KCERental

Kenosha County Eye

Search
Close this search box.
Search
Close this search box.

Kenosha County is getting Sued…. Again

Share
Tweet

            In a not surprising event, Kenosha County has been sued once again.  This time for violating constitutional rights.  On Wednesday, September 15, the Kenosha County Board of Supervisors voted by 12 to 6 to adopt new supervisory districts.  The problem with that is that the new map is likely illegal and unconstitutional.  In a letter sent before the meeting, Attorney Anthony Nudo of Terry & Nudo, LLC outlined the issues with the map and assured the County that his clients would sue the County if they approved it.  They approved it.  Now a lawsuit has been filed.

Paid Advertisement

            Under the Constitution, the government has to perform a census and create new districts every 10 years for equal representation of the people.  The County complied with creating the new districts, but that’s where it ends.  Nudo confirmed on Thursday that he filed a lawsuit on behalf of his 11 clients, all electors of Kenosha County that will be affected by the alleged illegal map.  According to Nudo, pursuant to state and federal redistricting law, new Kenosha County supervisory districts must: (1) be substantially equal in population; (2) be compact; (3) be contiguous; (4) maintain communities of interest within a district; (5) comply with the Voting Rights Act; (6) preserve political subdivisions; (7) preserve cores of districts; and (8) preserve incumbents.  The lawsuit alleges that the County failed to comply with the law on many different fronts.

            The main argument against the County is the violation of the “one-person, one-vote” rule created by the U.S. Supreme Court.  Basically, the Court stated that every district should have an equal amount of population.  A 2016 U.S. Supreme Court case (Evenwel v. Abbott, 577 U.S. 937, 136 S. Ct. 1120, 194 L. Ed. 2d 291) states, “[w]here the maximum population deviation between the largest and smallest district is less than 10%, the Court has held, a state or local legislative map presumptively complies with the one-person, one-vote rule. Maximum deviations above 10% are presumptively impermissible.”  Here, Kenosha County has a deviation of 12.16%, substantially more than is presumed permissive by our Supreme Court. 

Paid Advertisement
Attorney and Former Alderman, Anthony Nudo

            In this lawsuit, the County has the burden to prove that the map is constitutional (based on the fact that the deviation is more than 10%).  The County can prove the map is constitutional if it had a good reason to deviate more than 10%.  For example, if the County was trying to preserve a “community of interest” (another constitutional principle), then it could deviate.  The problem is the County failed miserably to preserve communities of interest within districts.  A glaring example of this is White Caps Subdivision.  A subdivision is a “community of interest” under redistricting guidelines, and should be represented by one supervisor.  The basic principle is that like-minded people in a neighborhood should be afforded the right to complain to one politician if they have a problem.  White Caps is represented by a homeowner’s association which is exclusive to the neighborhood.  The residents of White Caps have a common interest and should be able to deal with a single supervisor.  The new map has White Caps divided between three different supervisors.  This adds to confusion and disenfranchises voters and violates the constitution.  There are other examples of splitting neighborhoods just to benefit certain politicians, and not for the benefit of citizens.

Opinion           

Paid Advertisement

Once again the County has purchased a lawsuit at the expense of taxpayers.  It’s time for local politicians to start following the law – the law put in place to protect citizens, and not to protect politicians to keep their jobs.  One-person, one-vote is a simple principle, and a good one at that.  The County should follow it.   

Towards the end of Wednesday night’s debate, Supervisor Jeff Gentz seemed to taunt the large crowd that attended the meeting to oppose the map saying “It’s also been brought up that we are gonna be sued in the morning, so be it!” To which the crowd yelled in excitement. Gentz then lost his cool and shouted at the chairman and asked that the citizens be removed. The chairman refused.

Paid Advertisement

Here is the breakdown of how the board members voted:

Here is the video of the meeting. Map discussion starts at 54:11

Paid Advertisement

Author

  • Kevin Mathewson

    Kevin Mathewson is a disciple of Christ, husband and a father to two wonderful children. Mathewson was born and raised in Lake County, IL and worked as a police & fire dispatcher from 2005 to 2010 in Round Lake Beach, IL. Mathewson moved to Kenosha County in 2006, later being elected to the position of Alderman of the 8th District in 2012 and 2016. Mathewson is a private investigator, security contractor, journalist, and photographer. He enjoys spending time with his family, watching movies, camping and boating. His favorite amendment is the second, followed closely by the first. He loves his country and community.

Share
Tweet
LATEST NEWS

What Happened To Zha’riyah? – Sexual Assault And Mysterious Death Of Beloved 5-Year-Old Girl

***Explicate Content and KCE is using Zha’riyah’s name with permission from and at the request of her mother*** What happened to baby Zha’riyah Robinson? We know she was a cute, spunky, sweet and beloved little five-year-old little girl.We know she was brutally sexually assaulted on August 22, 2023, and unfortunately, passed away less than three months later on November 16, 2023 in Surprize, Arizona. What we don’t know is how she died. In court today, Assistant

Read More »

Kenosha Police, U.S. Marshals Conduct Early Morning Raid In McKinley Neighborhood – One In Custody

Kenosha residents of the McKinley neighborhood reported seeing as many as 15 U.S. Marshals and Kenosha Police Officers raid a home in the 5600 block of 35th Ave just after 8:00 am. KCE was in the area and received a tip. KCE arrived just in time to see a 40-year-old man named Jada R. Delaney be taken into custody. Neighbors report asking some law enforcement officers telling them that Delaney was arrested for an alleged violent

