Kenosha Man Charged with First-Degree Murder in Brutal Stabbing Incident – $1.5M Bail Set

Copied!
Justin L. Tercek (41) of Kenosha In Court Today
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

Kenosha, Wis. – A Kenosha man has been charged with first-degree intentional homicide following the brutal killing of a local resident and his dog earlier this week.

Paid Advertisement

Justin L. Tercek, 41, was formally charged in Kenosha County Circuit Court today in connection with the death of 52-year-old Andrew D. Pfannkuche. Prosecutors allege that Tercek fatally stabbed Pfannkuche multiple times inside his home on Monday, February 3, 2025. Pfannkuche’s dog, Jake, was also found dead at the scene with stab wounds.

Paid Advertisement
Kenosha County Circuit Court Commissioner William Michel II In Court Today
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

In addition to the murder charge, Tercek faces multiple felony charges, including mistreatment of animal, use of a dangerous weapon, and two counts of burglary. He is also charged with one misdemeanor count of criminal damage to property. Kenosha County Circuit Court Commissioner William Michel II set bail at $1.5 million cash.

Paid Advertisement

Incident Details

According to the criminal complaint, Kenosha Police responded to a residence at 8536 18th Avenue around 2:30 p.m. on February 3. Upon entering the home, officers discovered Pfannkuche deceased with multiple knife wounds. A bloody knife was recovered in the basement.

Paid Advertisement

Authorities noted that Pfannkuche had purchased the home only three days prior and lived there alone with his dog. Police arrested Tercek later that evening in an alley near 5017 22nd Avenue. At the time of his arrest, Tercek had blood on his hands and clothing, which was described as “covered” in blood. Officers also noted injuries to Tercek’s calf, consistent with dog bites, and a laceration on his scalp.

Paid Advertisement

Detective Morrissey, the lead investigator, reported that Pfannkuche had spoken with both his realtor and a Kenosha Police officer earlier in the day, recounting a disturbing encounter at 1:00 a.m. that morning. According to Pfannkuche, an intruder entered his home, confronted him about the property, and then stole a set of keys before leaving. Later, around 5:00 a.m., Pfannkuche saw an SUV on his lawn near the “For Sale” sign, which had been knocked down.

Surveillance footage later confirmed that a Dodge Nitro SUV registered to Tercek was abandoned after crashing through the front glass of a Dollar General store in Zion, Illinois, at approximately 6:00 a.m. Video from a nearby auto repair shop captured Tercek later that morning, showing no visible blood or injuries at that time.

At around 11:30 a.m., Pfannkuche sent a photo to his realtor showing that his back door had been smashed in. Several hours later, Tercek’s aunt and uncle visited Pfannkuche’s home to apologize for Tercek’s actions. They reportedly heard a dog in distress and saw blood inside, prompting them to call police.

Kenosha County Deputy District Attorney Andrew “Drew” Burgoyne In Court Today
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

Court Proceedings

During the court hearing, Deputy District Attorney Drew Burgoyne described the attack as a “brutal slaying inside a man’s own home,” stating that Tercek was upset that Pfannkuche had purchased his grandmother’s former home. “There’s no reasonable motive here,” Burgoyne said. “The defendant was apparently upset that Mr. Pfannkuche purchased what used to be his grandmother’s home. He returned several hours later, driving on the lawn, knocking over the sale sign. When he ultimately killed Mr. Pfannkuche, it was 25 knife wounds, according to the preliminary autopsy. He also killed his dog, Jake.”

The prosecution requested a $1.5 million cash bond, while the defense sought a significantly lower amount of $100,000. Commissioner Michel ultimately sided with the prosecution, stating, “The court has great concern for community safety. The court does believe a substantial amount of cash is warranted. The court is going to adopt the recommendation of the state for $1.5 million and adopt the non-monetary provisions.”

Next Steps

Tercek is scheduled to appear in court again on February 12, 2025, for a preliminary hearing. If convicted, he faces a mandatory life sentence.

Authorities continue to investigate the case, examining surveillance footage and forensic evidence to build their case against Tercek.

