Kenosha Woman’s Murder Could Have Been Prevented By Judges And DA’s Office: Opinion

Copied!
Roderick L. Smith, 39, of Kenosha

39-year old Gia Martin was found murdered last week in Kenosha after being missing for several weeks.

Paid Advertisement

Roderick L. Smith is expected to be charged on Wednesday with murder and several other charges including moving/hiding a corpse. If convicted, he will be sentenced to prison for the remainder of his life.

Paid Advertisement

We believe this death was preventable. As you might have guessed, Mr. Smith is not a stranger to the criminal justice system. He is a multiple felon and has a long rap-sheet of violent arrests. In the last 5 years, he has been arrested and convicted of domestic abuse right here in Kenosha County 4 times. Why wasn’t this violent man in prison where he belongs? To answer simply, he wasn’t in prison because of sweetheart deals offered by DA Michael Graveley’s office and signed off by the Judges. Let’s look at the last five years of domestic abuse allegations:

Paid Advertisement

2016CM861 (Two Misdemeanor Counts Charged) On June 30, 2016, Mr. Smith slapped his girlfriend (not Gia) in the face and she told the police he had a history of violence with her.

Paid Advertisement

Prosecutor ADA Jennifer Phan gave him a plea deal. He did no time and Judge Mary K. Wagner (D) fined him $500.

Paid Advertisement

2016CF1408 (Two Felony Counts Charged) On December 26, 2016, Mr. Smith Called his girlfriend a bitch, dumb-ass and fat-ass. He then threatened to break her hands if “she touched his xBox again”. He physically abused her face by grabbing it firmly with both hands.

Paid Advertisement

Prosecutor ADA T. Clair Binger dismissed one felony with a plea deal. He plead guilty to one felony. Judge Schroeder gave him no time and ordered two years of probation. His probation was later revoked and he got 1 year in prison.

Paid Advertisement

2017CF460 (Three felonies and one misdemeanor charged) On April 30, 2017 Mr. Smith pushed his penis in is girlfriend’s face without consent. He then physically abused her by punching her breast. He threatened to bash her head in with brass knuckles.

Paid Advertisement

Prosecutor Margie Drees dismissed two felonies and one misdemeanor and he plead guilty to one felony. Judge Mary K. Wagner (D) approved plea deal. Wagner gave him no time in prison.

2018CF122 (2 Felony Counts Charged) Smith was drunk and threatened to beat his girlfriend and murder her with one of his guns.

Prosecutor ADA Zach Brost dismissed both felonies with a plea deal. He plead guilty to one misdemeanor and Judge Schroeder gave him 90 days in jail.

Two years ago, Mr. Smith threatened to shoot his girlfriend with a gun and a couple of weeks ago, police say he did just that to another woman. These are ONLY the domestic abuse convictions. We reached out to Mike Graveley but he isn’t taking responsibility for Gia’s death. If the prosecutors and Judges wouldn’t have gone so easy on Mr. Smith, maybe Gia would be alive today with her children. When Judges and Prosecutors go easy on violent criminals, there are very very real consequences. People can and do die because of a weak criminal justice system. Unfortunately that may be the case here in Kenosha, WI.

Author

Copied!
LATEST NEWS
Plus +

Pleasant Prairie Man Charged With Felony Stalking After Allegedly Harassing Former Friend for More Than a Year

Pleasant Prairie Police(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye) PLEASANT PRAIRIE, Wis. — Michael L. Sarckees, 29, of Pleasant Prairie is facing a felony stalking charge after prosecutors allege he repeatedly followed, harassed, intimidated, and damaged the property of a former friend during a series of incidents spanning more than a year. You must be logged in to view the rest of

City Tells Residents to Water Fiber-Damaged Parkways, Drawing Fresh Complaints

KENOSHA, Wis. — More than a year after Kenosha County Eye first reported widespread complaints about damage and unfinished restoration work associated with the Kenosha Fiber City project, the City of Kenosha is now asking residents to help restore affected areas by watering newly seeded parkways. In a press release issued Tuesday, the city announced that SiFi Networks has begun what it describes

MORE TOP STORIES

June is Men’s Mental Health Month

Every year, thousands of Americans die by suicide. In the United States, men account for nearly 80% of those deaths. That’s about 107 men every day, 749 every week, more than 3,200 every month, and one man every 13 minutes. These aren’t random numbers. They’re real people—fathers, brothers, sons, husbands,

Kenosha County DA Xavier Solis Invited to Speak at Statewide Organized Retail Crime Conference

KENOSHA, Wis. — Kenosha County District Attorney Xavier Solis has been selected as a featured speaker at the Wisconsin Organized Retail Crime Association’s annual conference, where he will address prosecutors, law enforcement officials, retail investigators, and industry leaders from across Wisconsin and Illinois on Kenosha County’s efforts to combat organized

Categories
Archives
Authors

7 Responses

  1. The sad part is that it’s not like this guy was one person who fell through the cracks. No, there are lots of individuals in Kenosha with many DV arrests/charges and they basically all get plea bargained down to nothing here. This certainly won’t be the last time you see a situation like this.

