Kenosha Nurse To File Defamation Suit Against Kenosha DA’s Office For Writing Email That Got Her Fired

Copied!
Kenosha Assistant District Attorney Alexandra Smathers (33) of Cedar Grove, WI
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

Kenosha Assistant District Attorney Alexandra Smathers had only been a prosecutor in Kenosha for nine months when she wrote a scathing email on May 9, 2022. This email went to an administrator at Aurora Health Care and was sent to complain about a sexual assault nurse who testifies often in court for the State. We will call her Betty. She begins the letter with “I should note that I have not personally worked with [Betty].” She then makes a series of very serious accusations about Betty. She started by questioning her nursing license, saying “First, it is my understanding she was not a registered nurse when she began her career as a SANE (Sexual Assault Nurse Examiner) and was not a registered nurse for some time. This obviously caused credibility concerns at trial.” She then went on to document cases in which Smathers says that Betty gave bad information in court that resulted in a person being found not guilty. Smathers also complained to Aurora that Betty claimed to be a Facebook friend with a member of the DA’s office, but “she was not.” She then accused Betty of violating a patient’s HIPPA rights during a case which led to a mistrial. Finally, Smathers complained about Betty wearing clothing to court that was too tight and wearing too much makeup.

Paid Advertisement

She then ends the letter by saying that other employees of the DA’s office could corroborate her statements – ADA’s T. Clair Binger and James Kraus, the two prosecutors who were nationally embarrassed trying Kyle Rittenhouse and failing.

Paid Advertisement

Aurora Fired Betty, who was the Forensic Program Nursing Supervisor at the time, two weeks after they received this email. She earned about $106,000 and had been with Aurora for almost eight years.

Paid Advertisement

Betty’s Lawyer Responds

Paid Advertisement

Betty hired a lawyer and he served notice on the DA’s office that Betty intends to sue them and seek a quarter of a million dollars plus punitive damages. In the letter, the attorney says that his client Betty “categorically denies the statements made in the May 9, 2022 email. Smather’s email was made with no firsthand knowledge of my client…..Ms. Smathers acknowledges as much in the first paragraph of her email… It is deeply disturbing that a public official would write such an email without any knowledge or investigation of the facts.” He says the statement about Betty “not being a nurse” and “not being a SANE nurse” are “patently false and can be confirmed by a thirty second search on the website for the Wisconsin Department of Safety and Professional Services.” It took this author about 45 seconds to verify that Betty has been a licensed nurse since 3/8/2006 and her license needs to be renewed by 2/29/2024. Betty’s lawyer also denied the she violated HIPPA and said that the defendant that Smathers said was found “not guilty” was actually convicted and also easily verifiable on the Wisconsin Court Website (CCAP). “Given the nature of [Betty’s] employment and profession, allegations regarding her nursing credentials or concerning patient confidentiality were considered extremely serious by her employer. Ms. Smathers should know the weight and seriousness of such allegations. To author an email to [Betty’s] employer without exercising basic fact checking or without having any firsthand interaction with [Betty] is incredibly unprofessional and reckless. ADA Smathers should know better.” He also called the complaint about the clothing and makeup “petty” saying that she has never received any complaints in her 16-year career.

Paid Advertisement

He ends the letter with:

“As a licensed attorney and representative of the County of Kenosha, the District Attorney’s office, Ms. Smathers should be fully aware of the need to investigate any and all claims and present a tempered, level-headed analysis of any situation. More than others, attorneys placed in the public’s trust, such as Ms. Smathers, should know of the ramifications of their actions. When Ms. Smathers wrote her email, she wrote an email not just on behalf of herself, but as an agent of the Kenosha District Attorney’s Office and government employee. Her words were given great effect by [Betty’s] employer – understandably so. And her untrue statements have now greatly harmed [Betty] who has been involuntarily separated from her employment. She has placed [Betty’s] career in jeopardy. As a result of Ms. Smather’s actions, Betty has legal causes of action for defamation, section 1983 deprivation of rights, tortious interference with contract, intentional infliction of emotional distress, and civil conspiracy.”

