CAEGI 0003 November Ads 2022x250

Kenosha County Eye

Is Law Enforcement In Kenosha County Racist? A Local Attorney/Author Studies This Question

Share
Tweet
Kenosha Author and Criminal Defense Attorney Michael “Mike” D. Cicchini
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson)

In his latest law review article published by LMU Law Review, Kenosha criminal defense attorney and author Michael Cicchini studies claims of racism in policing, and he looks specifically at law enforcement agencies in Kenosha County.  Our interview is below.

Paid Advertisement

KCE:  Attorney Cicchini, thanks for doing this interview.  First, what’s your background in the criminal justice system?

____________________________

Paid Advertisement

CICCHINI:  I’ve been a Kenosha criminal defense lawyer for twenty years, and I’m also an author.  I write books, law review articles, essays, and blog posts on the criminal justice system with a heavy emphasis on Wisconsin criminal procedure.  That is, I tend to study and write about things like prosecutorial, judicial, and police misconduct.  An example would be the way the police violate Miranda when interrogating suspects.  Put another way, my writing centers on procedural fairness.  As far as my professional practice, I’m constantly battling law enforcement agents in pretrial hearings and in jury trials. 

KCE:  Why did you write this latest article, Disorderly Conduct: An Investigation into Police and Prosecutor Practices

Paid Advertisement

CICCHINI:  I stumbled across two law review articles on disorderly conduct (DC).  Despite my adversarial relationship with law enforcement, the authors’ claims seemed pretty outlandish to me.  They were claiming that the police are using the DC statutes as a justification to surveil black neighborhoods for signs of disorder.  This, the authors claimed, resulted in more arrests and convictions of black defendants.  To support their claim, they cited national arrest statistics showing that more black suspects were arrested than white suspects for the crime of DC, even though white citizens make up a higher percentage of the population. 

This struck me as one of those academia “equity” claims, where the claimant simply assumes that some evil thing is the cause of a disparate outcome, when in fact there could be many different explanations.  It’s like confusing correlation with causation, which is the very thing an academic should never do.  So I decided to test this claim by studying Kenosha County DC cases which would include three law enforcement agencies: KPD, KSD, and PPPD.

Paid Advertisement

KCE:  How did you do the study?

CICCHINI:  I looked at every single DC case filed by the Kenosha County District Attorney’s office for acts of DC alleged to have occurred in July of 2018.  (In the article, I explain why I picked that time-frame.)  I found that our local charging statistics closely mirrored the national arrest statistics cited by the authors.  That is, black defendants did, in fact, make up a disproportionate percentage of cases involving DC, relative to their percentage of the population.  My next step was to determine whether the disproportionate charging was caused by racist police surveillance.

KCE:  How did you do that?

CICCHINI:  I looked at the details of every single case filed.  First, I found that most DC cases were domestic (DV) in nature, which means that it’s almost certainly a case that does not involve police surveillance of any kind.  That is, nearly 100 percent of DC-DV cases will involve a complaining citizen witness summoning the police to the scene.  After checking the details of each case, I found this to be true 100 percent of the time in the sample.  Almost always the police were called by the alleged victim.  In the remaining DC-DV cases, the police were summoned by another citizen witness calling on behalf of the alleged victim.  Then I investigated the DC cases that were not DC-DV, but rather just plain DC.  If the police were surveilling anyone, it would be in this class of cases.  But once again, I found that in every single case, the police were summoned to the scene by a complaining witness.

The upshot is this: When zero percent of the DC cases are the result of police surveillance, we can rule out racist police surveillance as the cause of the disproportionate charging of DC cases.

KCE:  Did you determine what the cause of the disproportionate charging was?

CICCHINI:  No.  I didn’t have the data to test other hypotheses.  My only interest was testing a very narrow hypothesis: Was racist police surveillance the cause of the disproportionate charging of black defendants with DC in Kenosha County?  It was not.  Besides, the article was already over 50 pages, and I wasn’t interested in writing a book on the subject.

