Judge Leaves Door Open For Mistrial In 16-Year-Old’s Sex Conviction In Which At Least Four Jurors Believe He’s Innocent

Copied!
Martel Lee (16) of Kenosha and Defense Attorney Mike Barth In Court Today
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

A Kenosha Judge today held a special hearing to address an issue in which two jurors sent letters to the court and the District Attorney’s Office signalling that they didn’t agree with their guilty verdict rendered on August 15, 2024, for Martel Lee, 16, of Kenosha. A third letter was received before today’s hearing. Barth asked for a mistrial, but the judge denied it because there is no case law that supports declaring a mistrial after a verdict is received.

Paid Advertisement
Kenosha County Circuit Court Judge Gerad Dougvillo In Court Today
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

Lee was supposed to be sentenced on October 28, 2024, but today, Kenosha County Circuit Court Judge Gared Dougvillo delayed the sentencing. He gave defense attorney Mike Barth 10 days to file a motion to impeach the jury’s verdict. Although Judge Dougvillo is stoic, he appeared to have some sympathy for the defendant. In his analysis, he cited a case, Wery, that Barth can use as a basis to impeach the jury’s verdict. It’s comes with a high bar, is difficult to prevail, and it is rarely attempted.

Paid Advertisement
Kenosha County Assistant District Attorney Alexandra Smathers (D) In Court Today
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

Kenosha County Assistant District Attorney Alexandra Smathers opposed a new trial and that is typical for her win-at-all-cost approach to her role as an ADA that landed herself a demotion and seemingly, cost her prosecutor job in Sheboygan county.

Paid Advertisement
Martel Lee (16) of Kenosha and Defense Attorney Mike Barth In Court Today
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

Attorney Barth has asked the State Public Defender’s Office to appoint a private investigator to attempt to obtain sworn statements from the jurors who wrote the letters. Today, KCE learned of a fourth juror who also felt bullied into giving a guilty verdict.

Paid Advertisement

One juror told the DA’s office that he or she felt “bullied” to change to a “guilty” verdict. Another juror wrote a letter to the judge saying that she wasn’t completely convinced of the boy’s guilt. All mentioned a juror who locked themself in the bathroom and refused to deliberate.

Paid Advertisement

Lee stood trial on August 12 through August 15, 2024 for two very serious crimes. Lee was charged with Felony Second Degree Sexual Assault and Felony Intimidation Of A Victim on April 25, 2024 . He faced 60 years in the Wisconsin Prison System. During the trial, the Felony Intimidation Of A Victim charge was dropped at the request of the state.

Paid Advertisement

According to the criminal complaint, he raped another student at Indian Trail High School on January 15, 2024. On February 19, 2024 the victim made a delayed report to police that Lee went into the bathroom stall after him and raped him. The victim also told police that the Lee used a translation app on his phone that translated from english to spanish to order the man to do his bidding. The victim was a spanish-only speaker and just recently immigrated to the USA. The victim, however had some credibility issues. His story changed many times. He recanted his allegations at least once, and then re-reported the allegations after a suicide attempt in which he stabbed himself in the chest multiple times and told his father he was “speaking with Satan.” The victim, a non-citizen, also told police that he committed multiple murders in his home country of Colombia. Barth told KCE that a victim of a crime in the US can cause one to be given more time here or a quicker path to citizenship.

Paid Advertisement

KCE was only present during the reading of the verdict. At least four jurors were actively weeping as the judge read the verdict, “Guilty.” Lee’s mother, Jen Jones was at every day of the trial and told us about many inconsistencies. “First [the victim] said my son went under the wall of the bathroom stall, later he said he followed him into the stall. He recanted his story twice. Also, [the victim] and his dad testified differently from what police wrote in their reports. First, [the victim] said that Martel threatened him in the classroom, but at trial, said it happened in the bathroom.” That’s when the state moved to dismiss the second count. The victim, who was also 16 at the time of the alleged rape suffers from schizophrenia. (KCE doesn’t usually publish juvenile mental health information, but in this case, it goes to credibility.)

Paid Advertisement

When interviewed by a Kenosha Police Detective, the victim told him that he lied about the sexual assault. He did not know why, but he “just lied.” He was adamant that [he] was not sexually assaulted and “made the story up.”

Both the letter from a juror to the judge and a letter from a juror to the DA’s office both criticized the defense attorney, Michal Barth. “I would not say I felt forced or bullied into making a decision of guilt, but it was still so incredibly difficult and emotional to answer “yes” to agreeing to the verdict. It was incredibly difficult because I still did have questions that were just not allowed to [be] ask[ed] or have the answers to. I was, however, unsure and unsettled, that Martell had the best representation,” wrote a female juror.

