Kraus and Binger Lose Again: Jury Finds Rape Suspect Not Guilty After Year And A Half Behind Bars

Copied!
Robert Thomas, 24 of Kenosha

A Special Birthday

Paid Advertisement

Wednesday, December 8, 2021. Robert Thomas’s 24th birthday was almost certainly different from all of his others. This birthday, he spent outside of the Kenosha County jail, smelling the cold fall air after a year and a half behind bars.

Paid Advertisement
Kenosha ADA Jim Kraus (D)
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson)

Allegation and Charge

Paid Advertisement

Thomas was charged by Kenosha Prosecutor James Kraus (D) of an early-morning rape more than seven years ago, on October 2, 2014. According to court records, a woman, who was severely intoxicated, admitted to using hallucinogenics on the night of her alleged rape. She said that she left a Kenosha bar and was walking to another bar when she was approached by a black male. She said the next thing she remembered, she woke up with her pants down. She then pulled them up and hitched a ride to the Kenosha Police Department. The woman did not have much of a description of her alleged attacker. She was taken to the hospital for a SANE (Sexual Assault Nurse Exam). The swab contained DNA and it was sent to the Wisconsin crime lab. There were no matches. The case was cold. Just over 5 years later, a match was sent to KPD. It was a match to the defendant. He was convicted for disorderly conduct on 10/31/2019 and had to give his DNA to police. Police gave the woman a photo lineup with the defendant’s photo among others. She didn’t pick anyone out. Prosecutor James Kraus decided to charge Thomas anyway. That’s exactly what he did on March 20, 2020. Kraus charged Thomas with Second Degree Sexual Assault which carried a possible prison sentence of 40 years. Kraus had his wife Emily Trigg, notarize the sworn complaint, which is improper.

Kenosha ADA T. Clair Binger (D)
(Court TV non-copyrighted)

T. Clair Binger’s Trial

Paid Advertisement

We spoke to and heard from jurors about the trial. This gave us a lot of insight into the trial and the deliberations. The alleged victim and the defendant both took the stand. One female juror told us that defense attorney Brett Copeland was polite, non-judgemental, and fair, but seemed like a newer attorney. He has been practicing law for four years.. She told us that T. Clair Binger (D) was smart and well-researched. She did share some criticism with the KCE. She said the T. Clair could have done a much better job of focusing on the alleged victim and how the allegations affected her life in the last seven years. She said he relied too much on the DNA evidence and ignored other avenues to pursue. The defendant admitted to having sex with the woman, but said it was consensual. According to one of the jurors we spoke to, there just wasn’t enough evidence to support rape. “There were just too many holes in her story to convince us it wasn’t consensual”

Judge Jason Rossell
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson)

Theft and Third Degree Sexual Assault

Paid Advertisement

T. Clair made an unusual request. He asked Judge Rossell to allow an 11th hour charge of theft, saying there was evidence that Thomas stole the woman’s purse. The Judge denied his request. T. Clair also asked for a lesser-included charge of third degree sexual assault, which the judge allowed. As a former prosecutor, Rossell is seen as a judge by defense attorneys that typically sides with the prosecution.

Deliberations

About half of the jury recognized T. Clair Binger as the prosecutor that unsuccessfully prosecuted Kyle Rittenhouse. “Oh my God, he’s here again” one jurors said of Binger. The jury spoke briefly about the Rittenhouse case and deliberated for about 4 hours. They asked for a few exhibits and came to a unanimous verdict – NOT GUILTY.

We requested comment from T. Clair and have not heard back.

