Runnin’ With the Devil: KCE Q&A With Attorney and Author Michael Cicchini

Copied!
Michael D. Cicchini – Kenosha Criminal Defense Attorney and Author
(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

What’s the definition of an IMPARTIAL JUROR in a criminal case?  You might think it’s a juror who has no financial ties or loyalties to either the defendant or to the prosecutor’s office.  But you’d be wrong!  So says local defense attorney and author Michael Cicchini in his newest law review article, The Devil’s Dictionary of Criminal Procedure.   KCE asked him about the article, how he came up with that title, and what his definition is of impartial juror and other legal terms. 

Paid Advertisement

KCE:  Where did you get the title, The Devil’s Dictionary of Criminal Procedure?

Paid Advertisement

Cicchini:  The title was inspired by the great American author and journalist, Ambrose Bierce.  In the late 1800s, Bierce wrote a series of very cynical dictionary entries known as The Devil’s Dictionary.  It included some legal terms.  For example, he defined PRECEDENT as an existing court decision that has “whatever force and authority a judge may choose to give it, thereby greatly simplifying his task of doing as he pleases.”  There are “precedents for everything,” Bierce wrote, and judges just ignore the ones they don’t like and pick the ones they like―that is, when they’re not creating law out of whole cloth, he said.  As you can probably tell, Bierce hated the legal system and he especially hated judges.

Paid Advertisement

KCE:  So what is your dictionary’s definition of an IMPARTIAL JUROR? 

Paid Advertisement

CICCHINI:  I define it as “a juror who is employed by, works at, and receives a paycheck from the prosecutor’s office that actually prosecuted the case on which the juror served.”  That’s cynical, but accurate.  All the definitions in my article, including that one, are all well-supported by legal citations.  This particular citation is to the Wisconsin decision of State v. Smith, in which the court actually upheld a conviction where one of the jurors was employed by the prosecutor’s office that prosecuted the case.  There were some dissenting judges in that decision―voices of sanity, if you will―and they explained the obvious: an employee can’t “separate his or her economic and loyalty interests” from the legal obligation to be impartial.  Therefore, the dissenters wrote, “an employee of a district attorney’s office should be struck as a juror for cause when that office is prosecuting the case.”  Gee, do you think?

Paid Advertisement

KCE:  That is hilarious!  Well, it’s funny unless you’re that defendant.  But I’m sure that criminal defendants who happen to employ people would be allowed to have their employees sit on the jury, right?  (Laughs.)

Paid Advertisement

CICCHINI:  Your sarcasm is well taken.  Those potential jurors would be removed so fast their heads would spin.  No question about it.  Double standards are the norm in criminal law, which is one of the themes that runs throughout my article, including in my definitions of HEARSAY, CLOSING ARGUMENT, and DAUBERT STANDARD.

Paid Advertisement

KCE: Why did you write this article?

Paid Advertisement

CICCHINI: I wrote it because cynicism, when it’s justified, not only entertains but is an effective teaching tool.  Very few law students will ever be exposed to Bierce’s work while they’re in law school, which is unfortunate.  I was lucky enough to learn about him in an experimental first-year class at Marquette Law back in the 90s.  I wish I had taken his warnings more seriously.  If I had, I wouldn’t have been so shocked by the lawlessness in the practice of law.  So I wrote my own Devil’s Dictionary, strictly of criminal procedure terms, with an educational goal in mind.  It’s definitely not legal advice; rather, it’s designed to brace law students and new criminal defense attorneys for the unbelievable lawlessness that awaits them in the courthouse.  And general readers like your audience will, I think, find it entertaining.  I mean, you’re laughing, so we’re off to a good start here.

KCE:  This article is loaded with fantastic stuff!  Tell me about this one.  You define ACQUITTAL as “a jury’s finding of not guilty after a trial. An acquittal is recognized by everyone except the judge and prosecutor, both of whom remain in a post-verdict state of denial.  The judge may use the acquittal as evidence of guilt when sentencing the defendant for other charges, and the prosecutor may use the acquittal as evidence of guilt when prosecuting the defendant in future cases.”  What?!

CICCHINI:  I sense disbelief.  But it’s true.  I provide case law to substantiate that in the footnotes, as I do throughout the article.  In fairness though, the idea that an acquittal can be twisted into evidence of guilt is so bizarre, so anti-American that even some courts don’t buy into it.  I also cite a Massachusetts case, for example, which held that a prosecutor may not use a prior acquittal against a defendant in a future case because doing so “offends the presumption of innocence and notions of fairness and finality.”  That’s the minority view, unfortunately, but it proves that not all courts have gone off the rails.

KCE:  One more.  It’s a really short one.  The dictionary entry itself has me laughing: PROSECUTOR IN A ROBE.  And for the definition you simply write “see JUDGE.”  But you provide a great footnote here.  I have to tell you, normally I gloss over footnotes, but these are really fun!  Tell me about that entry and its footnote.    

