Court Transcripts Show Makayla Rutka-Plaza Begged for Restraining Order Weeks Before Death; Commissioner William “Bargain Bail Billy” Michel II Denied Request

Copied!
Kenosha Court Commissioner William “Bargain Bail Billy” Michel II
(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

KENOSHA, Wis. — Newly obtained court transcripts show Makayla Rutka-Plaza, 28, appeared before Court Commissioner William “Bargain Bail Billy” Michel II less than two months before she was killed and begged for a restraining order against her estranged husband during what she described as a toxic and deteriorating divorce.

Rutka-Plaza, who was later allegedly stabbed to death by Marckus Plaza inside the basement of their home while two of their young children watched, had asked Michel for a restraining order that would have lasted only through the remainder of the divorce proceedings. While harassment injunctions are often granted for as long as four years, Rutka-Plaza asked for only four months of protection so she could get through the divorce and figure out the next steps for her family. Instead, Michel denied the request after a brief hearing in February.

Marckus L.A. Plaza, 33, of Kenosha In Court
(Still Photo by WISN12 Pool Camera)

Many in the community now believe Michel’s decision may have played at least some role in the events that followed and the brutal killing that prosecutors say occurred weeks later.

According to the transcript, Rutka-Plaza initially considered dismissing the restraining order because she hoped Plaza would help financially and assist with the children if she withdrew it. But in court, she changed her mind and made clear she still wanted protection.

The Late Makayla Marie Rutka Plaza

“I don’t want him at the house,” she told Michel.

Rutka-Plaza then detailed a series of allegations against Plaza that included taking her vehicle without permission, allegedly monitoring her through cameras, posting concerning material to Snapchat, and refusing to leave her alone. She also told Michel she had repeatedly called police about Plaza’s behavior.

“When he was listening to me through the cameras, I called. I called when I found the Snapchat story,” she testified.

According to allegations she raised in court filings and testimony, Plaza had also allegedly posted naked photos of Rutka-Plaza’s new boyfriend on Snapchat as the divorce became increasingly hostile.

The hearing transcript also shows Michel would not allow Rutka-Plaza to call character witnesses on her behalf. Michel stated that only witnesses with firsthand knowledge of the incidents she described would be allowed to testify.

“If they’re just character witnesses, no. That’s — this is going to have to be actual witnesses to what she’s testifying to,” Michel said during the hearing.

The transcripts further show Michel was aware that police had been involved, that Plaza had been taken to the police station, fingerprinted, photographed and told criminal charges could be coming. Plaza himself acknowledged in court that police had originally discussed felony charges before deciding to reduce the matter to a misdemeanor.

Under Wisconsin law, a judge or commissioner does not need proof beyond a reasonable doubt to grant a harassment injunction. The burden is much lower. A petitioner only needs to show reasonable grounds to believe harassment occurred or may occur again.

Despite that being among the lowest burdens of proof in Wisconsin law, Michel denied the request.

A lawyer who reviewed the transcripts and petition for KCE said Michel’s denial appears particularly weak given several facts he either ignored or glossed over. First, although the bruising Makayla documented in her sworn petition never came up during the hearing itself, that petition was before Michel and was part of the record. Under Wisconsin’s reasonable-grounds standard for harassment injunctions, a commissioner is not limited to live testimony — the sworn petition itself is evidence. The physical contact Makayla described, including bruising she said she discovered on Dec. 29 after Marckus allegedly seized her phone, independently satisfies the statutory definition of harassment under Wisconsin law without any further analysis. The attorney said Michel’s failure to address the petition’s physical-contact allegations in his reasoning was itself a significant gap.

Second, Marckus disclosed on the stand that he had already been arrested in connection with the same events and was facing a misdemeanor charge, meaning law enforcement had already made an independent determination that probable cause existed for criminal conduct arising from the same facts Michel found insufficient for a restraining order. The attorney said denying a civil harassment injunction under a reasonable-grounds standard while the respondent is simultaneously facing criminal charges for the same conduct is a difficult position to defend.

Third, Michel himself indicated during the hearing that he would have liked to grant the injunction but felt constrained because the two were married and in the middle of a divorce. The attorney said that suggests the denial was driven more by equitable reluctance than a genuine finding that the legal standard had not been met, which is not a valid basis for denial under Wisconsin’s harassment injunction statute.

Rutka-Plaza testified under oath about the problems she was experiencing, and Michel had access not only to her testimony, but also to the written petition she filed with the court.

