Former Cop Charged With Armed Bank Robbery, Bomb Threat – $250,000 Cash Bail

Copied!
Paul J. Garchek (51) of Kenosha In Court Today
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

You’ve all seen it in the movies – the bad guy calls in a fake police call and robs a bank. All the police officers will be at the fake call and you can get away scot free, right? Not so fast, says Pleasant Prairie Police Chief David Smetana. “It doesn’t work.”

Paid Advertisement

Today, 51-year old former cop Paul J. Garchek was charged with armed bank robbery and a bomb threat, seemingly in a failed attempt to try the trick shown in TV and in the movies. He’s facing more that 40 years behind bars if convicted.

Paid Advertisement
Paul J. Garchek (51)
(Kenosha County Sheriff)

According to the criminal complaint:

Paid Advertisement

An anonymous caller called the non-emergency line at the Pleasant Prairie Police Department at about 12:30 p.m. on April 6, 2024, stating there was a bomb at Costco. The person making the call did so from a blocked number. The male stated, “I heard there were 3 or 4 tanks like explosive bombs at Costco, 94th Ave., in Pleasant Prairie.” and then caller disconnected.

Paid Advertisement

Members of the Pleasant Prairie Police department responded to Costco. A command post was set up next door to the Costco and officers began to check the perimeter of Costco and evacuate customers and employees from the building.

Paid Advertisement

Ultimately, no explosive devices were located. According to Costco, between the loss in revenue, employee payroll, and spoiled merchandise in the five hours the Costco had to be evacuated, Costco lost $327,038.

Paid Advertisement

At about 1PM while he was assisting moving people to safe locations from the Costco dispatch advised that Chase Bank in Pleasant Prairie had just reported a robbery. Police, upon arriving on scene at the bank, made contact with an employee of the bank. She stated that around 12:55PM a thin white male, in his 40s, with blue eyes, wearing all black clothing, gloves, and prescription glasses with the sunglasses flipped up, walked up to the counter and spoke with Teller Robert Casey. The employee stated that she could not hear what was being said at first but then heard the male say, “Give me the fucking money! Hurry up,” and “Nobody move.” Nicole stated after the suspect left she followed him and saw him get into a Toyota 4-door that was a shiny charcoal color that had a bluish tint on the license plate so she thought it was an Illinois tag. She stated he left south on 39th Ave.

Paid Advertisement
Paul J. Garchek (51) of Kenosha In Court Today
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

The teller told police he gave the robber a stack of money but it had several one dollar bills on the top and the suspect began yelling that he wanted big bills. The teller stated that he grabbed more big bills, showed the suspect and the suspect continued to yell telling him to hurry up. The teller stated at this point the suspect put his right hand into his pocket and appeared to be gripping something that Robert believed to be a firearm. The teller stated he quickly put the money in the bag and the suspect then removed his hand from his pocket, zipped up the bag and walked outside before getting into the gray Toyota. Robert stated the suspect made off with $7,274 from the bank.

Paid Advertisement

Police were quickly able to call AT&T and ascertain the even though the suspect dial *67 before the number to Costco, the number was still attainable. Records showed, he used a burner phone, but first used the burner phone to call his real phone to test the *67 feature.

Police narrowed down on Garchek and conducted a search warrant at his home. They found an airsoft gun. Garchek plead the fifth when questioned by police.

Pleasant Prairie Police Chief David Smetana
(File Photo By Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

Reached by phone after today’s court hearing, Pleasant Prairie Police Chief David Smetana applauded his officers and detectives for their work. “There is so much technology out there these days to help us catch [the bad guys,] said Smetana. “Also, we capitalize on the mistakes that they make.”

Smetana recognized, that although many of his officers were at Costco, there were still other officers form many other agencies available. “Our officer can’t always be everywhere,” he said. Smetana warns that committing serious crimes, whether while being planned out or not, you will be caught.

