Idaho and Wisconsin: A Tale of Two Preliminary Hearings

Copied!

Guest post by criminal defense attorney Michael D. Cicchini

Paid Advertisement

In the Idaho quadruple homicide case, defendant Bryan Kohberger is accused of murdering University of Idaho students Ethan Chapin, Xana Kernodle, Kaylee Goncalves, and Madison Mogen.  The defense waived the right to a timely preliminary hearing (14 days in Idaho) and set the hearing in June so it has enough time to go through all of the evidence.  The judge cleared five days on the calendar for the hearing itself.  This indicates that the defense gets the discovery materials (e.g., police reports, witness statements, etc.) before the prelim and the state has to call actual witnesses at the evidentiary hearing in order to establish probable cause.

Paid Advertisement

By comparison, in Wisconsin, the courts at all levels of the system have managed to super-legislate from the bench; they have somehow turned an evidentiary hearing, which was designed to prevent improvident prosecutions, into a prosecutorial weapon for charging anything and everything without probable cause and, certainly, without the presentation of any evidence.

Paid Advertisement

What do I mean?  Well, if pre-hearing discovery and actual witnesses are the hallmark of Idaho’s preliminary hearing, then these are the hallmarks of Wisconsin’s preliminary hearing:

Paid Advertisement

1.                  No pre-hearing discovery whatsoever.  (See pp. 499-504.)  The defense is kept in the dark and isn’t even entitled to police reports before the hearing.  And at the hearing itself, prosecutors have even dreamed-up a new objection whenever the defense asks a question of a witness that might produce some interesting information.  They pipe up, with a sense of urgency in their voice, “Objection, discovery!”  As I’ve pointed out to numerous court commissioners, “discovery” is not a proper objection.  No matter, the objection is nearly always sustained and the line of questioning is stopped dead in its tracks.  Ignorance, apparently, is the goal. 

Paid Advertisement

2.                 Witnesses without any knowledge of the case whatsoever.  (See pp. 493-499.)  In Wisconsin, prosecutors don’t have to call actual witnesses.  Instead, they call a “reader”—a law enforcement agent assigned to the courtroom for the day who had nothing whatsoever to do with the investigation of the case.  This reader reads and tries to memorize the criminal complaint—a document drafted by the prosecutor’s office—and then answers questions about it on the witness stand.  In other words, the state’s “evidence” at the prelim consists of a cop (with no personal knowledge of the case) saying that a prosecutor (who drafted the complaint) said that an investigating officer said that an informant or other witness said that the defendant said or did something.  Probable cause established!  Hearing over.  Thanks for playing.  I kid you not, dear reader.  

Paid Advertisement

3.                 Defense witnesses need not apply!  (See pp. 504-506.)   In order to prevent the defense from learning anything about the case, courts may also prohibit the defense from calling its own witnesses with personal knowledge of what allegedly happened.  And commissioners and judges deny defendants this right despite the clear, plain statute allowing—guess what?—the defense to call witnesses!  How can this happen?  Again, super-legislation from the bench at all levels of the court system starting with the court commissioner, then the trial court judge, then the appellate court, then the state’s high court.  Read the three pages in the above link to learn the logical and legal errors the courts commit when denying defendants their statutory right to present evidence at the hearing.

Paid Advertisement

4.                 The preliminary hearing is a prosecutorial weapon to add charges.  (See pp. 506-511.)  In Wisconsin, the preliminary hearing now benefits the prosecutor, not the defense.  Although the hearing is meant to provide felony defendants with additional protections compared with defendants charged with mere misdemeanors, prosecutors use the courts’ super-legislation to add charges without any probable cause in the hearing testimony or even the complaint!  Once again, this deplorable, pro-state, intellectually hollow tactic not only violates the purpose of the hearing, but also directly contradicts the statute which requires dismissal of all counts for which there was no probable cause!  Read the above pages to learn the intricate details.  Fair warning: it’s like watching the metaphorical sausage being made.

Although they’re violating law, logic, reason, and commonsense—and effectively eliminating an important part of criminal procedure in the process—you have to give these government agents points for sneaky efficiency.  I’m quoting myself here, but, “in today’s assembly-line approach to criminal law, prosecutors and judges have developed many ways to bypass this procedural safeguard [the preliminary hearing] and keep the criminal justice machinery humming along.”  It’s a volume business!

[This post has been cross-posted on The Legal Watchdog blog.]