Less than two months later, prosecutors say Marckus Plaza killed Rutka-Plaza inside the basement of their home at 7428 22nd Ave. According to the criminal complaint, police arrived after a welfare check and saw Plaza dragging Makayla’s body through a basement window. Officers forced entry and found her dead with a knife protruding from her eye.

Police say two young children inside the home — ages 4 and 2 — later described parts of the killing during child advocacy interviews.

Authorities then launched an enormous manhunt that lasted nearly 30 hours. At least 50 marked squad cars from the Kenosha Police Department, Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office and Pleasant Prairie Police Department flooded the area. Multiple drones, K-9 teams and tactical resources were used as officers searched neighborhoods and businesses near 23rd Avenue and 75th Street.

Plaza was ultimately found hiding in the basement of JH Salon at 2318 75th St. According to police, the four officers who physically wrestled him into custody were Kenosha Police Chief Patrick Patton, Deputy Chief Brent Sagedal, Inspector Aaron Dilhoff and Lt. Adam Jurgens. Two of those high-ranking officers suffered minor injuries during the struggle and were treated and released.

Marckus Plaza, 33, is now charged with first-degree intentional homicide with use of a dangerous weapon, along with additional charges related to the manhunt and arrest. Because first-degree intentional homicide is a Class A felony, Plaza faces a mandatory life sentence if convicted, with up to five additional years because prosecutors allege he used a dangerous weapon.

Supplemental Court Commissioner Aileen “Half-Off” Henry later raised his bail to $2 million cash after widespread criticism that the original $750,000 warrant signed by Judge Heather Iverson was too low.

WGTD reporter David Kollath (D)
(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

Separately, blogger David Kollath (D), who uses the name David Cole and works for the state-sponsored media outlet WGTD, repeatedly reported that Rutka-Plaza “dropped the order.” The transcripts show that was false. While Rutka-Plaza initially considered dismissing the restraining order request because of financial pressure and the children, she clearly changed her mind in court and told Michel she wanted the hearing to proceed. KCE is calling on Kollath to retract that claim.

Kollath also drew criticism at a recent press conference when he asked police whether Rutka-Plaza had a history of being violent toward Plaza, a question many in attendance felt was inappropriate given the brutality of the allegations and the fact that two young children allegedly witnessed parts of the killing.

For many following the case, the newly obtained transcripts raise troubling questions about whether more could have been done when Rutka-Plaza first came to court asking for help.

Author

Copied!
LATEST NEWS

Nearly 5 Kilograms Of Methamphetamine, Nine Guns Seized In Major Twin Lakes Drug Investigation Involving Local, County And Federal Authorities

TWIN LAKES, Wis. — A major multi-agency drug investigation in Twin Lakes resulted in the seizure of approximately five kilograms of suspected methamphetamine, nine firearms, marijuana, THC vapes and cash, according to Twin Lakes Police Chief Katie Hall. The investigation targeted a suspected kilogram-level methamphetamine distributor who police say is a convicted felon with a history of drug-related arrests. On Friday, November 13,

Plus +

Kenosha Man, 19, Wanted For Repeated Sexual Assault Of A Child: $50,000 Arrest Warrant Issued — Call 911 If You See Him

KENOSHA, Wis. — A 19-year-old Kenosha man is wanted by authorities after being formally charged Wednesday, November 18, 2026, with repeatedly sexually assaulting a young girl. Ahmad Jermaine Lea Jr., 19, of Kenosha, faces one count of repeated sexual assault of the same child, a Class C felony. Kenosha County Circuit Court Judge Heather Iverson issued a $50,000 arrest warrant Wednesday. Lea is

MORE TOP STORIES
Plus +

Wisconsin DOJ Investigating Racine County Sheriff’s Captain Cary Madrigal As Newly Obtained Emails Raise Questions About District Attorney’s Involvement In Child Pornography Case

Captain Cary Madrigal, Patricia Hanson, and Pedophile Preston Kite RACINE, Wis. — The Wisconsin Department of Justice’s Division of Criminal Investigation (DCI) has been asked to investigate Racine County Sheriff’s Captain Cary Madrigal over allegations involving the investigation of former Union Grove High School Superintendent Thomas Johnson, who was charged

Plus +

Kenosha Man Wanted On $300,000 Arrest Warrant After Being Charged With Sexually Assaulting Multiple Children: Police Say Alleged Abuse Dates Back More Than 25 Years