Andrew D. Pfannkuche, 52, of Kenosha
Jake
Kenosha County District Attorney Xavier Solis In Court Today
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)
Kenosha S.W.A.T
(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)
Kenosha S.W.A.T
(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

Author

Copied!
LATEST NEWS

Governor Tony Evers Denies Pardon For Kenosha County Serial Arsonist

Silver Lake, Wis. – Governor Tony Evers (D) has denied the pardon application of 48-year-old Allen M. Dunski, Jr., a former firefighter and convicted serial arsonist from Kenosha County’s west side. The rejection, issued on November 15, 2024, came despite Dunski’s claims of rehabilitation and community service. A letter sent to Dunski by the Governor’s Pardon Advisory Board stated: “While the Governor’s Pardon Advisory Board commends you for the positive strides you have taken since completing

Read More »

Kenosha Man Charged with Repeated Sexual Assault of a Child, Held on $1M Bail

Kenosha, Wis. – A 43-year-old Kenosha man was formally charged today with Repeated Sexual Assault of a Child in Kenosha County Circuit Court. If convicted, Jesus Alcocer-Bautista faces a maximum sentence of 60 years in prison. During his court appearance, Kenosha County District Attorney Xavier Solis requested a $1,000,000 cash bail, citing the severity of the allegations and the need to protect the community. Kenosha County Circuit Court Commissioner William Michel II granted the request and

Read More »
MORE TOP STORIES

10-Year-Old Girl Still Too Terrified To Return To School After Sexual Assault on Bus

**Explicit Content** Kenosha, Wis. — A 10-year-old girl from Nash Elementary School remains too afraid to return to school months after she was allegedly sexually assaulted by two male students on her bus ride home. Despite criminal charges, Title IX investigations, and pleas from the child’s mother, the Kenosha Unified School District (KUSD) has yet to remove one of the accused students from the school, leaving the victim in limbo. KCE first reported on this matter

Read More »

Two Twin Lakes Men Arrested On Child Pornography Charges

Twin Lakes, Wis. – Two Twin Lakes men have been arrested and charged with multiple counts of possession of child pornography following separate investigations by the Twin Lakes Police Department (TLPD) and the Wisconsin Division of Criminal Investigation (DCI) Internet Crimes Against Children (ICAC) Task Force. Arrests and Charges Nathan H. Bollow, 20, and Micah D. Griffiths, 20, were taken into custody in January 2025 after search warrants were executed at their respective residences. Bollow was

Read More »

Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office Welcomes K9 Joy, A Peer Support Dog

Kenosha, Wis. – The Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office (KCSO) has a new four-legged recruit. Sheriff David W. Zoerner announced today the addition of K9 Joy, a law enforcement peer support dog, to the department. K9 Joy’s handler, Detective Adam Barnard, is a 10-year veteran of the sheriff’s office, currently serving in the detective bureau as a general assignment detective. Detective Barnard also plays a key role as a lead investigator on the Major Crash Assistance Team

Read More »

Kenosha Judge Reversed Again as Court of Appeals Overturns Child Custody Ruling

Kenosha, Wis. – Kenosha County Circuit Court Judge Chad Kerkman (D) has once again found himself overruled by a higher court. On January 22, 2025, the Wisconsin Court of Appeals reversed a ruling made by Kerkman in a child custody case, marking yet another instance in which his decisions have been overturned—spanning cases from homicide convictions, public records cases, and even termination of parental rights. In the latest reversal, the Court of Appeals sided with a

Read More »

Kenosha Murder Trial: Defendant to Represent Himself in Court

Kenosha, Wis. — “The man who represents himself has a fool for a client.” – Abraham Lincoln. A high-profile murder trial is set to begin later this year, with 35-year-old Tiron M. Washington opting to represent himself despite facing life in prison. Washington is accused of orchestrating the December 10, 2021, assassination of 35-year-old Maximmillion A. Moore in what prosecutors describe as a hit-style execution. A Murder Linked to Federal Gun Investigation According to investigators, Moore

Read More »