Click the Photo To Review KCE Merchandise

Author

Copied!
LATEST NEWS

Retired Pleasant Prairie Judge Arrested, Admits To Soliciting Prostitutes

A joint investigation of the City of Milwaukee Police Department Human Trafficking Task Force and Sworn Law Enforcement Investigators with the Milwaukee County District Attorney’s Office has been concluded. It revealed a large network of crime, misconduct and prostitution. Yesterday, a lawyer named Travis C. Schwantes was charged with multiple crimes. Within his criminal complaint, Easton is mentioned as being a frequent solicitor of prostitutes. Easton served as the Pleasant Prairie Municipal Prosecutor for more than

Read More »

District Attorney-Elect Xavier Solis Announces Andrew “Drew” Burgoyne as Deputy District Attorney

District Attorney-Elect Xavier Solis is proud to announce Andrew “Drew” Burgoyne as his selection for Deputy District Attorney. Burgoyne brings 16 years of experience as a prosecutor in the Kenosha County District Attorney’s office, along with a well-earned reputation for fairness, integrity, and commitment to justice. A 2005 graduate of Marquette Law School, Burgoyne has served Kenosha County with distinction, earning the respect of both his colleagues and the defense bar. Known for his straightforward communication,

Read More »
MORE TOP STORIES

Kenosha Judge Grants 16-Year-Old New Trial After Several Jurors Say They Were Bullied Into Guilty Verdicts

In a courtroom filled to capacity this morning, a Kenosha Judge vacated a guilty verdict for 16-year-old Martel D. Lee. On August 15, 2024, Lee was found guilty of second degree sexual assault. The assault allegedly occurred at Indian Trail High School earlier this year. Lee was supposed to be sentenced on October 28, 2024, but three jurors sent letters to the Judge, expressing remorse for agreeing to a verdict that they did not believe in.

Read More »

Double Murder, Rape Suspect In Custody – US Marshals Found Lawrence Franklin In Texas

“We are pleased to announce that Lawrence G Franklin was arrested on 11-21-24 in Plano, Texas, by the United States Marshal Service’s Joint East Texas Fugitive Task Force with the assistance of the Plano Police Department,” said Kenosha Police Lt. Josh Hecker. “The Kenosha Police appreciates all of the assistance provided by the US Marshal Service and the support provided by the Plano Police Department. Franklin will attend an extradition hearing in Texas before being transported back

Read More »

Kenosha Prosecutor Who Lost Race For District Attorney To Quit, Work For Democrat DA In Rock County

Cali McNeil (D) has been a prosecutor in Kenosha for more than a decade. She had been the Deputy District Attorney for the last three years. She is known for her soft-on-crime plea% deals and far-left policies. She was dubbed as District Attorney Mike Graveley’s heir apparent. Xavier Solis, a republican defense attorney challenged McNeil and won handedly. Allegedly, McNeil told the Kenosha Judges privately that she has accepted a job as an Assistant District Attorney

Read More »

Drunk-Driving Mom Who Flipped Car With Kids Inside Given No-Cash Bail

A Kenosha woman was given a no-cash bail today in Kenosha County Circuit Court for allegedly driving drunk with her kids in the back seat. According to court records, Megan M. Schultz, 35, of Kenosha, was driving drunk while drinking alcohol and hit two parked cars, flipping her car which contained her boyfriend and 6 and 8-year-old children. She was charged with one misdemeanor count of OWI w/ minor under 16 years old and one county

Read More »

Former County Board Supervisor, Amateur Porn Star, Accused Of Sexual Harassment, Sending Penis Photos To BLM Activist

**Extremely Graphic Content** A social media battle is red hot tonight, as a BLM activist named Whitney Cabal has accused former county board supervisor, ametuer porn star, and fired corrections sergeant of sexual harassment. Cabal, who goes by “Billy Violet” on social media, took to facebook tonight to issue the following statement: “Andy Berg is a pig of a man, he legit will not stop sending me sexual advances and propositions for literal years now. Yes

Read More »

SBA, Local Officials To Shop, Dine Small In Kenosha To Launch Holiday Shopping Season

SBA’s Season of Small Business™ Encourages Shoppers to Gift Big, Shop Local™ Throughout the Holiday Season The U.S. Small Business Administration’s Regional Administrator Geri Sanchez Aglipay and SBA Wisconsin Director Eric Ness will join Kenosha’s mayor, SBA resource partner WWBIC, and woman and minority entrepreneurs to shop and dine small on Nov. 21. In advance of Small Business Saturday, officials will visit several small businesses in downtown and uptown Kenosha that are flourishing with  SBA support and