Author

Copied!
LATEST NEWS

Mayor David Bogdala’s Administration Hires Former Bristol School District Administrator Jack Musha To Lead Youth Academy Despite Previous Misconduct Allegations

KENOSHA, Wis. — Jack Musha, the former Bristol School District administrator who resigned in December 2024 while facing possible termination over allegations of misconduct, has been hired by the City of Kenosha to manage the Kenosha Emerging Leaders Academy (KELA), a taxpayer-supported youth development initiative. The hiring took place under Kenosha Mayor David Bogdala’s (R) administration, which bears ultimate executive responsibility for the

Plus +

Nearly 30 Years After Alleged Kenosha Car Break-In, Illinois Man Returns To Court On 1997 Criminal Charges, Posts $1,500 Cash Bail

Justin Picou, 47, of Beach Park, Illinois(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 47-year-old Beach Park, Illinois, man is back in Kenosha County Circuit Court nearly 30 years after prosecutors accused him of breaking into a former coworker’s vehicle and stealing approximately $1,400 worth of stereo equipment. Justin Picou, who was just 17 years old when the alleged crime occurred on April

MORE TOP STORIES
Plus +

Woman Who Was Just 18 When She Caused Four-Vehicle Crash During Second OWI Pleads Guilty To Felony; Judge Revokes Bail And Orders Her Into Custody

Karina Roque Kenyon, 22, of Grand Rapids, Michigan(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — Karina Roque Kenyon, 22, of Grand Rapids, Michigan, pleaded guilty Thursday, November 19, 2026, to a Class H felony charge of causing injury while operating a vehicle with a restricted controlled substance following a four-vehicle crash

Plus +

Salem Man Accused Of Trying To Enter Stranger’s Kenosha Home At 5 A.M., Yelling Racial Slurs And Profanities; Also Facing Retail Theft Charge With Felony Penalty Enhancer

William M. Fude, 32, of Salem(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 32-year-old Salem man is facing two separate criminal cases after Kenosha police say he attempted to enter a stranger’s home early Friday morning while yelling racial slurs, swearing and behaving erratically. William M. Fude, 32, of Salem,

Plus +

Wilmot Raceway Supporters Score Major Victory In Kenosha County Fair Board Election, Ousting Three Incumbents Amid Allegations Of Plot To Shut Down Racetrack

Wednesday’s Annual Meeting of the Kenosha County Fairgrounds(Cell Phone Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye) WILMOT, Wis. — An unusually large crowd descended on the Parkway Chateau Wednesday night, November 18, 2026, for the Kenosha County Fair Association’s annual meeting, in what fair insiders are calling an overwhelming mandate

Plus +

Kenosha Killer Who Sexually Assaulted And Brutally Murdered Mother Of Two In 2006 Seeks Commutation Of Life Sentence: District Attorney Xavier Solis Urges Governor To Deny Request

Convicted Murderer, Rapist, and and Sex Offender Anthony P. Heard Jr., 38, formerly of Kenosha(Wisconsin Sex Offender Registry) KENOSHA, Wis. — Anthony P. Heard Jr., 38, formerly of Kenosha, is seeking to have his life-without-parole prison sentence commuted nearly 20 years after he sexually assaulted and brutally murdered Carmen E.

Categories
Archives
Authors

6 Responses

  1. What a great piece. Thank you for the KCE for bring it to us. However, much of it will be lost on the majority of visitors to this site who blindly “back the badge.” People should understand that when you do not protect the rights of criminal defendants, you have the same system as North Korea. Anyone can find themselves in the sites of corrupt law enforcement. No one can say with certainty that it would never happen to them.

  2. Interesting article by Mr. Cicchini. A lot of what and, frankly, some chaff, too, as his recitation of Wisconsin law is not only skewed but occasionally inaccurate. Quibbling about what he got wrong would be counterproductive because what he got right is even more significant than what Mr. Cicchini wrote. So I’ll pick just one nit.

    The preliminary hearing is not a mini-trial or preliminary trial in Wisconsin. It is a screening device and thus the among of evidence necessary to give the green light for a prosecution to proceed is much less than needed for a conviction. With that out of the way the problem (well, one of the problems) in Kenosha County is that the district attorney’s office has chosen to reduce preliminary hearings to an almost meaningless waste of time and money that frustrates justice worse that what Mr. Cicchini laments.

    Remember that I said that preliminary hearings aren’t supposed to be mini-trials? Despite what the law reads (and the changes over the years) to be an effective screening device they are kinda, sorta mini-trials. Why? Because that’s how to separate the marginal cases from those with much more merit. How so? The answer begins with understanding how charges come about.