Editor’s Note (Updated November 18, 2026, at 7:38 p.m.): Terrence V. Mathis Jr. is now in custody. According to the Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office inmate roster, Mathis was booked into jail at 5:38 p.m., just 77 minutes after Kenosha County Eye published this story at 4:21 p.m. KENOSHA, Wis. —

Plus +

Illinois Man, 73, Accused Of Drunkenly Slamming Into Mother And Two Children In Somers, Fleeing Scene: Only $4,000 Cash Bail Set Despite Serious Injuries

John L. Bates, 73, of Medinah, Illinois(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) SOMERS, Wis. — A 73-year-old Illinois man is facing four felony charges and a misdemeanor after prosecutors say he drunkenly slammed his pickup truck into a vehicle occupied by a mother and her two young children Tuesday evening, seriously injuring

Categories
Archives
Authors

36 Responses

    1. They need Follow a list to go by and crime they committed. they need help ! enough people have been hurt.

      1
      2
  1. What an inept excuse of a commissioner. I hope he experiences guilt, sleepless nights and a lot of would have could have should of. The fear and pain that the victim endured in this case is horrific. Michels should at least think of her often as he closes his eyes. The image of her with a knife in her eye should be the last image he sees as he tries to sleep.

    26
  2. He denied me the minute I sat down. Had the nerve to say it wasn’t supposed to be in his courtroom and then denied me a chance to read a statement with dates and occurrences for evidence. Said you can’t read statements in his court room. This is after I seen 5-7 people read statements. It says on website to be prepared with statement. Tossed me out real fast… it on record!! He’s a Fuckn joke

    21
    2
  3. I just don’t get what he was doing here. It seemed like both parties were confused and he just took it as, “well, I don’t get it and I don’t feel like figuring it out, figure it out yourselves.” The thing about going through her phone just gets ignored and so does his completely unconvincing testimony. Just a lot of painful reminders of what not to do here.

    16
  4. This court commissioner would be charged with murder under Wallecks new bill he would pass in Congress.

    16
    2
  5. And fire him.
    What else needs to happen before they do ?

    Under what scrutiny does this commissioner get to keep his job ?!?

    What does someone have to do to get fired ?

    All judges who are his bosses need to be voted out on this instance alone.

    13
  6. It is crazy to know that he replaced Keating and worked under Keating. Keating seemed to feel that Michel was ready for the job. Michel was not and probably never will be. Kenosha Court System needs a complete overhaul with judges, commissioners and gals.

    10
    1
    1. Keating did not have any say in his hiring. The judges completely controlled that decision. Keating did his best to help Bill but Keating is in no way, shape, or form responsible for Bill’s ineptitude. This disaster falls squarely on the shoulders of the judges, who have known for years that Bill had an anti-restraining order mentality and he treated these hearings like he was the defense attorney for the men.

  7. Michele always has always been a hack attorney so the good old judges club gives him a court commissioner job sounds like they feel sorry for stupid attorneys. Why did they nominate non-qualified Michele in the first place?

  8. I hope Mikayla’s family sues Bargain Bail Billy!! What an @$$hat in not granting her a restraining order!! This just infuriates me every time I read anything about this case!!

    11
    1
    1. They are often filed for nothing, based on nothing, by crazy women.
      Women who are vengeful.
      Women who want an easy way to evict a boyfriend or husband.
      Women who use police and the court system as a break up tool.
      I have seen it all as an attorney.

      7
      4
      1. But then why are Restraining Orders heard before a lowly Commissioner ?

        Maybe Request for Restraining Orders should automatically go before a judge.
        Obviously the current system isn’t working.

        That seems like an easy change.
        Sure a judge can be as oblivious but at least he or she is a judge. An elected judge

        3
        1
    2. You can’t have a restraining order issued automatically just because someone files for one. Neither should you have it refused after you’ve presented or were ready to present a compelling argument, by someone who just shrugs and says go away. Most of all, people shouldn’t ever come to get a restraining order unless they are 100% sure they are willing to go through with it because they ruin it for everyone if they get all wishy-washy.

  9. Question…Who hires and fires court commissioners?
    Ultimately must be one person collecting a paycheck that is responsible. Or not.

  10. Bargain Billy is the worst here in Kenosha, next to Kerkman. We need a full housecleaning here, starting with Billy

  11. Here is the fact about Comm. Michel; he is lazy and picks a winner and cuts the other side off from presenting evidence to shorten the hearing.
    Look up how many of his decisions are reversed by judges who take the time hearing restraining orders that are appealed from Michel.
    Also a fact; the job is low paying so the peter principle has been proven again.
    Supplemental court commissioners are chosen by Judges who only want yes attorneys who will not make waves and follow judges orders, not their own legal knowledge or minds.

