Attorney For Man Alleged To Have Killed Two Friends In OWI Crash Uses Handwritten Note From Victim’s Mom To Reduce Bail

Copied!
Homicide Defendant Ajay Pierangeli and Attorney Dennis Melowski
(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

A lawyer for a Pleasant Prairie man named Ajay Pierangeli has asked a Kenosha Circuit Court Judge to reduce his client’s bail to the tune of one half million dollars – from $500,000 to $0. The Kenosha County DA’s office charged Ajay Pierangeli with two counts of homicide by intoxicated use of a vehicle, class D felonies, Injury by Intoxicated Use of Vehicle and OWI Causing Injury (2nd). If convicted of all counts, Pierangeli faces a maximum sentence of just over 68 years in the Wisconsin State Prison System – More than 40 years of initial confinement followed by 28 years of extended supervision.

Paid Advertisement
Paid Advertisement

The charges stemmed from a July 28, 2023 crash that took two lives and severely injured three others. At approximately 3:05 am, a 2008 Red Dodge Dakota occupied by five people crashed into Play It Again Sports located at 4017 75th St in Kenosha. The driver was identified as Pierangeli (formerly Fierke). According to the report, obtained by KCE from the Wisconsin Department of Transportation, and the criminal complaint, police allege Pierangeli was intoxicated and that speed also caused him to lose control of the truck. Pierangeli’s blood alcohol level was more than three and a half times the legal limit at .282 BAC. Two occupants of a private ambulance witnessed the crash and estimated the speed to be about 70 mph in a 30mph zone. They also saw the vehicle swerving and occupants of the vehicle “blowing kisses” out of the window before the crash. They noted the truck went airborne.

Paid Advertisement
Kenosha County Circuit Court Commissioner William Michel II
(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

Kenosha County Circuit Court Commissioner William Michel II signed Pierangeli’s arrest warrant and placed the cash value at $500,000. Defense counsel asked for a lower bail amount, but Michel  declined, citing the seriousness of the allegations.

Paid Advertisement
Kenosha County Circuit Court Judge Gerad Dougvillo
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

On September 20, 2023, Melowski asked Circuit Court Judge Gerad Dougvillo to give Pierangeli a no-cash bail. The arguments might sound strange to some. Melowski lists the number of family members of Pierangeli that live in the area. He also says that Pierangeli has many friends in the area. He also, strangely, even named one of Pierangeli’s aunts, who has a prominent last name in Kenosha. Melowski also says “Mr. Pierangeli will not try to ‘pull the wool over’ the Court’s eyes to imply that he attends church weekly-as he does not-however, neither does he completely abstain from a spiritual life.” Melowski also says that  the establishment where Pierangeli was employed will “immediately take Pierangeli back to work if he is released.” Melowski classifies this fact as something that “speaks volumes about Mr. Pierangeli’s character.” However,  KCE spoke to the owner of the business who said “I was never contacted by [the] attorney…. I was in law enforcement for over 30 years my heart goes out to families of the victims and of AJ’s. It is a horrible situation.”

Paid Advertisement

Melowski also cites to Pierangeli’s injuries he allegedly caused to himself as a reason why he must immediately be released from jail. Melowski also alleges, without citing any evidence that the victims’ families are not seeking severe punishment.

Paid Advertisement

Melowski did, however give Judge Dougvillo a letter allegedly written by one of the surviving victim’s mother and given to Pierangeli’s parents that said “I just wanted to stop by & give you all a hug. You are in our thoughts & prayers.”

Paid Advertisement

We asked Melowski if this letter was written to Pierangeli’s parents, who are also victims. Their son will likely spend many years in prison. We also asked him if he got the woman’s permission to use this personal letter to benefit his client. He didn’t respond.

Paid Advertisement

Melowski left some things out of his argument that the State of Wisconsin will likely add later:

Paid Advertisement
  1. This is his second OWI causing serious injury – both before he turned 21.
  2. He could be seen as a danger to the rest of the public as he seems to not believe the rules about not driving at 3.5 times the legal limit apply to him.
  3. Any health concerns are his fault and his fault alone, allegedly.

The judge will hear arguments on October 27, 2023 at 9:00 am.