    When police investigate a crime they can either make an arrest and refer the case to the district attorney for prosecution or sometimes they will just refer the case without keeping the suspect in custody. Either way in most situations the district attorney is making a charging decision based on police reports and witness statements with no meaningful chance (if any) to independently evaluate the quality of the case.

    As a practical matter preliminary hearings were an opportunity for both the prosecutor and defense attorney to “kick the tires” of the case. If the witnesses, especially the victim, were subpoenaed for the preliminary hearing the prosecutor would discuss the case with them and could determine if what was in the reports and witness statements squared with what would be their testimony. Often victims know defendants and had insights about the case and the people involved that isn’t in the police reports. Sometimes this process showed the holes in the case and sometimes the case was actually better than it may have initially seemed.

    Truth is most preliminary hearings wound up being waived by defendants but the presence of the key witnesses in the case at the preliminary hearing was helpful. Occasionally defense attorneys would have their own conversations with the witnesses and could size up the case and then recommend that their clients waive the hearing. Other times even though cross-examination was limited having the witnesses on the stand gave both attorneys a view of the evidence and how the witnesses would hold up at a trial. Many times after a preliminary hearing defense attorneys would come to the conclusion that the prosecution had a good case and attempt to settle it short of trial. Similarly prosecutors would see where a case was weak. A lot of cases were settled this way and scarce resources (and money) saved for the defendants and cases requiring a trial.

    Then the legislature expanded the law to broaden the acceptable use of hearsay testimony at a preliminary hearing. The truth is that some witnesses who were called to testify at a preliminary hearing added nothing meaningful. Let’s say the case was a felony level criminal damage to property case where the amount of damage is relevant to the charge and that American Family Insurance paid out $25,000 to fix the damage. Was it really necessary for someone from American Family to drive from Madison to Kenosha just to say that they paid out $25,000 to fix the damage when all that witness knows is that the company cut a check for $25,000 on that claim? 99% of the time the answer would be a solid “no” and hearsay would be an utterly acceptable conservation of time and cost at a preliminary hearing.

    The Kenosha County District Attorney’s office took this too far. Now most preliminary hearings don’t have witnesses subpoenaed to the courtroom but rather a police officer reads the criminal complaint. Almost always the officer has zero personal knowledge of the case and both the prosecutor and defense attorney have no chance to meet and hear from the people who do. The district attorney’s office doesn’t have the face-to-face ability to size up the witnesses and cases wind up on the trial calendar without that early vetting. Defense attorneys have a tougher time determining whether to go to trial or to settle a case that maybe if they heard some first hand testimony they’d be convinced their client had little chance of acquittal. Now that’s gone and trial calendars get clogged with cases that should have been resolved long ago. And prosecutors waste time and money dealing with them, too, instead of focusing on the ones that need more attention.

    There’s an old Army saying: “More sweat in training, less blood in combat.” The Kenosha County District Attorney’s office expends more blood in combat because of the lack of sweat in training. Experienced lawyers will tell you that many cases were settled because of the preliminary hearings after they heard from the witnesses (and sometimes defendants who may have been drunk or high at the time needed to hear what they did because they couldn’t remember).

    The district attorney’s notion is that by reducing preliminary hearings to the status of meaningless bobble-heads taxpayer money is being saved by not bringing in police officers and witnesses for preliminary hearings that are often waived. That’s foolish economy because even if the hearing is waived the prosecutor still has a chance to meet the people involved and size up the case plus it offers victims and witnesses a chance to give the prosecutor valuable insights. Yes, there are times when it’s a “slam dunk” case and the preliminary hearing would be a waste of time and, yes, it makes no sense to have someone from American Family drive here from Madison to just to say that they paid out $25,000 on a claim. But too much garbage stays in the system longer because of the lack of proper vetting that preliminary hearings used to offer. In that sense Mr. Cicchini is spot on. And he’s also correct that just because hearsay can be used at a preliminary hearing it doesn’t always mean that it’s proper evidence to be considered by the court.

    In order for hearsay to be admissible it should be “reliable.” And while the standard of proof at a preliminary hearing is probable cause the law also says that this level of probable cause may be higher than at the criminal complaint stage. For example, if the officer testifying says that “a witness told one of our officers that the defendant threw a brick at the window” that’s not reliable hearsay. Who said so? Why should they be believed?

