Man Charged With Serious Felonies After DNA Exonerates Girlfriend Who He Let Take The Fall For Almost A Year

Copied!
Elijah J. Schoffstall, 20, of Inverness, IL (Right) and Attorney Patrick Cafferty (Left)
(Photo by Nathan DeBruin, Kenosha County Eye)

A 20-year-old Illinois man, who was charged last month for two serious felonies and one misdemeanor, is facing more than 20 years in the Wisconsin Prison System if convicted. Elijah J. Schoffstall was charged on March 15, 2024 with Felony Injury By Intoxicated Use Of A Vehicle, Felony Second Degree Recklessly Endangering Safety, and Misdemeanor Obstructing an Officer.

Paid Advertisement

According to court documents, the charges stem from a May 20, 2023 incident in which Schoffstall drove drunk and almost killed himself and his then-girlfriend, Marissa Chon.

Paid Advertisement

On May 19, 2023, Chon and Schoffstall, both adults, but under 21 at the time, were doing what many college students do on a Friday night – drinking alcohol with friends. At about 2:21 am, the two were involved in a serious car wreck at Carthage College, a school where they both attended. Both were severely injured and were lucky to survive. Police and bystanders quickly arrived at the scene of the crash to render aid.

Paid Advertisement
Chon’s 2016 Honda Civic At Crash Scene
(Photo Courtesy Kenosha Police)
Chon’s 2016 Honda Civic At Crash Scene
(Photo Courtesy Kenosha Police)

Schoffstall was lying on the ground when police arrived and was quick to blame his girlfriend, Chon as being the driver of the vehicle. Two women, who were on the scene when police arrived, were not involved, but stopped to help. They told police that Marissa admitted to being the driver of the car, however, her acknowledgment was only a head-nod, not a verbal admission. Unknown to anyone at the time, Marissa had suffered a severe concussion and broken jaw. She did not remember who was driving, but told police that usually no one else drives her car. She didn’t even remember who was inside the car when it crashed. Both her and her boyfriend appeared intoxicated to police.

One Kenosha Police Officer did however note that the seat of the Honda Civic was all the way back. Chon is very short and Schoffstall is very tall. Schoffstall was in possession of a fake ID.

Paid Advertisement
Elijah J. Schoffstall, 20 Inverness, IL – Mugshot
(Kenosha County Sheriff)

Based on Eli Schoffstall’s statement that Chon was driving, and her “head nod admissions” to two witnesses, she was arrested and charged with a serious felony called “Injury by Intoxicated Use of A Vehicle.” She was facing 12.5 years being bars in a Wisconsin prison, Chon stuck to her original story that she was not driving. Her story never changed.

Chon’s 2016 Honda Civic At Impound Yard
(Photo Courtesy Kenosha Police)
Chon’s 2016 Honda Civic At Impound Yard
(Photo Courtesy Kenosha Police)

Police noticed that there were spots of blood on both the driver’s side and passengers’ side airbags. The detective collected the driver’s side airbag and swabbed the blood from the passenger side airbag.

Paid Advertisement
Criminal Defense Attorney Mark Richards
(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

Chon and her family hired prominent Racine criminal defense attorney Mark Richards and he got to work. Richards noticed the Kenosha Police officer who said on his body-worn-camera something to the effect of “there is no way she was driving, look how far back the seat is” He also noticed that police took the blood from the airbags. Eventually, Kenosha Police sent both airbags to the Wisconsin State Crime Lab. The results came back conclusively on September 20, 2023. The swab taken of the driver’s side airbag came back as a single source male profile that matched Elijah Schoffstall and excluded Marissa Chon. The swab taken from the passenger side airbag came back as a single source female profile that matched Marissa Chon and excluded Schoffstall. The result for each airbag indicated that the probability of the DNA belonging to an unrelated individual is not more frequent than one in one quadrillion (1:1,000,000,000,000,000).

Blood on Airbag
(Photo Courtesy Kenosha Police)

The results were remarkable. Chon’s blood was on the passenger side airbag and Schoffstall’s DNA was on the driver’s side airbag. The evidence is 100% conclusive that Schoffstall was driving, and thus lied to police and threw his girlfriend under the bus. The Kenosha District Attorney’s office dismissed charges against Marissa Chon.

