Kenosha Judge Rules 12-Year-Old Daughter And Passenger Of Drunk Driver Not A Victim – Reversed By Court Of Appeals

Copied!
Mark J. Gahart (61) of Burlington and Judge Jason Rossell)
(Mugshot from Kenosha Sheriff, Photo of Judge, KCE)

Kenosha Circuit Court Judge Jason Rossell had an important decision overturned by The Wisconsin Court of Appeals. This occurred a little less than two years ago, but KCE was only recently made aware of the decision by the higher court.

Paid Advertisement

Mark J. Gahart plead guilty to Felony Hit And Run – Involving Injury, and OWI (2nd With Passenger Under 16 Years Old.)

According to the Court of Appeals decision:

Paid Advertisement

Mark J. Gahart was convicted of operating while under the influence of an intoxicant (OWI) with a minor passenger in the vehicle. [Judge Rossell] determined that the minor was not a victim of the OWI offense and entered a judgment of conviction which was silent as to restitution and a postjudgment order stating that “Restitution is not ordered.” The State’s appeal raises the narrow issue of whether the minor passenger has a right to restitution. We conclude that the minor is a victim of Gahart’s crime under the restitution statute, Wis. Stat. § 973.20. Accordingly, we reverse [Judge Rosells’] postjudgment order denying the right to seek restitution and remand for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.

The minor’s mother told [Judge Rossell] at sentencing that Gahart “placed [his daughter] in a vehicle and scared her with his erratic driving from Burlington to Kenosha.” The mother reported that her daughter asked Gahart to slow down, but he “silenced her” as he followed other vehicles closely and attempted to “pass everybody.”

Paid Advertisement

The Court of Appeals wrote in part:

“The Legislature has determined to criminally punish and deter drivers who subject minors to the grave risks associated with drunk driving, identifying a minor as one against whom a crime has been committed. We reject Gahart’s contention that this is a victimless crime. As reported by his minor daughter’s mother, Gahart placed his daughter in the vehicle and drove erratically from Burlington to Kenosha, refused to slow down, followed other vehicles too closely, and frequently attempted to pass others. By directing his daughter to ride in a vehicle he was too intoxicated to drive safely, Gahart committed a crime against her.

Paid Advertisement

For the reasons set forth above, the minor passenger and her nonoffending parent are crime victims; each has the statutory rights of crime victims, including the right to seek restitution. The circuit court declined to address whether the mother is entitled to recover the expenses and fees she incurred in the family court proceeding as restitution. Accordingly, we reverse the postjudgment order denying restitution and remand to the circuit court to conduct further proceedings to determine whether an award of restitution is appropriate.”

Judge Rossell gave Gahart 90 days of work release and two years of probation for the felony conviction. Gahart’s attorney was Ted Kmiec.

Paid Advertisement
Mark J. Gahart (61) of Burlington)
(Mugshot from Kenosha Sheriff)

Author

Copied!
LATEST NEWS

Peter Barca Can’t Be Trusted, Especially With Illegal Immigration: Opinion

Kenosha County Eye agrees with Kenosha County Sheriff David W. Zoerner – Peter Barca can’t be trusted. In 2016, Peter Barca (D) voted against a bill that would have banned so-called “sanctuary cities.” Here was the roll-call vote that occurred on Tuesday, February 16, 2016. Even though just eight short years ago, he was a big supporter of “sanctuary cities,” he has now flip-flopped and says he no long supports them. Why the flip-flop Peter? We

Read More »

Kenosha Sheriff’s Department Solves 35-Year-Old Baby Homicide Cold Case: Prosecution Denied

After nearly 35 years and hundreds of hours of police work, the Kenosha County Sheriff’s Department has closed the 1989 homicide of Baby John Doe. Frustrating for law enforcement, however, the woman who they believe murdered the baby won’t face any charges. On Thursday, November 9, 1989, a couple of trappers made a grizzly discovery under the Highway N (38th St) bridge over the Des Plaines River in Paris. It was a very cold fall day

Read More »
MORE TOP STORIES

Journey Church Pastor Accused Of Capturing Intimate Photos: Holding On $7,500 Bail

The Kenosha Police Department is investigating Gabriel Mills, a 41-year-old Kenosha resident and pastor of Journey Church in Kenosha, for allegedly transferring intimate photographs without permission from the victim’s phone to his own. Gabriel reportedly borrowed the victim’s phone and proceeded to search through phone until finding intimate photos of the victim. He then sent the photos to his phone without consent. Gabriel was arrested by the Kenosha Police Department on September 30, 2024. Today, October

Read More »

Kenosha Board Member Calls For Vote To Discourage The Relocation of Refugees or Immigrants Without Proper Planning

One of the top issues for voters in the November 5, 2024, presidential election is immigration. Typically, it ranks as issue #2 after the economy. First-term Kenosha County Board Supervisor Keith Gray is listening to residents of his district and has proposed “A Resolution to Discourage the Resettlement of Migrants in Kenosha County”. The text of the resolution reads: WHEREAS, the immigration crisis in the United States, which involves a large influx of refugees and immigrants

Read More »

Women And Children’s Horizons Executive Director Resigns Week After Shelter Re-Opens

A week after Women and Children’s Horizons re-opened and after being closed for almost two months due to “staffing shortages,” its executive director has resigned. Yvonne MacDonald-Hames was on the job for less than three months and refused to talk to KCE today. The board president, Sandy Riese, did call KCE to answer our questions. “Our shelter is back open and the board has a plan to keep Women and Children’s Horizons a great resource to

Read More »

No Truth To Rumors Of Shuttered Schools Being Used To House Migrants: KUSD, City of Kenosha