    Now, imagine if the testifying officer said, “Sally Smith, who lives at 1234 Highway K, told Officer Dick Tracy that on November 2, 2022 at about 11:30 p.m., she brought her garbage can to the curb and looked across the street and saw the defendant throw a brick at the window of his ex-wife’s house and that she knew who he was because he used to live across the street before he got divorced and she met him several times.” Would that be more reliable as Sally Smith lives across the street, was standing outside when she saw the defendant throw a brick and knew who he was as a former neighbor that she’d met?

    At least one magistrate has occasionally tossed charges out because the hearsay was lacking reliability. Mr. Cicchini makes a very good point and perhaps more defense attorneys need to be prepared to properly argue when hearsay isn’t reliable and thus inadmissible. And the district attorney’s office may be squandering both resources and justice. They may think they’re saving money but experience teaches that it’s often the cheapskate that spends the most.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LATEST NEWS

Mayor David Bogdala’s Administration Hires Former Bristol School District Administrator Jack Musha To Lead Youth Academy Despite Previous Misconduct Allegations

KENOSHA, Wis. — Jack Musha, the former Bristol School District administrator who resigned in December 2024 while facing possible termination over allegations of misconduct, has been hired by the City of Kenosha to manage the Kenosha Emerging Leaders Academy (KELA), a taxpayer-supported youth development initiative. The hiring took place under Kenosha Mayor David Bogdala’s (R) administration, which bears ultimate executive responsibility for the

Plus +

Nearly 30 Years After Alleged Kenosha Car Break-In, Illinois Man Returns To Court On 1997 Criminal Charges, Posts $1,500 Cash Bail

Justin Picou, 47, of Beach Park, Illinois(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 47-year-old Beach Park, Illinois, man is back in Kenosha County Circuit Court nearly 30 years after prosecutors accused him of breaking into a former coworker’s vehicle and stealing approximately $1,400 worth of stereo equipment. Justin Picou, who was just 17 years old when the alleged crime occurred on April

Kenosha County’s Annual Christmas Tree Lighting Returns November 28 With Santa, Live Reindeer, Christmas Carols And Free Family Activities

SOMERS, Wis. — Kenosha County residents are invited to kick off the Christmas season with a full day of holiday festivities as the fourth annual Kenosha County Tree Lighting Ceremony returns to Petrifying Springs Park on Saturday, November 28, 2026. The free, family-friendly celebration will feature Santa and Mrs. Claus, live reindeer, Christmas carols, ornament decorating, holiday food and drinks, and the lighting

Plus +

Woman Who Was Just 18 When She Caused Four-Vehicle Crash During Second OWI Pleads Guilty To Felony; Judge Revokes Bail And Orders Her Into Custody

Karina Roque Kenyon, 22, of Grand Rapids, Michigan(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — Karina Roque Kenyon, 22, of Grand Rapids, Michigan, pleaded guilty Thursday, November 19, 2026, to a Class H felony charge of causing injury while operating a vehicle with a restricted controlled substance following a four-vehicle crash in Somers in May 2022. Despite being just 18 years old at the

Plus +

Registered Sex Offender Accused Of Battering Pregnant Girlfriend In Kenosha Released On No-Cash Bail Despite Repeat Offender Status

Sherman T. Hill, 33, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 33-year-old Kenosha man and registered sex offender is facing two criminal charges after allegedly battering his girlfriend, who is eight months pregnant with his child. Sherman T. Hill, 33, of Kenosha, was charged Friday, November 20, with misdemeanor battery and disorderly conduct, both carrying domestic abuse and repeat offender enhancements.

Plus +

Salem Man Accused Of Trying To Enter Stranger’s Kenosha Home At 5 A.M., Yelling Racial Slurs And Profanities; Also Facing Retail Theft Charge With Felony Penalty Enhancer

William M. Fude, 32, of Salem(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 32-year-old Salem man is facing two separate criminal cases after Kenosha police say he attempted to enter a stranger’s home early Friday morning while yelling racial slurs, swearing and behaving erratically. William M. Fude, 32, of Salem, was charged Friday, November 20, 2026, with misdemeanor disorderly conduct and a separate

Plus +

Wilmot Raceway Supporters Score Major Victory In Kenosha County Fair Board Election, Ousting Three Incumbents Amid Allegations Of Plot To Shut Down Racetrack

Wednesday’s Annual Meeting of the Kenosha County Fairgrounds(Cell Phone Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye) WILMOT, Wis. — An unusually large crowd descended on the Parkway Chateau Wednesday night, November 18, 2026, for the Kenosha County Fair Association’s annual meeting, in what fair insiders are calling an overwhelming mandate to preserve Wilmot Raceway and continue the hundreds of thousands of dollars in

