CAEGI 0003 November Ads 2022x250

Kenosha County Eye

Chrystul Kizer Defense Scores Small Win – Case Still Strong Says DA

Share
Tweet
Accused Murderer Chrystul Kizer In Court Tuesday
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

A Kenosha Judge today, ruled that a interview of homicide defendant Chrystul Kizer will not be admitted in her trial. Kenosha County Circuit Judge David P. Wilk in an oral ruling today, found that two Kenosha Police detectives should have re-read Miranda warnings to Kaiser while she was in custody before questioning her. Therefore, everything that Kaiser said in the interview from October 26, 2018, isn’t going to be allowed into Kizer’s murder trial next year.

Paid Advertisement

Kizer is facing a mandatory life sentence for allegedly shooting her alleged sex trafficker, Randall Volar III on June 5, 2018. He was being investigated at the time for serious crimes including sexual assault of children and possession of a plethora of child porn. On June 9, 2018, Kizer agreed to waive her right to self-incrimination and counsel before she had an attorney and gave detectives her version of the incident, where she admitted to shooting Volar, lighting his home on fire, and stealing his car. She was read her Miranda rights at this interview.

Still Photo From Hybrid Hearing
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

Kizer first appeared in court on June 11, 2018 and a temporary bail was set in the amount of $1 Million. On June 13, 2018, she was officially charged with murder, along with other felonies.

Paid Advertisement

On or about October 26, 2018, Kizer sent a note to the Kenosha Police Department indicating that she wished to speak with detectives and cooperate. Two Kenosha Police detectives went to the jail the next day, October 26, 2018 to speak with her. The interview lasted for almost one hour and 40 minutes. The detectives never read Kizer her Miranda rights or called her attorneys.

The defense attorney argued, simply, that the detectives erred in not reading Miranda warnings. The prosecution argued that Kizer, herself, initiated the contact.

Paid Advertisement
Kenosha County Circuit Court Judge David P. Wilk In Court Tuesday
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

“The common thread in the evolution of the law in this area which invokes both the fifth and sixth amendments, is the need to balance police flexibility in investigating criminal activity, with the fundamental fair treatment of criminal defendants,” said Judge Wilk. “Waivers of counsel must not only be voluntary, but must also constitute a knowing and intelligent relinquishment or abandonment of a known right or privilege… Ultimately, the issue before this court is whether the defendant freely, voluntarily, knowingly and understandingly waived her fifth and sixth amendment rights as guaranteed by Miranda, and the cases that followed it. This court would be hard-pressed to conclude that a proper waiver occured when the defendant was not advised of those rights. For the reasons stated herein, the defendant’s motion to suppress is granted.”

In the second interview, Kizer gave police a different version of events than her first interview, blaming her boyfriend for some of her actions. Police didn’t believe her new story. The jury will not hear about Kizer changing her version of events.

Paid Advertisement

Reached by email after the ruling, Kenosha County DA Mike Graveley indicated that even with today’s ruling, the state’s case is still very strong. Kizer is due back in court on January 18, 2023 for a motion hearing, where the spring trial will likely be scheduled.

Accused Murderer Chrystul Kizer In Court Tuesday
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

Author

  • Kevin Mathewson

    Kevin Mathewson is a disciple of Christ, husband and a father to two wonderful children. Mathewson was born and raised in Lake County, IL and worked as a police & fire dispatcher from 2005 to 2010 in Round Lake Beach, IL. Mathewson moved to Kenosha County in 2006, later being elected to the position of Alderman of the 8th District in 2012 and 2016. Mathewson is a private investigator, security contractor, journalist, and photographer. He enjoys spending time with his family, watching movies, camping and boating. His favorite amendment is the second, followed closely by the first. He loves his country and community.

Share
Tweet
LATEST NEWS

County Executive Hires Woman Fired For Fraud, Under Criminal Investigation

County Executive Samantha Kerkman isn’t answering any questions about a very risky hire she maid a few months ago – Sherry Kruse. Kruse is the County’s new Veterans Benefits Representative. Before County Executive Samantha Kerkman hired her for the important role, she worked for the Veterans Assistance Commission of Lake County as its Assistant Superintendent. According to her personnel file, released by VACLC by means of a F.O.I.A. reques, she had been in extremely hot water

Read More »