    1. I’ll just use this post to say…..I told you so.

      Ranon Brownlee….case dismissed in 2020 by Kenosha County DA for domestic violence against same woman he killed.

  2. This is horrible. But you used the wrong kind of “week” in the sentence. This is the word you were looking for “weak”.

  3. Kit Stilwell is an escalating domestic abuser. And he’s about to get out with just probation. I witnessed Judge Schroeder’s warning that he’s had miscreants detained for lesser crimes than Stilwell’s. Please don’t let him out. He’s a monster.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LATEST NEWS
Plus +

Pleasant Prairie Man Charged With Felony Stalking After Allegedly Harassing Former Friend for More Than a Year

Pleasant Prairie Police(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye) PLEASANT PRAIRIE, Wis. — Michael L. Sarckees, 29, of Pleasant Prairie is facing a felony stalking charge after prosecutors allege he repeatedly followed, harassed, intimidated, and damaged the property of a former friend during a series of incidents spanning more than a year. You must be logged in to view the rest of

City Tells Residents to Water Fiber-Damaged Parkways, Drawing Fresh Complaints

KENOSHA, Wis. — More than a year after Kenosha County Eye first reported widespread complaints about damage and unfinished restoration work associated with the Kenosha Fiber City project, the City of Kenosha is now asking residents to help restore affected areas by watering newly seeded parkways. In a press release issued Tuesday, the city announced that SiFi Networks has begun what it describes

Plus +

Teacher Previously Suspended 10 Days for Using N-Word Suspended Again for 5 Days After Asking Girl About Her Period, Making Race-Based Comment to Student

Paul Mommaerts – Teacher, Tremper High School KENOSHA, Wis. — Paul Mommaerts, the Tremper High School teacher who was suspended 10 days, demoted, and docked pay in 2024 for using the N-word in class and telling a student “fuck you,” has been suspended again after students accused him of loudly asking a female student whether she had gotten her period, making a race-based

June is Men’s Mental Health Month

Every year, thousands of Americans die by suicide. In the United States, men account for nearly 80% of those deaths. That’s about 107 men every day, 749 every week, more than 3,200 every month, and one man every 13 minutes. These aren’t random numbers. They’re real people—fathers, brothers, sons, husbands, and friends. A lot of men deal with things quietly. They keep moving

Kenosha Woman Who Claimed She Was Falsely Branded a Prostitute and Drug User Loses Restraining Order Bid; Records Show Prior Harassment Allegations and Multiple Reduced Cases

KENOSHA, Wis. — A Kenosha woman known to some local residents for years of online feuds and social media disputes, and who continues to use a Facebook account under the alias “Aiste Marie,” has lost her bid for a harassment restraining order after claiming another woman falsely accused her of being a prostitute, drug user and animal abuser. The ruling comes after years

Kenosha County DA Xavier Solis Invited to Speak at Statewide Organized Retail Crime Conference

KENOSHA, Wis. — Kenosha County District Attorney Xavier Solis has been selected as a featured speaker at the Wisconsin Organized Retail Crime Association’s annual conference, where he will address prosecutors, law enforcement officials, retail investigators, and industry leaders from across Wisconsin and Illinois on Kenosha County’s efforts to combat organized retail theft. Solis is scheduled to present Tuesday at the WIORCA Annual Conference

BLM Activist Charged With Two Criminal Misdemeanors Nearly Four Years After License Revocation

SOMERS, Wis. — A local Black Lives Matter activist who has faced criminal convictions, civil judgments, municipal citations, tax warrants, restraining-order litigation and a unanimous defamation verdict is now facing two new criminal misdemeanor charges after authorities say he was caught driving despite having a revoked license and no court-ordered ignition interlock device installed in the vehicle. Raymond Karim Roberts, 44, of Somers,

Plus +

Illinois Man Accused of Fleeing Crash That Left Kenosha Driver With Broken Leg, Held on $4,000 Cash Bail