Plus +

Kenosha Killer Who Sexually Assaulted And Brutally Murdered Mother Of Two In 2006 Seeks Commutation Of Life Sentence: District Attorney Xavier Solis Urges Governor To Deny Request

Convicted Murderer, Rapist, and and Sex Offender Anthony P. Heard Jr., 38, formerly of Kenosha(Wisconsin Sex Offender Registry) KENOSHA, Wis. — Anthony P. Heard Jr., 38, formerly of Kenosha, is seeking to have his life-without-parole prison sentence commuted nearly 20 years after he sexually assaulted and brutally murdered Carmen E. Barranco-Dax, a 38-year-old mother of two from Gurnee, Illinois. Heard, who was already

Plus +

17-Year-Old Kenosha Man Charged With Armed Burglary, Robbery After Allegedly Kicking In Ex-Girlfriend’s Door, Threatening To Shoot Her And Her Brother

Sahmere J. Powers, 17, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 17-year-old Kenosha man is facing eight criminal charges, including two felonies, after prosecutors say he kicked in his ex-girlfriend’s door, repeatedly assaulted her and her brother, threatened to shoot them, and stole her cellphone. Sahmere J. Powers, 17, of Kenosha, appeared in court Thursday, November 19, 2026, where Kenosha County

Plus +

Kenosha Music Store Manager Criminally Charged After Allegedly Making Sexually Inappropriate Comments To Teenagers: Owner Seemingly Misled Kenosha County Eye About His Knowledge Of Investigation

Julian J. Paulsen, 44 of Kenosha – Manager at Music Center, Inc(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 44-year-old Kenosha man who manages a longtime local music store has been criminally charged with three counts of disorderly conduct following allegations that he repeatedly made sexually inappropriate comments to teenagers, including a 16-year-old female employee and two teenage boys. Julian J. Paulsen, a

Plus +

Threat Against Staff Member Prompts Brief Secure At Whittier Elementary School, Pleasant Prairie Police Response

Pleasant Prairie Police Department(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye) PLEASANT PRAIRIE, Wis. — Students and staff at Whittier Elementary School, 8542 Cooper Road, were placed in a brief classroom secure Thursday, November 19, 2026, after Pleasant Prairie police responded to a report of a possible threat involving a school staff member. Pleasant Prairie Police Officer Ben Arzikovic, a member of the

Christmas At Kemper Returns With Holiday Market, Santa, S’mores, Historic Mansion Tours And Gallery Of Trees

KENOSHA, Wis. — One of Kenosha’s longtime holiday traditions is returning to the lakefront this year, bringing Christmas trees, historic mansion tours, local shopping, visits with Santa, live music and family activities to the Kemper Center campus. Christmas at Kemper will feature several events beginning November 28 and continuing through December 12, 2026, including the 30th anniversary celebration of the popular Gallery of

Plus +

Kenosha Man Accused Of Choking Ex-Girlfriend Until She Nearly Lost Consciousness, Stalking Her And Breaking Into Her Apartment: $10,000 Cash Bail Set

Kurtis Bolton, 46, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 46-year-old Kenosha man is facing eight criminal charges, including five felonies, after prosecutors say he choked his ex-girlfriend until she nearly lost consciousness, repeatedly stalked her and forced his way into her apartment. Kurtis Bolton, 46, of Kenosha, appeared in court Thursday, November 19, 2026, before Kenosha County Court Commissioner Daniel

Kenosha Unified School District Among 31 Districts Nationwide Helping Develop Innovative High School Math Program

KENOSHA, Wis. — Kenosha Unified School District (KUSD) is one of just 31 school districts participating in a national pilot program designed to change how high school students learn mathematics. The innovative program, already being taught at Harborside Academy, focuses on real-world problem-solving, statistics, and critical thinking skills intended to better prepare students for college and careers. The course, called Integrated Statistics and

Kenosha Common Council Approves $111.4 Million Budget For 2027: City Property Tax Rate Drops Despite Spending Increase

KENOSHA, Wis. — The Kenosha Common Council approved a $111.4 million operating budget for 2027 on Wednesday evening, November 18, 2026, increasing city spending by approximately 4.68% while lowering the city’s portion of the property tax bill for homeowners. The budget, supported by Mayor David Bogdala, includes a reduction in the city’s property tax rate that will save the owner of a home

Plus +

Kenosha Man Charged With Two Felonies After Allegedly Breaking Into K-Town Cafe And Stealing Cash: Police Find Suspected Stolen Coins During Search Of Home