KCE spoke with Chon’s mother Kirsten, who said that Marissa is very traumatized by this entire ordeal. She wishes that the DA’s office would have waited to charge her daughter until all of the evidence was back. Kirsten is furious that Schoffstall lied to the police and let Marissa take the fall. Kirsten was upset that police didn’t let Marissa call her family after the crash. Chon’s extended family felt that the Kenosha DA appeared to be “trying to sweep this under the rug.”

Chon and her mother are both very thankful that Kenosha Police and Attorney Richards were able to exonerate Marissa.

Kenosha County DA Michael Graveley (D)
(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

KCE spoke with Kenosha County DA Mike Graveley immediately after the charges against Chon were dismissed. He couldn’t comment on specifics, but did tell us that the case was still under review by its office. KCE does have knowledge that medical blood draws require extra time to be used in court for prosecution, so it didn’t immediately appear that the DA’s office is doing anything unusual.

A spokesman from the Kenosha Police Department sympathized with Chon and explained to KCE that the evidence available at the time was enough to establish probable cause to charge Chon. The DA’s office, which is the only agency with the authority to issue charges, agreed. KPD says that when their investigation took a turn, they immediately notified the DA’s office that they had the wrong person.

Kenosha County Sheriff’s Department
(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

KCE spoke to Chon’s family, who were present in court today. They are understandably upset with a couple of key differences in the prosecution of the two. Chon’s mugshot was and still is on the Sheriff’s Department website, even though she was exonerated. The Sheriff’s Department knows she was exonerated but leaves the mug shot up anyway, even after she submitted the necessary paperwork according to the Sheriff’s policy on its website. Chon is so prejudiced by her mugshot and dismissed charges being publically displayed, that she is missing school and employment opportunities, and istaking other measures to restore her reputation.

Mugshot Blurred by KCE

Shoffstall’s mugshot, however, isn’t on the website. The Kenosha County Sheriff’s Department scrubbed it off of the website. This is due to an outdated policy that is set to automatically remove mugshots from suspects that aren’t booked in to the jail (pics and prints.) KCE asked the Sheriff’s Department why they keep the seemingly unfair policy in place, and they didn’t wish to address the issue.

Chon and her family believe she is being treated differently. Chon had to pay a $1,000 cash bail to be released. Schoffstall, however was given a no-cash bail from commissioner Michel. Instead of having Schoffstall arrested with a warrant, DA Mike Graveley (D), instead, asked Schoffstall by mail to come to court for his initial appearance on March 19, 2024. We asked Graveley why he was given the white-glove treatment, and Graveley did not wish to answer the tough question.

Elijah J. Schoffstall, 20, of Inverness, IL (Right) and Attorney Patrick Cafferty (Left)
(Photo by Nathan DeBruin, Kenosha County Eye)

Schoffstall is due back in court on June 13 for a judicial pre-trial. Today, he waived his right to a preliminary hearing and probable cause was found to bind him over for trial. Shoffstall remained stoic and seemingly unapologetic in court today in the presence of the victim’s family members.

Chon’s family told KCE that she has always been an honor student, from early school years through college. She loves the outdoors and staying active. She enjoys cross country and soccer. Chon’s extended family relayed their biggest concerns today. They really are looking for Schoffstall to take responsibility, apologize, and atone for his mistakes. Her family doesn’t necessarily hold a grudge over what they call a “tragic accident”, but the continuous and sustained lies after the fact that cost Chon her reputation and tens of thousands of dollars in damages. The accusation that Schoffstall lied to the police, is the family’s biggest concern. Chon had to drain her college savings for her legal defense and after that was gone, her family sustained a major financial impact. Chon’s family wants to be made whole financially with full restitution for all expenses incurred as a result of Eli’s lies

If you’re interested in helping Ms. Chon, here is a link where you can chip in five bucks or more.

https://gofund.me/2f71cddf

Author

Copied!
LATEST NEWS

Give Your Heart A Hug With A $49 Scan – I Did It And You Should Too, It Could Save Your Life

The two hospitals in Kenosha offer “Coronary Artery Calcium Scoring” tests, both for $49. No insurance? No problem. Yesterday, I paid $49 and got my heart scanned. It took about 7 minutes, but could take longer, but not much. I’m only 40, but I’m a big boy. Better safe than sorry. This non-invasive scan does not require injections, needles or contrast dye. With the scan results, you and your doctor will be able to determine the

