Milwaukee Man Given Half Million Dollar Bail For Allegedly Stalking Former School Board Member And His Boyfriend, Threatened To Kill A Detective

Copied!
Paul L. Augustine (31) of Milwaukee
(Kenosha County Sheriff)

A Milwaukee man is holding at the Kenosha County Jail on a $500,000 cash bail for more than a year of serious allegations. Paul L. Augustine is facing the following criminal charges:

Paid Advertisement

5 Counts of Felony Stalking
11 Counts of Felony Bail Jumping
1 Count of Felony Intimidation of a Witness/Threaten Force, etc.
5 Counts of Felony Misappropriate ID Info – Harm Reputation
3 Counts of Felony Threats to Communicate Derogatory Info
2 Counts of Felony False Reporting of an Emergency (Swatting)
3 Misdemeanor Counts of Defamation
and
4 Counts of Obstructing an Officer

Paid Advertisement

If convicted of all charges, Augustine faces almost 150 years in the Wisconsin Prison System. According to the criminal complaint, between May 1, 2023 and March 25, 2024, Augustine intentionally engaged in a course of conduct directed at a specific person to wit former KUSD School Board member Carl Bryan, his lover, and his former lover’s mother, that caused those people and that would cause a reasonable person under the same circumstances to suffer serious emotional distress or to fear bodily injury or death to themselves or to a member of their family or household.

Paid Advertisement

A Kenosha County Sheriff’s Department detective was investigating a complaint made by Bryan, who said that he broke up with his boyfriend when his boyfriend was sent to prison for OWI (4th). Bryan’s best friend, Paul Augustine, began to contact Bryan, pretending to be Bryan’s ex boyfriend and his ex-boyfriend’s mother. He was spoofing Bryan. Spoofing is when you use an app or a device that makes the person you are calling think it is someone else they know. Bryan’s new boyfriend “Spencer” started to receive many spoofed messages as well. Spencer’s mother then received similar messages. Bryan kept a spreadsheet of the contacts and said he was contacted by random phone numbers over 200 times.

Paid Advertisement

The ongoing harassment has included not only phone calls and text messages but also phone calls, often utilizing a voice changer, to services such as tow companies, plumbers, and electricians directing these unwanted services to Bryan and Spencer’s residences and calls to Spencer’s place of work falsely accusing him of sending inappropriate photos to minors, and swatting type calls.

Paid Advertisement

Augustine gave a signed, written statement to the Sheriff’s Department claiming that about two months after Bryan’s ex boyfriend was released from jail, he sent Augustine a message on “Grindr” (a dating app) accusing Bryan of cheating on his ex with Augustine. Augustine also claimed that Bryan’s ex made accusations that Augustine was the reason Bryan’s ex and Bryan’s relationship ended.

Paid Advertisement

A Kenosha County Sheriff’s Detective served a search warrant for a popular “spoofing” app and learned that Augustine was lying to investigators and he was the one contacting the trio. The Detective stated that on September 6, 2023, Bryan received two text messages from a random number. These messages began “You will have hell to pay & all I can[‘t] wait for is the shit storm that is about to wreak havoc on your life…on all three of you. From the times you made me believe we had a chance even after I should have known you were a liar”. The second message begins “How hard was it to call me an Uber that night almost like you’re glad that it went the way it did”.

Paid Advertisement

Augustine’s behavior escalated to swatting Bryan and his boyfriend. Swatting is defined as “the action or practice of making a prank call to emergency services in an attempt to bring about the dispatch of a large number of armed police officers to a particular address.” Augustine called the police to advise that there was an interaction with a knife involved at Bryan’s home. This elicited an emergency response from the Sheriff’s Department. The dispatcher noted that it sounded like the called was using a voice changer.

Paid Advertisement

Augustine was interrogated by a Kenosha County Sheriff’s Department’s detective where he changed his story several times and finally admitted he had spoofing apps on his phone, but that he didn’t download them and his phone must have been hacked. Augustine was arrested and charged with three counts of stalking and one count of obstructing an officer for giving false statements to police.