Ron J. Spohn, 58, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 58-year-old Kenosha man is facing two felony charges and one misdemeanor after police say he targeted a local restaurant on two separate occasions, eventually breaking inside and stealing approximately $100 from the cash register. Ron J. Spohn, also known as Ronnie Jay Spohn, was charged Thursday, November 19, 2026, with

Plus +

Kenosha Man, 70, Accused Of Calling Children Racial Slurs, Throwing Scooter At Child And Spitting On Father At Somers Motel

Daniel P. Graham, 70, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) SOMERS, Wis. — A 70-year-old Kenosha man is facing a criminal charge after authorities say he repeatedly yelled racial slurs at young children, threw a scooter toward a fleeing child and spit on a father who confronted him at a Somers motel. Daniel P. Graham was charged Thursday, November 19, 2026, with misdemeanor disorderly

Plus +

Union Grove Nursing Student Accused Of Driving Drunk With .213 Alcohol Level, More Than 2.5 Times Legal Limit, Crashing Jeep Into Tree And Berating Hospital Staff

Mia C. Kirk, 24, of Union Grove(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) SOMERS, Wis. — A 24-year-old Union Grove woman who allegedly drove drunk with a preliminary breath test reading of .213, more than two and a half times Wisconsin’s legal limit, crashed her Jeep into a tree, and then spent hours screaming at and insulting hospital employees has been charged with two misdemeanors in

Nearly 5 Kilograms Of Methamphetamine, Nine Guns Seized In Major Twin Lakes Drug Investigation Involving Local, County And Federal Authorities

TWIN LAKES, Wis. — A major multi-agency drug investigation in Twin Lakes resulted in the seizure of approximately five kilograms of suspected methamphetamine, nine firearms, marijuana, THC vapes and cash, according to Twin Lakes Police Chief Katie Hall. The investigation targeted a suspected kilogram-level methamphetamine distributor who police say is a convicted felon with a history of drug-related arrests. On Friday, November 13,

Plus +

Kenosha Man, 19, Wanted For Repeated Sexual Assault Of A Child: $50,000 Arrest Warrant Issued — Call 911 If You See Him

KENOSHA, Wis. — A 19-year-old Kenosha man is wanted by authorities after being formally charged Wednesday, November 18, 2026, with repeatedly sexually assaulting a young girl. Ahmad Jermaine Lea Jr., 19, of Kenosha, faces one count of repeated sexual assault of the same child, a Class C felony. Kenosha County Circuit Court Judge Heather Iverson issued a $50,000 arrest warrant Wednesday. Lea is

Plus +

Wisconsin DOJ Investigating Racine County Sheriff’s Captain Cary Madrigal As Newly Obtained Emails Raise Questions About District Attorney’s Involvement In Child Pornography Case

Captain Cary Madrigal, Patricia Hanson, and Pedophile Preston Kite RACINE, Wis. — The Wisconsin Department of Justice’s Division of Criminal Investigation (DCI) has been asked to investigate Racine County Sheriff’s Captain Cary Madrigal over allegations involving the investigation of former Union Grove High School Superintendent Thomas Johnson, who was charged with possessing child pornography. Sources familiar with the situation in Kenosha County believe

Plus +

City Of Kenosha Pays $35,000 To Woman Who Sued Police Over Traffic Stops And Drug Searches; Criminal Charges Dismissed

KENOSHA, Wis. — The City of Kenosha has paid $35,000 to Erica Lea Hawkins, 42, of Kenosha, after she filed a federal civil rights lawsuit accusing Kenosha police officers of violating her constitutional rights during two separate traffic stops. The lawsuit, filed March 10, 2026, was resolved just over five months later, without a trial, after the city offered to allow a $35,000

Kenosha Area Chamber Of Commerce Moving To Historic Downtown Building After Nearly 20 Years At Current Location

KENOSHA, Wis. — The Kenosha Area Chamber of Commerce announced Wednesday, November 18, that it will relocate its downtown headquarters after nearly two decades at its current location. The organization plans to move into the historic Schwartz Building at 520 58th Street in downtown Kenosha, with an anticipated opening in January 2027. The Chamber has operated out of 600 52nd Street, Suite 130,

Thanksgiving Holiday Will Delay Garbage And Recycling Collection In Kenosha; Fall Compostables Program Coming To An End