Author

Copied!
LATEST NEWS

Illinois Teen Faces Over 75 Years in Prison for Fleeing Police, Shooting Into Occupied Kenosha Apartment

Kenosha, Wis. — A 19-year-old Illinois man appeared in Kenosha County court Thursday on two sets of felony charges tied to a high-speed police chase and a shooting into an occupied apartment. Zjevon A. Romero, of Zion, faces a total of 10 felony charges across two cases, including multiple counts of first-degree recklessly endangering safety, fleeing and eluding, and felony bail jumping. If convicted on all charges, he faces more than 75 years in prison. Kenosha

Read More »

Kenosha Man Faces Nearly 15 Years in Prison for Elder ID Theft, Standoff with Police

Kenosha, Wis. — A 37-year-old Kenosha man appeared in court Thursday facing a slew of felony charges stemming from allegations of identity theft against his elderly father and a standoff with police during his arrest. Kenneth S. Grandow, Jr. was charged in two separate criminal cases with felony identity theft to obtain money or credit from an elderly person, felony failure to comply with officers attempting to take a person into custody, disorderly conduct with a

Read More »
MORE TOP STORIES

Indian Trail Math Teacher Previously Disciplined for ‘Heil Hitler’ Comment Now Under Investigation Again

Kenosha, Wis. — A math teacher at Indian Trail High School and Academy has once again been placed on administrative leave—this time for allegedly making racist comments in front of students, sparking renewed outrage from parents, students, and community members. Ryan Nachtigal, a longtime math teacher in the Kenosha Unified School District (KUSD), was reportedly escorted out of his classroom on March 19, by Assistant Principal Matt St. Martin, according to multiple sources who contacted KCE.

Read More »

National Association of Letter Carriers (NALC) to Hold Emergency Rally to Defend the U.S. Postal Service Amid Threats to Dismantle & Privatize America’s Most Trusted Public Institution

The National Association of Letter Carriers (NALC) will hold an urgent rally on March 23 to oppose reported efforts to take away the independence of the U.S. Postal Service (USPS) and degrade its universal delivery mandate, which would affect every local resident, business, organization and neighborhood. We oppose any plans to eliminate the USPS leadership, abolish regulatory oversight, and carve up postal operations, thereby threatening the universal mandate to deliver everywhere and for the same price

Read More »

Title IX Complaint Filed Against Westosha Central High School Over Locker Room Policy

Salem, Wis. — The Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty (WILL) has filed a Title IX complaint against Westosha Central High School District, alleging the district engaged in sex-based discrimination against female students by allowing a biological male student to use the girls’ locker room. The complaint, submitted to the U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights (OCR) and the Department of Justice’s Civil Rights Division, outlines allegations that two female students, referred to as

Read More »

Pleasant Prairie Man Charged with Bigamy Following Court Revelations

Pleasant Prairie, Wis. – A 62-year-old Pleasant Prairie man is facing a felony charge of bigamy after authorities discovered he was allegedly married to multiple women at the same time. Thomas R. Angeloff, Sr. was officially charged with bigamy on March 3, 2025. In Wisconsin, bigamy is classified as a felony, carrying a maximum penalty of three and a half years in prison and a $10,000 fine, or both. A warrant was issued for Angeloff’s arrest

Read More »

Kenosha Man Charged with Possession of Child Pornography, Held on $150,000 Bail

Kenosha, Wis. – A 23-year-old Kenosha man has been charged with ten counts of possession of child pornography following an extensive investigation that began with a cyber tip from the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children (NCMEC). Romeo L. Brantley was formally charged on March 3, 2025, and made his initial court appearance before Kenosha County Circuit Court Commissioner William Michel II, who set his bail at $150,000. Brantley faces a maximum sentence of 250

Read More »

Kenosha County Cases Face Scrutiny After Former Officer’s Troubling History Comes to Light

A former Kenosha Police officer and Kenosha County Deputy Sheriff, Michael Rizzo, has become a liability for multiple prosecutions in Kenosha County due to a history of disciplinary actions, a restraining order, accusations of violating a court order, and dishonesty. His record is likely to be exploited by defense attorneys to challenge his credibility as a witness in ongoing cases. Rizzo’s Turbulent Law Enforcement Career Rizzo was first hired by the Kenosha Police Department (KPD) on

Read More »

The Racine County Bar Association Announces the Results of its Judicial Qualification Poll

Members of the Racine County Bar Association were asked to vote on the qualifications of the candidates for the upcoming elections for Racine County Circuit Court Judge Branch 7. The following poll was sent to current members of the RCBA: Please vote for the individual that you believe is most qualified based upon your personal knowledge, investigation, or experience: a) Jon Fredricksonb) Jamie McClendonc) Both equally qualified The results of the poll were tabulated by the