The other juror wrote, “I was one of the jurors who was not convinced. I am still not convinced. I felt bullied by other jurors who felt so strongly for a ‘guilty’ verdict. They eventually wore me down. Defense should have had a better case. He needed to poke holes in the states case. I believe if there was a better prepared defense attorney the verdict could have easily been ‘not guilty.’ “

Barth noted today that he believes the jury shifted the burden, unfaily to him. “The burden is on the state. Not me. And those holes they say were poked in the case? I poked them.”

Smathers wrote to the court that she believed the two jurors were one in the same, despite the stark contrast in messaging.

KCE also spoke to multiple jurors including one that was on the “guilty” side. She said the jurors that thought Lee was not guilty said there wasn’t enough evidence. The woman, in her 20’s, said the jury was close on multiple occasions to telling the judge that they were “hung.”

On October 18, 2024, a third juror told the judge in part:

“I should have written this letter sooner but I didn’t know exactly what to say and how to say it. Simply put, this case hunts me everyday. As you may recall, we had a somewhat long deliberation. Me, along with several other jurors believed he was “not guilty…” Something was missing – some things didn’t just make sense. I fought for so long – as long as I could and honestly I wish I fought harder… At one point, directed to some of us jurors who are not guilty, someone said ‘well don’t make a decision, we’ll make it for you and then we can all go home.’ I cannot believe this was said. Anyways, fast forward – I felt I was eventually more down and ‘bullied’ into verdict. I know there may not be anything I can do about it now. I could have said ‘no’ in court… Perhaps there is nothing to be done now but I would never be able to forgive myself if I didn’t try, at least.”

Today, KCE heard from a fourth juror today that said she read our story and felt the need to tell us that she also felt bullied into a guilty verdict. That’s now one third of the jury that believed Martel is “not guilty.”

KCE asked Smathers for comment and chose not to talk to KCE.


Martel Lee (16) of Kenosha Leaving Court Today
(Photo by Kevin Mathewson, Kenosha County Eye)

Author

Copied!
LATEST NEWS

Fired Kenosha Teacher Pleads Guilty to 15 Counts of Disorderly Conduct in Grooming Case

Kenosha, Wis. — Former Kenosha Unified School District teacher Christian J. Enwright pleaded guilty Friday morning to 15 counts of disorderly conduct, admitting in court to engaging in a months-long Snapchat-based grooming campaign targeting a 13-year-old student. The student, referred to in Kenosha County Eye reporting by the pseudonym Holly, sat in the courtroom with her parents as Enwright uttered the words “Guilty, Your Honor” fifteen times—once for each count. The hearing, initially set as a

Read More »

Long-Time Detective Resigns Amid Internal Investigation into Mishandled Cases

Kenosha, Wis. — A longtime Kenosha police detective has resigned just days before the conclusion of a sweeping internal investigation that sources say uncovered years of mishandled cases and investigative shortcuts. Detective Jason Melichar, who joined the Kenosha Police Department in 1999, resigned effective April 2, 2025, according to a department spokesperson. KPD confirmed that Melichar stepped down before the internal inquiry had concluded but declined to comment further, citing the investigation as a personnel matter.

Read More »
MORE TOP STORIES

Ziminski’s Bid for Early Prison Release Denied by Kenosha Judge

Kenosha, Wis. — Joshua Ziminski, the man who fired the first gunshot during the August 2020 riots in Kenosha, has been denied early release from prison. Ziminski, 40, is serving a three-year prison term after pleading guilty last year to armed robbery and armed burglary stemming from an August 2022 incident. Prosecutors said Ziminski and his wife, Kelly, robbed a man at knifepoint and attempted to withdraw cash from his bank account. As part of a

Read More »

Pleasant Prairie Police Department Opens Doors to the Public with State-of-the-Art Facility

Pleasant Prairie, Wis. — Residents in Pleasant Prairie will get their first public look inside the community’s new police station during an open house on Saturday, April 12, offering a glimpse into what law enforcement officials say is a facility built for both the present and the future. Located just south of Village Hall at 10111 39th Avenue, the new 58,000-square-foot station represents a significant leap forward for the Pleasant Prairie Police Department. After years of

Read More »

High-Speed Chase Ends in Courtroom: One Faces Potential Child Pornography Charges

