Rittenhouse and Race
 

Copied!
Rittenhouse and Defense Team (Mark Hertzberg /Pool Photo via ZUMA PRESS)

This is a guest post by Kenosha criminal defense attorney Michael Cicchini 

Paid Advertisement
Michael Cicchini – Kenosha Criminal Defense Attorney and Author
(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

In a recent article in the Guardian, an author named Michael Harriot criticized the Kyle Rittenhouse trial, including the jury’s verdict and Wisconsin’s law of self-defense.  I believe his claims are rooted in common errors of fact and law.

Paid Advertisement

 

When reading Harriot’s article, I got the same feeling I often get during the prosecutor’s closing argument in a criminal trial.  Whether I’m responding to this talented writer in print or to a rhetorically skilled prosecutor in the courtroom, their claims feel “very much like landmines: they are easy to lay, but difficult and time-consuming to clean up.”  Therefore, to keep this article from becoming book-length, I’ll address in detail only two of Harriot’s criticisms.

Paid Advertisement

 

The alleged “fear of black people”

Paid Advertisement

 

Harriot claims that Rittenhouse was acquitted, at least in part, because “white people find black protesters scary.”  He similarly alleges: “[O]ne of the scariest, most dangerous situations those white jurors could imagine [is] a BLM protest.”  And, in his most extreme race-based claim: “The Rittenhouse verdict is proof that it is reasonable to believe that the fear of Black people can absolve a white person of any crime.” 

Paid Advertisement

 

No, the jury’s verdict is not “proof” of any such thing.  But to begin, in fairness to Harriot, he does mention in his article that the three people Rittenhouse shot, two of whom died, were white.  This is better than other critics, many of whom completely ignore that fact or even falsely state that the decedents were black.  Nonetheless, Harriot’s attempt to tie a white person’s shooting of three white men to race doesn’t withstand scrutiny.  Rittenhouse’s actions and the jury’s verdicts had nothing to do with “fear of [b]lack people” or even of “BLM protest[ers].”

Paid Advertisement

 

First, by the time of the shootings, legitimate BLM protests had been replaced by acts of arson, mayhem, and general lawlessness.  The first person Rittenhouse shot—a white man named Rosenbaum—had threatened to kill him, chased him, and tried to take his gun.  And before Rosenbaum even decided to attack Rittenhouse, he was caught on film repeatedly yelling the n-word.  In short, Rosenbaum was not black, nor was he a BLM protester.

 

Second, the two white men that Rittenhouse subsequently shot went even further than Rosenbaum did.  One pulled a gun and pointed it at Rittenhouse.  The other struck Rittenhouse in the head with a skateboard and then grabbed his rifle.  In an example of extreme spin-doctoring, the state’s prosecutors mocked the idea of a skateboard being a dangerous weapon.  However, that term is defined by how an object is used.  Wisconsin prosecutors have even won convictions on dangerous weapon-related charges when a defendant uses a pillow (conviction upheld) or even his bare hands (conviction eventually reversed).  A heavy object like a skateboard, when used to strike a person in the head or neck, most certainly qualifies.

 

The point, of course, is that Rittenhouse didn’t fear the three men because they were black (they weren’t), or because they were BLM supporters.  Rittenhouse feared these three white men, and the jury found his fear reasonable, not because of who the men were, but because they were acting aggressively and violently at that time.

 

The alleged white supremacy of self-defense

 

In a related topic, misconceptions about Wisconsin’s self-defense law are staggering.  Before being fired for alleged journalistic violations when defending his brother against what he believed to be false allegations, CNN personality Chris Cuomo criticized Wisconsin’s self-defense law because, he claimed, it doesn’t incorporate the reasonable person standard.  Conversely, in his article in the Guardian, Harriot claims that Wisconsin’s reasonable person standard is not only racist—“[a] white person must have come up with this,” he wrote—but actually helped Rittenhouse escape conviction. 

 

Both are wrong.  As for Chris Cuomo, Wisconsin’s law already incorporates a reasonable person standard.  As for Harriot’s claim, the second part of the self-defense test, the reasonable person standard, makes it more difficult for a defendant to win a self-defense trial. 