Andrei C. Bobadilla, 31, of Waukegan, Illinois(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — An Illinois man is facing felony charges after prosecutors say he ran a red light in Kenosha, crashed into another vehicle, seriously injuring its driver, and then fled the scene for more than three hours before turning himself in. Court Commissioner Alexandra Smathers ordered a $4,000 cash bail Monday after

Plus +

Pleasant Prairie Man Accused in 115 MPH Stolen-Car Chase Released on No-Cash Bail After Felony Charge Dismissed

Rey Gutierrez, 19, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) PLEASANT PRAIRIE, Wis. — Liberal Activist Supplemental Court Commissioner Aileen “Half-Off” Henry on Monday dismissed a felony vehicle-theft charge and a drug possession charge against a Kenosha man accused of riding in a stolen car during a 115-mph police chase before releasing him on a no-cash bail, despite prosecutors seeking cash bail. A courthouse insider

Plus +

Felon Accused of Possessing Loaded Handgun Gets $1,500 Cash Bail After State Sought $20,000

Brandon R. Martin, 47, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A Kenosha man accused of illegally possessing a loaded handgun despite being a convicted felon was given a $1,500 cash bail Monday by Court Commissioner Alexandra Smathers (D) after prosecutors sought $20,000 cash. The decision drew immediate criticism from a courthouse insider who described the bail as extraordinarily low for a

Plus +

Felony Domestic Violence Charges Filed Against Kenosha Woman Just Two Months After Prior Conviction

Vanessa Vallejo, 34, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A Kenosha woman is facing new felony domestic violence charges after prosecutors say she brutally attacked her live-in boyfriend during a drunken argument, less than two months after being convicted in another domestic abuse case. Vanessa Vallejo, 34, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) You must be logged in to view the rest

Plus +

Registered Sex Offender Accused of Cutting Off GPS Monitor Gets $7,500 Cash Bail

Markece D. McCovery, 37, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A Kenosha man who authorities say cut off a court-ordered GPS monitoring device while under Department of Corrections supervision was ordered held on a $7,500 cash bail Monday after prosecutors argued he intentionally removed the tracking bracelet and disappeared for more than two weeks. Markece D. McCovery, 37, of Kenosha(Kenosha County

Plus +

Tremper Chemistry Teacher Suspended 3 Days Without Pay, Assigned ‘Thought Partner’ After Telling Students She Was ‘A Little Bit Racist’

Amanda Nickel – Science Teacher, Tremper High School KENOSHA, Wis. — A Tremper High School chemistry teacher who told students she was “a little bit racist,” said “everybody is a little bit racist,” and allegedly told students she would be more cautious if a Black person was behind her on a dark street was suspended without pay for three days and assigned a

Spring Curbside Compostables Collection Ending This Week in Kenosha

KENOSHA, Wis. — Residents who use the City of Kenosha’s spring curbside compostables collection service have only a few days left before the seasonal program concludes for the year. City officials announced Monday that the 2026 spring curbside compostables collection will end on June 5. The program provides residents with an opportunity to dispose of compostable yard waste and other eligible materials through

Americans for Prosperity Backs Ellen Schutt in State Senate Race

CLINTON, Wis. — Republican State Senate candidate Ellen Schutt has secured the endorsement of Americans for Prosperity-Wisconsin, adding another prominent conservative organization to her growing list of supporters as she campaigns for the State Senate.

Plus +

County Executive Kerkman Denies Favoritism Allegations In Three-Year Health Department Internship, Declines To Address Neighbor Claim

Kenosha County Executive Samantha Kerkman(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye) KENOSHA COUNTY, Wis. — County Executive Samantha Kerkman is denying allegations that a paid Kenosha County Health Department internship was awarded through favoritism after the same individual was hired for three consecutive summers, referred by a department supervisor, and alleged to be the supervisor’s neighbor and a close friend of the

Plus +

Woman Accused of Letting Dog Rot to Death Gets $1,000 Cash Bail After Prosecutors Sought $25,000 on Seven-Count Animal Neglect Case

Shunlisa Carter, 39, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) SOMERS, Wis. — A courtroom observer described the bail decision as “grotesquely low” after Liberal Activist Supplemental Court Commissioner Aileen “Half Off” Henry ordered just $1,000 cash bail for a woman accused of leaving a dog to die in deplorable conditions, despite prosecutors requesting $25,000 cash bail. The observer further told Kenosha County Eye that

Bill Hopkins Named 2026 Kenosha County Veteran of the Year at Annual Veterans Picnic