However, in the article I do discuss some of the other possibilities and explain how they might be difficult to test.  For example, is it possible that police are racist in their arrest decisions after initially being summoned to the scene?  It’s possible, although mandatory arrest laws would probably mitigate that.  Anyway, how would you measure racism in arrest decisions?  Take the usual situation of a DC-DV situation between a black suspect and a black alleged victim. Would the police be racist for arresting the black suspect, or would they be racist for not arresting the black suspect and ignoring the claims of the black alleged victim?  When academics make broad, sweeping claims of racism in the criminal justice system, they often forget to examine the race of the alleged victim.

KCE:  Were there any other findings in your article?

CICCHINI:  I did test one other hypothesis, and the findings won’t surprise any criminal defense attorney.  The DC statute is being abused not by police, but in a race-neutral way by prosecutors.  In other words, in the vast majority of cases, regardless of the defendant’s race, DC was not charged alone but rather was used as a tack-on charge to other charges.  When prosecutors stack charges, they are able to extort a plea out of the defendant by offering to dismiss some of the charges.  The classic example is charging a defendant with battery and DC (and sometimes other charges) for a single, alleged act.  In my sample of cases, when DC was used as a tack-on charge, 100 percent of the cases were resolved by plea bargain and not a single case went to trial.  For reasons I explain in the article, this doesn’t conclusively prove that DC is an effective, charge-stacking weapon, but it is strong evidence in support of that claim.  Also, I used the words abuse and extortion, but I should note that this prosecutorial practice of charge-stacking to force plea bargains is perfectly legal, although it shouldn’t be.

KCE:  So what’s the bottom line?  Police are not racist?

CICCHINI: There was no evidence of racist policing whatsoever in the study.  You have to understand its limits.  This article studied only one county (Kenosha) in one state (Wisconsin) and very few law enforcement agencies (primarily KPD).  On top of that, it dealt with only one particular police practice (surveillance) in one type of case (DC).  So it is a very limited finding.  And that’s the important lesson.  Those who make claims of racism should be specific, should have evidence or at least a well-formed hypothesis to begin with, and should not assume as the cause of the observed outcome the very thing that must be tested, i.e., racism.  In other words, they should avoid these broad, far-ranging claims of systemic racism that are currently all the rage in legal academia and in academia generally.  Such claims, when unsupported by evidence, may even mask the true, underlying problems that have nothing whatsoever to do with race.

KCE: Thanks for the interview!

Cicchini has been featured in the KCE in this post about his statewide criminal defense award, and he also wrote this guest post on Rittenhouse and Race.

Author

  • Kevin Mathewson

    Kevin Mathewson is a disciple of Christ, husband and a father to two wonderful children. Mathewson was born and raised in Lake County, IL and worked as a police & fire dispatcher from 2005 to 2010 in Round Lake Beach, IL. Mathewson moved to Kenosha County in 2006, later being elected to the position of Alderman of the 8th District in 2012 and 2016. Mathewson is a private investigator, security contractor, journalist, and photographer. He enjoys spending time with his family, watching movies, camping and boating. His favorite amendment is the second, followed closely by the first. He loves his country and community.

Share
Tweet
LATEST NEWS

Embattled Director Of Women’s Shelter Drops Lawsuit That Was Allegedly Filed Illegally

The embattled director of Women and Children’s Horizons dropped a lawsuit yesterday, two weeks after it was filed, and only 10 days after KCE published an article alleging she was practicing law without a license. According to a 8-count findings document outlining an investigation into misconduct, Paine was disbarred May 20, 2023. The documents says in part, “After proceedings conducted pursuant to [Michigan Supreme Court Rules], the panel found, based on [Paine’s] admissions to all of the

Read More »

Man Who Escaped Kenosha Prison In July Captured In Milwaukee County, Was In Possession of Firearm

On July 26, 2023 a State Prison inmate named Parish Eckford escaped from a Kenosha Prison. This is a State of Wisconsin Department of Corrections Facility and not associated with the Sheriff’s Department jail. Eckford was serving a 16-year prison sentence for the following convictions in Milwaukee Circuit Court: Eckford was scheduled to be released the month he escaped. He previously served 5 years for armed Robbery. The prison, is a minimum security prison that is