 

First, to prevail on self-defense, the defendant must have actually, subjectively believed certain things about the danger he was in and the force that he used to protect himself, i.e., “the defendant believed . . .”  Second, the defendant’s beliefs must also have been reasonable, i.e., the test is “what a person of ordinary intelligence and prudence would have believed . . .”  This second part of the self-defense standard benefits the state, not the defendant. 

 

Without this second part of the test, i.e., the reasonable person standard, the Rittenhouse prosecutors would have been dead in the water at trial.  Rittenhouse proved his personal, subjective beliefs through his own testimony and the multiple videos that showed him literally fleeing all three of his attackers.  As far as what he subjectively believed, those two pieces of evidence were unimpeachable.  

 

The only reason the prosecutors had a prayer of winning a conviction, and probably the reason the jury took longer than expected to acquit, was the reasonable-person prong of the test.  The prosecutors argued several times that Rittenhouse’s beliefs about the danger he was in and the force he needed to terminate the threats against him were not reasonable.  (They even went so far to argue that Rittenhouse should have just taken his beating at the hands of his white attackers.)  The jury ultimately rejected the state’s position.  But the state didn’t lose because a reasonable person would be “in fear of black people” or of “BLM protest[ers],” as Harriot argues.  Rather, the state lost because Rittenhouse was, and a reasonable person would have been, in fear of the three white men who threatened him, chased him, grabbed for his rifle, struck him in the head with a skateboard, and pulled a pistol on him.  

Harriot calls this “white reasoning,” but I have no idea what self-defense standard he would use in its place.  And before proposing a new standard, any proponent should look beyond a single case that they like or don’t like, and keep in mind that the standard will apply to black defendants as well.

 

A smorgasbord of spin

 

I have to once again, and genuinely, give Harriot credit for avoiding in his article the often repeated but false claims that Jacob Blake was shot seven times “in the back,” or that he was “unarmed.”  Harriot also didn’t accuse Rittenhouse, as so many others have, of “crossing state lines,” as if there is something sinister or even illegal about traveling a few miles from Antioch, Illinois to Kenosha, Wisconsin.  (When I was Rittenhouse’s age, I routinely “crossed state lines” to go from Kenosha, where I lived, to Antioch, where I had a part-time job.  This is the reverse of what Rittenhouse did, as he lived in Antioch but had a job, a parent, and friends in Kenosha.) 

 

But Harriot does make other claims in his article with which I disagree or which could, I fear, be misleading.  For example, his article could be read to imply a causal relationship between Kevin Mathewson’s “call to arms” and Rittenhouse’s presence in Kenosha.  But the possibility of cause-and-effect has been thoroughly investigated and ruled-out.  (See, e.g., here and here.)  Further, witness testimony at trial revealed why Rittenhouse came to Kenosha and, in particular, to the downtown area; it had nothing to do with Mathewson. 

 

Similarly, Harriot’s article claims that thousands of people responded to Mathewson’s “call to arms” because of their fear of black people.  In reality, they responded because our city was being destroyed—some of it was literally on fire—and law enforcement and our local and state “leaders” were either unable or unwilling, for political reasons, to prevent further damage.  (Ironically, the rioters’ destruction was mostly inflicted on economically poor areas, the black residents therein, and the small businesses serving those neighborhoods.)

Finally, Harriot doesn’t claim that Rittenhouse provoked the attacks by Rosenbaum, et al.; however, he does claim, in criticizing the self-defense law, that Rittenhouse could have claimed self-defense even if he had provoked the attacks.  Harriot is saying, for example, that if Rittenhouse (rather than Rosenbaum) had been yelling the n-word, thus provoking three black men (rather than three white men) to attack him, he still could have argued self-defense at trial.  But as explained in the provocation jury instruction, Harriot’s claim is false, or at a minimum is incomplete.

 

I have not addressed these last three claims in-depth, and I have not addressed other of Harriot’s claims at all.  Rather, I leave you, dear reader, to keep an open mind and rationally investigate them for yourself.

