus +

Twin Lakes Father Charged With Two Felonies After Allegedly Choking 12-Year-Old Son Twice, Leaving Boy Pretending To Be Unconscious

Dale B. Shaffer, 30, of Twin Lakes(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — Dale B. Shaffer, 30, of Twin Lakes, faces two felony charges after prosecutors say he twice choked his 12-year-old son, including lifting the boy off the ground by his neck during an attack in which the child

October 27, 2026 6 Comments

About 7,000 Lead Service Lines Remain In Kenosha; Families With Young Children Urged To Seek Replacement Assistance

KENOSHA, Wis. — Approximately 7,000 lead service lines remain across Kenosha, and the Kenosha Water Utility is urging households with children younger than 7 or a pregnant woman to contact the utility promptly about replacement assistance. For qualifying households, available funding could cover the full cost of replacing the pipes

October 27, 2026 3 Comments

Plus +

Career Criminal Accused Of Passing Out Drunk And Blocking Apartment Exit As Crying 10-Year-Old Son Sought Help; Kellum Sets No-Cash Bail

Devon S. Leedom, 31, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — Devon S. Leedom, 31, of Kenosha, a career criminal whose convictions include felony child abuse, felony fleeing and third-offense OWI, was granted no-cash bail Tuesday by Kenosha County Court Commissioner Daniel “Catch & Release” Kellum after prosecutors accused

October 27, 2026 7 Comments

Plus +

Zion Woman Charged With OWI 1st With 8-Year-Old Girl In Vehicle; Kellum Sets $500 Cash Bail

Brittani M. Elmore, 34, of Zion, Illinois(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) PLEASANT PRAIRIE, Wis. — Brittani M. Elmore, 34, of Zion, Illinois, is charged with first-offense operating while intoxicated with a passenger younger than 16 after police say she drove with an 8-year-old girl in the front seat following tequila consumption.

October 27, 2026 No Comments

Authors

Add a Comment Cancel reply

LATEST NEWS

Fire Causes Estimated $50,000 In Damage To Twin Lakes Home; Chief Credits Staffing And Volunteers

October 27, 2026 3 Comments

Kenosha Defense Attorney Tells Client She’s ‘Stuck In Traffic,’ Never Shows Up — Court Records Place Her In Another County As Juror Questions Her Nose Ring, KCE Criticism

October 27, 2026 23 Comments

Plus +

Two Brothers Accused Of Repeatedly Sexually Assaulting Two Girls Beginning Around Ages 6 And 7; Each Held On Half A Million Dollar Bail

October 27, 2026 5 Comments

Pleasant Prairie Clerk’s Office Sends Duplicate Absentee Ballots; Village Does Not Disclose How Many Voters Affected

October 27, 2026 24 Comments

Plus +

Twin Lakes Father Charged With Two Felonies After Allegedly Choking 12-Year-Old Son Twice, Leaving Boy Pretending To Be Unconscious

October 27, 2026 6 Comments

About 7,000 Lead Service Lines Remain In Kenosha; Families With Young Children Urged To Seek Replacement Assistance

October 27, 2026 3 Comments

Plus +

Career Criminal Accused Of Passing Out Drunk And Blocking Apartment Exit As Crying 10-Year-Old Son Sought Help; Kellum Sets No-Cash Bail

October 27, 2026 7 Comments

Plus +

Zion Woman Charged With OWI 1st With 8-Year-Old Girl In Vehicle; Kellum Sets $500 Cash Bail

October 27, 2026 No Comments

Plus +

Pleasant Prairie Man Accused Of Pushing 99-Year-Old Mother After Political Argument Gets Only $250 Cash Bail In Domestic Abuse Case

Craig R. Carver, 53, of Pleasant Prairie(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) PLEASANT PRAIRIE, Wis. — Craig R. Carver, 53, of Pleasant Prairie, is accused of pushing his 99-year-old mother during a confrontation at their home following a family argument about politics. Kenosha County Court Commissioner Daniel “Catch & Release” Kellum set only $250 cash bail Tuesday on charges of disorderly conduct with a domestic

October 27, 2026 16 Comments

A Comprehensive Look At “Jump Kick Man”: Man Who Attacked Kyle Rittenhouse During Kenosha Riots Has Extensive Criminal History And Close Ties To Financially Troubled Racine County Eye