CICCHINI:  Yes, some judges abandon their role as a neutral magistrate and turn into an advocate for the state.  It’s like having a second prosecutor in the courtroom, but this one sits in an elevated position and wears a robe, hence the saying “prosecutor in a robe.”  The phenomenon is quite common, especially in motion hearings.  A recent Wisconsin appellate decision even had to remind everyone that a court “may not abandon its neutral role to develop an argument for the State.”  But my favorite example is in the footnote that you’re talking about, which involves a jury trial in Maryland.  I’ve only experienced something like this in Kenosha jury trials a handful of times, and those offending Kenosha judges are no longer on the bench.  But in the Maryland case, Johnson v. State, the judge kept encouraging the prosecutor to object during trial.  The defense lawyer asked, “Judge, do we have two prosecutors here?”  And when the prosecutor wouldn’t object when the judge told him to, the judge would simply “sustain objections never made.”   Imagine that: a judge excitedly blurting out “sustained” without any objection from the prosecutor.  That’s one way to shut down a defense, for sure.  It was an absolute fiasco―a literal case of the judge prosecuting from the bench.  Presumably while wearing a robe.

KCE:  This is too much!  Well, a lot of these other definitions are just as good.  Where is your Devil’s Dictionary of Criminal Procedure published, and can people read it for free?

CICCHINI:  It has just been published by the Denver Law Review Forum.  If I can take a sidebar here: I’ve published in nearly fifty different law reviews, including some of the most selective in the country, and this experience was among the two or three best I’ve ever had.  Charlotte Rhoad, the Review’s senior editor, handled everything from making the initial publication offer all the way through the final edits, and it was a fantastic publishing experience every step of the way.  And yes, the article is available to everyone.  Your readers can find it on the Denver Law Review website.  No subscription required.

KCE:  What’s next for you, as far as publishing goes?

CICCHINI:  I have one more Ambrose Bierce-related article that was just accepted for publication in the Georgia Criminal Law Review.  That will be published later this spring.  As I might have mentioned earlier, Bierce hated judges.  And back in the Gilded Age, which was the late 1800s, he was highly critical of their refusal or inability to follow basic procedural law, among other things.  Criminal procedure is my area of interest and research, and my article is a follow-up to Bierce’s century-old, largely forgotten work.  I analyze whether his criticisms are still valid today, more than 100 years after he wrote them.

KCE:  What’s your verdict?

CICCHINI:  I’ll just say that, the more things change, the more they stay the same.  But the devil, as they say, is in the details.  I’ll send you a copy of the article when it’s hot off the press.

You can find Michael Cicchini’s Devil’s Dictionary of Criminal Procedure on the Denver Law Review website.  You can find all of his articles, including that one, on the articles page of his own website.

Author

Copied!
LATEST NEWS

Kenosha Woman Arrested After Alleged Sledgehammer Attack on Roommate

Kenosha, Wis. – A violent attack early Monday morning has left a woman hospitalized and a repeat offender back in police custody. Early Monday morning, Kenosha police responded to a 911 call from the area of 54th Street and 14th Avenue, where reports indicated that a woman had attacked her roommate with a sledgehammer. Upon arrival, emergency responders transported the victim to a nearby hospital, and is expected to survive After a brief manhunt, authorities located

Read More »

Monday Morning Fire Displaces Southwire Workers

Dozens of employees of Southwire were displaced early this morning just after 7:30 a.m. Pleasant Prairie Fire received a fire alarm call and an employee called in reporting smoke on the second floor. When the fire department arrived, they called for a (Mutual Aid Box Alarm System) MABAS. This prompted fire departments from all over Kenosha and Lake County, IL to respond with equipment. The fire appeared to be under control very quickly after the fire

Read More »
MORE TOP STORIES

Community Rallies Behind Tremper High Student Battling Hodgkin’s Lymphoma

Kenosha, Wis. – The Kenosha community is coming together to support Zane, a 16-year-old sophomore at Tremper High School, after he was recently diagnosed with Stage 3B Hodgkin’s Lymphoma. A GoFundMe campaign has been launched to assist his family as he undergoes treatment. Zane’s journey began unexpectedly on February 25, when he, his father, and his sister were involved in a minor car accident. Just days later, he began experiencing severe chest and shoulder pain, leading

Read More »

Kenosha Police Investigate After Two Found Dead in SUV on Kenosha’s North Side

Kenosha, Wis. – Kenosha Police are investigating after two people were found deceased inside a vehicle on the city’s north side Friday morning. Around 9:30 a.m., officers alerted dispatch to a suspicious vehicle in the 1000 block of 48th Street. The vehicle, a silver or grey Ford Explorer, was later found to contain two deceased individuals. Radio traffic indicated that an officer on the scene requested a supervisor and the medical examiner, signaling a serious incident.