Read More »

Long-Time Kenosha Police Detective Placed On Leave, Under Investigation

A long-time Kenosha Police detective has been placed on administrative leave. KCE was tipped off and we confirmed with a KPD spokesman. Although KPD can’t comment, as it is a personnel issue, KCE is told that the investigation is work-performance related and isn’t related to any use-of-force or other similar misconduct. KCE isn’t naming the detective, as he or she has not been disciplined. If he or she receives discipline that is severe, we will get

Read More »
MORE TOP STORIES

Salem Lakes Village President Announces Bid For Re-Election – “Let’s keep building a village that we can all be proud of.”

Rita Bucur, the Village of Salem Lakes’ president announced today that she is seeking re-election to the Village’s top elected spot. If needed, a primary election will occur on February 18, 2025 and the general election will be held on April 1, 2025. “Today, I am officially announcing my candidacy for reelection as Salem Lakes Village President. Serving our community has been an honor and I am proud of the progress we have made together over

Read More »

Kenosha Police Officer Resigns In Lieu Of Termination For Using Position To Get Dates, Other Misconduct

A brand new Kenosha Police Officer has resigned on October 16, 2024. This comes days before he was allegedly going to be fired for conduct unbecoming of an officer and other policy violations. Christopher Henley was with the Kenosha Police Department less than a year and had barely finished training when he resigned in lieu of termination. According to an internal affairs investigation obtained by KCE, Henley violated at least five department policies including: According to

Read More »

Kenosha District Attorney To Spend Thousands To Retry Marijuana Mistrial

The Kenosha County District Attorney’s office today announced that they intend to retry a 25-year-old Milwaukee man for a minor marijuana case. The trial is expected to cost up to or more than $10,000. The first trial of Ruben Mizrain-Aguilar was a hung jury, with 5 jurors voting “not guilty” and 7 voting “guilty.” Outgoing District Attorney Michael Graveley (D) made the decision to put Mizrain-Aguilar through another trial. Everyone in the room -, the prosecutors,

Read More »

Indian Trail Student Makes Threat, Brings Gun To School, School Resource Officer Misses It During Pat Down

At about 6:00 p.m. last night, an automated message from Indian Trail and Academy Principal Scott Kennow went out to ITA parents about a student who “snapped” a threat involving a gun saying something to the effect of “I’m going to take care of business.” Kennow, in his statement stated that KUSD did not believe that there was a credible threat: Good evening, Indian Trail families. This is Principal Kennow calling to share that today we

Read More »

Drug Charges From 1996 Resurface For Possible Expensive And Difficult Trial

Over 28 years ago, when Jorge B. Trujillo was 28-years-old, he allegedly sold cocaine to undercover law enforcement officers and a confidential informant in Kenosha County. For the controlled buys, a state agent and local police posed as drug users and met up with him on two occasions and Trujillo allegedly sold $150 worth of cocaine on April 30, 1996, and $300 worth on June 25, 1996. A warrant was issued and he was pulled over

Read More »

Kenosha Man Holding On $10,000 For Shooting Gun Inside Home, Violence

A violent confrontation between a Kenosha man and his roommate almost turned deadly Sunday evening after a violent melee and a gunshot. Robert B. Parise, 53, of Kenosha was charged today with Felony First Degree Recklessly Endangering Safety, Felony Possession Of A Firearm By A Felon, Possession Of A Firearm While Intoxicated, Obstructing An Officer, Domestic Abuse Battery and Domestic Abuse Disorderly Conduct. The Kenosha DA’s office did not include any drug charges or felony strangulation

Read More »

Update: Martel Lee Released From Jail Just Before 4:00 p.m.