KCE reached out to Advocate Aurora and spoke with Cheri Mantz, Regional Communications Manager, and she provided KCE with the following statement:

“Forensic nurses provide invaluable services to survivors of sexual assault and are held to the highest standards of professional conduct. When there are allegations of misconduct, we initiate a thorough internal review and take action as appropriate. Out of respect for privacy, we do not comment on personnel matters.”

KCE also reached out to Smathers, who ignored our communication. Smathers became a lawyer in 2013 after graduating from the University of Wisconsin Law School. She worked briefly as a prosecutor for Columbia County, WI and then for the Sheboygan County DA’s office for almost eight years where she was promoted to Deputy DA in 2020 but then was demoted in 2021 according to her Linkedin. She was then hired by DA Michael Graveley in August of 2021. T. Clair and Kraus also didn’t return our communications. DA Mike Graveley was not available to talk this week but we will follow up with him at a later date.

Author

Copied!
LATEST NEWS

Civil Suit Against Fired Groomer KUSD Teacher Moved To Federal Court, More Defendants Added

Kenosha, Wis. – Former KTEC West science teacher Christian Enwright is facing a civil lawsuit and criminal charges after allegedly grooming a 13-year-old student, later 14, over an eight-month period from June 2023 to February 2024. The lawsuit, filed on May 20, 2024, in Kenosha County Circuit Court, accuses Enwright of manipulating and emotionally abusing the student to establish a future sexual relationship. The Kenosha Unified School District (KUSD), which originally faced the lawsuit in state

Read More »

Here Are The Government Employees Who Work In Kenosha County And How Much They Make

In the spirit of transparency, Kenosha County Eye requested salary information from the following government agencies in late 2024: Kenosha Unified School District (KUSD)City of KenoshaCounty of Kenosha Kenosha County District Attorney’s OfficeWisconsin State Public Defender’s Office Village of Paddock LakeVillage of Pleasant PrairieVillage of Twin LakesVillage of Salem LakesVillage of Somers Town of RandallTown of Wheatland Westosha Central High SchoolTrevor-Wilmot School DistrictTwin Lakes School DistrictWilmot Union High SchoolRiverview Salem Silver Lakes Silver Lakes School DistrictUW

Read More »
MORE TOP STORIES

KUSD’s Choral Fest Marred By Referendum Advocacy From Guest Conductor

Kenosha, Wis.– The 58th Annual Choral Festival, a cherished event that showcases the talent of Kenosha’s youth choirs, was overshadowed tonight by a controversial political speech that left many attendees feeling uncomfortable and disappointed. The evening, which was meant to celebrate the hard work and musical accomplishments of local students, took an unexpected turn when Ms. Lynn Swanson, the director of the New South Festival Singers and the Cobb Summer Singers from suburban Atlanta, Georgia, took

Read More »

75-Year-Old Bar Owner Sentenced to Four Years for Fatal Hit-and-Run in Kenosha

Kenosha, Wis. – A 75-year-old man was sentenced on Thursday to four years in prison for a fatal hit-and-run that claimed the life of a pedestrian in Kenosha in 2023. William E. Koprovic pleaded guilty to Hit and Run Involving Death, a charge stemming from the June 25, 2023, incident in which he struck and killed 42-year-old Scott Mingilino. He owns Rendezvous Tiki Bar in Kenosha. Kenosha County Judge Anthony Milisauskas handed down the sentence after reviewing

Read More »

Runnin’ With the Devil: KCE Q&A With Attorney and Author Michael Cicchini

What’s the definition of an IMPARTIAL JUROR in a criminal case?  You might think it’s a juror who has no financial ties or loyalties to either the defendant or to the prosecutor’s office.  But you’d be wrong!  So says local defense attorney and author Michael Cicchini in his newest law review article, The Devil’s Dictionary of Criminal Procedure.   KCE asked him about the article, how he came up with that title, and what his definition is

Read More »

Menominee Tribe Responds to KCE’s Report On Casino Concerns Amid Community Skepticism