 

About the Author

Michael Cicchini is a Kenosha criminal defense lawyer and author.  His written work includes nearly forty law review articles and four books on criminal law and procedure.

Author

Copied!
LATEST NEWS

Steil Secures $700K Federal Grant for Pike River Restoration in Kenosha County

KENOSHA, Wis. – Kenosha County will receive $700,000 in federal funding to support water quality improvements and habitat restoration along the Pike River, Congressman Bryan Steil announced Friday. The money, awarded through the Environmental Protection Agency’s Great Lakes Restoration Initiative, will go to the Kenosha County Division of Parks. The grant is intended to help restore more than 3,200 feet of streambank and

Plus +

Teen Charged in High-Speed Chase That Endangered Multiple Children

SOMERS, Wis. – A Kenosha teenager is facing six felony charges after allegedly leading deputies on a dangerous high-speed chase through residential neighborhoods with three juveniles in the vehicle, including two minors who had reportedly stolen a relative’s car. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

MORE TOP STORIES

Somers Man Accused of Assaulting Elderly Housemate, Obstructing Arrest

SOMERS, Wis. — A 61-year-old Somers man is facing felony charges after allegedly assaulting his elderly housemate and refusing to cooperate with sheriff’s deputies during a chaotic arrest at a deteriorating home in the Town of Somers. Nick W. Picazo was formally charged Friday in Kenosha County Circuit Court with

Plus +

Underwear-Clad Intruder Charged After Breaking Into Porch, Banging on Door

Phillipp Schiavi, 58, of Kenosha KENOSHA, Wis. — A 58-year-old Kenosha man is facing three criminal charges after allegedly running through a neighborhood in his underwear and trying to force his way into a stranger’s home while screaming profanities. You must be logged in to view the rest of this

Plus +

Trio Charged in Kenosha Wallet Theft and Gift Card Scheme

Keir Saunders, 47, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff) KENOSHA, Wis. — Three suspects are facing felony charges after a Kenosha grocery store manager’s stolen wallet was used to buy over $1,200 in gift cards at Walmart last month. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Categories
Archives
Authors

4 Responses

  1. i would enjoy reading your decimation of the remaining claims of harriet. what you wrote so far is insightful and i appreciate you using words to help a lay person as myself to understand.
    as far as kyle/race and that night in kenosha- can you just imagine what would have been said and done had he not missed jump kick man? whoa nelly. it is a shame kyle missed.

  2. I’ve seen most of Harriot’s work – this is typical and if you critique him or post a poem on WACDL you get banned lol. :).

  3. Why are we still giving these fucks the time of day? It serves no purpose. You’re not going to get the ideologically possessed to see their wrongs.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LATEST NEWS

Steil Secures $700K Federal Grant for Pike River Restoration in Kenosha County

KENOSHA, Wis. – Kenosha County will receive $700,000 in federal funding to support water quality improvements and habitat restoration along the Pike River, Congressman Bryan Steil announced Friday. The money, awarded through the Environmental Protection Agency’s Great Lakes Restoration Initiative, will go to the Kenosha County Division of Parks. The grant is intended to help restore more than 3,200 feet of streambank and

Plus +

Teen Charged in High-Speed Chase That Endangered Multiple Children

SOMERS, Wis. – A Kenosha teenager is facing six felony charges after allegedly leading deputies on a dangerous high-speed chase through residential neighborhoods with three juveniles in the vehicle, including two minors who had reportedly stolen a relative’s car. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Plus +

$17,500 Bail Set for Kenosha Man Caught with Fentanyl, MDMA, and Marijuana, Police Say

Elijah B. Echols, 27, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff) KENOSHA, Wis. – A 27-year-old Kenosha man with a violent criminal history is facing three new felony drug charges after police say they caught him with more than 30 counterfeit pills containing fentanyl and MDMA, along with a stash of marijuana hidden in his body. You must be logged in to view the rest of

Somers Man Accused of Assaulting Elderly Housemate, Obstructing Arrest

SOMERS, Wis. — A 61-year-old Somers man is facing felony charges after allegedly assaulting his elderly housemate and refusing to cooperate with sheriff’s deputies during a chaotic arrest at a deteriorating home in the Town of Somers. Nick W. Picazo was formally charged Friday in Kenosha County Circuit Court with felony physical abuse of an elder person—intentionally causing bodily harm. He also faces

