Kenoshacountyeye

Kenosha County Eye

Search
Close this search box.
Search
Close this search box.

Who Says You Can’t Fight City Hall? : Kenosha Resident Takes Property Tax Dispute To Supreme Court Who Accepted The Case

Share
Tweet

The Wisconsin Supreme Court accepted a petition to review a case involving the City of Kenosha today, March 24.  The case involves a local resident who disputed the City’s classification of his land.  In 2017, Anthony Nudo purchased vacant land in the City of Kenosha to develop into a residential subdivision.  The City Assessor changed the classification to residential after Nudo purchased the land.  Nudo, a local attorney and former City Alderman knows the rules well. He objected on the grounds that the land, although purchased for residential purposes, was not yet residential.  In fact, Nudo argued, the land was agricultural land because of a walnut orchard and Christmas trees growing on the property along with chickens being kept on the land.  However, the City held that they can consider what the future use of the land could be to get higher taxes. 

Paid Advertisement

Why does this matter?  Well, under Wisconsin law, agricultural land is taxed MUCH less than residential land.  Nudo was registered with the State of Wisconsin as a livestock premises and obtained a license from the City of Kenosha and County Health Department to keep chickens on the land known as Nudo Farms.  The County Clerk issued Nudo a harvesting license to cut and sell Christmas trees from the land.  Walnuts were harvested from the orchard.  But none of that mattered to the City.  After several appeals, including a split decision from the Court of Appeals with a scathing dissent against the City, the case has found its way in front of the Supreme Court. 

            Only 5-8% of appeals made to the Supreme Court are accepted.  The vast majority of cases never get there.  Under state statute, the “Supreme [C]ourt review is a matter of judicial discretion, not of right, and will be granted only when special and important reasons are presented.”  Wis. Stat. § 809.62(1r).  It appears here that the Supreme Court wants to make sure that landowners are treated fairly under the law and not on the whim of an assessor.  How much has this fight cost the taxpayers?  Likely tens of thousands of dollars that the City cannot recover. 

Paid Advertisement

Nudo is representing himself in this case. Not many attorneys they have been practicing law for only 3 years have argued in front of the highest court in Wisconsin. As for a timeline, both sides have about a month each to file a brief. Then comes the oral arguments. It could take another 6 months to a year before we hear the court’s decision.

The old adage goes “you can’t fight City Hall.”  One brave citizen has gone against that and brought the fight all the way up to the top.  Let’s hope this fight helps the City to start following the law and stop bullying taxpayers. 

Paid Advertisement

Author

  • Kevin Mathewson

    Kevin Mathewson is a disciple of Christ, husband and a father to two wonderful children. Mathewson was born and raised in Lake County, IL and worked as a police & fire dispatcher from 2005 to 2010 in Round Lake Beach, IL. Mathewson moved to Kenosha County in 2006, later being elected to the position of Alderman of the 8th District in 2012 and 2016. Mathewson is a private investigator, security contractor, journalist, and photographer. He enjoys spending time with his family, watching movies, camping and boating. His favorite amendment is the second, followed closely by the first. He loves his country and community.

Share
Tweet
LATEST NEWS

Man Killed In Brighton After Striking Cow With Vehicle

On Thursday, March 28, 2024, around 4:50 AM, the Kenosha County Sheriff’s Department responded to the 29500 block of 31st Street  (CTH-JB) in the Town of Brighton for a single-vehicle crash that had hit a cow. The cow had escaped its pasture and was found in the middle of 31st Street at the time of the crash. The vehicle operator was the only occupant of the vehicle and was pronounced deceased at the scene by the Kenosha County

Read More »

Kenosha Judge Candidates Debate Issues At Forum Hosted By The Kenosha County BAR Association: Video

Lawyers from the private and public sectors, prosecutors, judges, court staff, the Sheriff, other members of the legal community, and members of the public packed into Casa Capris tonight to watch a spirited debate between the two candidates for Circuit Court Judge in Kenosha’s Branch 3. Court Commissioner Heather Iverson and Judge Frank Gagliardi are going head-to head for the position which will be decided by voters on April 2, 2024. Gagliardi was appointed by Governor

Read More »
MORE TOP STORIES

Kenosha Man Known As The “Black Kyle Rittenhouse” Is Free After Having Charge Dismissed