KENOSHA, Wis. — City of Kenosha residents who normally have their garbage and recycling collected on Thursdays or Fridays will need to adjust their schedules next week as the Thanksgiving holiday brings changes to several city services. The City of Kenosha Department of Public Works announced Wednesday that there will be no curbside garbage, recycling, brush, compostables, tire or bulk collection on Thanksgiving

LATEST NEWS

Mayor David Bogdala’s Administration Hires Former Bristol School District Administrator Jack Musha To Lead Youth Academy Despite Previous Misconduct Allegations

KENOSHA, Wis. — Jack Musha, the former Bristol School District administrator who resigned in December 2024 while facing possible termination over allegations of misconduct, has been hired by the City of Kenosha to manage the Kenosha Emerging Leaders Academy (KELA), a taxpayer-supported youth development initiative. The hiring took place under Kenosha Mayor David Bogdala’s (R) administration, which bears ultimate executive responsibility for the

Plus +

Nearly 30 Years After Alleged Kenosha Car Break-In, Illinois Man Returns To Court On 1997 Criminal Charges, Posts $1,500 Cash Bail

Justin Picou, 47, of Beach Park, Illinois(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 47-year-old Beach Park, Illinois, man is back in Kenosha County Circuit Court nearly 30 years after prosecutors accused him of breaking into a former coworker’s vehicle and stealing approximately $1,400 worth of stereo equipment. Justin Picou, who was just 17 years old when the alleged crime occurred on April

Kenosha County’s Annual Christmas Tree Lighting Returns November 28 With Santa, Live Reindeer, Christmas Carols And Free Family Activities

SOMERS, Wis. — Kenosha County residents are invited to kick off the Christmas season with a full day of holiday festivities as the fourth annual Kenosha County Tree Lighting Ceremony returns to Petrifying Springs Park on Saturday, November 28, 2026. The free, family-friendly celebration will feature Santa and Mrs. Claus, live reindeer, Christmas carols, ornament decorating, holiday food and drinks, and the lighting

Plus +

Woman Who Was Just 18 When She Caused Four-Vehicle Crash During Second OWI Pleads Guilty To Felony; Judge Revokes Bail And Orders Her Into Custody

Karina Roque Kenyon, 22, of Grand Rapids, Michigan(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — Karina Roque Kenyon, 22, of Grand Rapids, Michigan, pleaded guilty Thursday, November 19, 2026, to a Class H felony charge of causing injury while operating a vehicle with a restricted controlled substance following a four-vehicle crash in Somers in May 2022. Despite being just 18 years old at the

Plus +

Registered Sex Offender Accused Of Battering Pregnant Girlfriend In Kenosha Released On No-Cash Bail Despite Repeat Offender Status

Sherman T. Hill, 33, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 33-year-old Kenosha man and registered sex offender is facing two criminal charges after allegedly battering his girlfriend, who is eight months pregnant with his child. Sherman T. Hill, 33, of Kenosha, was charged Friday, November 20, with misdemeanor battery and disorderly conduct, both carrying domestic abuse and repeat offender enhancements.

Plus +

Salem Man Accused Of Trying To Enter Stranger’s Kenosha Home At 5 A.M., Yelling Racial Slurs And Profanities; Also Facing Retail Theft Charge With Felony Penalty Enhancer

William M. Fude, 32, of Salem(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 32-year-old Salem man is facing two separate criminal cases after Kenosha police say he attempted to enter a stranger’s home early Friday morning while yelling racial slurs, swearing and behaving erratically. William M. Fude, 32, of Salem, was charged Friday, November 20, 2026, with misdemeanor disorderly conduct and a separate

Plus +

Wilmot Raceway Supporters Score Major Victory In Kenosha County Fair Board Election, Ousting Three Incumbents Amid Allegations Of Plot To Shut Down Racetrack

Wednesday’s Annual Meeting of the Kenosha County Fairgrounds(Cell Phone Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye) WILMOT, Wis. — An unusually large crowd descended on the Parkway Chateau Wednesday night, November 18, 2026, for the Kenosha County Fair Association’s annual meeting, in what fair insiders are calling an overwhelming mandate to preserve Wilmot Raceway and continue the hundreds of thousands of dollars in

Plus +

Kenosha Killer Who Sexually Assaulted And Brutally Murdered Mother Of Two In 2006 Seeks Commutation Of Life Sentence: District Attorney Xavier Solis Urges Governor To Deny Request