Augustine was arrested on January 23, 2024 and charged on January 25, 2024. He was given a $5,000 cash bail after court on the 25th, which he paid promptly and was released.

It wouldn’t take long for Augustine’s behavior to continue and turn potentially deadly. Augustine continued to call, text and otherwise communicate with Bryan and Spencer. Augustine then tried to buy a gun, but failed the background check. He then started to research where the Sheriff’s Detective lived. He wanted to blow up the Detective or hire someone kill the Detective.

Augustine was charged with a new felony file on August 7, 2024 and re-arrested on August 8, 2024. He was then slapped with a $500,000 bail. Bryan and Spencer have since filed restraining orders and have court on those later this month.

Author

Copied!
LATEST NEWS

Teen Avoids Adult Court After Bringing Loaded Gun to Indian Trail

Kenosha, Wis. — In a decision that’s raising eyebrows across the community, Kenosha County Circuit Court Judge Chad Kerkman (D) on Friday rejected a request from prosecutors to waive 16-year-old Jaheem Wright into adult court, allowing the teen who brought a loaded gun to school and made threats to be sentenced in juvenile court instead. Wright, who terrified students and staff at Indian Trail High School in December, took a plea deal and pleaded guilty to

Read More »

Counselor on Leave Amid Allegations at Westosha Central High School; Parents Demand Transparency

Paddock Lake, Wis. — A counselor at Westosha Central High School is currently on leave, and parents are once again demanding transparency from school leadership. Kenosha County Eye has confirmed through multiple sources that the counselor is accused of inappropriate communication with a student. According to individuals familiar with the situation, the counselor allegedly used his or her personal cellphone to communicate with a student and is also believed to have given the student a ride

Read More »
MORE TOP STORIES

Kenosha Cop Sues City, Claims Anti-Gay Discrimination Over Missed Promotion

Kenosha, Wis. — A longtime Kenosha police officer who was once accused—but never charged—of rape has filed a federal lawsuit claiming the city and its police chiefs passed him over for promotion because he is gay. Officer Pep Moretti, who has worked for the Kenosha Police Department since 2009, filed the Title VII discrimination lawsuit in late March against the City of Kenosha, former Chief Eric Larsen, and current Chief Patrick Patton. In his complaint, Moretti

Read More »

Wilmot High School Quiz on Trump Tariffs Draws Parental Criticism

Kenosha, Wis. — Some Wilmot Union High School parents are speaking out this week, accusing a 10th grade World History teacher of pushing a politically biased message in the classroom. The criticism centers on a quiz that students were given concerning the economic impacts of former President Donald Trump’s tariff policies — a quiz many say unfairly portrays Trump in a negative light. The assignment, titled “The Consequences of Black Friday,” includes four questions directly targeting

Read More »

Kenosha Law Enforcement Agencies Diverge on Radio Dispatch Policy Changes

Kenosha, Wis. — A recent shift in radio dispatch protocols by the Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office has sparked discussion among local law enforcement leaders, with the Kenosha Police Department opting not to follow suit. As of April 1, the Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office has implemented a revised dispatch policy for non-emergency and low-priority calls. The change, outlined in a March 11 email by Captain Eric Klinkhammer, is aimed at enhancing privacy and reducing radio clutter while

Read More »

Convicted Child Predator Extradited to Kenosha for New Sexual Assault Charge

Kenosha, Wis. — A Racine County man already serving 30 years in state prison for sexually assaulting a 4-year-old girl was extradited to Kenosha County this week to face a new charge involving a different child victim. Seth C. Beining, 23, of Wilmot, is now charged in Kenosha County with first-degree sexual assault of a child under 13. According to the criminal complaint, Beining allegedly assaulted an 11-year-old girl in June 2022 while the two were

Read More »

Kenosha County Scanner Admin Harasses Young Woman for Sharing Post, Reigniting Concerns Over His Criminal Past

Kenosha, Wis. — A 21-year-old Kenosha County woman says she is being harassed by a convicted serial arsonist after sharing one of his Facebook posts in a community thread. The man at the center of the controversy, 48-year-old Allen M. Dunski, Jr, co-manages the Kenosha County Scanner Facebook page with his partner John Broemelkamp. The page charges subscribers $4.99 per month to view posts, which often summarize local police and fire activity. Dunski has previously claimed—without