Kenosha County Court Commissioner Bill Michel In Court Today
(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

Kenosha County Court Commissioner Bill Michel today set a cash bail of $250,000, citing the danger to the community. Garchek, a former police officer is a convicted felon who had drug convictions, and believe it or not, a conviction for armed robbery.

Garchek is due back in court on April 23, 2024 for a preliminary hearing.

Kenosha County Assistant District Attorney Zachary Brost In Court Today
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)




Author

Copied!
LATEST NEWS

Kenosha Man Accused of Sexual Assault and Battery Outside Somers Bar

Somers, Wis. – A Lake Geneva man appeared in Kenosha County Circuit Court on Monday after being charged in connection with a disturbance outside a Somers tavern involving allegations of sexual assault and battery. Adam Garcia Jr., 35, made his initial appearance before Court Commissioner William Michel II and is being held in the Kenosha County Jail on a $1,500 cash bond. According to a criminal complaint, Kenosha County Sheriff’s deputies were responding to an unrelated

Read More »

Three Sex Offenders Released into Pleasant Prairie Community

Pleasant Prairie, Wis. — Three convicted sex offenders have been released into the Village of Pleasant Prairie and will be under close supervision, the Pleasant Prairie Police Department announced Monday. The department, working in coordination with the Sex Offender Registration Committee, issued community notifications for Perfecto Navarro Jr., Gonzales Williams, and Jon G. Kubart. Authorities emphasized that while none of the men are wanted by police at this time, public notification is being made to enhance

Read More »
MORE TOP STORIES

Kenosha Man Accused of Stealing Car, Crashing, and Leaving Toddler Alone

Kenosha, Wis. — A Kenosha man remains in custody after court proceedings Friday, facing multiple criminal charges stemming from an alleged vehicle theft, hit-and-run crash, and child neglect incident earlier this week. Cortney J. Brantley, 36, appeared before Kenosha County Court Commissioner Michael Masnica on April 25, 2025, where his cash bail was set at $4,000. He remains in the Kenosha County Jail as of Monday. According to a criminal complaint filed by the Kenosha County

Read More »

Kenosha Man Accused of Fleeing Crash, Resisting Officers After Cocaine Discovery

Kenosha, Wis. — A Kenosha man is facing multiple felony and misdemeanor charges after a violent and chaotic incident earlier this week that put officers and the public at risk, according to court records. Kaden J. Gayheart, 23, made his initial appearance Wednesday afternoon before Court Commissioner William Michel II. Michel set Gayheart’s bail at $7,500 cash, which he posted Friday. He is now out of custody pending further proceedings. According to a criminal complaint filed

Read More »

Pleasant Prairie Man Charged with 28 Counts Including Racketeering After Retail Theft Crime Spree, Held on $25,000 Cash Bond

Pleasant Prairie, Wis. — A man already facing numerous retail theft charges in Milwaukee and Waukesha Counties is now charged with 28 criminal counts in Kenosha County, including Racketeering under Wisconsin’s RICO statute, following an extensive, organized retail theft operation that endangered workers and defied court orders at every step. Camari O. Russell, 26, was arrested in Lake County, Illinois, and extradited back to Wisconsin to face new charges stemming from repeated thefts at the Pleasant

Read More »

Kenosha CNA Accused of Assaulting Elderly Resident at Care Facility

Kenosha, Wis. — A Kenosha woman stands accused of abusing a 73-year-old man at a local care facility where she worked, according to a criminal complaint filed in Kenosha County Circuit Court. Jahnix A. Medina, 27, was charged with one count of physical abuse of an elder person, intentionally causing bodily harm, a Class H felony. If convicted, she faces up to six years in prison, a $10,000 fine, or both. According to the complaint, officers

Read More »