Kenosha Woman Announces Bid for Mayor

Elizabeth Garcia quipped Kenosha is her hobby, saying “I wish it were my job!” A workingmother who uses her free time towards bettering our city, Garcia has announced her bid forMayor of Kenosha. Enthusiastic and determined Garcia asserts, “ I am solution oriented: when Isee a problem, I try to fix it. If I can’t fix it, I find out who can. I want Kenoshans to know theirtax dollars are being used in meaningful ways; I

Read More »
MORE TOP STORIES

Kenosha College Student Thanks Lawyer For Her Recent Exoneration For Charges Related To Near-Deadly Crash

On May 19, 2023, Marissa Chon was doing what many college students do on a Friday night – drinking alcohol with friends. She was with her then-boyfriend, Elijah J. Schoffstall, a Carthage soccer player. At about 2:21 am, the two were involved in a serious car wreck at Carthage College, a school where they both attended. Both were severely injured and were lucky to survive. Police and bystanders quickly arrived at the scene of the crash

Read More »

Kenosha Judge Eviscerates First Amendment In Bizarre Ruling – Opinion

Circuit Court Judges, like David Wilk (D), can’t change the first amendment, no matter how much they hate it. It’s part of our great constitution and there are many layers of the judiciary above them, that work as checks and balances. That doesn’t mean that they can’t try, however. That’s exactly what David Wilk tried to do in an oral/written ruling from this past Monday. Lets begin with Judge WIlk’s beginning. Wilke attended Hamline University School

Read More »

Embattled Director Of Women’s Shelter Drops Lawsuit That Was Allegedly Filed Illegally

The embattled director of Women and Children’s Horizons dropped a lawsuit yesterday, two weeks after it was filed, and only 10 days after KCE published an article alleging she was practicing law without a license. According to a 8-count findings document outlining an investigation into misconduct, Paine was disbarred May 20, 2023. The documents says in part, “After proceedings conducted pursuant to [Michigan Supreme Court Rules], the panel found, based on [Paine’s] admissions to all of the

Read More »

Man Who Escaped Kenosha Prison In July Captured In Milwaukee County, Was In Possession of Firearm

On July 26, 2023 a State Prison inmate named Parish Eckford escaped from a Kenosha Prison. This is a State of Wisconsin Department of Corrections Facility and not associated with the Sheriff’s Department jail. Eckford was serving a 16-year prison sentence for the following convictions in Milwaukee Circuit Court: Eckford was scheduled to be released the month he escaped. He previously served 5 years for armed Robbery. The prison, is a minimum security prison that is

Read More »

After 30 Years On The Job, Kenosha Deputy Police Chief To Retire: Q and A

After 30 years on the job, the Kenosha Police Department’s # 2 is hanging up his gun belt. Deputy Chief Tom Hansche announced his retirement officially on October 4, 2023 in a memo to the Chief. “This memo is to inform you that I will officially retire from the Kenosha Police Department on December 31, 2023…I have been blessed with many opportunities and I wish you and the department nothing but the best of success in

Read More »

Salem Lakes Fire Chief, Inspector, Intimidated Subordinates Not To Cooperate With Investigation: Document

In an explosive report released to KCE following a public records request, investigators outline an inquiry into misconduct that was obstructed by the former Salem Lakes Fire Chief and Fire Inspector. The eight-page report begins with an executive summary saying “Overall, following nearly two-dozen interviews and the review of hundreds of pages of communications and records, it could be determined significant deficiencies exist in the respective performances of the Fire Chief and Fire Marshal. However, as

Read More »

11 Responses

  1. Guilty! You can’t be answer a ad for prostitution Then decide to get a ride to his house and kill him! Murder is murder

    2
    2
  2. The police blew it. All they needed to do was read the Miranda warnings to a person who was in custody. If they had any doubts, there’s a prosecutor on call that they could have called.

    1. They did blow it. Pure incompetence on the part of these two detectives. They violated what they should have been taught in their training academy or what they would have been taught in any inservice or college course on interviews and interrogations. Their incompetence is stunning.

  3. First the cops don’t prosecute Randall Volar, which led to this death. Then they botch the interview of Chrystul Kizer.

    1. The reason he wasn’t prosecuted is that he was extrajudicially executed by one of his “victims” without a trial or due process of any kind.

  4. The reason he wasn’t prosecuted is that he was extrajudicially executed by one of his “victims” without a trial or due process of any kind.

  5. This case is similar in nature to Donna Matthews. A lady who in her own mind was victimized and went out of her way to kill the person she hated most.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LATEST NEWS

Subscribe to updates

Get notified of new articles. We'll never share your email address.