Read More »

Three Kenosha Police Officers Honored With Life Saving Awards After Reviving Unresponsive Man

Kenosha, Wis. — Three Kenosha Police Department officers were recognized Tuesday morning for their heroic actions that saved a man’s life during a critical medical emergency earlier this year. Officers Kyle Toppel, Charles Lyons, and Matthew Lovell were each presented with the department’s Life Saving Award during the Kenosha Police and Fire Commission meeting today. Their swift and coordinated response on February 15, 2025, helped resuscitate a 59-year-old man who was found unresponsive and not breathing

Read More »

High-Speed Chase Ends in Rollover Crash, Injuries and Felony Charges for Kenosha Man

Kenosha, Wis. — A Kenosha man with a lengthy criminal record is facing 14 new criminal charges, including multiple counts of reckless injury and endangerment, after he allegedly led police on a dangerous, high-speed chase through city streets Friday evening, causing a rollover crash that seriously injured at least two passengers. Joshua J. McCarthy, 38, appeared in court Monday afternoon where a court commissioner set his cash bail T $75,000. McCarthy is on a probation hold,

Read More »

Racine County Sheriff’s Deputy Arrested in Domestic Incident in Somers

Somers, Wis. — A Racine County Sheriff’s Deputy is under internal investigation after he was arrested earlier this month for allegedly assaulting his wife during an alleged drunken domestic dispute at their home. According to law enforcement records obtained by Kenosha County Eye, Kenosha County Sheriff’s Deputies were dispatched to a Somers residence around 10:26 p.m. on April 4, 2025, for a welfare check. Deputies arrived to find what they determined to be a physical domestic

Read More »

Receptionist Resigned Amid Allegations of Attendance Record Tampering, District Records Show

Kenosha, Wis. — A receptionist at Indian Trail High School and Academy resigned last month while under investigation for improperly altering student attendance records, according to newly released internal documents from the Kenosha Unified School District. Danielle Nixon, who worked at the school’s front desk and had access to pupil databases, left her position on March 7, 2025, just days after being questioned about potentially unauthorized modifications to student absences. The district’s records, obtained by Kenosha

Read More »

Flag Protest Sparks Vandalism Probe in Kenosha Neighborhood — But No Charges Filed

Kenosha, Wis. — A neighborhood quarrel over a politically inverted American flag spiraled into a month-long police investigation in the St. Peter’s Park neighborhood — and ended with no arrests, no charges, and rising tensions between residents. The dispute began early on March 1, when a couple living on 22nd Street, just behind St. Peter’s Catholic Church on 30th Avenue, called police to report that both of their vehicles had been vandalized. Windshield wipers were bent

Read More »
Categories
Archives
Authors

40 Responses

  1. Carl was Yolanda’s hand picked replacement on the KUSD Schhol Board for Eric Meadows (when she tried to push him out). What a great candidate he would have been…

    8
    4
    1. Wow victim blaming much??? I’m sure you also believe that Casey Anthony’s daughter had it coming and that Elizabeth Smart deserved to be kidnapped.

  2. Kevin, could you look into and do an article on Kevin Siler arrested yesterday by Pleasant Prairie for HOMICIDE BY NEGLIGENT HANDLING OF DANGEROUS WEAPON/EXPLOSIVE

    3
    1
    1. Kevin, There was a murder in 2019 in Pleasant prairie that never went public and I have no idea why, this guy was rumored immediately to be the one that did it. Yet he been free and in and out of jail for other reasons since then. I’m wondering if this is related to the 2019 murder. And why was the murder never public

      1
      1
    1. It’s sick to see how many homophobic people are still out there in 2024. This is a story about something terrible that happened to someone, and these are responses to it? I hope you are just dumb kids or something.

      12
      3
  3. This guy initially contacted me on Grindr awhile back. Glad I never got involved with now with what I know! He must have some real mental issues!

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LATEST NEWS
Categories
Archives
Authors

Subscribe to updates

Get notified of new articles. We'll never share your email address.