Maine Man Accused of Violent Robbery in Kenosha; Bail Set at $10,000

Kenosha, Wis. — A Maine man is facing felony charges in Kenosha County after allegedly assaulting a woman and robbing her of a necklace in a violent altercation last fall. On Wednesday, Court Commissioner William Michel II set bail at $10,000 cash for Lewis A. Covington, 32, who is charged with robbery with use of force and substantial battery—both with domestic abuse enhancers. According to the criminal complaint, the incident occurred on October 12, 2024, when

Read More »

Village Administrator Lawyers Up Amid DNR Wetland Investigation

Salem Lakes, Wis. — The Village of Salem Lakes’ top administrator is under scrutiny after the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources (DNR) launched an investigation into potential illegal wetland disturbances on municipal property. The property in question is zoned C1. Lowland Resource Conservancy (C1) zoning is intended to prevent the destruction of valuable natural resources, including wetlands, shorelands, and areas subject to flooding. This is among the most restrictive zoning in the County. Cassandra Hiller, the

Read More »

Kenosha Alderman Accused of “Playing Cop” Again, Raising Concerns Over Overreach: Video

Kenosha, Wis. – Alderman Rollin Pizzala is facing renewed scrutiny after being spotted once again engaging in actions that appear to be outside the scope of his duties as a city legislator. On Thursday afternoon, a tip-off to Kenosha County Eye (KCE) reported Pizzala actively patrolling the 43rd Avenue neighborhood north of 60th Street, raising concerns among residents about his actions. Pizzala was reportedly “inspecting” properties in the area for code violations, such as property maintenance,

Read More »

Racine Officer Shoots Armed Suspect During Home Invasion: Investigation Underway

Racine, Wis. — An officer with the Racine Police Department shot and injured a suspect during a tense encounter inside a residence Tuesday night following a reported armed home invasion. The incident occurred in the 1100 block of Hamilton Street and has triggered an outside investigation, officials confirmed. According to a news release from the Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office, Racine officers responded to the scene on April 22 after receiving reports of a home invasion involving

Read More »

Kenosha Man Accused of Strangling Girlfriend, Causing Severe Facial Injury

Kenosha, Wis. — A 56-year-old Kenosha man is facing multiple criminal charges after allegedly assaulting his live-in girlfriend, choking her and striking her in the face hard enough to require stitches and cause temporary vision loss. Allen S. Meyer was charged in Kenosha County Circuit Court with substantial battery, strangulation and suffocation, and disorderly conduct — all with domestic abuse enhancers. The alleged attack occurred on March 21 at Meyer’s upper unit residence on 17th Avenue.

Read More »

Kenosha Woman Charged Again for Stealing Family’s Car While Out on Bail for Doing the Same

Kenosha, Wis. – A 36-year-old Kenosha woman remains in the county jail on a $7,500 cash bail after being charged with stealing her daughter’s car over the weekend—despite already being out on bail for a similar car theft involving her own mother just months earlier. Kristy R. Delaney now faces a total of ten new charges in a case filed Monday, including five felony counts of bail jumping, misdemeanor bail jumping, misdemeanor theft, operating while revoked,

Read More »
Categories
Archives
Authors

20 Responses

  1. If in fact this guy got his shtick from TV he didn’t take enough notes.
    It isn’t rocket science to figure how to call on a burner phone without doing a test on your own phone.
    Should have bought two from different locations 100 miles apart if he thought he needed to test the process.
    Even at minimum wage the guy only scored a little over two months income. With all the job openings he should have just gotten a job !
    Yes Costco lost a lot but I’m sure they have insurance. They should sue for reimbursement by taking the guys house.

    3
    4
  2. Bug-eyed dumbsh*t drug addict from Illinois. Obviously a Democrat. Hopefully he hasn’t spawned. There were friends of mine with their 2 toddlers at Costco the day this degenerate called in a bomb threat. He should be charged with domestic terrorism.

    12
    3
    1. I read an article that he robbed Walmart and was sentenced to 4 years in prison and another 4 years of supervision. That was like back in 2014 or something like that.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Categories
Archives
Authors

Subscribe to updates

Get notified of new articles. We'll never share your email address.