    1. Bill is not supplemental and he is paid very well. Hes not smart or a hard worker, which is why the judges picked him. In case you are new here, birds of a feather – judges and commissioners flock together.

      1. There was a time when we had some commissioners who truly cared and worked hard. We also had judges with leadership.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LATEST NEWS

Nearly 5 Kilograms Of Methamphetamine, Nine Guns Seized In Major Twin Lakes Drug Investigation Involving Local, County And Federal Authorities

TWIN LAKES, Wis. — A major multi-agency drug investigation in Twin Lakes resulted in the seizure of approximately five kilograms of suspected methamphetamine, nine firearms, marijuana, THC vapes and cash, according to Twin Lakes Police Chief Katie Hall. The investigation targeted a suspected kilogram-level methamphetamine distributor who police say is a convicted felon with a history of drug-related arrests. On Friday, November 13,

Plus +

Kenosha Man, 19, Wanted For Repeated Sexual Assault Of A Child: $50,000 Arrest Warrant Issued — Call 911 If You See Him

KENOSHA, Wis. — A 19-year-old Kenosha man is wanted by authorities after being formally charged Wednesday, November 18, 2026, with repeatedly sexually assaulting a young girl. Ahmad Jermaine Lea Jr., 19, of Kenosha, faces one count of repeated sexual assault of the same child, a Class C felony. Kenosha County Circuit Court Judge Heather Iverson issued a $50,000 arrest warrant Wednesday. Lea is

Plus +

Wisconsin DOJ Investigating Racine County Sheriff’s Captain Cary Madrigal As Newly Obtained Emails Raise Questions About District Attorney’s Involvement In Child Pornography Case

Captain Cary Madrigal, Patricia Hanson, and Pedophile Preston Kite RACINE, Wis. — The Wisconsin Department of Justice’s Division of Criminal Investigation (DCI) has been asked to investigate Racine County Sheriff’s Captain Cary Madrigal over allegations involving the investigation of former Union Grove High School Superintendent Thomas Johnson, who was charged with possessing child pornography. Sources familiar with the situation in Kenosha County believe

Plus +

City Of Kenosha Pays $35,000 To Woman Who Sued Police Over Traffic Stops And Drug Searches; Criminal Charges Dismissed

KENOSHA, Wis. — The City of Kenosha has paid $35,000 to Erica Lea Hawkins, 42, of Kenosha, after she filed a federal civil rights lawsuit accusing Kenosha police officers of violating her constitutional rights during two separate traffic stops. The lawsuit, filed March 10, 2026, was resolved just over five months later, without a trial, after the city offered to allow a $35,000

Kenosha Area Chamber Of Commerce Moving To Historic Downtown Building After Nearly 20 Years At Current Location

KENOSHA, Wis. — The Kenosha Area Chamber of Commerce announced Wednesday, November 18, that it will relocate its downtown headquarters after nearly two decades at its current location. The organization plans to move into the historic Schwartz Building at 520 58th Street in downtown Kenosha, with an anticipated opening in January 2027. The Chamber has operated out of 600 52nd Street, Suite 130,

Thanksgiving Holiday Will Delay Garbage And Recycling Collection In Kenosha; Fall Compostables Program Coming To An End

KENOSHA, Wis. — City of Kenosha residents who normally have their garbage and recycling collected on Thursdays or Fridays will need to adjust their schedules next week as the Thanksgiving holiday brings changes to several city services. The City of Kenosha Department of Public Works announced Wednesday that there will be no curbside garbage, recycling, brush, compostables, tire or bulk collection on Thanksgiving

Plus +

Kenosha Man Wanted On $300,000 Arrest Warrant After Being Charged With Sexually Assaulting Multiple Children: Police Say Alleged Abuse Dates Back More Than 25 Years

Editor’s Note (Updated November 18, 2026, at 7:38 p.m.): Terrence V. Mathis Jr. is now in custody. According to the Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office inmate roster, Mathis was booked into jail at 5:38 p.m., just 77 minutes after Kenosha County Eye published this story at 4:21 p.m. KENOSHA, Wis. — A 39-year-old Kenosha man is wanted on a $300,000 arrest warrant after prosecutors

Plus +

Illinois Man, 73, Accused Of Drunkenly Slamming Into Mother And Two Children In Somers, Fleeing Scene: Only $4,000 Cash Bail Set Despite Serious Injuries

John L. Bates, 73, of Medinah, Illinois(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) SOMERS, Wis. — A 73-year-old Illinois man is facing four felony charges and a misdemeanor after prosecutors say he drunkenly slammed his pickup truck into a vehicle occupied by a mother and her two young children Tuesday evening, seriously injuring the mother and her 9-year-old son before driving away from the crash scene.