KENOSHA, Wis. — Veterans from across generations gathered Friday at the Kenosha County Veterans Memorial Park for the annual Veterans Appreciation Summer Picnic, an event that celebrated military service, community involvement, and this year’s Kenosha County Veteran of the Year honoree, Bill Hopkins. Hopkins, a U.S. Navy veteran and longtime community volunteer, received the 2026 Kenosha County Veteran of the Year award, which

Plus +

Felony Battery Charge Filed After Kenosha Man Allegedly Strikes Officer During Arrest; $6,000 Cash Bail Set

Shawn P. Stachnik, 48, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A Kenosha man accused of striking a police officer in the face while officers attempted to arrest him on an outstanding felony warrant was ordered held on a $6,000 cash bail Friday by Liberal Activist Supplemental Court Commissioner Aileen Henry after prosecutors sought $8,000 cash bail. Shawn P. Stachnik, 48, of

Outta Sight Kite Flight Returns to Kenosha Lakefront for 23rd Year

KENOSHA, Wis. — Hundreds of colorful kites will once again fill the skies above Kenosha’s lakefront next weekend as the annual Outta Sight Kite Flight returns to Kennedy Park for its 23rd year in the city. The free family-friendly event will take place Saturday, June 6, and Sunday, June 7, from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. at Kennedy Park, 4051 Fifth Ave. Organizers

Plus +

No-Cash Bail Ordered for Kenosha Woman Charged With Felony False Imprisonment in Domestic Violence Case

Samantha Caprice Washington, 22, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 22-year-old Kenosha woman is facing a felony charge after prosecutors allege she physically prevented the father of her child from leaving a room at the Shalom Center, pulled his hair, punched him, and continued assaultive behavior as he attempted to leave. Court records show Liberal Activist Supplemental Court Commissioner Aileen

Plus +

Kenosha Man Accused of Throwing 67-Year-Old Woman Onto Couch; Liberal Activist Supplemental Court Commissioner Aileen Henry Orders $5,000 Cash Bail

Damian J. Pavlovich, 38, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A Kenosha man accused of picking up a 67-year-old woman and throwing her onto a couch during a domestic disturbance was ordered held on a $5,000 cash bail Friday after prosecutors argued the allegations warranted detention. Damian J. Pavlovich, 38, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) You must be logged in to

LATEST NEWS
Plus +

Pleasant Prairie Man Charged With Felony Stalking After Allegedly Harassing Former Friend for More Than a Year

Pleasant Prairie Police(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye) PLEASANT PRAIRIE, Wis. — Michael L. Sarckees, 29, of Pleasant Prairie is facing a felony stalking charge after prosecutors allege he repeatedly followed, harassed, intimidated, and damaged the property of a former friend during a series of incidents spanning more than a year. You must be logged in to view the rest of

City Tells Residents to Water Fiber-Damaged Parkways, Drawing Fresh Complaints

KENOSHA, Wis. — More than a year after Kenosha County Eye first reported widespread complaints about damage and unfinished restoration work associated with the Kenosha Fiber City project, the City of Kenosha is now asking residents to help restore affected areas by watering newly seeded parkways. In a press release issued Tuesday, the city announced that SiFi Networks has begun what it describes

Plus +

Teacher Previously Suspended 10 Days for Using N-Word Suspended Again for 5 Days After Asking Girl About Her Period, Making Race-Based Comment to Student

Paul Mommaerts – Teacher, Tremper High School KENOSHA, Wis. — Paul Mommaerts, the Tremper High School teacher who was suspended 10 days, demoted, and docked pay in 2024 for using the N-word in class and telling a student “fuck you,” has been suspended again after students accused him of loudly asking a female student whether she had gotten her period, making a race-based

June is Men’s Mental Health Month

Every year, thousands of Americans die by suicide. In the United States, men account for nearly 80% of those deaths. That’s about 107 men every day, 749 every week, more than 3,200 every month, and one man every 13 minutes. These aren’t random numbers. They’re real people—fathers, brothers, sons, husbands, and friends. A lot of men deal with things quietly. They keep moving

Kenosha Woman Who Claimed She Was Falsely Branded a Prostitute and Drug User Loses Restraining Order Bid; Records Show Prior Harassment Allegations and Multiple Reduced Cases

KENOSHA, Wis. — A Kenosha woman known to some local residents for years of online feuds and social media disputes, and who continues to use a Facebook account under the alias “Aiste Marie,” has lost her bid for a harassment restraining order after claiming another woman falsely accused her of being a prostitute, drug user and animal abuser. The ruling comes after years

Kenosha County DA Xavier Solis Invited to Speak at Statewide Organized Retail Crime Conference