Kenosha residents and local officials are raising serious concerns over the proposed Menominee Hard Rock Hotel & Casino project, as promises made by the tribe remain unfulfilled and new doubts emerge about the viability of the venture. After years of assurances that federal approval was imminent, the Menominee Tribe has yet to deliver, leaving many in the community questioning whether this casino will ever materialize—or if it should at all. A History of Missed Deadlines and

Read More »

KUSD Cuts Law Enforcement Access to Student Database, Citing Privacy Law

Kenosha, Wis. – The Kenosha Unified School District (KUSD) has reportedly restricted law enforcement access to a critical student database, raising concerns about school safety and investigative efforts. The database, known as Infinite Campus, is widely used by KUSD parents and staff to manage student records. Local law enforcement has historically relied on the system for various investigations, from issuing truancy citations to gathering intelligence on school threats, including potential shootings and other emergencies. A reliable

Read More »

Kenosha County Eye to Intensify Focus on Judiciary

Kenosha, Wis. – Kenosha County Eye (KCE) is sharpening its investigative focus on the Kenosha judiciary, a move prompted by growing concerns over judicial accountability and transparency. KCE has, at times, been critical of the Kenosha County Circuit Court judges, who, in a unique rotation system, oversee all areas of law. Currently, Judges Anthony Milisauskas, Angelina Gabriele, Jason Rossell, and Gerad Dougvillo handle criminal cases, while Judges Jodi Meier, Chad Kerkman, David Wilk, and Heather Iverson preside

Read More »

Governor Tony Evers Denies Pardon For Kenosha County Serial Arsonist

Silver Lake, Wis. – Governor Tony Evers (D) has denied the pardon application of 48-year-old Allen M. Dunski, Jr., a former firefighter and convicted serial arsonist from Kenosha County’s west side. The rejection, issued on November 15, 2024, came despite Dunski’s claims of rehabilitation and community service. A letter sent to Dunski by the Governor’s Pardon Advisory Board stated: “While the Governor’s Pardon Advisory Board commends you for the positive strides you have taken since completing

Read More »

Kenosha Man Charged with Repeated Sexual Assault of a Child, Held on $1M Bail

Kenosha, Wis. – A 43-year-old Kenosha man was formally charged today with Repeated Sexual Assault of a Child in Kenosha County Circuit Court. If convicted, Jesus Alcocer-Bautista faces a maximum sentence of 60 years in prison. During his court appearance, Kenosha County District Attorney Xavier Solis requested a $1,000,000 cash bail, citing the severity of the allegations and the need to protect the community. Kenosha County Circuit Court Commissioner William Michel II granted the request and

Read More »

10-Year-Old Girl Still Too Terrified To Return To School After Sexual Assault on Bus

**Explicit Content** Kenosha, Wis. — A 10-year-old girl from Nash Elementary School remains too afraid to return to school months after she was allegedly sexually assaulted by two male students on her bus ride home. Despite criminal charges, Title IX investigations, and pleas from the child’s mother, the Kenosha Unified School District (KUSD) has yet to remove one of the accused students from the school, leaving the victim in limbo. KCE first reported on this matter

Read More »

Two Twin Lakes Men Arrested On Child Pornography Charges

Twin Lakes, Wis. – Two Twin Lakes men have been arrested and charged with multiple counts of possession of child pornography following separate investigations by the Twin Lakes Police Department (TLPD) and the Wisconsin Division of Criminal Investigation (DCI) Internet Crimes Against Children (ICAC) Task Force. Arrests and Charges Nathan H. Bollow, 20, and Micah D. Griffiths, 20, were taken into custody in January 2025 after search warrants were executed at their respective residences. Bollow was