Convicted Murderer, Rapist, and and Sex Offender Anthony P. Heard Jr., 38, formerly of Kenosha(Wisconsin Sex Offender Registry) KENOSHA, Wis. — Anthony P. Heard Jr., 38, formerly of Kenosha, is seeking to have his life-without-parole prison sentence commuted nearly 20 years after he sexually assaulted and brutally murdered Carmen E. Barranco-Dax, a 38-year-old mother of two from Gurnee, Illinois. Heard, who was already

Plus +

17-Year-Old Kenosha Man Charged With Armed Burglary, Robbery After Allegedly Kicking In Ex-Girlfriend’s Door, Threatening To Shoot Her And Her Brother

Sahmere J. Powers, 17, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 17-year-old Kenosha man is facing eight criminal charges, including two felonies, after prosecutors say he kicked in his ex-girlfriend’s door, repeatedly assaulted her and her brother, threatened to shoot them, and stole her cellphone. Sahmere J. Powers, 17, of Kenosha, appeared in court Thursday, November 19, 2026, where Kenosha County

Plus +

Kenosha Music Store Manager Criminally Charged After Allegedly Making Sexually Inappropriate Comments To Teenagers: Owner Seemingly Misled Kenosha County Eye About His Knowledge Of Investigation

Julian J. Paulsen, 44 of Kenosha – Manager at Music Center, Inc(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 44-year-old Kenosha man who manages a longtime local music store has been criminally charged with three counts of disorderly conduct following allegations that he repeatedly made sexually inappropriate comments to teenagers, including a 16-year-old female employee and two teenage boys. Julian J. Paulsen, a

Plus +

Threat Against Staff Member Prompts Brief Secure At Whittier Elementary School, Pleasant Prairie Police Response

Pleasant Prairie Police Department(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye) PLEASANT PRAIRIE, Wis. — Students and staff at Whittier Elementary School, 8542 Cooper Road, were placed in a brief classroom secure Thursday, November 19, 2026, after Pleasant Prairie police responded to a report of a possible threat involving a school staff member. Pleasant Prairie Police Officer Ben Arzikovic, a member of the

Christmas At Kemper Returns With Holiday Market, Santa, S’mores, Historic Mansion Tours And Gallery Of Trees

KENOSHA, Wis. — One of Kenosha’s longtime holiday traditions is returning to the lakefront this year, bringing Christmas trees, historic mansion tours, local shopping, visits with Santa, live music and family activities to the Kemper Center campus. Christmas at Kemper will feature several events beginning November 28 and continuing through December 12, 2026, including the 30th anniversary celebration of the popular Gallery of

Plus +

Kenosha Man Accused Of Choking Ex-Girlfriend Until She Nearly Lost Consciousness, Stalking Her And Breaking Into Her Apartment: $10,000 Cash Bail Set

Kurtis Bolton, 46, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 46-year-old Kenosha man is facing eight criminal charges, including five felonies, after prosecutors say he choked his ex-girlfriend until she nearly lost consciousness, repeatedly stalked her and forced his way into her apartment. Kurtis Bolton, 46, of Kenosha, appeared in court Thursday, November 19, 2026, before Kenosha County Court Commissioner Daniel

Kenosha Unified School District Among 31 Districts Nationwide Helping Develop Innovative High School Math Program

KENOSHA, Wis. — Kenosha Unified School District (KUSD) is one of just 31 school districts participating in a national pilot program designed to change how high school students learn mathematics. The innovative program, already being taught at Harborside Academy, focuses on real-world problem-solving, statistics, and critical thinking skills intended to better prepare students for college and careers. The course, called Integrated Statistics and

Kenosha Common Council Approves $111.4 Million Budget For 2027: City Property Tax Rate Drops Despite Spending Increase

KENOSHA, Wis. — The Kenosha Common Council approved a $111.4 million operating budget for 2027 on Wednesday evening, November 18, 2026, increasing city spending by approximately 4.68% while lowering the city’s portion of the property tax bill for homeowners. The budget, supported by Mayor David Bogdala, includes a reduction in the city’s property tax rate that will save the owner of a home

Plus +

Kenosha Man Charged With Two Felonies After Allegedly Breaking Into K-Town Cafe And Stealing Cash: Police Find Suspected Stolen Coins During Search Of Home

Ron J. Spohn, 58, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 58-year-old Kenosha man is facing two felony charges and one misdemeanor after police say he targeted a local restaurant on two separate occasions, eventually breaking inside and stealing approximately $100 from the cash register. Ron J. Spohn, also known as Ronnie Jay Spohn, was charged Thursday, November 19, 2026, with

Categories
Archives
Authors

Wake Up to What You Missed

Get notified of new articles. We'll never share your email address.