Broadway Favorite ‘Annie’ Comes To Downtown Kenosha This Week, With Mayor David Bogdala Playing President Franklin D. Roosevelt

KENOSHA, Wis. — The sun will come out tomorrow in downtown Kenosha as KAPA Repertory Theatre prepares to bring the beloved Broadway musical “Annie” to the stage for four days of performances beginning Thursday, November 19. The production, which runs through Sunday, November 22, at the Ralph J. Houghton Performance Center, 934 58th St., will feature professional actors, local talent, a live orchestra

Kenosha Man Accused Of Firing Six Gunshots Near Lotus Sports Bar Released On No-Cash Bail By Commissioner Daniel “Catch & Release” Kellum: Courtroom Observers Stunned: Video

Juan Noel Rodriguez, 32, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 32-year-old Kenosha man accused of recklessly endangering the lives of people near a local bar by firing gunshots in the early morning hours was released on no-cash bail Wednesday, November 18, 2026, by Kenosha County Court Commissioner Daniel “Catch & Release” Kellum. Juan Noel Rodriguez, 32, of Kenosha, appeared in

Plus +

Kenosha Man Accused Of Using Dead Man’s Credit Card To Buy $1,899 Samsung Phone Just Hours After His Death

Todd N. Gotta, 60, of Kenosha(faceboook.com) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 60-year-old Kenosha man has been criminally charged after prosecutors say he used a deceased man’s credit card to purchase a nearly $1,900 Samsung cellphone just hours after the man died. Todd N. Gotta, 60, of Kenosha, was charged Tuesday, November 17, 2026, with one count of misdemeanor theft, a Class A misdemeanor punishable

Racine County Board Moves Toward Releasing Secret Investigation Into Former Deputy Convicted Of Child Pornography Crimes, Captain Cary Madrigal’s Handling Of Misconduct Allegations

RACINE COUNTY, Wis. — The Racine County Board of Supervisors took a significant step Tuesday evening, November 17, 2026, toward publicly releasing two previously confidential investigative reports involving former Sheriff’s Deputy Preston Kite and Captain Cary Madrigal, who was disciplined for her handling of misconduct allegations involving Kite. The development comes less than two weeks after Madrigal, the recently defeated Republican candidate for

After Judge Chad Kerkman (D) Refused To Try Teen With Loaded Gun At Bradford High School As Adult, Teen Shoots Himself With Another Gun, Lies To Police About Masked Gunman

KENOSHA, Wis. — Evan Braithwaite Jr., 17, of Kenosha, is facing a new felony and three misdemeanor charges after police say he accidentally shot himself in the leg with a handgun he was prohibited from possessing, then invented a story about a masked gunman that sent Kenosha police searching for a nonexistent suspect. The November 9 shooting comes less than nine months after

Kenosha Unified School District Scores Near Bottom Of Wisconsin In Key Academic Categories As State Report Card Shows Declining Overall Performance

KENOSHA, Wis. — The Kenosha Unified School District (KUSD) received another disappointing assessment from the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction (DPI) Tuesday, November 17, 2026, with newly released state report cards showing the district performing near the bottom of Wisconsin in several critical measures of academic achievement and student success. Although the district maintained its three-star “Meets Expectations” designation, its overall score declined

Plus +

Kenosha Woman Accused Of Running Over 17-Year-Old Boy With Jeep, Threatening To Kill Ex-Boyfriend With Knife Gets Only $500 Cash Bail On Five Criminal Charges

Angeleah Frances Gigliotti, 21, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 21-year-old Kenosha woman accused of deliberately running over a 17-year-old boy with her Jeep, attempting to strike several other people with the vehicle, and later threatening to kill her ex-boyfriend while holding a kitchen knife appeared in court Tuesday afternoon, where Kenosha County Court Commissioner Daniel “Catch & Release” Kellum

Financially Troubled KTEC’s State Report Card Scores Drop For Third Straight Year, Ranks In Bottom 6% Of Wisconsin Schools For Academic Growth Under Founder And “CEO” Angela Andersson’s Leadership