Plus +

Underwear-Clad Intruder Charged After Breaking Into Porch, Banging on Door

Phillipp Schiavi, 58, of Kenosha KENOSHA, Wis. — A 58-year-old Kenosha man is facing three criminal charges after allegedly running through a neighborhood in his underwear and trying to force his way into a stranger’s home while screaming profanities. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Plus +

Trio Charged in Kenosha Wallet Theft and Gift Card Scheme

Keir Saunders, 47, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff) KENOSHA, Wis. — Three suspects are facing felony charges after a Kenosha grocery store manager’s stolen wallet was used to buy over $1,200 in gift cards at Walmart last month. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Plus +

Salem Lakes Board Sparks Outrage After Voting to Let Convicted Predator Live Near Park, Boy Scout Camp

Child Predator Joshuah C. Koboldt, 40, of Salem Lakes (9416 276th Avenue)(Wisconsin Sex Offender Registry) SALEM LAKES, Wis. — The Salem Lakes Village Board ignited a firestorm this week after narrowly approving a convicted child predator’s request to live just steps away from a children’s park and Camp Wonderland, a well-known Boy Scout campground. You must be logged in to view the rest

Extreme Heat Warning: Kenosha County Reminds Residents of Available Cooling Centers

KENOSHA COUNTY, Wis. – With extreme heat warnings in effect this week, Kenosha County officials are urging residents to take precautions and make use of designated cooling centers throughout the area. Cooling centers are available at various municipal buildings, libraries, and community organizations across the county. These locations offer air-conditioned relief and are open to the public during the hours listed below: .

Plus +

Strangulation, Threats, and False Imprisonment: Kenosha Man Faces 10 Charges

Arturo L. Martinez III, 24, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff) KENOSHA, Wis. – A 24-year-old Kenosha man is facing ten criminal charges—including felony strangulation, false imprisonment, and threats to injure—after a woman reported months of domestic violence that allegedly occurred in front of their young children. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Plus +

Kenosha Man Charged in Drive-By Shooting at Family Party

Damien C. Wess, 24, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff) KENOSHA, Wis. – A 24-year-old Kenosha man is facing two felony charges after allegedly driving a getaway vehicle from a shooting that took place at a family gathering. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Paddock Lake Man Accused of Strangling Neighbor Over Property Dispute

PADDOCK LAKE, Wis. — A 54-year-old Paddock Lake man has been charged with felony strangulation and elder abuse after allegedly attacking his 66-year-old neighbor during a property line dispute on June 15 in the Village of Paddock Lake. Richard K. Ruck faces three charges: physical abuse of an elder person, strangulation and suffocation, and disorderly conduct. The criminal complaint, filed June 17 in

Free German-Style Pop-Up Biergarten Returns to Kenosha’s Lakefront July 17–19

KENOSHA, Wis. — A popular summer tradition is returning to HarborPark as the Hofbräu Pop-up Biergarten sets up along the lakefront from July 17 through July 19. The event is free to attend and promises three days of festive, family-friendly fun in the spirit of a traditional German Biergarten. Held at Celebration Place, 5501 Ring Road, the biergarten will serve authentic Hofbräuhaus beer

Plus +

Kenosha Riot Participant Denied Early Release by Judge

Kelly Ziminski, 34(Kenosha County Sheriff and Wisconsin DOC) KENOSHA, Wis. — One of the rioters present the night Kyle Rittenhouse shot three people in Kenosha has been denied early release from prison. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Plus +

Kenosha Woman Sues County After Sheriff’s Squad Crashes Through Funeral Procession

Kenosha Sheriff’s Squad(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye) KENOSHA, Wis. — A Kenosha woman is suing Kenosha County after a sheriff’s squad allegedly ran a red light and drove through a funeral procession, crashing into her vehicle and causing serious injuries. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Restraining Order Violator Allegedly Threatened to “Make Body Disappear,” Witness Says