Just before 4:00 p.m. today, Martel Lee is out of custody, after more than eight months behind bars. He was greeted by his little brother, 12-year-old Cameron, and his mother, Jenifer. “It’s a long time coming,” said Jones. “My baby is home and I’m so excited he will be home for the holidays,” she added. Earlier today, a Kenosha Judge has ordered the release of 16-year-old Lee. In a courtroom filled to capacity last week, Judge

Read More »

Partners With Paws Donates Therapy K-9 To The Kenosha Police Department

For years the Kenosha Police Department has heavily focused on mental health awareness within our ranks. The Kenosha Police Department’s PEER Support Team is a well-trained team of officers who provide support to their fellow officers. We also have Kristen, our Mental Health and Wellness Clinical Advisor, who meets with officers when needed and conducts yearly one on one check-ins with all of our sworn staff. We believe that keeping our officers well ensures that we can

Read More »

Judge Orders 16-Year-Old Martel Lee Released Pending Possible New Trial

A Kenosha Judge has ordered the release of 16-year-old Martel Lee this morning. In a courtroom filled to capacity last week, Judge Dougvillo vacated a guilty verdict for 16-year-old Martel D. Lee. On August 15, 2024, Lee was found guilty of second degree sexual assault. The assault allegedly occurred at Indian Trail High School earlier this year. Lee was supposed to be sentenced on October 28, 2024, but three jurors sent letters to the Judge, expressing

Read More »

KCE, Father Sue Mukwonago Area School District For Concealing Allegations Of Inappropriate Touching, Grooming

KCE Editor Kevin Mathewson and a parent at Mukwonago Area School District filed suit today in Waukesha County Circuit Court. In the lawsuit, the duo is requesting a judge to force MASD and it’s Superintendent Joseph Koch to release records involving alleged inappropriate touching and grooming of a then-14 year old by a teacher named Steve Telkamp. On March 14, 2024, Sallee’s daughter made a complaint to the school district and her parents then got involved.

Read More »
Categories
Archives
Authors

70 Responses

  1. ************ This whole thing is a shit show. His family should be embarrassed for their actions and the lies told. Must be nice to have money and to be privileged. Good luck to this piece of shit for not taking responsibility of HIS actions. They owe her a public apology just as they smeared her name.

    31
  2. Another rich liberal being protected by an elitist liberal in the DA’s office. Both scum… DA is a slithering coward!

    16
    3
    1. what does politics have to do with any of this…. you are incompetent. i knew this kid, definitely not a liberal nice try tho!

      6
      2
  3. If he got away with it, he would just be doing it again.
    Glad this was nipped in the bud.
    Hopefully, he will be the girlfriend in prison and get
    snitched on for something he didn’t do.

    8
    1
  4. Aside from his ” boyfriend of the year ” award , it would interesting to know who his father is.
    Once again , our illustrious DA is not gravely concerned with the truth . I believe this poor girl has several potential lawsuits at her disposal.

    13
  5. How many times has Gravely jumped to conclusions and charged people too quickly and without sufficient evidence? The Kyle Rittenhouse situation woke us all up. He can’t be gone soon enough. It’s a real shame. At one time, I had respect for the man.

    13
  6. This is once again such a bullshit biased article. All she had was a head injury and you don’t know what type of injuries Eli suffered. This whole article is shit and so are you

    11
    34
    1. Nobody ever denied that he had suffered terrible injuries, because they were bad. But he caused both of the injuries as the driver.

      16
    2. Lol funny, her jaw was split open and had to have stitches. Sounds like you dont know all of it either <3

      2
      0
    3. Biased?? Are you okay, there was literally dna proof of who was on which side. No one said he didn’t suffer injuries but he literally lied and almost killed himself and her. Get some help seriously, defending a liar is crazy

      6
      1
      1. You are clueless to this world, obviously his injuries are left out to make her side seem the right one. If you are in a life or death situation not knowing if you will be able to live again, how much thought and effort is really going into his response?

        3
        5
        1. So…I think that you are the one that may be “clueless to this world”. He LIED for almost a year and let this girl take the fall for something he was responsible for! It speaks to his character and the character of the people around him. He’s a shitty human end of story.

          4
          1
    4. All she had was head injuries because she wasn’t driving. Wow takes a genius to figure out that a car that hits on the passenger side would have the passenger glued hitting her head on the tree. And the worthless little bitch of a man flying towards the point of contact hence his injuries which should have killed him so he can’t do this to someone else. Must have paid a lot for that education to offer up defense for your scummy ass kid/friend.

  7. You must be a friend of Eli’s and/or family. It’s not a biased article. Sure he suffered injuries but he was wrong by driving and lying to the police. She had a broken jaw (says in the article) and had to have surgery. He could have killed them both. He needs to take responsibility and own his up to his mistake. There is always more to the story. But the bottom line is he’s at fault and a liar by trying to lay blame elsewhere.