Kenosha, Wis. — A 23-year-old Milwaukee man who led sheriff’s deputies on a high-speed chase through western Kenosha County is being held on $75,000 cash bail as prosecutors weigh possible child pornography charges related to his relationship with a 16-year-old girl. Jose Luis Soto-Nunez appeared in Kenosha County Circuit Court on March 27 and faces six felony charges stemming from the March 26 incident, including fleeing police, multiple counts of recklessly endangering safety, and operating a

Read More »

New Christian School Opens in Kenosha With Free Tuition for Eligible Families

Kenosha, Wis. — A new private school offering free tuition for qualifying families has opened in Kenosha, thanks to a partnership between Shining Star Christian Schools and Heritage Baptist Church. The new campus is located inside Heritage Baptist Church at 2313 17th Ave., and enrollment is now open for students entering kindergarten through eighth grade. Pastor Curtis McMiller, who leads the church, said he’s excited to welcome families and provide children with access to a quality,

Read More »

Salem Man Gets Two-Year Sentence in Fond du Lac Despite High-Speed Chase, Firearm, and Drug Allegations

Kenosha, Wis. — A 24-year-old Salem man with a long history of criminal charges was sentenced to just two years in prison last month after pleading guilty to multiple felonies tied to a 2021 high-speed chase that endangered motorists and law enforcement in Fond du Lac County. Trenton Benjamin Kmiec, the son of local attorney and ousted politician, Theodore “Ted” Kmiec, appeared before Fond du Lac County Circuit Judge Tricia Walker on Feb. 25, 2025. Walker

Read More »

Deputy Suspended Over Retaliatory Traffic Stop After Middle Finger Incident

Kenosha, Wis. — The Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office has disciplined a deputy who conducted a questionable traffic stop after a driver gave him the middle finger — a gesture protected by the First Amendment. Deputy Manuel Mandujano Jr. received a one-day unpaid suspension and mandatory constitutional policing training following an internal investigation into the February 1 incident, which gained traction online after video footage was posted to the “LackLuster” YouTube channel. The footage showed Mandujano initiating

Read More »

Salem Elementary Teacher Arrested After Alleged THC-Fueled Disturbance at Home

Kenosha, Wis. — A preschool teacher at Salem Elementary School was arrested late Saturday night after authorities say she ingested THC edibles and began behaving violently inside her Salem Lakes home. Melissa E. Briggs, 42, was taken into custody by the Kenosha County Sheriff’s Department just after 11 p.m. Deputies responded to the 10000 block of 256th Avenue after her husband called 911, reporting that Briggs was experiencing a mental health crisis and pounding on a

Read More »

Body Cam Footage Contradicts Pastor’s Claim of Cooperation in Youth Minister Sex Crime Case

Kenosha, Wis. – Despite publicly claiming that Journey Church was cooperating with police, newly released body-worn camera footage obtained by Kenosha County Eye reveals that lead pastor Kevin Taylor declined to give a statement to investigators following the arrest of a fellow pastor now charged with 15 felonies involving intimate images of two women. Gabriel Mills, a former “Guest Experience Pastor” at Journey Church in Kenosha, was first arrested on September 30, 2024. According to a

Read More »

Dominick Black Violates Probation, Faces Arrest Warrant If He Fails To Return To Wisconsin

KENOSHA, Wis. — The Wisconsin Department of Corrections has notified a Kenosha County judge that Dominick Black, a probationer best known for his connection to the Kyle Rittenhouse case, violated the terms of his probation and is being ordered back to Wisconsin. In a letter sent yesterday to Judge Angelina Gabriele, Probation and Parole Agent Kimberly Ruhle reported that Black failed a drug test, was kicked out of substance use programming, and missed a mandatory probation

Read More »

Illinois Man Faces 46 New Charges, Possible Life In Prison After Multi-Agency Highway Pursuit

Kenosha, Wis. — An Illinois man already out on bond for multiple pending felony cases in Kenosha County was charged Thursday with 46 new counts in connection to a daytime police chase that spanned multiple jurisdictions and ended on the interstate. John S. Miller, 56, of Zion, now faces a staggering range of charges including first-degree recklessly endangering safety, criminal damage to property, fleeing and eluding police, and 36 counts of felony bail jumping. Prosecutors say

Read More »
Categories
Archives
Authors

41 Responses

  1. Explain to us all how an over 6 foot tall over 200 lb victim is physically overpowered by a 150lb skinny kid. All this allegedly happened in an occupied school during the day, and nobody heard a sound or struggle? I’m surprised there were only 4 jurors who weren’t totally convinced.