KENOSHA, Wis. — Maurice James Freeland, 44, the man whose flying kick toward Kyle Rittenhouse was captured on video and seen around the world during the August 2020 Kenosha riots, is married to Jamie Freeland, who works in advertising and revenue generation for the financially troubled Racine County Eye and is now the executive director of Racine’s Senior Companion Program. A comprehensive investigation

October 26, 2026 24 Comments

Plus +

Kenosha Man Accused Of Trying To Stab Father Inside Home With Screwdriver While Children Watched, Released On No-Cash Bails Three Times Before Latest Arrest

Nazsir Tyrone Ellis, 25, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 25-year-old Kenosha man who was released on no-cash bail three separate times since July is now facing a felony burglary charge after police say he attempted to stab a man inside his home with a large screwdriver while the man’s children were nearby. Nazsir Tyrone Ellis appeared before Kenosha County

October 26, 2026 4 Comments

Downtown Kenosha Café Expands With Healthy Catering Options For Local Businesses, Launches “Wellness Wednesday” Lunch Delivery

KENOSHA, Wis. — A locally owned downtown Kenosha café is expanding its offerings, giving area businesses and residents a healthier alternative to traditional catering options. Southport Wellness Café & Smoothie Bar, owned by Meg Faulkner, has announced the launch of its new catering services, featuring freshly prepared meals, locally sourced ingredients and convenient delivery throughout the greater Kenosha and Pleasant Prairie areas. The

October 26, 2026 2 Comments

Plus +

Kenosha Man Gets $1,500 Cash Bail After Grappler Stop Of Stolen Audi; Resisting Charge Dismissed: VIDEO

Erick Castro Gomez, 25 of Kenosha (Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office)Crime Scene Photo by Incident Response KENOSHA, Wis. — Erick Castro Gomez, 25, of Kenosha, was ordered held on $1,500 cash bail Monday by Court Commissioner Daniel E. “Catch & Release” Kellum after prosecutors accused him of operating a stolen Audi stopped by Pleasant Prairie police using a Grappler device. Kellum also dismissed a

October 26, 2026 4 Comments

Plus +

Illinois Man Found Passed Out Behind Wheel On Kenosha Front Lawn With $12,000 Cash, Charged With Second OWI Just 18 Days After First Conviction, Released On No-Cash Bail

Demitrius D. Bryan, 34, of Zion, Illinois(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 34-year-old Zion, Illinois, man accused of driving drunk in Kenosha just 18 days after being convicted of his first OWI was released on no-cash bail Monday afternoon by Kenosha County Court Commissioner Daniel E. “Catch & Release” Kellum. Demitrius D. Bryan, who was arrested early Sunday morning, October 25,

October 26, 2026 4 Comments

Plus +

Kenosha Woman Accused Of Felony Hit-And-Run, Cocaine Possession Arrested 17 Months After Bench Warrant Issued

Ann-Marie Rose Stachura, 45, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 45-year-old Kenosha woman accused of running a red light, crashing into another vehicle, injuring its driver, and fleeing the scene was arrested Sunday, October 25, 2026, approximately 17 months after a bench warrant was issued for her arrest. Anna M. Stachura, also known as Ann-Marie Rose Stachura, appeared in Kenosha

October 26, 2026 4 Comments

Prosecutors Dismiss Third OWI Charge Against Genoa City Man After Defense Objects To Trial Adjournment

RANDALL, Wis. — A drunk driving case against a 64-year-old man originally charged with felony fourth-offense operating while intoxicated has been dismissed after prosecutors requested additional time before trial and the defense objected. The dismissal came more than a year after Michael Shawn Guilfoil, formerly of Genoa City and now listed as a Lake Geneva resident, was arrested following an incident in which

October 25, 2026 10 Comments

“The Difference Is Astounding”: Abel Sauceda Celebrates Completion Of Kenosha County Treatment Court

KENOSHA, Wis. — When Judge David Wilk first encountered Abel Sauceda in July 2015, he saw a man whose substance abuse and legal troubles had placed him on a troubling path. Eleven years later, Sauceda stood before the judge to celebrate completing Kenosha County’s Treatment Court — with a job, a driver’s license, a residence of his own and a safe place for

October 24, 2026 47 Comments

Kenosha County Residents Dispose Of Unneeded Medications At Five Drug Take Back Day Locations

KENOSHA, Wis. — Residents had an opportunity to clear unneeded medications from their homes Saturday, October 24, as five locations across Kenosha County hosted National Prescription Drug Take Back Day collection events. The free events also offered training and free supplies of Narcan, the overdose-reversing medication. The Kenosha County Division of Behavioral Health Services organized the events in partnership with the host sites.