Jarred Cooks, a 28-year-old Kenosha man, walked out of the Kenosha County Courthouse today as a free man, with a big smile. In court today, preparations were underway for a trial that was scheduled for April 8, 2024 – just 11 days away. Instead, today a Circuit Court Judge dismissed the serious felony against Cooks, at the request of the prosecutor. He was facing one count of First Degree Recklessly Endangering Safety, Use of a Dangerous

Read More »

Kenosha’s Peter Barca Leaves Governor’s Administration

MADISON — Gov. Tony Evers today announced Wisconsin Department of Revenue (DOR) Secretary Peter Barca will be leaving the Evers Administration after serving the administration for more than five years. Secretary Barca was one of the governor’s first appointments to his cabinet in 2019. “Peter has been with our administration since Day One, and I knew from the beginning that he would be a dedicated, enthusiastic, and effective leader for the Department of Revenue,” said Gov.

Read More »

Carthage College Student Assaulted on Campus – Person of Interest in Custody

On Tuesday, March 26, 2024, at about 8:30 PM, officers from the Kenosha Police Department responded to the campus of Carthage College to investigate an attempted assault and robbery that occurred on campus. The adult female student screamed for help during the attack, causing another student to respond. Their actions caused the man to flee. The Kenosha Police Department and Carthage Public Safety immediately began a collaborative investigation. The campus community was notified of the incident

Read More »

Controversy Surrounds Kemper Center Appointment of Daniel Gaschke as Executive Director

In a move that has sparked controversy and raised serious questions about its transparency and governance, the Kemper Center has appointed Daniel Gaschke, a Kenosha County Board Member, as its new executive director. Gaschke’s appointment comes amidst allegations of impropriety and procedural irregularities, further compounded by attempts to suppress information and limit public scrutiny. Gaschke will succeed Ed Kubicki, another County Board member, who was hired in 2018 under similarly suspicious circumstances. Citizens and politicians claimed

Read More »

Kenosha Unified School District To Host Events Celebrating Legacy Of Schools Slated To Close

WHAT: At the end of this school year, the Kenosha Unified School District will have six schools closing, one merging with another, and one changing locations. To honor their legacy in our community, the district will be celebrating the history of each of the buildings impacted prior to the end of the school year. WHO: All current and past students, staff and families, as well as general community members, are invited to celebrate the history of

Read More »

Video Released Of High School Teacher’s Police Chase And Arrest For Third OWI – No Discipline From School District

The dash-cam and body-cam footage of a Tremper High School teacher leading police on a drunken pursuit through Kenosha was released today. Pursuant to a public records request, KPD turned over the videos to KCE today. Mark P. Wisniewski, 41, of Kenosha, was sentenced to six months in jail earlier this month after leading Kenosha Police on a 1 mile chase with a blood alcohol content of .300 – almost four times the legal limit. Wisniewski

Read More »

6 Responses

  1. Kudos to Mr. Nudo. I have great respect for people who judiciously question authority when authority loses its way. Wishing you well with the Supreme Court.

    Also, Thank you Kenoshacountyeye for keeping us informed.

  2. Nudo is a great man and I’m sure he will succeed. Maybe the wrong platform. But maybe a post on how all the “Kenosha 7” Kevin Glowicki “never stop lying media” and other activists don’t post or make a big deal about the fuller trial, or the murder that happened a few weeks ago by the 51 year old murderer? Does it not hit the profile of “activists?”

  3. Or Josh barker? Any word?
    Shawnell gross? He has a no contact order for jury tampering for Martice fuller. Also a KUSD employee. Kinda a trend I see

  4. Eh…..I guess you could summarize the case that way. In reality, Nude worked for Bear Property, he isn’t stupid.

    I’m pretty sure he didn’t buy this land for farming and the stuff on that “farmland” was already there when he bought them.

    I think the decision provides a lot more detail here…..he isn’t going to win at the SC level….but hey, good luck.

    https://www.anylaw.com/case/nudo-holdings-llc-v-board-of-review-for-the-city-of-kenosha-recommended-for-publication/court-of-appeals-of-wisconsin/11-25-2020/EPPiCXYBoz_ZJnepqMpL

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LATEST NEWS

Subscribe to updates

Get notified of new articles. We'll never share your email address.