    15
    1
  8. Hey Anonymous Comment from Apr 5, 2024 at 3:51 PM

    “All she had was a head injury”
    Really? That’s how you think? Since when is a head injury a minor injury? Bones heal, head injuries are often much more serious. Think about it! Educate yourself! You’re not well informed.

  9. This scumbag took my sister to prom in 9th grade and after reading this I started crying thinking how that could have been my sister. This piece of shit better get what he deserves

    9
    2
    1. Crazy how someone can say this while being so uneducated over a situation? Your crying over a situation that never happened, tell me a 9th grader that has their license. Get the fuck on with your life cause your the real scum bag, u fool.

      6
      7
  10. !!! Knowing Eli from Highschool, I can confidently say this wasn’t his first time drinking and driving. His friends can all confirm this. It finally caught up to him. Hopefully he learned his lesson. I feel so bad for that poor girl & her family.

    5
    3
    1. !!!!! You don’t know shit Karen, and I can guarantee you don’t know Eli either. Sure you may say you know him from high school but everyone knows him from high school, all state soccer player, popular kid. I can guarantee you were not friends with Eli in high school because the things you just said are far from the truth🤣

      1
      3
      1. And for you to take the time to come onto this corny ass website when I know you are just some fan of Eli is fuckin absurd. Fremd was filled with people like you that just utterly disgust me, too quick to judge and can never see the other side through. I’ve probably spotted you in the halls and laughed, because you are a joke and I can tell!!

        3
        1
        1. 😭😭 ^ The fact you’re defending him shows your morals… I’m not lying when I say he was in my hs friend group, so I’ve witnessed him and his boys (probably you included🙄) drink and drive after party’s all the time. You guys thought you were so cool. Drinking and driving is not cool! He is lucky he didn’t kill himself or others. He lied to us (his friends) after the accident and told us he wasn’t the driver, I didn’t believe it at first just knowing his behavior, but later fell for the lie. We felt sorry for him. Later to find out now he was being a d$ck (per usual) and lied to save his ass. I wish I was lying Mr. Eli wannabe, but thankfully I’m not a lying manipulator 🤣

          1. Eli has never drank and drove in high school and I stand by that you fuckin fool, once again average Fremd student. You honestly suck ugly ass whore, go read a book or talk to ur other gossip fiending friends. Get a fucking grip.

    2. You are irrelevant and I can tell you 100% you do not know what Eli’s friends would be doing. You would not be anywhere close to around them. And for you to throw people under the bud by saying lies in complete bullshit.

      3
      1
      1. “Irrelevant” that’s what his bully boy group used to call girls who rejected them. You’re 100% one of Eli’s d sucking minions. The fact you still stand by his behavior is pathetic. Misery loves company, you should join him in prison😌💅

  11. I felt so bad for her. I just happened to be in jail, when she got released from the hospital. I could not believe they released her in the condition she was in, I am sure it was all just to get her booked, and in the amount of pain from the broken jaw was extremely noticeable. She told me herself she was not driving (however I had no idea if you could believe or not at the time). She was supposed to even get medication upon release and she had to sit there I believe around 2-3 hours in severe pain and they would not give her medications. I am happy to hear this was reversed but sad to see it took so long. While i am an idiot for the mistake I made, I am glad I was able to talk to her and console her as the cell was empty and she was clearly very upset before they took her to county jail.

  12. Where is the video from the bar, that will prove who was driving … and why was car towed when it was suppose to be at police department for investigation. And who took the air bags to have tested ??? Was that legal ?

  13. Both were drinking and underage … also Where is the video from the bar, that will prove who was driving … and why was car towed when it was suppose to be at police department for investigation. And who took the air bags to have tested ??? Was that legal ?

  14. Played bball with Eli. Was a great athlete and competitor, and I respect that. This is unbelievable though. I can’t believe this guy would let his girl take the fall for almost killing them both. Didn’t know him well, but I could always see how entitled he was. Gonna make a great gf in jail Frr

    4
    2

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LATEST NEWS
Categories
Archives
Authors

Subscribe to updates

Get notified of new articles. We'll never share your email address.