Timmy L. Brooks (30) of Milwaukee, WI will spend the rest of his life in prison without the chance for parole. This is the sentence handed down from Judge Gerald Dougvillo Thursday afternoon.

Paid Advertisement

Brooks previously pleaded guilty of first degree intentional homicide for the May 25, 2022 murder of his girlfriend, Montreach Mitchell. According to the criminal complaint, a member of the housekeeping staff at Wyndham Garden hotel, which is located at 5125 6th Ave, found a deceased woman in a hotel room. She was later identified as 30-year-old Mitchell. The suspect, Timmy Brooks turned himself in later that day at the request of his mother. He confessed. He told police he was tired of arguing with Mitchell, so he shot her in the back of her head, and later, two more times.

In court today, more than 30 friends and family members of Mitchell filled the room. Mitchell’s brother, sister, and father spoke in favor of a harsh sentence, describing how beautiful Mitchell was, inside and out.

Paid Advertisement

In court for the DA’s office were DA Michael Graveley (D) and ADA Daniel Tombasco. Tombasco made the sentencing arguments today, detailing a man who had no regard for rules or human life. He asked for the maximum sentence the judge could give.

Defense attorney Chad Shamali acknowledged the seriousness of the crimes his client committed, but argued for parole eligibility, noting that Brooks turned himself in, gave a confession and pleaded guilty, waiving his constitutional right to a jury trial. Schamali also said the Brooks had mental health issues. He said that if released, Brooks would give his life to God.

Paid Advertisement

Kenosha Circuit Court Judge Gerald Dougvillo first apologized to the family and friends of the victim. “There is nothing that I’m going to do. There’s nothing that I’m going to say that will put you back in the position that you deserve to be in. And that is to have Ms. Mitchell here with you.” Dougvillo then detailed Brooks’ criminal history and noted all of the chances Brooks had to address his mental health issues. “You had the chances to do what God expected of you, and you have opted to walk away from all of this,” said Dougvillo. “This wasn’t senseless. This was callus, cold, and heartless. This wasn’t a momentary decision….. because if it was, it would have been one shot. But it wasn’t. As laid out by the state here, this was one shot to the back of her head, and she went to the ground. There was no threat to you….” at this time Brooks interrupted yelling “Man you gonna give me life!” The six deputies in the room, got closer the Brooks and the Judge continued. “And you fired not one, but two more shots.”

Dougvillo then gave Brooks the maximum sentence allowed under the law.

Paid Advertisement

Although Brooks apologized to the victim and her family, he looked back at them many times throughout the hearing to smile and mock them. The deputies, under the command of Lt. Gilley, however did a good job of shielding him from their view.

After court was adjourned and Brooks was being brought back to the jail, he later yelled at the family members saying “I could have got two life sentences, I don’t care!”

With that, the family left the courthouse and Brooks will be off to the big house until he dies.