Layout 1

Kenosha County Eye

Search
Close this search box.
Search
Close this search box.

Former Kenosha Police Officer Raises Bizarre Defenses To Alleged Sexual Assault

Share
Tweet
Former Kenosha Police Officer Joshua Sylvester (28)
(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

A fired Kenosha Police Officer who is facing four decades behind bars if convicted for alleged sexual assault, seemed to detail his defenses to allegations of sexual assault in recently filed court documents.

Paid Advertisement

According to the 8-page criminal complaint, the now-fired police officer, 28-year-old Joshua Sylvester, is accused of some very serious crimes. The below allegations are graphic in nature and intended to be read by adults:

Former Kenosha Police Officer Joshua Sylvester (28)
(Racine County Sheriff)

Former Kenosha Police Officer Joshua Sylvester was at Aurora Hospital on August 18, 2022 monitoring an intoxicated 24-year-old woman who he arrested for OWI after crashing into a tree and losing consciousness. Sylvester inserted his fingers into the victim’s vagina several times while at the hospital. He also pulled out his penis and asked her to touch it. She refused but he forced her to. He added his cell phone number to hers as “Officer Josh” and sent himself nude photos of the woman from the woman’s phone. A Kenosha County Sheriff’s Detective viewed body camera footage, some of which had to be recovered by I.T. staff due to Sylvester turning off the camera. The footage supported all of the victim’s allegations. Sylvester even tried to cover the body-camera with his hand, but he was still seen sexually assaulting the victim. Sylvester later took the victim to the jail, but before they got into the squad car, he asked her not to “have a conversation about any of that in the car” because the squad cars have microphones and cameras. The victim didn’t initially want to tell her story but her friend and her Dad told her to go to the Kenosha Police Department. They met with Kenosha Lt. Joseph Nosalik, the then-commander of the Internal Affairs unit. On August 22, 2022, Kenosha Sheriff’s detectives executed a search warrant at Sylvester’s home and he immediately knew why there were there. His wife told police that Sylvester washed his uniform once to remove blood, but police found no uniform in the home. Sylvester waived his fifth amendment rights and made unreasonable excuses. When asked why he had vaginal secretions on his hands, he said it was because he “stopped her from masturbating.” He also said he held her hand to pray. He denied sending the nude photos to himself.

Paid Advertisement
Former Kenosha Police Officer Joshua Sylvester (28) and Criminal Defense Attorney Timothy Baldwin
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

Sylvester’s legal team is comprised of seasoned criminal defense attorney Timothy Baldwin and another lawyer in his firm who’s been an attorney for about a year and a half – Erica Young. Young filed a series of legal documents that seem to give us a glimpse into the disgraced former officer’s defense.

  1. This case is a he said/she said case.
  2. Complaining witness (victim) engaged in erotic and flirtatious behavior by rubbing and exposing her breast and vaginal area while she was in custody.
  3. Sylvester was an inexperienced officer, and still on probation.
  4. Complaining witness’s lack of memory and shadowy inserted false memories
  5. Police didn’t perform a thorough enough investigation.
  6. Police didn’t seize the complaining witness (victim)’ ‘s phone for evidence.

In Attorney Young’s motions, she is also requesting to do something that isn’t done in this state for criminal cases barring exigent circumstances – depositions. Young wants to depose, or question under oath before trial, the complaining witness (victim), police officers, and other witnesses. Attorney Young cites the 6th Amendment (Right of Confrontation) as the basis for her request for depositions.

Paid Advertisement
Michael D. Cicchini, Criminal Defense Attorney and Author
(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

We asked criminal defense attorney and author Michael D. Cicchini to opine on some of the defenses and other motions that were filed.

“Depositions are quite rare in Wisconsin criminal law.  One requirement is to show that a particular witness will be unavailable for trial.  Without such a showing, I can’t see any Kenosha judge granting a defense lawyer’s request for a deposition,” Cicchini told KCE Wednesday. “The right of confrontation is a trial right.  I’m not aware of any right of confrontation in pretrial discovery.  I’ve never heard of the Sixth Amendment right of confrontation being applied in such a context.” 

Paid Advertisement

“I don’t see how [the complaining witness’s sexual behavior] or [Sylvester’s inexperience as a police officer] could be defenses to the charged crime of Sexual Assault by a Law Enforcement Officer. The complaining witness’s lack of memory or misremembering (false memory) is certainly a defense, as it goes to whether the incident actually happened. The failure to properly investigate the case is a recognized defense.  It is sometimes called the investigative ‘omission defense.’ I don’t know if [law enforcement] would have the right to take the complaining witness’s phone or force her to have an invasive SANE evaluation.”

KPPA (Kenosha Professional Police Association) President Pete Deates

The Kenosha Professional Police Association condemned the allegations against Sylvester and immediately supported the termination, which was swiftly made by the-chief Eric Larsen.