SALEM, Wis. — Michael A. Daniels, a failed farmer with a long trail of legal troubles, was in court Tuesday after allegedly violating a temporary restraining order just hours after being served. Kenosha County Court Commissioner William Michel set bail at $500 cash. Daniels, 48, of Salem, is charged with violating a temporary restraining order issued May 19. If convicted, he faces up

Kenosha Bartender Accused of Scissors Attack On Sister

KENOSHA, Wis. — In the early hours of June 2, 2025, a 33-year-old Kenosha bartender, Justine E. Bloxdorf, was arrested after allegedly attacking her sister with a pair of scissors following a reported dispute involving drugs. According to police sources, a 9-1-1 call was made around 2:22 a.m., shortly after Bloxdorf finished her shift at a downtown tavern. Responding Kenosha officers recommended criminal

Fourth OWI Defendant Wanted After Failing to Appear in Court

KENOSHA COUNTY, Wis. — A Burlington man is now the subject of an active arrest warrant after failing to appear in court Wednesday on felony charges related to an alleged fourth drunk driving offense earlier this month. Matthew J. Mortensen, 47, was summoned to appear at 1 p.m. in Kenosha County Circuit Court for an initial appearance in case 2025CF000855. When he failed

Plus +

Man Accused of Pointing Gun at Neighbor During Lakefront Dispute

Thomas L. Carlson Jr., 50, of Burlington(Kenosha County Sheriff) WHEATLAND, Wis. — A 50-year-old Burlington man is facing criminal charges after allegedly pulling a gun on his neighbor during a late-night confrontation at Lily Lake, escalating what authorities described as an ongoing feud between the two men. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Plus +

Kenosha Man Held Woman Hostage at Knife Point for Seven Hours, Prosecutors Say

Glen D. Pipkin Jr., 40, of Kenosha in Court Today(Photo by Nathan DeBruin, for Kenosha County Eye) KENOSHA, Wis. — A Kenosha man is facing serious felony charges and is being held on a high cash bail after police say he brutally attacked and held a woman hostage inside their shared home for over seven hours, using a knife to threaten, injure, and

Plus +

Kenosha Woman Accused of Stealing SUV, Resisting Arrest While Out on Bond for Two Other Cases

Crystal S. Wakefield, 31, of Kenosha of Kenosha In Court Today(Photo by Nathan DeBruin for Kenosha County Eye) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 31-year-old Kenosha woman is facing six new criminal charges after allegedly stealing a vehicle and resisting arrest while already out on bond in two separate cases. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

LATEST NEWS

Steil Secures $700K Federal Grant for Pike River Restoration in Kenosha County

KENOSHA, Wis. – Kenosha County will receive $700,000 in federal funding to support water quality improvements and habitat restoration along the Pike River, Congressman Bryan Steil announced Friday. The money, awarded through the Environmental Protection Agency’s Great Lakes Restoration Initiative, will go to the Kenosha County Division of Parks. The grant is intended to help restore more than 3,200 feet of streambank and

Plus +

Teen Charged in High-Speed Chase That Endangered Multiple Children

SOMERS, Wis. – A Kenosha teenager is facing six felony charges after allegedly leading deputies on a dangerous high-speed chase through residential neighborhoods with three juveniles in the vehicle, including two minors who had reportedly stolen a relative’s car. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Plus +

$17,500 Bail Set for Kenosha Man Caught with Fentanyl, MDMA, and Marijuana, Police Say

Elijah B. Echols, 27, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff) KENOSHA, Wis. – A 27-year-old Kenosha man with a violent criminal history is facing three new felony drug charges after police say they caught him with more than 30 counterfeit pills containing fentanyl and MDMA, along with a stash of marijuana hidden in his body. You must be logged in to view the rest of

Somers Man Accused of Assaulting Elderly Housemate, Obstructing Arrest

SOMERS, Wis. — A 61-year-old Somers man is facing felony charges after allegedly assaulting his elderly housemate and refusing to cooperate with sheriff’s deputies during a chaotic arrest at a deteriorating home in the Town of Somers. Nick W. Picazo was formally charged Friday in Kenosha County Circuit Court with felony physical abuse of an elder person—intentionally causing bodily harm. He also faces