Read More »

Harborside 6th Graders Bring Hand-Written Thank You Cards, Gifts To Kenosha Police

About 84 Harborside students marched from school to the Kenosha Police Department today to say “Thank you!” Today’s event was part of a student-lead event to show appreciation for law enforcement. This event is sponsored by Link Crew. This club is led by trained 11th/12th graders at Harborside Academy who focus on making the school’s 6th and 9th graders feel connected to Harborside. They lead “Gear Up” which is the schools before-school orientation, to teach lessons

Read More »

Kenosha Mom Arrested For Driving While Intoxicated With Her 6 and 8-Year-Old Children In The Car

Megan Oster-Schultz was a champion figure skater in the 2000’s. She was the 2006–07 Junior Grand Prix Final bronze medalist. Oster-Scholtz is now a long-time figure skating coach and off ice trainer. She’s now in hot water for allegedly dangerous behavior that fortunately resulted in no injuries. At about 7:41 p.m. on Sunday, November 17, 2024, Kenosha Police were summoned to the 3600 block of 40th street to what was reported to be a car crash with injuries.

Read More »

Fired Special Education Teacher Charged With Possession of Cocaine, Paraphernalia On School Grounds

A now-fired special education teacher for Salem Grade School has been officially charged in Kenosha County Circuit Court. Monday, Kayla L. Fasko, 42, of Janesville, was charged with one count of Possession of Cocaine, School Enhancer, and one count of Possession of Drug Paraphernalia. If convicted, Fasko faces more than one year in jail. According to the criminal complinat: A Kenosha County Sheriff’s deputy reported that on October 16, 2024, he responded to Salem Grade School

Read More »

Kenosha County Video Collaboration Scores Emmy

Uniquely Wisconsin Video on Kenosha Comets Wins Emmy Award:Kenosha County’s “Field of Dreams: AAGPBL 80th Reunion” Recognized Uniquely Wisconsin has received an Emmy Award for a story featuring Kenosha County’s “Field of Dreams: All-American Girls Professional Baseball League (AAGPBL) 80th Reunion.” The 66th Annual Chicago/Midwest Emmy Awards, which recognized excellence within various areas of television and emerging media, was held Nov. 2 in Chicago. This is the second Emmy Award win for the Uniquely Wisconsin brand,

Read More »
Categories
Archives
Authors

8 Responses

  1. Speaking of rape…After the last story on Smith Pumkin Farm and Michael Perrine (Registered Sex Offender against children) being associated with them they would have washed their hands of him as they said they would. Also said they didn’t know the extent of his assault.(were informed) Michael Perrine has been seen working a stand again at the Smith Pumkin Farm’s Christmas Lights On The Farm last week. Why would a business that caters to children allow this? Makes a lot of us speculate

  2. God some jurors are so stupid. What would how it affected her life over the last few years have any effect on whether it was consensual or not?

    This was always the biggest threat in the Rittenhouse case….stupid ass people on the jury.

    That being said, Binger and Kraus need to move on from the Kenosha County DA’s office. They don’t come across as likable to jurors anymore and they are always going to be “those guys”. Guilty people are going to walk because of this.

    1. I can think of one plausible reason…it might be to evaluate the believability of the witness. A blackout story is pretty hard to cross-examine/ask useful questions about, however, the effect on someone who knows they were raped vs one who knows they had consensual sex will be different…such that if the witness were lying, they would have to make something up, and a brave defense attorney may be able to point out some inconsistencies. A female juror in particular will want to evaluate not only the witness’s words, but the body language and whatever else feeds into their intuition.

  3. Eighteen months in prison, awaiting trial. Whatever happened to the “speedy and public trial” that the Sixth Amendment enumerates?

  4. God bless prosecutors like Binger and Krause. They are the Justice system’s best hope for fair and balanced justice for all.

    I’m totally messing with you.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LATEST NEWS
LATEST NEWS
Categories
Archives
Authors

Subscribe to updates

Get notified of new articles. We'll never share your email address.