Read More »
MORE TOP STORIES

After 30 Years On The Job, Kenosha Deputy Police Chief To Retire: Q and A

After 30 years on the job, the Kenosha Police Department’s # 2 is hanging up his gun belt. Deputy Chief Tom Hansche announced his retirement officially on October 4, 2023 in a memo to the Chief. “This memo is to inform you that I will officially retire from the Kenosha Police Department on December 31, 2023…I have been blessed with many opportunities and I wish you and the department nothing but the best of success in

Read More »

Salem Lakes Fire Chief, Inspector, Intimidated Subordinates Not To Cooperate With Investigation: Document

In an explosive report released to KCE following a public records request, investigators outline an inquiry into misconduct that was obstructed by the former Salem Lakes Fire Chief and Fire Inspector. The eight-page report begins with an executive summary saying “Overall, following nearly two-dozen interviews and the review of hundreds of pages of communications and records, it could be determined significant deficiencies exist in the respective performances of the Fire Chief and Fire Marshal. However, as

Read More »

After More Than A Year On Bail, Exonerated Kenosha Man Speaks Out

When then 28-year-old Arris Parker tried to break up a fight on August 3, 2022, he never though he would be fighting the Kenosha DA’s office to determine where he would spend the next 20 years of his life – in prison, or as a free man. But that is exactly what Mr. Parker says happened. The same day that he was arrested for trying to help quell a disturbance, one where someone was stabbed, Parker

Read More »

Gov. Evers Appoints Toni L. Young to the Racine County Circuit Court

MADISON — Gov. Tony Evers announced today his appointment of Toni L. Young to the Racine County Circuit Court – Branch 3. The appointment fills the vacancy created by Judge Maureen M. Martinez’s resignation, effective Nov. 17, 2023. Young will complete a term ending July 31, 2024.  “Toni Young is a well-respected attorney with broad experience who is committed to seeking justice for everyone who enters her courtroom,” said Gov. Evers. “She will be an excellent judge for

Read More »

Gov. Evers Appoints Frank Gagliardi to the Kenosha County Circuit Court

MADISON —Gov. Tony Evers announced today his appointment of Frank Gagliardi to the Kenosha County Circuit Court – Branch 3. The appointment fills the vacancy created by Judge Bruce E. Schroeder’s resignation, effective Nov. 27, 2023. Gagliardi will complete a term ending July 31, 2024. “Frank Gagliardi has strong connections to the community and is committed to fairness and integrity,” said Gov. Evers. “He will serve the people of Kenosha County well as their next circuit court

Read More »

Commissioner William Michel II Declares Candidacy For Kenosha Judge

KENOSHA, WI | Longtime Kenosha lawyer and Kenosha Circuit Court Commissioner William Michel has announced his candidacy for the office of Circuit Court Judge. This announcement follows the retirement of longtime Circuit Court Judge Bruce E.Schroeder. “Judge Schroeder is an incredible role model, the ultimate professional, and a fair minded jurist who has served our community for more than four decades. He has served with dignity and has kept our community safe, ensured justice, and elevated

Read More »

6 Responses

  1. Can’t imagine what it’s like constantly dealing with a prosecutor’s office like Kenosha. I highly doubt Binger and Kraus are the exception.

    Hey what’s goin’ on with Black? Binger still on him like a pitbull on a mailman?

  2. I had read a book written by Mike Chicchini, a very good lawyer. If my memory recalls correctly, in his book he mentions how common a defendants constitutional right are often violated not only by the police, but prosecutors and judges alike. Read the book several yeas ago though I seem to recall this with great interest.

  3. Charge stacking. Disorderly conduct indicative of racism, huh? Guess thatmakes the Fed prosecutors racist as heck because damn near every person charged for 1/6 has two or more DC charges, and the ‘stacking’ is absolutely blatant.

    This is all so disgusting. They’re the enemy and see us as complaining useless eaters.

  4. I don’t believe the PD is racist one bit. I believe the activists and some “county supervisors “ who are wanna be activist are racist. I think the word racist is now thrown around when someone don’t get their way or are upset with a outcome. I mean the “activist “ of kenosha called rittenhouse a white supremacy member, for shooting 3 white people and calling one white guy that yelled the N word a hero. So ass backwards the hypocrites are in this city

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LATEST NEWS

Subscribe to updates

Get notified of new articles. We'll never share your email address.