KENOSHA, Wis. — The financially troubled KTEC Schools of Innovation, founded and led by Angela Andersson (D), has received another dismal report card from the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction (DPI), marking the third consecutive year the independent public charter school has earned the state’s two-star rating of “Meets Few Expectations.” Even worse, the school’s overall accountability scores have declined each year, falling

No Snow? No Problem! Kenosha’s Alternate Side Parking Returns December 1, Along With $30 Tickets For Parking On The Wrong Side Of The Street

KENOSHA, Wis. — It’s that magical time of year again in Kenosha! The time when you can look out your window, see green grass, dry pavement, and not a snowflake in sight, but still get slapped with a $30 parking ticket because your car is on the wrong side of the street. That’s right, folks. Kenosha’s annual alternate side parking season is almost

Magic At Muni Returns To Kenosha With Christmas Lights, New Private Igloos And Toy Drive To Benefit Local Children

KENOSHA, Wis. — A popular Kenosha holiday tradition is returning later this month, bringing thousands of festive lights, more than two dozen Christmas displays and a brand-new attraction to Washington Municipal Golf Course. This year’s Magic at Muni will feature private, see-through Christmas igloos and a special toy drive in partnership with the Kenosha Police Department to help local children celebrate the holiday

Plus +

Semi-Truck Driver Accused Of Watching Video While Driving, Striking Woman’s Car And Fleeing Scene On I-41 In Somers: Felony Charges Filed

KENOSHA, Wis. — A 59-year-old Illinois semi-truck driver is facing a felony charge after authorities say he was watching a video while driving his commercial truck, struck a woman’s vehicle on Interstate 41 in Somers, nearly caused a potentially fatal crash, and continued driving without stopping to help. Enrique Guerrero, 59, of Brookfield, Illinois, was charged Tuesday, November 17, 2026, with second-degree recklessly

Pleasant Prairie Plan Commission Approves Plans For 391 New Apartments And 342,000 Square Feet Of Industrial Development

PLEASANT PRAIRIE, Wis. — The Village of Pleasant Prairie is moving forward with two major development projects that could bring hundreds of new apartments and more than 340,000 square feet of industrial space to the community. During its Monday, November 16, 2026, meeting, the Pleasant Prairie Plan Commission approved plans for the second phase of Inspire Prairie Springs, which will add 391 apartment

Plus +

18-Year-Old Racine Man Charged In Two Separate Attacks At Indian Trail, Including Allegedly Beating Teen And Causing More Than $3,000 In Damage To Truck: Previously Given Deferred Prosecution Deal After Injuring Kenosha Police Officer

Arnold Garcia, 18, of Racine(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — An 18-year-old Racine man who previously received a deferred prosecution agreement after being accused of injuring a Kenosha police officer is now facing six new criminal charges stemming from two separate attacks near Indian Trail High School and Academy. Arnold Garcia, 18, of Racine, was charged Tuesday, November 17, with felony criminal

Plus +

Illinois Man Accused Of Punching Girlfriend In Face, Pushing Her To Ground While She Held Baby: Released On No-Cash Bail

Ethan James Shearer, 24, of Grayslake, Illinois(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 24-year-old Grayslake, Illinois, man is facing two domestic abuse-related criminal charges after police say he punched his girlfriend in the face and pushed her to the ground while she was holding a baby. Ethan James Shearer appeared before Kenosha County Court Commissioner Daniel “Catch & Release” Kellum on Tuesday,

Plus +

Former Kenosha Cop Found Guilty Of Sexual Assault Minutes Before Trial; Liberal Judge Lets Him Walk Free, Suggesting Lenient Sentence May Follow

Fired Kenosha Police Officer Joshua Timothy Sylvester, 31, of Kenosha in Court(File Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye) KENOSHA, Wis. — Former Kenosha Police Officer Joshua Timothy Sylvester, 31, of Kenosha, was found guilty Monday, November 16, 2026, of felony sexual assault after accepting a last-minute plea agreement just minutes before his jury trial was scheduled to begin. Kenosha County District Attorney

Liberal Kenosha Alderman Anthony Kennedy Loses Restraining Order Case Against Sexual-Misconduct Accuser — Court Vacates Earlier Order

KENOSHA, Wis. — Kenosha Alderman Anthony Kennedy (D), 59, of Kenosha, failed Monday to obtain a harassment injunction against Whitney Cabal, who publicly accused him of seeking sexual favors in connection with financial assistance during her divorce. Kenosha County Court Commissioner Daniel “Catch & Release” Kellum dismissed Kennedy’s case after hearing testimony from both parties and vacated the temporary restraining order previously entered