Read More »
Categories
Archives
Authors

21 Responses

  1. Obviously cases should be tried in court and not in the media but these allegations, for the most part, seem bizarre. One of the parts that does not make sense is about whether she was a registered nurse when she began as a SANE (a highly intensive training program). What was she then if not a registered nurse? The claim about “not a registered nurse for some time” seems ambiguous. Was that when she began as a SANE or at some point thereafter? A license could lapse for nonpayment of fees or failure to comply with continuing education but would be reinstated upon proof of compliance (some lawyers have been negligent in this respect). While much of this seems bizarre Aurora’s actions also seem bizarre. Would you can someone on the basis of one E-mail without an investigation and verification. KCE seems to blast the prosecutor but goes soft on Aurora. Obviously Aurora is not going to publicly comment but if the prosecutor’s complaints were bogus then Aurora, too, could be on the hook. You’d think that they would do more than rely on one complaint without doing their own internal investigation. Maybe they did do one and found a reason to terminate employment. In any event, this is all speculative and especially so because a suit apparently has not been filed but only threatened. What is the rest of the story?

    1. Good points here. I am under the understanding that in Wisconsin, most employees in the private sector are “at will.” So if they did not fire her for being in a protected class then I don’t think she has any legal recourse against Aurora. It would seem like Aurora wants to appease the government. The document was a notice of claim which is generally a precursor to a civil suit and is actually required under statute before you can legally sue the government

      1. I wondered if she was at will or a contract employee as a supervisor. They have the job posted now but it’s unclear. Whatever weirdness may have come from the DA’s office seems compounded by Aurora. I kept thinking what if someone at Aurora wrote the same thing about the Asst. DA. Would she have been fired for that? Don’t think so.

      2. Most large employers have Employee/Employment Handbooks that contain sections on termination. For example, there might be warnings or write ups and a procedure before termination. Those are legally binding and employers can be sued for failing to follow those provisions. Aurora is way too big with lots of lawyers on their payroll… they probably followed their procedures after getting the email – that would explain why they are not the #1 target of the lawsuit.

        It will all come out during discovery – too bad we can’t see the depositions that will take place!! The real shame is the taxpayers will have to pay the bill for the attorney fees and settlement (no way can this go to trial – the punitive damages would be insane!).

        One final thought – what kind of an attorney puts defamatory statements in writing using their official work email?!? What an idiot.

        1. There’s no “#1 target” in this kind of action. All potential defendants must be included. The notice of claim (the accuracy of which itself could be subject to debate) implied that the ADA’s E-mail to Aurora got the nurse fired. If so, and the allegations were false, there would be a claim against both. There are some BIG “ifs” here. Obviously the E-mail’s claims need to be false AND the reason Aurora canned her. But what if that was not the reason she was fired? Maybe Aurora had something else going on or, even without that, what if they had determined that the nurse, regardless of whether the E-mail’s claims were false, had a fractured working relationship with the DA’s office that impaired her ability to do the job? Or there was some other issue? If she was an at will employee that might be enough to do it. There must be more to the story here or Aurora’s team of lawyers was also asleep at the switch. And some of the E-mail’s assertions are peculiar. But maybe the HIPAA matter was enough. Who knows? But if Aurora says false claims in the E-mail were not the cause of her firing the case is DOA.

          Agree that the E-mail was bush league. If there were concerns, at first you do your homework and then you get off your ass and go see the people you need to see. But the DA’s office seems to be in their own ivory tower insulated from the community.

  2. It is a very long daily commute from Cedar Grove to Kenosha.

    Staff at the DA’s office has a long history of writing deceptive letters and memos about matters in which they have no expertise and standing to write. There is a current Circuit Court case in Brown County involving, at its core, the malicious actions of DA Graveley. Graveley wrote a misleading and deceptive letter and put it into the record of a 2019 John Doe proceeding into the death of Michael Bell, a serious violation of ethics rules. The Kenosha News never reports on this case nor its significance. This link will take you to one of the briefs filed in this case that describes Graveley’s unethical actions in great detail.

    https://drive.google.com/file/d/1cL3UjwCHkM3do5ZT4i-QJyu3o-21QIem/view?usp=sharing

    1. Even if we accept for argument there was impropriety in the Michael Bell investigation that statute of limitations for any relevant crime expired long ago. I may be wrong but didn’t Judge Schimel say that when he was AG?

