KENOSHA, Wis. — The foreman of the jury that convicted Justin Tercek of killing Andrew Pfannkuche and his dog Jake has spoken publicly with Kenosha County Eye, providing insight into the panel’s thinking despite what courtroom observers described as unusual remarks from Judge Jodi Meier cautioning jurors about speaking with the media.

Tim Borop, who served as jury foreman, spoke with Kenosha County Eye shortly after the verdict and reflected on the weight of the case and the jury’s decision.

Borop told Kenosha County Eye that the jury took its responsibility “very seriously” and believes it “made the right decision based on the evidence.” He said the jurors felt justice was served, while also acknowledging that nothing can bring Andrew Pfannkuche and his dog, Jake, back. Borop added that the jury’s thoughts remain with Pfannkuche’s family and loved ones and that the case was “tragic, brutal, and unnecessary.”

Borop’s decision to speak publicly comes after Judge Meier addressed jurors in court following the reading of the verdict, instructing them to be mindful about discussing deliberations and to respect the privacy of fellow jurors. Observers in the courtroom said the judge emphasized that jurors should avoid exposing others to fear, anger, or unwanted attention and should be cautious when speaking about what occurred in the jury room.

Kenosha County Eye has never heard a judge make such pointed remarks to jurors regarding post-verdict media contact, and multiple attorneys consulted after the trial said they had never encountered similar instructions. Jurors have an absolute legal right to speak to the media, to anyone they choose, or to no one at all, and they cannot be prohibited or punished for doing so.

Despite that backdrop, Borop chose to speak, offering insight into the jury’s perspective.

A Kenosha County jury found Tercek guilty on all four counts, including criminal damage to property, burglary while a person was present, first-degree intentional homicide with use of a dangerous weapon, and mistreatment of an animal causing death with use of a dangerous weapon.

The case centered on the violent killing of Andrew Pfannkuche, 52, who was found stabbed to death inside his home, and the killing of his dog, Jake. The jury deliberated over parts of two days before reaching its verdict.

Tercek is scheduled to be sentenced on July 17, 2026, at 1 p.m.

The verdict marked the conclusion of a closely watched trial that drew significant attention across Kenosha County because of both the brutality of the crime and the contentious nature of the courtroom proceedings.