Paid Advertisement
Complaining Witness
(Kenosha County Sheriff)

According to court documents, the complaining witness in this case was alleged to be driving on 64th St near 96th Ave in Kenosha, with a .242 Blood Alcohol Level – more than three times the legal limit. She lost control of her car and hit a tree. She was charged with OWI.

Christine Genthner (D) – City of Kenosha Municipal Prosecutor
(facebook)

City prosecutor Christine Genthner (D) dismissed the OWI in October of this year and won’t tell KCE why. This means, when and if this woman drives intoxicated again, it will be her first under statute. Genthner, a lifelong democrat, is the wife of the embattled former Joint Services Director Tom Genthner and a 30-year parishioner of St. Mary’s Catholic Church in Kenosha. This is the church with the rogue priest Roman Stikel (D) that supports C.U.S.H.’s pro-abortion and pro-trans activism.

Sylvester’s wife paid for the $15,000 bail and is standing by her husband, even being aware of Body-Worn-Camera footage depicting her husband “fingering” a drunk prisoner. They recently celebrated their 4 year anniversary.

Sylvester is scheduled to stand trial in May of 2024.

Author

Share
Tweet
LATEST NEWS

Kenosha Police Officer Who Wrote More Than 2,000 Citations In Last Five Years Doesn’t Lead By Example: Opinion

In the last five years, Kenosha Police Officer Nicholas J. Benvenuto has written more than 2,000 citations. That is more than 95% of law enforcement in the Kenosha area. In the same time period, he wrote 99 warnings. Benvenuto also does a seasonal motorcycle detail. In the 2023 season, from 4/1/2023 to 9/30/2023, Benvenuto wrote 489 citations. That’s about 100 per month. When Benvenuto is on the motorcycle detail, it’s his job to keep the roads

Read More »

36-Year-Old Salem Lakes Woman Passes Away From ATV Crash Sunday

During the evening hours of June 9th, 2024, members from the Kenosha County Sheriff’s Department, Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources, and Salem Lakes Fire Department responded to a single ATV crash in the 8600 block of 234th Avenue in the Village of Salem Lakes. This crash resulted in a single fatality. At approximately 9:11 PM on June 9th, Kenosha Joint Services 911 received a call from area residents stating they observed a single ATV that crashed into

Read More »
MORE TOP STORIES

A Life Remembered: Troy Wohlgefahrt

Troy Wohlgefahrt made a sudden and tragic exit from this world this weekend. Here is a glimpse about who Troy was during his life. KCE sat down with Troy’s Mom, Gail Kulbacki and Troy’s two younger sisters, Nicole Wohlgefahrt and Theresa Busanet. Troy came into this world with a lot of luck. Troy was a twin, who’s brother didn’t survive childbirth. The doctor’s told his mother he was lucky to have been born healthy. He was

Read More »

Parade To Be Held In Honor Of Bradford High School’s State Title

After a tremendous season, the Bradford girls’ softball team won the WIAA Division I state championship title. The Kenosha Unified School District and the City of Kenosha invite the community to celebrate this momentous victory with a hometown parade on Wednesday, June 12, at 5 p.m. “This incredible achievement is a testament to Bradford’s hard work and dedication,” said KUSD Superintendent Dr. Jeff Weiss. “Let’s come together to cheer on the Red Devils and show our

Read More »

Woman Accused Of Dragging, Killing Man Charged Today – $50,000 Bail Ordered

A woman who splits her time between Illinois and Wisconsin has been charged for Sunday morning’s crash that took the life of 52-year-old. Sheila Tennin was charged today with three felonies: Homicide By Vehicle – Use of a Controlled SubstanceHit and Run – Resulting in Death, and Knowingly Operate Motor Vehicle Without a Valid License – Cause Death If convicted of all counts, Tennin faces about 56 years in the Wisconsin Prison System. According go the

Read More »

FBI, Kenosha County Sheriff Raid Somers Home Last Wednesday

KCE was made aware of a warrant that was served on a Somers home last Wednesday, June 5, 2024 in the 1200 Block of 42nd Ave in Somers. As many as 20 Sheriff and FBI vehicles were reported to be on scene before noon. KCE reached out to the home’s owner, Steve Rezmer, who hung up on KCE when asked about the raid. We then heard from Rezmer’s attorney, Patrick Cafferty who told KCE that he

Read More »

Racist Bristol Neighbor Charged With Two Misdemeanor Counts Of Violating A Restraining Order

An 83-year-old Bristol man was charged last week with two criminal counts of “Violating A Restraining Order.” Felix N. Siordia was in court on Thursday, June 6, 2024 and pleaded ‘not guilty’ to both counts. Siordia is a racist neighbor that is upset that a black man, and his family bought the property next to him and want to build their dream home. Siordia then enlisted the help of the Village of Bristol Administrator Randy Kerkman,

Read More »

Pastor’s Sexual Assault Trial Postponed Until December – Late Evidence From Prosecution