LATEST NEWS

Nearly 5 Kilograms Of Methamphetamine, Nine Guns Seized In Major Twin Lakes Drug Investigation Involving Local, County And Federal Authorities

TWIN LAKES, Wis. — A major multi-agency drug investigation in Twin Lakes resulted in the seizure of approximately five kilograms of suspected methamphetamine, nine firearms, marijuana, THC vapes and cash, according to Twin Lakes Police Chief Katie Hall. The investigation targeted a suspected kilogram-level methamphetamine distributor who police say is a convicted felon with a history of drug-related arrests. On Friday, November 13,

Plus +

Kenosha Man, 19, Wanted For Repeated Sexual Assault Of A Child: $50,000 Arrest Warrant Issued — Call 911 If You See Him

KENOSHA, Wis. — A 19-year-old Kenosha man is wanted by authorities after being formally charged Wednesday, November 18, 2026, with repeatedly sexually assaulting a young girl. Ahmad Jermaine Lea Jr., 19, of Kenosha, faces one count of repeated sexual assault of the same child, a Class C felony. Kenosha County Circuit Court Judge Heather Iverson issued a $50,000 arrest warrant Wednesday. Lea is

Plus +

Wisconsin DOJ Investigating Racine County Sheriff’s Captain Cary Madrigal As Newly Obtained Emails Raise Questions About District Attorney’s Involvement In Child Pornography Case

Captain Cary Madrigal, Patricia Hanson, and Pedophile Preston Kite RACINE, Wis. — The Wisconsin Department of Justice’s Division of Criminal Investigation (DCI) has been asked to investigate Racine County Sheriff’s Captain Cary Madrigal over allegations involving the investigation of former Union Grove High School Superintendent Thomas Johnson, who was charged with possessing child pornography. Sources familiar with the situation in Kenosha County believe

Plus +

City Of Kenosha Pays $35,000 To Woman Who Sued Police Over Traffic Stops And Drug Searches; Criminal Charges Dismissed

KENOSHA, Wis. — The City of Kenosha has paid $35,000 to Erica Lea Hawkins, 42, of Kenosha, after she filed a federal civil rights lawsuit accusing Kenosha police officers of violating her constitutional rights during two separate traffic stops. The lawsuit, filed March 10, 2026, was resolved just over five months later, without a trial, after the city offered to allow a $35,000

Kenosha Area Chamber Of Commerce Moving To Historic Downtown Building After Nearly 20 Years At Current Location

KENOSHA, Wis. — The Kenosha Area Chamber of Commerce announced Wednesday, November 18, that it will relocate its downtown headquarters after nearly two decades at its current location. The organization plans to move into the historic Schwartz Building at 520 58th Street in downtown Kenosha, with an anticipated opening in January 2027. The Chamber has operated out of 600 52nd Street, Suite 130,

Thanksgiving Holiday Will Delay Garbage And Recycling Collection In Kenosha; Fall Compostables Program Coming To An End

KENOSHA, Wis. — City of Kenosha residents who normally have their garbage and recycling collected on Thursdays or Fridays will need to adjust their schedules next week as the Thanksgiving holiday brings changes to several city services. The City of Kenosha Department of Public Works announced Wednesday that there will be no curbside garbage, recycling, brush, compostables, tire or bulk collection on Thanksgiving

Plus +

Kenosha Man Wanted On $300,000 Arrest Warrant After Being Charged With Sexually Assaulting Multiple Children: Police Say Alleged Abuse Dates Back More Than 25 Years

Editor’s Note (Updated November 18, 2026, at 7:38 p.m.): Terrence V. Mathis Jr. is now in custody. According to the Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office inmate roster, Mathis was booked into jail at 5:38 p.m., just 77 minutes after Kenosha County Eye published this story at 4:21 p.m. KENOSHA, Wis. — A 39-year-old Kenosha man is wanted on a $300,000 arrest warrant after prosecutors

Plus +

Illinois Man, 73, Accused Of Drunkenly Slamming Into Mother And Two Children In Somers, Fleeing Scene: Only $4,000 Cash Bail Set Despite Serious Injuries

John L. Bates, 73, of Medinah, Illinois(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) SOMERS, Wis. — A 73-year-old Illinois man is facing four felony charges and a misdemeanor after prosecutors say he drunkenly slammed his pickup truck into a vehicle occupied by a mother and her two young children Tuesday evening, seriously injuring the mother and her 9-year-old son before driving away from the crash scene.