Plus +

Underwear-Clad Intruder Charged After Breaking Into Porch, Banging on Door

Phillipp Schiavi, 58, of Kenosha KENOSHA, Wis. — A 58-year-old Kenosha man is facing three criminal charges after allegedly running through a neighborhood in his underwear and trying to force his way into a stranger’s home while screaming profanities. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Plus +

Trio Charged in Kenosha Wallet Theft and Gift Card Scheme

Keir Saunders, 47, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff) KENOSHA, Wis. — Three suspects are facing felony charges after a Kenosha grocery store manager’s stolen wallet was used to buy over $1,200 in gift cards at Walmart last month. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Plus +

Salem Lakes Board Sparks Outrage After Voting to Let Convicted Predator Live Near Park, Boy Scout Camp

Child Predator Joshuah C. Koboldt, 40, of Salem Lakes (9416 276th Avenue)(Wisconsin Sex Offender Registry) SALEM LAKES, Wis. — The Salem Lakes Village Board ignited a firestorm this week after narrowly approving a convicted child predator’s request to live just steps away from a children’s park and Camp Wonderland, a well-known Boy Scout campground. You must be logged in to view the rest

Extreme Heat Warning: Kenosha County Reminds Residents of Available Cooling Centers

KENOSHA COUNTY, Wis. – With extreme heat warnings in effect this week, Kenosha County officials are urging residents to take precautions and make use of designated cooling centers throughout the area. Cooling centers are available at various municipal buildings, libraries, and community organizations across the county. These locations offer air-conditioned relief and are open to the public during the hours listed below: .

Plus +

Strangulation, Threats, and False Imprisonment: Kenosha Man Faces 10 Charges

Arturo L. Martinez III, 24, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff) KENOSHA, Wis. – A 24-year-old Kenosha man is facing ten criminal charges—including felony strangulation, false imprisonment, and threats to injure—after a woman reported months of domestic violence that allegedly occurred in front of their young children. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Plus +

Kenosha Man Charged in Drive-By Shooting at Family Party

Damien C. Wess, 24, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff) KENOSHA, Wis. – A 24-year-old Kenosha man is facing two felony charges after allegedly driving a getaway vehicle from a shooting that took place at a family gathering. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Paddock Lake Man Accused of Strangling Neighbor Over Property Dispute

PADDOCK LAKE, Wis. — A 54-year-old Paddock Lake man has been charged with felony strangulation and elder abuse after allegedly attacking his 66-year-old neighbor during a property line dispute on June 15 in the Village of Paddock Lake. Richard K. Ruck faces three charges: physical abuse of an elder person, strangulation and suffocation, and disorderly conduct. The criminal complaint, filed June 17 in

Free German-Style Pop-Up Biergarten Returns to Kenosha’s Lakefront July 17–19

KENOSHA, Wis. — A popular summer tradition is returning to HarborPark as the Hofbräu Pop-up Biergarten sets up along the lakefront from July 17 through July 19. The event is free to attend and promises three days of festive, family-friendly fun in the spirit of a traditional German Biergarten. Held at Celebration Place, 5501 Ring Road, the biergarten will serve authentic Hofbräuhaus beer

Plus +

Kenosha Riot Participant Denied Early Release by Judge

Kelly Ziminski, 34(Kenosha County Sheriff and Wisconsin DOC) KENOSHA, Wis. — One of the rioters present the night Kyle Rittenhouse shot three people in Kenosha has been denied early release from prison. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Plus +

Kenosha Woman Sues County After Sheriff’s Squad Crashes Through Funeral Procession

Kenosha Sheriff’s Squad(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye) KENOSHA, Wis. — A Kenosha woman is suing Kenosha County after a sheriff’s squad allegedly ran a red light and drove through a funeral procession, crashing into her vehicle and causing serious injuries. You must be logged in to view the rest of this article.

Categories
Archives
Authors

Wake Up to What You Missed

Get notified of new articles. We'll never share your email address.