Since the fall of 2023, Kenosha County Eye has received countless tips via phone calls, text messages, anonymous emails, and other methods, about rumors of migrants being housed in KUSD schools that are now closed.  In January of this year, we spoke with unified who assured us that there was no truth to these rumors.  A renewed round of speculation has been circulating the county with people asserting that the schools would be used to house

Read More »

Tremper English Teacher Suspended For 10 Days, Demoted, For Using “N” Word And “F” Word In Class

According to an English teacher’s personnel file, obtained by KCE, he used the “N” word in class and told a student “Fuck you.” Paul Mommaerts admitted to the actions, was suspended for 10 business days, and was demoted, costing him $10,000 annually. Mommaerts filed a grievance with the union, but lost. According to the Mommaert’s personnel file: Mommaerts admitted to his principal that he used a racial slur during his third period English Perspectives class. He

Read More »

Law&Crime To Premiere New Original Documentary, The Trials of Kyle Rittenhouse

Top legal and true crime network Law&Crime announces the premiere of its newest original documentary, The Trials of Kyle Rittenhouse, which will air on its network on Friday, Sept 27 at 7pm CST and be available on Law&Crime’s video-on-demand offerings.The 90-minute documentary, directed and produced by award-winning journalists Brian Ross and Rhonda Schwartz, sheds new light on the investigation into the events of that fateful evening in Kenosha August 2020 when Rittenhouse shot and killed two

Read More »

Kenosha Unified School District Seeks Community Input On Operational Needs Via Survey – Referendum Likely

The Kenosha Unified School District is asking all residents to participate in a referendum survey to evaluate the district’s operational needs, consider possible solutions, and contribute feedback as it plans for the future. Residents can take the anonymous survey online at kusdsurvey.com. It takes approximately 10-15 minutes to complete and is available through Thursday, October 10. “While our schools are a big point of pride in our community, KUSD has financial needs stemming from the state’s inequitable

Read More »

KUSD Teacher, Who Is Also A Powerful Milwaukee County Democrat Politician, Disciplined By District

Kathleen Vincent (D) is a powerful Milwaukee-area politician. She is the president of the School Board in Greendale, and she is on the Milwaukee County Board of Supervisors. Her full-time job, however, is a middle school english teacher. According to public records, she has a hard time juggling the three roles and has actually been disciplined several times by the Kenosha Unified School District for doing elected duties while working for KUSD as a teacher, among

Read More »

Grooming Case Against Fired Teacher Goes To Trial – Motion To Dismiss Denied

A 29-year-old fired KUSD teacher named Christian Enwright is headed to trial on 22 counts of Disorderly Conduct for allegedly grooming a 14-year-old student. Judge Gerad Dougvillo today, denied Enwright’s attorneys’ motion to dismiss after extensive briefing and short oral arguments. Enwright is now scheduled to go to trial on April 21, 2025. He faces over four years in jail, if convicted of all counts. Enwright’s attorneys brought up a recent bill signed into law that

Read More »

Congressman Bryan Steil Endorses Xavier Solis For Kenosha County District Attorney

A key endorsement has been announced in the Kenosha County DA’s race. Carli’s McNeill (D) is running against Xavier Solis (R) for Kenosha County District Attorney. “Xavier Solis stands with law enforcement and is committed to keeping Kenosha County safe,” said Congressman Brian Steil (R). “I believe everyone deserves to feel safe in their communities, and that’s why I’m supporting Xavier Solis for Kenosha County District Attorney.” “I want to sincerely thank Congressman Steil for his

Read More »
Categories
Archives
Authors

15 Responses

    1. The offender or the judge.

      What a fool of a judge. Did the girl have the means to disagree with the custodial adult? What bs. Had better hopes for rossell.

      11
      1
    1. Mental anguish, pain and suffering.
      She can never ride a car again as she developed a fear of them and regresses into a infantile state when ever a horn beeps or an engine revvs.
      It’s a million dollar lawsuit coming.

      6
      4
    2. Yes she is a victim. It’s called domestic abuse and potentially kidnapping if she was forced to stay in the vehicle while he terrorized her by intentionally driving to inflict fear. This child will have PTSD the rest of her life. I experienced this with an e, cannot imagine having a father do this. Horrible.

      3
      2
    3. You sound like a person who thinks inflicting fear in someone is ok, especially if it’s a child.

      You are probably the same type of person who would invalidate someone by saying “get over it”.

      Do better

      2
      1
  1. Judge Rossell has always been a fair and impartial judge. The initial report seems like Judge Rossell errored, his reasons need to be known. Either way the Appellate had their say.

    6
    3
    1. Maybe if he wasn’t multitasking and was paying attention he would have made a better decision. I have been in his court and have witnessed him answering messages while tasked with overseeing a motion hearing. Smathers is no better, she was playing games on her phone while the defense was questioning people. Completely unprofessional. And these are the people responsible for deciding a person’s fate.

  2. WTF is up with our courts? Joel Trudell charges dismissed, bergs dismissed and stealing tens of thousands of dollars and no charges?

    9
    1
    1. Yes it is and unfortunately people ate unaware of how corrupt Kenosha county is. They need to be investigated by the Attorney General of Wisconsin. People who have experienced the corruption need to write the Attorney General and voice their concerns. Everything from the courts to the jail is corrupt and abuse of power is allowed. Did you know the staff at Kenosha county jail can deny people their medication? And the jail staff put people in restraint chairs and laugh about the fact that the person can sit there and piss and shit on themselves? This city is terrible and has terrible people working for them.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LATEST NEWS
LATEST NEWS
Categories
Archives
Authors

Subscribe to updates

Get notified of new articles. We'll never share your email address.