Read More »

Legend Lake Property Owners Association Files Lawsuit Against Menominee County Over Alleged Tax Discrimination

Menominee County, Wis. – A property owners’ association representing hundreds of landowners at Legend Lake has filed a lawsuit against Menominee County, the Town of Menominee, and the Menominee Indian School District (MISD), alleging that their members have been unfairly burdened with excessive property taxes while other similarly classified properties remain tax-exempt. The Menominee Tribe is proposing to build a Kenosha Casino. The lawsuit, filed in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of

Read More »

Kenosha Woman Charged with First-Degree Attempted Murder Following Brutal Attack

Kenosha, Wis. – A Kenosha woman has been charged with first-degree attempted murder following a brutal attack on her roommate in the early hours of March 17, 2025. Jessica D. Lentz, 46, faces additional charges, including battery and disorderly conduct, each accompanied by three enhancers: repeater, use of a dangerous weapon, and domestic abuse. If convicted, Lentz could face more than 70 years in prison. During her initial court appearance, Lentz exhibited erratic behavior, screaming long before

Read More »

Meadows for the Prairie: Opinion

Pleasant Prairie has an interesting quirk among its residents. Each time a local election comes around, I find my neighbors begin speaking and asking questions in hushed tones.  They’re perfectly normal questions, such as “have you looked at who’s running for the Village Board?” or “did your property taxes go up this year?” I’ve always found it odd that such things are discussed over backyard fences with frequent glances to the side. My family moved to

Read More »
Categories
Archives
Authors

21 Responses

  1. Disgusting. I know people who have sat longer for far less serious crimes. This man killed 2 people. Oh poor baby, he harmed himself. Thanks for letting me know where not to eat in Kenosha. Boycott all their businesses

    26
    7
      1. Why would you suggest not patronizing his uncles business when his uncle had nothing to do with this horrible accident? Just because his uncle said he’d allow Ajay to come back to work there? It’s obvious that Ajay is not getting out unless someone can post his bail. To encourage not patronizing a small, independent business is so wrong. Maybe you need to go eat at Applebees.

  2. Here we go again. The perpetrator of a horrific crime is the victim because he is behind bars waiting trial. Well I am going to say that his actions that night/ early morning are a clear display of why he needs a high cash bond. Bond protects our community from reckless behavior from individuals who have no regard for everyone’s safety. In this case he can use the time to clean his system from alcohol, as this seems to be his issue in the first place. This is not punishment it’s for the community’s safety. This is his second incident involving a drunken driving crash. Do we even want to consider the possibility of a third? Look at how many people violate conditions of bond. This may save him from even more exposure. Hope bond stays right where it has been set.

    15
  3. Jail time. Maybe somewhere down the road he will get let out early, but there are consequences for his actions, and he needs to be held accountable.

    1. Speaking of consequences and being held accountable for someone’s actions, what’s new or going on in the Steinbrink JR case? Let’s not allow this to be buried! Let’s keep it open and talked about!

      I don’t know the EXACT quote, but in the beginning of all the Steinbrink JR case, KCE mentioned that the prosecutor, Hansen, tends to help make things “go away.” Let’s not allow that to happen PLEASE. Keep posting court dates and anything to inform us of things happening with his case.

  4. It is so unbelievable that people want to turn a blind eye to such egregious behavior. People should come forward who have lost a relative or friend to a drunk driver or who have been maimed by one.

  5. Such sadness for all; however, he has to be held accountable for his actions. Unfortunately he did not learn the first time. He will have plenty of time in prison to think about future choices.

  6. This is his 2nd OWI!! First OWI I can see as a horrible mistake that a truly remorseful person would not allow to happen again. Anything after that is a conscious decision for that action and a complete disregard for anybody else’s safety.

  7. The felony D charges have been changed to Felony C since it is not his first offense. The letter from Sarah Wajerski was written 2 days after the accident happened before all the details were even known. He belongs in prison. Actions have consequences, and he has never had any from his family or otherwise. Every time he gets in trouble, mommy and daddy hire an attorney to get him out of it and get it off his record. He is a danger to anyone around him.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LATEST NEWS
Categories
Archives
Authors

Subscribe to updates

Get notified of new articles. We'll never share your email address.