Today, the trial of a 61-year-old pastor from Agape Love Christian Church here in Kenosha has been postponed until December 16, 2024. Pastor Monroe Mitchell III stands accused of repeatedly sexually assaulting his own granddaughter. Late evidence sparked defense attorney Aileen Henry to ask for an adjournment. Henry said she was “blind-sided” by Assistant District Attorney Alexandra Smathers when she got two witness statements after the final pre-trial on May 30, 2024. Henry said she didn’t have

Read More »

Woman In Custody For Allegedly Striking, Killing, Dragging Pedestrian Under Car For Five Blocks

(This story has been updated to reflect the victim’s correct age due to a Police clerical error and to correct the point of alleged contact and the length that the man was dragged under the car.) Late last night, Saturday, June 8, 2024, at about 8:52 p.m., a man was walking when he was struck struck near the intersection of Sheridan Road and 58th Street. The man was identified as 52-year-old Troy Wohlgefahrt. It wasn’t until

Read More »

Law Firm Hired By Kenosha County Concludes Violations By Former Board Member – Milwaukee District Attorney Refuses To Take Action

Leading up to this April’s election, when County Board member Andy Berg (D) lost his seat, he admitted to handing out “hundreds” of county maps and “hundreds” business cards during the election season. This seems to be clearly illegal and seems to clearly violate county ordinances and state statute. KCE filed a complaint with the Kenosha County DA and the Wisconsin Ethics Commission. Kenosha DA Mike Graveley sent KCE’s complaint to the Milwaukee County DA. At

Read More »

Judges Denies Rogue Prosecutor’s Motion To Dismiss Serious Sexual Assault Charges Against Pleasant Prairie Man

Rashan H. Romaine, 49, of Pleasant Prairie walked into court today and had a noticeable grin on his face for the entirety of two hearings. When he left court, however, he had no look of happiness. This is probably becuase he was expecting to go home today, but he didn’t. Romaine, accused of forcible rape, was set to have his criminal case dismissed today at the request of Kenosha County Assistant District Attorney Alexandra Smathers. In

Read More »

Long-Time Trevor Fire Chief Passes

Thomas Gary Seep, 74 years old of Trevor, WI passed away Saturday, June 1, 2024. He was born December 7, 1949 in Chicago, IL the son of the late Robert H. and Beth E. (Stratton) Seep. On January 31, 1970, Thomas married Linda Dunn in Des Plaines, IL.  Tom proudly served his country in the United States Marine Corps during the Vietnam War. He was an active part of the Trevor community, serving on the school

Read More »
Categories
Archives
Authors

38 Responses

    1. If the woman was known to have one prior OWI within ten years or three or more total then the city has no jurisdiction. The case must be dismissed and referred to the DA for charging as a state case. It happens from time to time and ordinarily no big deal. The municipal citation is essentially superseded by a criminal complaint.

      If this is the case, the city attorney had no choice. Only a first offense can be a municipal case.

      1
      1
      1. Continuing….

        Forgot to note that under no circumstances can the city attorney simply “dismiss” an OWI. Wisconsin law prohibits a prosecutor from amending or dismissing an OWI charge without court approval. Then it’s up to the municipal judge. There are three typical acceptable reasons:

        1. No jurisdiction as it should have been charged by the DA in a criminal complaint in circuit court.
        2. Defendant deceased.
        3. Evidentiary problems, such as the blood test coming back with zero alcohol or drugs (it happens). With a .242 not likely the case here.

              1. Assuming it would be a second or subsequent offense then the DA will have to charge it but that puts Graveley’s office in a pickle of prosecuting the officer, in which case the woman would be a witness, and simultaneously prosecuting her with the former officer that they are prosecuting as the lead witness.

              2. Even if it’s a first offense the OWI case may be dead in the water. The arresting officer is charged with sexually assaulting the OWI defendant during the traffic stop. If he testified at her trial he could “take the fifth.”

                1
                2
  1. Absolutely disgusting on so many levels. Sylvester belongs in prison for the full 40 years, his wife needs her head examined for stupidity, Genther should be fired and Stikel should be laicized.

    10
    1
  2. If the warrant didn’t take place until the 22nd and this happened on the 18th, why were there still vaginally secretions on his hands? “When asked why he had vaginal secretions on his hands, he said it was because he “stopped her from masturbating.” Gross!

  3. With our district attorney’s office, I’m surprised they don’t let him cop to a plea of, “looking for spare change”.

  4. All you cop bashers need to back the blue. they are doing a Tony the Tiger great job. bunch of clowns. also, it is racist to hold colored folks accountable for their many crimes. shame shame

  5. KPD, like other local police departments, have not only lowered hiring standards including background requirements, as they actively pursue equity which values skin color above all else.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LATEST NEWS
Categories
Archives
Authors

Subscribe to updates

Get notified of new articles. We'll never share your email address.