      I find Mr. Bell, sr., to have his own credibility issues. He sued after his son’s death, which is his right, and then took the settlement money and has since run a nonstop smear campaign ostensibly seeking to litigate his beliefs that the police acted improperly. Missing from this is Mr. Bell’s own complicity in frustrating the truth surrounding his son’s death. Instead of taking the blood money he could have continued his suit and then the case would have had a thorough, public airing and, also, the officers would have had the chance to defend themselves. Mr. Bell and Mr. Bell alone stopped that process so he has nobody to blame but himself.

      1. Officers have a duty to tell the truth when they use deadly force. Their accounts conflict with the mountain of forensic evidence that has been uncovered since the two day investigation that cleared them.

        It is Bell’s, and many peoples’, well-reasoned opinion that there has been and continues to be an intentional concealment of the truth about this case at the highest levels of Kenosha Government, including DA Graveley. In other words, a cover-up.

        I would welcome attorneys to chime in, but in many cases of an intentional conspiracy to cover up a crime, the statute of limitations does not start until the cover-up is exposed. The local governments have never come clean.

        This is the September 27, 2017 letter that Graveley sent to Mr. Bell about his son’s case. Please note the paragraph that starts on the bottom of page 1 and ends at the top of page 2. Graveley writes a misleading and deceptive opinion on touch DNA. He then submitted this letter into the record of a 2019 John Doe proceeding into the Bell death. This letter helped convince the judge to dump the case.

        https://drive.google.com/open?id=18n3TPxJcQ74mmJEHv98UjDxA4HOGvqpH

        This letter is now the subject of a ethics complaint against Graveley that was filed with the Wisconsin Office of Lawyer Regulation, which is now the subject of the court action in Brown County Circuit Court.

        Dr. Karl Reich, a renowned forensic DNA expert, was retained to evaluate Graveley’s claims on touch DNA in aforementioned letter. You can read Dr. Reich’s affidavit and CV here: This is also an appendix in the Brown County action.

        https://drive.google.com/file/d/1_rywAkU8tCGkwOVc58mdTJyf22hkamCY/view?usp=sharing

        The bottom line is there are big problems with how the Bell case was handled. Maybe Mr. Bell could have handled things better. However, there is no guide book on what to do when your son is killed by the police and the police lie about the true circumstances of the death. Would you be Ok with it if it was someone you love?

  3. I would question Aurora’s actions more than the idiots in the District Attorney’s office, based only on what I’ve read here. I guess that’s why we have trials, so that the only facts that come out are attached to testimony from sworn witnesses.

    1. I would, too. So the E-mail begins with the prosecutor saying that she has no personal working relationship with the SANE which leads into some inaccurate allegations and upon that Aurora fires the nurse??? If that’s the way Aurora does things maybe we should question whether to get medical care from such a slipshod operation! Granted that the prosecutor seems off-base but man, WTF with Aurora? Either they’re off-base here or there’s some slippery attorney making a false claim.

  4. Clothes too tight
    Wore too much makeup
    This sounds like female jelousy at an 8th grade level
    I suspect this nurse is hot, while Smathers is not…

  5. A long time ago, a coworker pointed out to me certain realities in the work place. The one that really stood out was ‘the boss never wants to hire anyone smarter than himself’. It seems like embattled and bungling DA Mike Gravely is doing exactly this. By firing off a defamatory email, Smathers demonstrated her unprofessional judgement and conduct as well as a lack of concern for the consequences of her actions. I’d say ‘Conduct unbecoming of a Public Official’. It seems our Civil Servants picture themselves as Civil Masters! So did Graveley intentionally scrape the bottom of the barrel when he hired Smathers? Looking a little deeper, another question pops up, did Jambois or Zapf, whichever, hire Graveley for the same reason?
    Aurora’s firing of ‘Betty’ is equally unjust and I hope Betty’s attorney is one that issue also.

  6. Would bet she was demoted in Sheboygan because she isn’t really that tough on crimes done by certain individuals……which obviously are the type of prosecutors that Kenosha wants.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Categories
Archives
Authors

Subscribe to updates

Get notified of new articles. We'll never share your email address.