Read More »

Kenosha Woman Arrested After Altercation and Resisting Police

Somers, Wis. – A 42-year-old woman from Somers, Nicole M. Lehman, is being released today after her arrest earlier this morning. Lehman faces charges of Resisting an Officer and Disorderly Conduct after a disturbance at her home. In court this afternoon, she was granted a no-cash bail and pleaded not guilty. Lehman will return to court for a hearing on April 4, 2025. If convicted, she could face up to a year in jail and a

Read More »

Indian Trail High School Receptionist Resigns Amid Misconduct Investigation

A receptionist at Indian Trail High School & Academy has resigned her position as of March 7, 2025. Danielle Nixon was allegedly under investigation by the Kenosha Unified School District for misconduct. According to a source familiar with the matter, Nixon was accused of modifying attendance records for varsity boys’ basketball players to to circumvent Wisconsin Interscholastic Athletic Association (WIAA) eligibility rules. KCE has requested the investigative files and will report back when the exact details

Read More »

Alleged Drug-Dealing Teacher To Return to Classroom At Washington Middle School Monday

Kenosha, Wis. – A group of parents at Washington Middle School within the Kenosha Unified School District (KUSD) are voicing their outrage after learning that one of their children’s teachers, Alyssa L. Jurasik, 24, has a criminal record involving drug-related offenses. Despite being placed on paid administrative leave on February 21, 2025, following inquiries by Kenosha County Eye (KCE), Jurasik is set to return to the classroom on Monday, March 17, 2025—fueling even greater frustration among

Read More »

Kenosha Unified School District Employee Fired Following Allegations of Physical Misconduct with Student: Video

Kenosha, Wis. – A Kenosha Unified School District (KUSD) employee has been terminated following an investigation into alleged inappropriate physical interactions with a student at Chavez Learning Station. Makaella Toney, a Head Start employee, was placed on administrative leave on November 4, 2024, and officially terminated on November 21, 2024, after a review of surveillance footage and witness statements. Incident Overview The incident in question occurred on October 31, 2024, when Toney was bringing a class

Read More »

New Complaint in Bristol Raises Concerns Over Clerk Brickner’s Re-Election Bid in Paddock Lake

A recent complaint, filed with the Wisconsin Elections Commission (WEC), was filed by Chief Election Inspector Kenneth Wolfe against Bristol Village Clerk Renee Brickner. Notably, this is the second formal complaint filed against Brickner. The newest complaint details a series of alleged violations and mismanagement during the November 2024 General Election. Brickner’s response to the complaint, while attempting to address the allegations, has done little to quell concerns about her ability to administer elections effectively, and

Read More »

Against All Odds: Racine Man Transforms Life and Becomes Deputy Sheriff

Kenosha, Wis. – Sometimes, life offers second chances to those willing to fight for them. For Endel Williams, 50, that second chance is more than just a fresh start—it’s a full-circle moment. The once-troubled teen and twice-convicted felon will be sworn in as a Deputy Sheriff for the Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office on March 31, 2025, marking an extraordinary turnaround. Williams’ past was anything but picture-perfect. His troubles with the law began early, leading to convictions

Read More »

Nedweski’s K9 Riggs Act Advances to Strengthen Protections for Police Animals

Madison, Wis. – State Representative Amanda Nedweski (R-Pleasant Prairie) issued the following statement after the passage of AB 61—The K9 Riggs Act, which she authored to increase penalties for injuring or killing police or fire animals: “I am grateful for the overwhelming bipartisan support for AB 61, the K9 Riggs Act,” Nedweski said. “This bill resonates deeply with our local law enforcement agencies, and speaks directly to the heart of the Kenosha County community.” In October 2021, Kenosha

Read More »

Missing Kenosha Woman Confirmed Deceased

On Sunday, March 9, 2025, at about 4:55 PM a woman was found dead within a Lake Michigan break wall at Eichelman Park. The identity of the woman was initially unknown. With the assistance of the Kenosha County Medical Examiner’s Office and a forensic odonatologist, the woman has been identified as 18-year-old Kayla Sobczak of Kenosha. On December 23rd, 2024, Kayla’s family contacted the Kenosha Police Department to report her missing, after last seeing her on

Read More »
Categories
Archives
Authors

5 Responses

  1. Thanks, Kevin. Love the title! Ambrose Bierce, David Lee Roth, and Van Halen all tied into MY very own Q&A. I’m only partly joking when I say that I can now wrap it up and call it a career!

    And to “David Lee Van Halen”: “I found the simple life, ain’t so simple . . .”

    8
    2
    1. Made me feel as though the Defense Attorney, Defendant are playing against the odds in the courtroom of Sharks. Having a Prosecutor who may believe in your innocence yet does not care or a Judge who may be to hell bent on a guilty verdict out of his own ignorance surely seems like an uneven playing field for the Defendant. I would have never envisioned a Judge and Prosecutor as one and the same. Naturally thought a Judge was a very seasoned stand up Attorney there to observe the letter of the law in his courtroom. Not a Prosecutor in a robe. Left with the feeling there is a good chance the Judge wouldn’t even know the law. Eye opening read.

  2. Though I know he’s to professional to agree or not agree, I’d be willing to bet one of those Prosecutor In A Robe judges would have been Mary Kay Wagner. Real piece of work she was. Great article. Looking forward to the reading.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Categories
Archives
Authors

Subscribe to updates

Get notified of new articles. We'll never share your email address.