KENOSHA, Wis. — Kenosha County District Attorney Xavier Solis has been selected as a featured speaker at the Wisconsin Organized Retail Crime Association’s annual conference, where he will address prosecutors, law enforcement officials, retail investigators, and industry leaders from across Wisconsin and Illinois on Kenosha County’s efforts to combat organized retail theft. Solis is scheduled to present Tuesday at the WIORCA Annual Conference

BLM Activist Charged With Two Criminal Misdemeanors Nearly Four Years After License Revocation

SOMERS, Wis. — A local Black Lives Matter activist who has faced criminal convictions, civil judgments, municipal citations, tax warrants, restraining-order litigation and a unanimous defamation verdict is now facing two new criminal misdemeanor charges after authorities say he was caught driving despite having a revoked license and no court-ordered ignition interlock device installed in the vehicle. Raymond Karim Roberts, 44, of Somers,

Plus +

Illinois Man Accused of Fleeing Crash That Left Kenosha Driver With Broken Leg, Held on $4,000 Cash Bail

Andrei C. Bobadilla, 31, of Waukegan, Illinois(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — An Illinois man is facing felony charges after prosecutors say he ran a red light in Kenosha, crashed into another vehicle, seriously injuring its driver, and then fled the scene for more than three hours before turning himself in. Court Commissioner Alexandra Smathers ordered a $4,000 cash bail Monday after

Plus +

Pleasant Prairie Man Accused in 115 MPH Stolen-Car Chase Released on No-Cash Bail After Felony Charge Dismissed

Rey Gutierrez, 19, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) PLEASANT PRAIRIE, Wis. — Liberal Activist Supplemental Court Commissioner Aileen “Half-Off” Henry on Monday dismissed a felony vehicle-theft charge and a drug possession charge against a Kenosha man accused of riding in a stolen car during a 115-mph police chase before releasing him on a no-cash bail, despite prosecutors seeking cash bail. A courthouse insider

Plus +

Felon Accused of Possessing Loaded Handgun Gets $1,500 Cash Bail After State Sought $20,000

Brandon R. Martin, 47, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A Kenosha man accused of illegally possessing a loaded handgun despite being a convicted felon was given a $1,500 cash bail Monday by Court Commissioner Alexandra Smathers (D) after prosecutors sought $20,000 cash. The decision drew immediate criticism from a courthouse insider who described the bail as extraordinarily low for a

Plus +

Felony Domestic Violence Charges Filed Against Kenosha Woman Just Two Months After Prior Conviction

Vanessa Vallejo, 34, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A Kenosha woman is facing new felony domestic violence charges after prosecutors say she brutally attacked her live-in boyfriend during a drunken argument, less than two months after being convicted in another domestic abuse case. Vanessa Vallejo, 34, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) You must be logged in to view the rest

Plus +

Registered Sex Offender Accused of Cutting Off GPS Monitor Gets $7,500 Cash Bail

Markece D. McCovery, 37, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A Kenosha man who authorities say cut off a court-ordered GPS monitoring device while under Department of Corrections supervision was ordered held on a $7,500 cash bail Monday after prosecutors argued he intentionally removed the tracking bracelet and disappeared for more than two weeks. Markece D. McCovery, 37, of Kenosha(Kenosha County

Plus +

Tremper Chemistry Teacher Suspended 3 Days Without Pay, Assigned ‘Thought Partner’ After Telling Students She Was ‘A Little Bit Racist’

Amanda Nickel – Science Teacher, Tremper High School KENOSHA, Wis. — A Tremper High School chemistry teacher who told students she was “a little bit racist,” said “everybody is a little bit racist,” and allegedly told students she would be more cautious if a Black person was behind her on a dark street was suspended without pay for three days and assigned a

Spring Curbside Compostables Collection Ending This Week in Kenosha

KENOSHA, Wis. — Residents who use the City of Kenosha’s spring curbside compostables collection service have only a few days left before the seasonal program concludes for the year. City officials announced Monday that the 2026 spring curbside compostables collection will end on June 5. The program provides residents with an opportunity to dispose of compostable yard waste and other eligible materials through

Americans for Prosperity Backs Ellen Schutt in State Senate Race

CLINTON, Wis. — Republican State Senate candidate Ellen Schutt has secured the endorsement of Americans for Prosperity-Wisconsin, adding another prominent conservative organization to her growing list of supporters as she campaigns for the State Senate.

Categories
Archives
Authors

Wake Up to What You Missed

Get notified of new articles. We'll never share your email address.