    5
    2
    1. You are the piece of trash for even coming on here for attention you don’t know my son you don’t know his story so how about you go find something else to do for some attention you stupid stupid person

      19
      3
      1. My heart goes out to you. Praying you and your son will be able to go on with your lives and heal from this nightmare.

        10
        2
    2. Lets lock you up for something you didn’t do and then lets watch you fight for your innocence while we shout lock you up get a life Talk to God you seem to need him and his Love!

      5
      1
    3. The problem of wrongful convictions is real.

      People who study the phenomenon believe 4% to 6% of the U.S. inmate population has been wrongfully convicted. Since people of color are wrongfully convicted at higher rates, many dim-witted people, like you, don’t care.

      It can happen to anyone. Yes, it can happen to you. Then you will change your toon.

      5
      1
    4. I am his sister !! You da piece of trash speak on what you know not Whatchu think which is nothing thank you 🙌🏾

      5
      1
      1. Innocent as hell . Your racist and it shows you don’t even know the full story to even be saying someone is guilty do your research dumb ass.

      2. Innocent as hell . Your racist and it shows you don’t even know the full story to even be saying someone is guilty do your research dumb ass. Now find you something to do white racist piece of shit kindly from a black women😁 now I’m being racist you gone learn and I can’t wait to see your downfall bastard.

      3. FREE THE INNOCENT! You white racist peace of 💩 and fuck the system now what bitch now you go and make a joke about that. AND YES IM MAD don’t nobody reply to my shit because I’m angry and will treat ANYBODY and they momma. this white racist b!tch keep talking shit and nobody’s saying anything half of y’all under here knows this case is bullshit. Now have a nice day I will be back to check some more people ‼️.

        1. Im not saying he’s guilty— it would definitely seem as though he’s innocent. But, let’s get real, here. To start throwing around racism when someone says “guilty as hell” is a bit far fetched. You have no clue as to the race of the commenter or the reasoning behind the comment. Automatically going to “racism” is why no one takes ACTUAL racism seriously, anymore. It’s thrown around randomly as a buzzword with zero meaning behind it.

          Ignorant? Ok.
          Poorly-informed? Sure.
          Misled, misunderstanding of the situation? Yep.

          Racism? Weak argument.

  2. Why is the judge giving the defense case law suggestions? Seems strange. the scales of justice are far from balanced especially for colored folks

    3
    6
    1. Wow! You are a POS. Maybe the judge is concerned about justice. I assume it would be ok with you is the judge gave this tip to a white defendant. So “colored people’” can be wrongfully convicted? That is exactly what you are saying.

      Someday those “colored people” in that shithole country you moved to will figure you out. They may then turn on you. That will stop you from being such an ass.

      4
      3
    2. The judge actually said the area of law is not well developed and gave both sides a chance to weigh in. Judges do that all the time.

      4
      1
  3. These Judges and lawyers play fast and loose with peoples lives and then wonder why a jury can’t come to a conclusion based on the evidence, or lack there of.

    1
    2
  4. Damn feel sorry for this young man if he is truly innocent, but even if he is proven innocent, this will haunt him for the rest of his life.

    9
    2
  5. “Barth told KCE that a victim of a crime in the US can cause one to be given more time here or a quicker path to citizenship” this is a true statement and it this will not be the first time we see this in the news. News reports around the country have stated that this is well known within the immigrant community. If this is true and this young man was set up he needs to be released and the Barth needs to be charged with filing a false police report.

  6. That case is a classic example of what THE WATCHER has observed over the years. I bet the District Attorney’s office-Victim Witness department called the shots for the prosecution. I always thought there were ethics that you don’t prosecute unless you know you will get a guilty conviction. Bet the old witch in that department called the shot!

  7. I don’t care what anyone says, my white ass says he should be freed immediately. According to another source below, the ‘victim’ changed his story numerous times Zero credibility, lies are hard to remember, the truth is not.

    Free this young man and be sure to hire an attorney to have the arrest removed from any future FBI background checks as this will show up and any future employers will hold it against him even if found innocent. DROP them charges!

    An examination of the police report in the case shows that the victim changed his story numerous times. Several jurors contacted by WGTD said the majority overcame the weak evidence by placing greater weight on powerful testimony from the victim and his father.

  8. Why would the jurors convict, and then regret the guilty verdict they themselves just turned in………. I will never understand this.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LATEST NEWS
Categories
Archives
Authors

Subscribe to updates

Get notified of new articles. We'll never share your email address.