October 24, 2026 7 Comments

Plus +

Kellum Cuts Bail In Half To $25,000 For Kenosha Man Accused Of Hellcat Street Race That Left Victims With Skull Fracture, Shattered Femurs

Jose Daniel Alvarez-Nunez, 27, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — Jose Daniel Alvarez-Nunez, 27, of Kenosha, appeared Friday, October 23, before Court Commissioner Daniel E. “Catch & Release” Kellum on four felony charges stemming from an alleged street race that left multiple people seriously injured. Although courthouse observers were surprised Kellum required cash bail at all rather than granting no-cash bail,

October 23, 2026 6 Comments

Kenosha Internet Troll “Sue Grace,” Husband Sued Over Allegedly Stiffing Local Contractor For Nearly $28K; Husband Files Bizarre, Error-Ridden Counterclaim

PLEASANT PRAIRIE, Wis. — Kenosha-area internet troll Susan Grace Castagnoli-Krokosz (D), 73, known online as “Sue Grace,” and her husband were sued for allegedly stiffing a local contractor for nearly $28,000. Castagnoli-Krokosz is a disbarred Illinois attorney whose disciplinary proceedings documented a fraudulent scheme to collect unauthorized fees from financially struggling bankruptcy clients. The local contractor filed the lawsuit September 28 in Kenosha

October 23, 2026 14 Comments

Plus +

Kenosha Man Accused Of Driving SUV At 65-Year-Old, Punching Him And Chasing Him With Box Cutter Held On $4,500 Cash Bail

Jerome Kirk, 67, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — Jerome Kirk, 67, of Kenosha, faces seven criminal charges across two cases alleging he attacked the same 65-year-old man in September and again Thursday, when prosecutors say he drove an SUV directly at the man, punched him and chased him with a box-cutter-type object. Court Commissioner Daniel E. “Catch & Release” Kellum

October 23, 2026 1 Comment

Plus +

Salem Man Who Previously Had Criminal Charges Dismissed In Silo Rescue Case Now Charged With Felony Domestic Abuse After Allegedly Knocking Woman Unconscious

Michael Lewis Strobach, 22, of Salem(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) SALEM LAKES, Wis. — A 22-year-old Salem man who previously received a favorable resolution to criminal charges stemming from a highly publicized silo rescue is now facing a felony domestic abuse charge and three misdemeanor charges following two separate incidents involving his romantic partner. Michael Lewis Strobach appeared in Kenosha County Circuit Court Friday

October 23, 2026 18 Comments

Plus +

“Catch & Release” Kellum Sets Only $2,500 Cash Bail For Trevor Man Accused Of Felony Fleeing While Under The Influence Of Drugs, Recklessly Endangering Safety And Domestic Abuse

Erik Tyler Gratiot, 32, of Trevor(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — Erik Tyler Gratiot, 32, of Trevor, had his cash bail set at only $2,500 Friday by Court Commissioner Daniel E. “Catch & Release” Kellum after allegedly fleeing deputies while impaired by drugs, striking roadside equipment and frightening his parents. Gratiot faces two felony charges, three misdemeanors and a separate first-offense OWI

October 23, 2026 2 Comments

Plus +

Soft-On-Crime Judge Hughes Gives Work Release And Probation In Concrete-Rock Beating And Drunk-Driving Crash That Left Woman With Broken Ribs, Pelvic Fractures And Partially Collapsed Lung

Juan R. Reyes-Moreno, 28, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — Juan R. Reyes-Moreno, 28, of Kenosha, received probation and 270 days of work release Friday from liberal Evers-appointed Kenosha County Circuit Judge David Hughes (D) in two felony cases involving a violent beating and a drunk-driving crash that seriously injured a woman while he was out on bail. The remarkably lenient

October 23, 2026 2 Comments