Read More »
MORE TOP STORIES

Felix Garcia Takes Oath Of Office As New County Board Supervisor

Supervisor Felix Garcia, Jr took the oath of office today to be Kenosha County’s newest, and youngest supervisor. Today at 11:30 am, Garcia took the oath of office after his favorite judge agreed to administer it. I respect [Judge Milisauskas’] values and the way he runs his courtroom. I’ve seen him [on the bench] before. He is very fair and judges with common sense. He likes to see everybody’s side of the story. He really puts

Read More »

KUSD Middle School Teacher Fired, Then Later Allowed To Resign For Multiple Racist Remarks To Students

A middle school teacher named Marcus Gallo at Brompton has been fired. Two days later, he resigned. If that didn’t make sense to you, you aren’t alone. It didn’t make sense to KCE either. We were first tipped off about Marcus Gallo being placed on administrative leave for racist remarks on February 11, 2024. We asked KUSD to confirm this. They only confirmed that he was on leave. We then had to check in every once

Read More »

Kenosha Judges Sentences Pleasant Prairie Pedophile To More Than 23 Years In Prison

A Pleasant Prairie man will be spending more than two decades in prison following his sentencing for very serious child rapes convictions. Andre Poventud, 58, pleaded guilty in February of Repeated Sexual Assault of Same Child (At Least 3 Violations of 1st Degree Sexual Assault) and Possession of Child Pornography. He was initially charged with four felony sex offences on July 21, 2023, but the Pleasant Prairie Police Department, through further investigations, discovered other abhorrent acts.

Read More »

Indian Trail Orchestra Teacher To Be Given Plea Deal For Sex Crimes With Student – DA To Recommend 10 Years In Prison

A soon-to-be convicted pedophile and former Indian Trail High School orchestra teacher has accepted a plea deal recently and will be in court this week for a hearing. Nathan R. Gardner, 28, of Racine was charged with serious sex felonies on November 8, 2023: Gardner faced 97 years in the Wisconsin Prison System, however, Kenosha Police found more child pornography in Garner’s possession. Instead of adding the charges to Gardner’s docket, he was given a generous

Read More »

There Is One Man Mostly To Blame For Liberal Shift On County Board – Former Chairman Nudo: Opinion

People keep asking me the same thing – “What happened to the county board?” So many people, in fact, that I chose to write my opinion on what happened. Many share the blame – the local party, voters, but the lion’s share of the blame goes to one man – Gabe Nudo, the former Chairman of the board. Gabe was my friend for some 12 years. He became Chairman and thought he was my superior, like

Read More »

Kenosha Police Say 29-Year-Old Teacher Groomed 12-Year-Old Student – KUSD Won’t Fire Him, DA Won’t Charge Him: Updated

**The article was modified on April 19, 2024 @ 11:56am. See end of story for additions.*** On February 20, 2024, we told you about a 7th Grade teacher named Christian Enwright who was placed on administrative leave for an inappropriate relationship with a female student from the age of 12 through 14. The case is now closed and it appears Enwright will face no consequences for his egregious behavior. According to to a police report recently

Read More »

Kenosha County Board Back Under Democrat Control – Monica Yuhas Elected As Chair

Last night at the Kenosha County Board organizational meeting, two of the board’s most extreme democrats were elected to the two positions of leadership. Monica Yuhas (D) and Daniel Gaschke (D) were voted to be the chair and vice chair of the Kenosha County Board respectively for the next two years. The liberal nominee, Monica Yuhas garnered 12 votes and the conservative nominee, David Geersten garnered 9. Current chairman, Gabe Nudo, who was whipping votes for

Read More »

Promotions, Retirements At Today’s Kenosha Police And Fire Commission Meeting

Two long-time police supervisors, a patrol Lieutenant and a Detective Sergeant retired today. Also, four firefighters were promoted at today’s Police and Fire Commission meeting. City Hall was packed with supporters of the six City employees. Captain Todd Leipzig Promoted To Battalion Chief Captain/Paramedic Todd Leipzig has been a member of the KFD for 24 years. He earned an Associate and Bachelor’s Degree through Columbia Southern University in Fire Service Management. Prior to being hired by

Read More »

David F. Bogdala Sworn In As Kenosha’s 51st Mayor Tuesday Morning

This morning, at 8:00 a.m., 48-year-old David F. Bogdala was sworn in as Kenosha’s 51st Mayor. City Clerk Michelle Nelson administered the oath to Bogdala in his office on the third floor of City Hall. The short ceremony was attended by family and close friends. Bogdala will be sworn in again at tonight’s organizational meeting as more of a ceremonial event, but this morning made it official – and legal. Bogdala began his first four-year term

Read More »

Pleasant Prairie Police Dispatcher Charged With Serious Sex Crimes

**Editor’s Note – Explicit Material** A Pleasant Prairie Police dispatcher has been charged with two counts of posession of childpornography and three counts of exposing a child to harmful material today. He faces more than 60 years in prison if convicted. Kenosha County Eye is intentionally being non-specific and vague to protect the identity of victims and reporting parties. According to the criminal complaint: Brian J. Gildenstern, according to Kenosha County Sheriff’s Detectives and prosecutors, did

Read More »

4 Responses

  1. It’s of no surprise berg was absent, he only shows when it’s if benefit to him or one of the 200 fundraisers he does, or when he wants to play activist. Him and his buddy cardinalli and Roberts are his buddies in crime.

    1. Hey Q. If you ever wanna meet for coffee or lunch, my number is public. Unless you prefer to type on the keyboard instead of meeting face to face.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LATEST NEWS

Subscribe to updates

Get notified of new articles. We'll never share your email address.