KUSD To Host 62nd Orchestra Festival

Kenosha, Wis. – Kenosha Unified School District’s 62nd annual Orchestra Festival will be presented on Saturday, March 8, at 6:30 p.m. at Indian Trail High School and Academy, 6800 60th St. This event will showcase nearly 1,400 elementary, middle, high and charter school orchestra students. Tickets are available at kusd.edu/tickets. Field house seating is $10 (a maximum of 3). Tickets will not be available at the door and field house seating may sell out in advance. The

Read More »

City of Kenosha Employee Charged with Misdemeanor Theft From Taxpayers

Kenosha, Wis. – A City of Kenosha employee has been charged with one count of misdemeanor theft, according to court records. Jamie D. Watkins, a 54-year-old arborist employed by the city, is accused of stealing Menards rebate checks meant for the Parks Department. Watkins is scheduled to make his initial court appearance on February 27, 2025. If convicted, he faces a maximum sentence of nine months in jail, a $10,000 fine, and possible restitution. City Administrator

Read More »

Casey Family Options Funeral Home Accused of Predatory Practices, Families Speak Out

Kenosha, Wis. – A Kenosha-based funeral home, Casey Family Options Funerals & Cremations, is facing public scrutiny after a family accused its directors of predatory behavior, price gouging, and a lack of compassion during their times of grief. Allegations from Grieving Sisters Two women, Alexis Quirk and Kiki Nicole, recently took to social media and Google reviews to share their troubling experiences with the funeral home. Their accounts describe an ordeal that exacerbated their grief as

Read More »

Vote No On February 18 To Give KUSD $115 Million Dollars: Opinion

Do not miss your chance! You have between now and February 18th to VOTE NO on KUSD’s $115 Million property tax increase. Last week, newly reported national NAEP test scores – also known as the Nation’s Report Card – revealed that 69% of Wisconsin K-12 students cannot READ at grade level. The math scores were nearly just as abysmal. Wisconsin ranks dead last in teaching black students to read, and the opportunity gaps in math are

Read More »

Follow The Money on KUSD Referendum Campaign

Wondering where all of the KUSD referendum propaganda is coming from? Not surprisingly, this aggressive effort to tax you out of your homes is coming from the teachers’ union. People are still struggling to afford gas and groceries, but the teachers’ union believes they deserve more of your hard earned money than you already contribute. It’s in your mailbox, on your social media, and you can’t scroll YouTube without seeing their constant ads. Quite a hefty

Read More »
Categories
Archives
Authors

69 Responses

    1. Why the downvotes LOL. Serious question, shouldn’t most pits have attacked that intruder once it sensed a problem?

      4
      1
      1. I would say that’s a generalization. It depends on how they are raised. Then again, I’m sure I’ll be told I’m wrong.

        1. You are not wrong. Uncle Andy raised Jake to be gentle and loving. I wish he would have trained him to be a killer and maybe……. 😭

  1. My condolences to the family of Mr. Pfannkuche and Jake. I hope there are plenty of dog lovers in prison that will express their displeasure to the perpetrator.

    23
    1. So wish they would bring back the death penalty for evil like him. Taking the life of an innocent man and his dog just sickens me. If nothing else, may this monster live his days in prison surrounded by those who love dogs.

      26
      1. Same here, but the blue cancer that exists in Wisconsin insists that they’re simply nothing you can do in this state bad enough for you to deserve capital punishment. Including this travesty.

        1. Of course your going to make this political. Only a Trumper would care that it’s a blue state. Our hearts are broken over our family member murdered and you post something stupid.

      2. His criminal history really isn’t that bad. I would guess he just sometimes loses his mind when he is strung out on meth. This time, resulting in tragedy. Maybe he is also evil, I don’t know. The beard with shaved head make him look quite evil indeed. I would think 40 years to life would be an appropriate penalty. Death penalty seems excessive. Maybe he will find God in jail, and be able to live a few years on the outside before he dies.

        1. Excuse me? Did he murder someone you love? Well we loved Uncle Andy and he did not deserve to be murdered by a meth head. Uncle Andy never heard a hair on anyone’s head.
          I pray that none of your loved ones are ever senselessly murdered. Maybe you won’t be such a blessing heart.