Broadway Favorite ‘Annie’ Comes To Downtown Kenosha This Week, With Mayor David Bogdala Playing President Franklin D. Roosevelt

KENOSHA, Wis. — The sun will come out tomorrow in downtown Kenosha as KAPA Repertory Theatre prepares to bring the beloved Broadway musical “Annie” to the stage for four days of performances beginning Thursday, November 19. The production, which runs through Sunday, November 22, at the Ralph J. Houghton Performance Center, 934 58th St., will feature professional actors, local talent, a live orchestra

Kenosha Man Accused Of Firing Six Gunshots Near Lotus Sports Bar Released On No-Cash Bail By Commissioner Daniel “Catch & Release” Kellum: Courtroom Observers Stunned: Video

Juan Noel Rodriguez, 32, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 32-year-old Kenosha man accused of recklessly endangering the lives of people near a local bar by firing gunshots in the early morning hours was released on no-cash bail Wednesday, November 18, 2026, by Kenosha County Court Commissioner Daniel “Catch & Release” Kellum. Juan Noel Rodriguez, 32, of Kenosha, appeared in

Plus +

Kenosha Man Accused Of Using Dead Man’s Credit Card To Buy $1,899 Samsung Phone Just Hours After His Death

Todd N. Gotta, 60, of Kenosha(faceboook.com) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 60-year-old Kenosha man has been criminally charged after prosecutors say he used a deceased man’s credit card to purchase a nearly $1,900 Samsung cellphone just hours after the man died. Todd N. Gotta, 60, of Kenosha, was charged Tuesday, November 17, 2026, with one count of misdemeanor theft, a Class A misdemeanor punishable

Racine County Board Moves Toward Releasing Secret Investigation Into Former Deputy Convicted Of Child Pornography Crimes, Captain Cary Madrigal’s Handling Of Misconduct Allegations

RACINE COUNTY, Wis. — The Racine County Board of Supervisors took a significant step Tuesday evening, November 17, 2026, toward publicly releasing two previously confidential investigative reports involving former Sheriff’s Deputy Preston Kite and Captain Cary Madrigal, who was disciplined for her handling of misconduct allegations involving Kite. The development comes less than two weeks after Madrigal, the recently defeated Republican candidate for

After Judge Chad Kerkman (D) Refused To Try Teen With Loaded Gun At Bradford High School As Adult, Teen Shoots Himself With Another Gun, Lies To Police About Masked Gunman

KENOSHA, Wis. — Evan Braithwaite Jr., 17, of Kenosha, is facing a new felony and three misdemeanor charges after police say he accidentally shot himself in the leg with a handgun he was prohibited from possessing, then invented a story about a masked gunman that sent Kenosha police searching for a nonexistent suspect. The November 9 shooting comes less than nine months after

Kenosha Unified School District Scores Near Bottom Of Wisconsin In Key Academic Categories As State Report Card Shows Declining Overall Performance

KENOSHA, Wis. — The Kenosha Unified School District (KUSD) received another disappointing assessment from the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction (DPI) Tuesday, November 17, 2026, with newly released state report cards showing the district performing near the bottom of Wisconsin in several critical measures of academic achievement and student success. Although the district maintained its three-star “Meets Expectations” designation, its overall score declined

Plus +

Kenosha Woman Accused Of Running Over 17-Year-Old Boy With Jeep, Threatening To Kill Ex-Boyfriend With Knife Gets Only $500 Cash Bail On Five Criminal Charges

Angeleah Frances Gigliotti, 21, of Kenosha(Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office) KENOSHA, Wis. — A 21-year-old Kenosha woman accused of deliberately running over a 17-year-old boy with her Jeep, attempting to strike several other people with the vehicle, and later threatening to kill her ex-boyfriend while holding a kitchen knife appeared in court Tuesday afternoon, where Kenosha County Court Commissioner Daniel “Catch & Release” Kellum

Financially Troubled KTEC’s State Report Card Scores Drop For Third Straight Year, Ranks In Bottom 6% Of Wisconsin Schools For Academic Growth Under Founder And “CEO” Angela Andersson’s Leadership

KENOSHA, Wis. — The financially troubled KTEC Schools of Innovation, founded and led by Angela Andersson (D), has received another dismal report card from the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction (DPI), marking the third consecutive year the independent public charter school has earned the state’s two-star rating of “Meets Few Expectations.” Even worse, the school’s overall accountability scores have declined each year, falling

Categories
Archives
Authors

Wake Up to What You Missed

Get notified of new articles. We'll never share your email address.