    2. Thank you for your condolences. Uncle Andy was a wonderful, generous, kind hearted, living and passive man. We love him and miss him and pray that justice will be served. Tercek does not deserve to breathe the air that Uncle Andy should be breathing! This man is pure evil

    1. I didn’t think Uncle Andy thought this guy would do something like this. Where we are from, murders are rare and trusting in strangers is common. 😭

    1. 100%. This story sickens me. This scum does not deserve another day here on earth after what he did to this innocent man and his dog.

      27
  2. this story seems unbelievable. It’s just another day in Kenoshavillle, similar to Pottersville. SR’s Kenoshaville

    2
    6
  3. And the circus begins. The system will make money while a man is dead. Throw him in the lake and let’s see how long he lasts.

    5
    1
  4. This is sickening that KPD let another Death by negligence happen again! Him and his dogs death should’ve been completely avoidable. How Many more lawsuits are KPD going to face before they learn and train to do the correct protocol ?? This is just more proof of negligence, corruption and laziness on KPD’s part. And they don’t care about their constituents Safety. The Poor kids growing up in Kenosha. Y’all deserve better, so demand better.

    4
    10
    1. KPD wasn’t involved until the dead guy was found. Doesn’t sound like he asked for police assistance when his keys were stolen.

      1
      3
        1. Uncle Andy DID CALL THE POLICE!
          Why don’t you people just shut the FUCK UP!
          OUR HEARTS ARE BROKEN AND ALL OF YOU JUST WANT TO RUN YOUR MOUTHS.

  5. I am so very sorry for this happening to this man. My gosh, after just owning the home for three days. I hope that disgusting pig spends the rest of his life in prison–i wish we had the death penalty here in WI

    10
  6. I see that this guy was a convicted felon and had charges for carrying a concealed knife at least twice. The latest charge was in December and it appears that a deal with the current DA was made and adjudicated on January 29. What was the deal made and did the judge follow it? It appears the Judge and DA let this guy walk and he likely was handed his knife back as he was released from jail. Kevin I hope you follow up on this a report the facts here.

    9
    2
  7. So it appears that this guy was a felon and was charged multiple times for carrying a concealed knife. The latest occurred in December 2024. It appears the current DA’s office struck a deal with this guy and on January 29 he was sentenced to the 48 days served. I’m guessing that when he left jail he was handed his knife back.

    Kevin I’m looking forward to a follow up story on this. What was the deal that the current DAs office recommended and did the judge follow it? Did he get his knife back when he left jail? I’m sure there is a paper trail a mile long and Kevin can get the documents for all to see.

  8. Pit Bulls in the cell with him. Not a death sentence. Should be fun to watch. Probably a Illinois state reject anyway. Nothing lost, dogs are fed. Everyone is happy.

    1. It’s terrible this guy and the dog are dead, but at least this “long time resident of Kenosha” is off the streets for good. Watching him in the video, you can see pure evil in his eyes.

    1. Every cop that writes a speeding ticket in Kenosha county is a hero. Speeding and loud vehicles are the number one problem in the area.

  9. Evil just evil. What did he think? When he got out of prison his Grandmas house would be his? So sorry for the family’s loss and the loss of his beloved dog. Hang that POS high

  10. Apparently Grandma used to bail Tercek out and offer him shelter when he had no where else to go. So it just wasn’t “right” for Pfannkuche to take that away from him.
    A brain fried on a lifetime of illicit drug use may help to explain his demonic actions.
    Look up his 20+ court record (https://wcca.wicourts.gov).

  11. What is so sad about this is that the accused looks so evil with his shaved head and beard, and the victim looks like such a nice guy, with the loyal dog trying to protect him, who also is killed. I don’t think there is anything that could excuse that type of act, even if he was out of his mind on drugs and recently sent to jail for crimes that shouldn’t be crimes, and while he is in jail the system takes his/grandmothers house and justifialbly pissed off at the system. Doesn’t excuse stabbing to guy an innocent man and his dog. Drugs can make you do terrible and stupid things, but they don’t make you do EVIL things like this.

  12. Congratulations to the Branch Manager. Schatz has always favored the tree chipper as a deterrent to criminals. Also useful in returning illegals to their homeland.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Categories
Archives
Authors

Subscribe to updates

Get notified of new articles. We'll never share your email address.